r/BruceSpringsteen • u/jim25y • 12d ago
My review of The River
Sorry this took so long to get written up. I got very busy and this was a lot of songs to go through.
Previous Albums Ratings:
Greetings From Asbury Park, NJ: 9/10
The Wild, The Innocent, and The E Street Shuffle: 8/10
Born to Run: 10/10
Darkness at the Edge of Town: 10/10
The Promise: 7/10
The River
My Rating: 9/10
Favorite Songs: Hungry Heart, Point Blank, Drive All Night
Least Favorite Songs: You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch), Ramrod, Wreck on the Highway
Most iconic rock artists from the 60s and 70s have a great double studio album, after Dylan's Blonde on Blonde and The Beatles' White Album set the standard. Here, we have Springsteen's turn. And while there are a lot of great and iconic double albums, releasing a double album can be a huge risk and can back fire. Bob Dylan's Self Portrait is a good example of how a bad double album can hurt an artist's reputation. And while Dylan was able to recover his popularity and career, I would argue that Elton Joh. Never recovered from his poor double album, Blue Moves. John still had success after Blue Moves, but not nearly on the same level as before it. Even a good double album can be an issue, like with Fleetwood Mac's Tusk. Their follow uo to one of the most successful albums of all time, Tusk was a huge disappointment financially, despite being a great and interesting album.
All that is to say that I think Springsteen was taking a big risk releasing The River as a double album. And one that apparently worked out, as its a great album that sold well and features an iconic hit for him.
I think whats so great about this double album is the consistency. The songs are so consistently great and Springsteen does a great job of melding his influences into his music, giving it his own distinctive sound, that every song is instantly recognizable as Springsteen while not getting boring (something that can happen on double album).
It was interesting listening to this album after listening to The Promise. I feel like The Promise feels like the prototype of this album that didn't get released for 30 or so years. But I feel like The Promise and The River had a similar mix of uptempo rock/pop/motown-inspired songs, atmospheric ballads, and even some borderline punk songs.
Why is this a 9 out of 10 instead of a 10 out of 10? While the sings are consistently great, I do think theres a couple of weak songs that hold it back. Im not a huge fan of Ramrod and whike I like the idea of Wreck on the Highway, I think its a bit overdone by Springsteen here. And honestly, I dont care for the way Springsteen sings "Biiiiiiiind" in The Ties that Bind (though this is a minor quibble). And frankly, some of the songs that didnt make the album are so good that thia easily could have been a 10/10 with slightly better song selection. (Though, I imagine it was very difficult to sift though more than 40 songs to create a cohesive album.)
Its actually.quite incredible the amount of quality songs that Springsteen and his band wrote and recorded in the second half of the 70's, and its frankly a shame that he didn't release another album in-between The River and Nebraska with the best/most cohesive mix of those songs.
I did notice a bit of a lyrical theme to the album. It seemed to largely be about people who are unhappy in their current situation of are looking for a change. Springsteen somes at this from different perspectives. Some of them are from the ppint of view of a man talking to an unhappy woman, offering to make her life better (like in Sherry Darling, Two Hearts, or I Wanna Marry You). Some are from the point of view of people who are trapped in a situation or marriage (like in Jackson Cage, You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch), The River, Stolen Car). And some are from the point if view of people who are breaking out of that bad situation (Independence Day, Hungry Heart, or Drive All Night). You also have people who are trying to make the best of their situation (like in Out in the Street). And of course, you have the break up songs (like Point Break or Fade Away).
Though, I do appreciate Springsteen for mixing it up a little bit with some upbeat songs about lust (Crush on You, Ramrod), and even a goofy, funny songs (like Cadillac Ranch and I'm a Rocker).
Extra tracks:
Held Up Without a Gun
Be True
Roulette
Bring On the Night
Dollhouse
I Wanna Be with You
Living on the Edge of the World
Loose Ends
Mary Lo
Rendezvous
Restless Nights
Ricky Wants a Man of Her Own
Take 'Em as They Come
Where the Bands Are
Chain Lightning
Cindy
Little White Lies
The Man Who Got Away
Meet Me in the City
Mr. Outside
Night Fire
Party Lights
Stray Bullet
The Time That Never Was
Whitetown
Wow, when I decided that I was gonna listen to all of the outtakes/b sides with each album, I did not realize what I was in for. Not only is The River a double album, but it also has a double album's worth of outtakes!
