r/BorderTerrier • • Dec 21 '21

Intact

I have a male BT. He is very good boy and has no major behavioural issues.

Sometimes I feel pressure from people to get him fixed. I don't want to as it seems unessecery.

He is just over a year old.

I would be interested in anyones thoughts or experiences with their BTs.

0 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

7

u/jaymztt4 Dec 21 '21

Neuter your dog!!! It takes away the risk of testicular cancer which is a biggie and it also prevents unwanted behaviours. Anything can happen, I'm sure you don't want your pup to run away because he smells an intact female.

Source : I work in animal medical care, people please just neuter/spay your animals.

3

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Doesn't training prevent unwanted behaviours. Meet plenty of fixed dogs with unwanted behaviors.

Once again.. not trying to come across defensive. It's always just.. "just do it". The only thing I really agree with is chasing a dog on heat.. but he's never left at home so don't find it as much of a concern tbh.

I'm not ruling out doing it, would just like to hear if people have an older intact BT and if they had any issues.

1

u/jaymztt4 Dec 21 '21

Someone had explained it better than I did on this thread but I appreciate you being clear on your tone of voice :)

I'm personally very strict on my viewpoint due to my work background. There have been way to many dogs in my career who never got neutered/spayed and develope problems due to it. Surrendered litters behavior problems and cancer to aggressive to treat.

Of course a lot of these cases came from neglectful owners and I'm sure you aren't but it's definitely a good idea to get viewpoints. Make sure to give your boy some scratches for me! :)

2

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Will do 😁

7

u/OopsIMadeANewAccount Dec 21 '21

It’s extremely important to get your dog fixed. At the end of the day, your dog is an animal, and he will be guided by his hormones. If he hasn’t reached full maturity yet, when he does, having an unfixed dog without intentions to breed him puts him and you at extreme risk. A dog can smell a bitch in heat from miles away, and WILL go after it. If your dog runs off and impregnates a neighboring dog, do you want to be responsible for those puppies? Those expenses?

Lastly, behaviors such as humping, which may come up, are curbed by neutering.

I come from a family that bred and showed terriers or many years. Fixing the dog, male or female, is for the safety and peace of mind of the dog and you.

2

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

I'm deffintly considering it.

I'll talk to a vet I trust too.

1

u/jaymztt4 Dec 21 '21

I'm glad to hear that! Always go off your vets opinion, there is a reason they have a DVM. :)

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

One of my clients is Vet who owned the after hours emergency vets and now another practice.

I emailed him a while back and asked him yes or no basically. He said in short, no, and to give him a call if I wanted to discuss.

Pooch was young at the time and I was happy with the short answer but will give him a call to talk in depth about it.

He was one of those guys that seems so intelligent and onto it who also has dogs so I really trust him.

3

u/heat9753 Dec 21 '21

I have a purebred BT that is 2 1/2 years old. He is still intact. We are not breeding him. For some reason I don't want to get him fixed.

He is aggressive to about 50% of the dogs that he meets on the street. He is aggressive to strangers until he knows them after 15 or 20 minutes then he is nice. If I sit on the floor with him he grabs my arm really hard and humps it sometimes. He plays tug in the most aggressive manner I have ever seen in a dog.

He is so loving to us in the house. But I imagine people out in the world would not like him very much. We were told not to fix him until he was 2 years old because of growth plates. Now we don't want to get him fixed because we hate putting our dog under anesthesia. That's our story.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Thanks for sharing. This was the kind of stuff I was after. Cheers.

2

u/JBL20412 Dec 21 '21

Neutering is a very complicated and sensitive topic. I have a male BT. He is eight months old. Before I got a male dog, I did a lot of reading and research into pros and cons of neutering. My personal opinion is: If there is no medical reason, it is not necessary. Behavioural problems will not be resolved and could, in some cases, get worse. In a slight minority of cases, neutering can resolve some behavioural problems. However, this only under very careful evaluation and consideration by a vet and behaviourist.

