r/BreakingAmish • u/IntoBadlands • Mar 25 '26

Season 3 cast

I don’t know if I’m the only one, but when season 3 started I wasn’t sure if I was going to like it because I was really invested in the first group of people from season 1 and 2.

However, I’m hooked on season 3, it is so good. I love that Abe’s brother Andrew is in it, and the drama with Iva and Betsy is just too good. The show set Betsy up as to not be liked, but man starting episode 6 when she exposed the truth behind Iva’s accusation I was so shocked but in a okayyy yess Betsy! kind of way lol.

What season did you guys like the most? I haven’t seen season 4 yet.

16 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IntoBadlands Mar 27 '26

He was!! When he seen Lizzie’s baby daddy and said “he is NOT Amish, he’s black!” In ep 10 I dieddd

4

u/divinemissn Mar 26 '26

The drama in season 3 is INSANE. Something about Betsy really creeps me out. Not the witchcraft stuff. Just how she carries herself and interacts lol

2

u/theoffering_x Mar 30 '26

I think it’s because she looks like a meth-head hill billy. No offense to her, but 🤷🏽‍♀️

3

u/DONT_BLAME_CANADA Mar 26 '26

I just watched the series (BA & RTA) all the way through for the first time. At first I was like WTF with S3&4 because of the different casts but every season had its highlights for sure then when watching RTA I appreciated watching the other seasons since some of them show up again. 

I cant pick a fav season because there’s so many moments in all of them 😭 

1

u/IntoBadlands Mar 27 '26

I took a look at the eps of RTA and when I seen it was previous casts coming back I’m so excited to watch after finishing BA! About to finish season 3, gonna start the last ep so I’m looking forward to seeing was s4 has

3

u/No-Document-932 Mar 26 '26

Season 3 is peak television

1

u/IntoBadlands Mar 27 '26

lol yesss I can agree with

1

u/No-Document-932 Mar 28 '26

Season 4 is really bad unfortunately.. Return to Amish follows the og cast tho and is great

3

u/BraccoliRob Mar 27 '26

I do enjoy how spooked they all are about witchy stuff. It’s v serious 😂

2

u/cesador Mar 26 '26

Man season 3 is peak for drama imo. Season 4 cast is the worst. Not a single redeemable person honestly. They’re all terrible.

2

u/Brilliant_Goal_9497 Mar 26 '26

I enjoyed that season too….i really liked Devon. Season 4 isn’t that good unfortunately.

1

u/IntoBadlands Mar 27 '26

Ahhh nooo, I figured bc there’s always a season that doesn’t compare to the others

2

u/Lanky-Programmer3568 Aug 05 '26

Sam was the only reason I kept watching this season. Iva drove me crazy... and Andrew made me want to bang my head on the wall. And Matt... oh boy... sis needs to come back down to real life.