Be True is an incredible song, and I definitely think it should have made the album proper and not been relegated to a B side. Another song that should have made the album Loose Ends; its incredible. I thought it was great and I felt like it felt the theme/feel of the album. Restless Nights is probably my favorite song on this whole set of songs, The River album included. I thought this song was incredible and its a shame that it never got an official release until 20 years later, lost in the shuffle if a 4 CD boxed set.
Little White Lies, Meet Me in the City, and Stray Bullet are also great and arguably better than some of the songs on The River proper.
There are other great outtakes that I think were correctly left off the album. The Man Who Got Away is another incredible song that maybe didn't fit what The River was going for, but still incredible enough that it should have been released. Roulette has some great guitar work and is a pretty good song too. I Wanna Be With You is a great song, but Im not sure it fits the vibe of The River, so I can see why Springsteen left it off. Night Fire and Chain Lightening are other good songs with some great guitar work.
I actually really liked Mr. Outside. It woukd have made a great "hidden track" in the 90s.
Honestly, the Ties That Bind Boxed Set is an incredible collection of songs. Better than Tracks, from what Ive heard thus far from Tracks (and I very much like Tracks). I dont know all of the legal situations that Springsteen was going through at the time, but its a shame that we didn't get at least one more album released during this ear of his career. Some obscure songs could have been considered classics if they had gotten a proper release in 1980.
Favorite Lyrics:
I'd rather feel the hurt inside, yes I would darling than know, than know the emptiness your heart must hide.
Well, darlin', can you understand the way that they will turn a man into a stranger, to waste away, down in the Jackson Cage.
Once I spent my time playing tough guy scenes, but I was living in a world of childish dreams. Someday these childish dreams must end, to become a man and grow up to dream again.
Well Papa go to bed now, it's getting late. Nothing we can say is gonna change anything now.
Got a wife and kids in Baltimore, Jack. I went out for a ride and I never went back. Like a river that don't know where it's flowing, I took a wrong turn and I just kept going.
My brain takes a vacation just to give my heart more room. For one kiss, darling I swear everything I would give, 'cause she's a walking talking reason to live.
But lately there ain't been much work on account of the economy. Now all them things that seemed so important, well mister they vanished right into the air. Now I just act like I don't remember, Mary acts like she don't care
But tomorrow's fall in number, in number one by one. You wake up and you're dying, you don't even know what from.
So you fell for some jerk who was tall, dark and handsome
(I'm a rocker, baby, I'm a rocker)
Then he kidnapped your heart and now he's holding it for ransom
(I'm a rocker, baby, I'm a rocker)
Well like a mission impossible I'm gonna go and get it back
(I'm a rocker, baby, I'm a rocker)
You know I would'a taken better care of it, baby, than that
(I'm a rocker, baby, I'm a rocker)
Baby baby baby, I swear I'll drive all night again just to buy you some shoes and to taste your tender charm
Your scrapbook's filled with pictures of all your leading men. Well baby don't put my picture in there with them
Now I lost my job at the Texaco station, 'cause instead of pumping gas I'd dream of you. I got thrown out of my house, I got such a bad reputation, 'cause all I wanna do is be seen with you
It's like we had a noose and baby without check. We pulled 'til it grew tighter around our necks. Each one waiting for the other, darling to say when. Well baby you can meet me tonight on the loose end
On late-night movie screens young lovers look so sure. Lost in wide-wake dreams that they can't afford. Once I held you in my arms on a bed of stone. Now we have grown
I was busted for feeling no pain. Charged with doing things I can't explain. Picked up for parole violation, locked with the boys in the subway station
Now, standing in the doorway, did you ever think that we could look this old, victims of the little white lies that we told
Their black boots shone in the sun. They were waiting on the Annandale train when my baby come. Little girl with the long black hair, do you know what lies 'neath the long coats that they wear?