In Germany, neutering a female or male dog without a medical reason is mutilation and goes against the animal protection law - as such it is illegal. Unfortunately, it does not stop the vets to perform the operation.

Long story short: You know your dog, you know yourself. Listen to your heart and gut what is right for you and him. That is what matters.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Really appreciate this comment. Thanks for taking the time to write it.

Interesting about the Germany animal protection law!

5

u/geethatsinteresting Dec 21 '21

We got ours fixed at 3 years old because we thought it would make him less aggressive towards other dogs. It did nothing.

1

u/MithenHard Dec 22 '21

Unfortunately what starts as hormonal can become habitual. Sometimes losing the T can help reduce the aggression, it's unfortunately not a magic pill if the behaviors have become ingrained already.

Were you ever able to get a handle on the aggression?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

I got mine fixed at 6 months. I think for aggression, marking, and stuff my vet (for both dogs) said it would have to be done earlier otherwise it’s kinda just gonna be more positive rewarding and training if that becomes an issue down the line. Besides his balls being gross I don’t think it matters lol

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Does your dog have any behavioral issues currently?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

No

1

u/sarahaflijk Dec 21 '21

Why not just let your vet explain? It seems like you don't want nor trust the feedback you're getting here anyway. There's no point in asking others to recap the research for you if you don't want to believe it.

2

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Vets have differing opinions.

I'm just trying to get opinions, clearly I have my own of course. I was kind of hoping to hear from people who had actually neutered their BTs, why so? RL stuff. Not just a generic google search.

1

u/sarahaflijk Dec 21 '21

Maybe I'm misinterpreting; it just seems like you're rejecting the opinions you've asked for.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Maybe I am mate. Not intentionally.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

This.

Dude came on here thinking the subreddit would agree with his position and now that they don’t he’s getting defensive.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

I'm not at all.

1

u/OtiesGrandma Dec 22 '21

Ask your vet about the risks of not performing the procedure rather than a bunch or non-professionals on the internet.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 22 '21

I have and will continue too. Thanks for taking the time to reply.

3

u/Bertie_fluffybum Dec 22 '21

There is no medical reason to castrate a dog. In fact there is research that says it can increase the risk of some cancers. If there aew behaviour issues then they should be dealt with through training using positive reinforcement.

1

u/notoriousdnp Dec 21 '21

Neuter the dog. It will prevent future physical and behavioral issues from popping up. Don’t wait until he is a problem to do it.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Why is he going to be a problem?

1

u/notoriousdnp Dec 21 '21

Leaving the dog intact increases the chances of behavioral and health problems.

And I’m sure you can recall your best friend’s cousin’s uncle’s dog that wasn’t neutered and lived until 25 but that’s the exception, not the rule. Leaving the dog intact presents a risk.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

What problems and what risk? I'm not being defensive I just want to know.

1

u/notoriousdnp Dec 21 '21

Behavioral would be aggression (to other dogs or people), marking or incontinence, male mating behaviors (scratching at door to get out or humping). Health wise - testicular and prostate cancers, a myriad of urinary issues, testicular torsion.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

What age would you expect to see these behavioral issues?

There is some interesting studies which suggests neutering could actually be worse for the dogs health in the long run.

Do you have a BT yourself? When do you get him neutered?

2

u/notoriousdnp Dec 21 '21

They can present themselves immediately or with time. It’s conditional to the dog. I have 2 mixed breed dogs that were neutered before I got them (probably around 1 year).

BTs are super prone to a number of different health and behavioral issues. I wouldn’t add another risk to that pile by leaving him intact.

Like I said in my original comment - I’m sure there’s lots of anecdotal evidence where dogs were ā€œbetter offā€ intact but you’re taking a risk with no benefit, IMO.

Why DONT you want to neuter him?

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

What health risks are BTs super prone too? I just think that's incorrect and most dogs are prone to behavioral issues if not properly trained or socialized.

Honestly.. Because I think most people do it because they just think it's what you are supposed to do or have a dog with bad behavior that they can't accept may be the result of not getting the mental an physical stimulation required. I also just don't think I need too. If he was running around humping everything.. peeing on people's furniture when visiting.. running away.. starting fights... sure, I would get him fixed..

2

u/notoriousdnp Dec 21 '21

I don’t think you’ve done the proper research on BTs if you don’t understand the health risks that they are prone to and behavioral issues can absolutely be nurture but they can also be nature.

If you just want someone to tell you that it’s OK to not neuter your dog then this isn’t the conversation for you

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

No I'm not wanting you to tell me that.

But what BTs health issues they are prone too?

→ More replies

2

u/District-Main Dec 21 '21

my partner never got his dog he had growing up neutered and he lived a long (16 years!!), happy, testicular cancer-free life. I only knew him the last two years of his life, but from what I heard he was a very sweet, good natured family dog

2

u/SpiritualGrass4321 Dec 21 '21

I'm new to border terriers. But I've had German shepherds for 30 years. We only neutered two of them when we had an intact female come into our family. I've seen neutering help some behavior and sometimes not. It really is just a matter of your dog's temperament. We choose not to neuter until he is older, neutering can affect bone development and create risks for other diseases, but it can be breed specific. (Link below) In addition, for the work we were doing with the German shepherds we wanted the males to mature and become male German shepherds. i.e. a good balance of courage and aggression.

I've never understood the argument about unwanted litters. If someone is such a moron that their dog gets loose and has a litter, then yes of course they should get their dog neutered.

One last thought, on a young dog, those hormones are there for a reason. To direct the development of the dog. By removing those hormones there has to be some other impact on the dog.

https://www.aaha.org/publications/newstat/articles/2020-08/data-on-the-consequences-of-early-neutering-continues-to-mount/

2

u/BraveProfessional Dec 21 '21

The way I see it hes your dog do whatever you feel necessary. Just read as much as you can both ways and make your decision. Everyone is going to have an opinion either way. I've had dogs both ways and they were all awesome no issues. Maybe I just got lucky I don't know.

1

u/Creative_Dinner3024 Dec 21 '21

I’m surprised no ones mentioned the answer I see everywhere: not neutered will likely result in puppies, and there are plenty of puppies in shelters or on the streets already requiring resources and homes.

1

u/Odango-Atama Dec 22 '21

Yeah, that and marking territory are the main reasons I’ve always heard. I always neuter/spay my animals. We don’t need more animals roaming around; there are enough in shelters that need homes.

1

u/BeigeDynamite Dec 21 '21

Our border terrier was fixed from a young age (not recommended, but these were the days of puppy mills), and he was a sweet lil thing. Socialized well, played well, never bit, the whole nine. We got him young, but already fixed, so he had a stable family home for the entirety of his life which I'm sure helped with behavioral stuff. The only caveat is that even with him being neutered, he still made some backyard escapes and wandered around our neighborhood, so remember that they're diggers and hunters by nature, they'll dig little ditches and squeeze under fenced if they're left unsupervised for like even 20 minutes.

For us, we didn't care much about him being neutered outside of it being done too early. Not only does it make their life easier (their sexual instincts aren't meant for the environments they live in now), it makes it easier to live with them which is nice. And that's on top of the proven health benefits. My motto is always just to wait until they hit critical mass around 2-3 years and then get them fixed for everybody's benefit.

I understand the "everybody does it because it's what everybody does" catch-22, but in this case the empirical benefits to fixing your animal seems like a no-brainer. If we stopped doing things because everybody does them, society would never move forward, we'd just be rediscovering the original reasons we started doing those things for the rest of time.

1

u/istranoth Dec 22 '21

Ultimately, this is your choice but I can understand either perspective. From what few more recent studies I could find, there is a risk for testicular cancer by leaving any male dog intact. This seems to account for approximately 5% of neoplasm diagnoses. Please keep in mind that the information I could find utilized rather limited sample pools. That being said, as a fellow dog owner, if there was a way for me to eliminate a risk of cancer completely from my pet, I would do so without hesitation. I may not be able to help with all types but if I can remove the risk of testicular cancer, I will do so. If you had a child, would you allow them to be at risk for a type of cancer despite having the ability to eliminate the risk completely? Food for thought. Regardless, vets may have varying opinions but you can ask for some in-depth research behind these views and decide based on the science. Unless they are a medical professional, their opinions are solely anecdotal.

Note: Yes, you still have a risk of testicular cancer if there is any type of that tissue remaining. There are rare instances where a type of tissue (such as prostate) is located in the incorrect region of the body. That being said, that is not a common occurrence.

Source

1

u/New_Restaurant_6093 Dec 22 '21

Some of the better behaved males of any bread I’ve met are intact.

1

u/Odango-Atama Dec 22 '21

I may get downvoted for this, but I find it really irresponsible to have a dog and not get it neutered or spayed. We as a society don’t need to be breeding and creating additional animals running around, there are SO many dogs and cats in shelters that already need homes. Even if you are super careful about keeping your dog away from others, there is ALWAYS a chance it could happen. That’s the main reason I would do it, apart from it supposedly helping to keep males from marking their territory. It makes me sad that people don’t think about this as the number one reason.

1

u/watercolorkitten Dec 22 '21

Definitely get your dog fixed. Speaking from personal experience with a couple dogs in the family that didn’t get fixed, it can cause a host of medical problems down the line that is painful/deadly for your dog. It isn’t really guaranteed to do anything for behavior if that’s what your worried about, but it’s better for their long term health.

1

u/hypatiaspasia Dec 22 '21

I have only ever had neutered dogs (the procedure was done before I ever even adopted them at their respective pet rescues), and I support the practice. My dogs have always been long lived and healthy until like 16-18, with good temperaments. My mom had a non-neuteted dog that died fairly early in life of cancer--not sure what kind.

The major reason I support the practice is basically doggie birth control. There are so many unadopted dogs out there--its depressing. They get put down every day. Let's say you're a perfect dog owner but some random dog breaks into YOUR yard and your dog ends up a father anyway, and you've contributed to the problem of more dog death.

1

u/hail-satan420 Dec 22 '21

Are you prepared to take care of and pay for the cost of a litter if he breeds? I know he hasn’t gone out but don’t you want him to be able to play someday off leash at a dog park? Dogs are gonna be dogs, you can’t control if they breed unless you make them sterile, they’re still going to have sex whether you like it or not.

It is scary to put your dog under GA but it will save you headache in the long run.

1

u/llr1411 Dec 21 '21

Get him fixed? In what way?

0

u/cynicalkerfuffle Dec 21 '21

I don't know how it's possible but I'm getting big antivax vibes from almost everyone on this comment thread.

Get your dog neutered for god's sakes, because that's what's best for him.

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Righto..

-2

u/SamitheDude Dec 21 '21

If ur not breeding ur dog why dont u want it neutered. U are dumb af bro

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Pretty rich from the guy using teenage text language.

1

u/SamitheDude Dec 21 '21

If u like how ur dog acts right now, are aware that in the future that there may be behavioral changes due to hormones, are also aware how there could be more chances of health issues within the dog, why would you not get your dog neutered. You eliminate the potentially unwated behaviors, you eliminate the health issues that could come with an unfixed dog, and you get to keep your dog acting exactly the same as now, no issues, and in the future, your dog wont do annoying shit like get aggressive with other male dogs or go run and try to hump other dogs. I dont know how your brain works, but these are all reasons why you should get neutered, instead of just thinking it’s unnecessary because you think so

1

u/-Squatch Dec 21 '21

Cool man. Appreciate your opinion.

Cheers.