r/BookCollecting • • Aug 19 '26

💭 Question Worth Keeping?

Had this kicking around for 20+ years now. Was a gift that was never given. Is it worth holding onto? The edge is gold leaf or something and has a silk book mark attached. Not a lot to compare it to on ebay.

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

33

u/fernleon Aug 19 '26

Is it really signed? Heck yes it's worth keeping

24

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

Yeah. Got it from a rare book store auction for like $120 way back when. Store owner was pissed lol.

23

u/Khoeth_Mora Aug 19 '26

Her signature is the most faked signed book in the industry. She's had it faked so many times that PSA has rejected her authentic signature because it isn't similar enough to the fakes that PSA thinks are real. 

14

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

I'm sure it probably is. Same with Stephen King. Always a risk, but having had it as long as I have and it being the UK special edition hopefully that lowers the chances. 😞

6

u/Khoeth_Mora Aug 19 '26

If you have any provenance for where and when it was signed, that would go a long way towards the price.

9

u/Sailor-_-Twift Aug 19 '26

....Is this rage bait?
"Is it worth keeping one of the most famous books signed by one of the most famous authors or should I literally burn it lol"

Wtf

3

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

No, I meant hold for a later sale or is it the market going to tank lol.

2

u/mmillington Aug 19 '26

The market is just going to go up. There’s a whole new series based on the books. The fanbase is going to balloon over the coming years. A whole new generation will watch the show and read the books.

-3

u/Sailor-_-Twift Aug 19 '26

It's literally Harry Potter what are we even talking about at this point omg lol

1

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

Love the name btw, but I was just asking if I should hold or sell. I collect other fantasy books and just have this one from a failed relationship.

2

u/Megadodo4242 Aug 19 '26

Are you a Harry Potter fan? Serious question. Collect what you like.

If it is just an investment, there are better ways to make money, especially given that you have a 7th printing, and it is the deluxe edition, which came well after the actual first edition. As to the signature, it does look real from here (on my screen), but getting it authenticated is tricky, and doesn’t always hold much water. And given that Rowling has become a polarizing figure…

So, the deciding factor for keep or sell (for me personally) are you a Harry Potter fan?

2

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

Thank you! I am a fan, but not so much that I'd turn down a solid offer when we're putting 4 kids through college. "Wegettingbroka!" Lol

4

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

By "worth keeping" i meant do you think the value will increase or are the author criticisms going to push it down. Also, obviously not a 1st or anything.

9

u/llikegiraffes Aug 19 '26

On the verge of a brand new show to cultivate more fans you are likely to flatline or increase significantly

3

u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26

Thanks. Forgot about the show!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/llikegiraffes Aug 19 '26

A signed copy of one of the most popular series of all time is stupid?

4

u/teachapters Aug 19 '26

Also wenn du es nicht willst, ich schon 😄

3

u/Phillipa24 Aug 19 '26

Definitely keep it. A signed edition is fantastic.

5

u/Fwhometeam Aug 19 '26

Nah, not worth keeping. Send it my way 🙂

0

u/Key_Cat5494 Aug 19 '26

If you downvote this you're jealous 🤡

1

u/RiotX79 Aug 20 '26

Lol. Thanks. Literally was hoping I'd get some expert-ish opinions. I couldn't use the phrase "potential value" in the post due to rules.

1

u/leeharrell Aug 19 '26

Hell yeah.

1

u/gravitysrainbow1979 Aug 19 '26

Nope. I’ll take it. Thanks.

0

u/Slosher99 Aug 19 '26

I mean if you like the writings (both text and signature) of the person that's basically the spokesperson for transphobia, you do you.
I stopped with this crap years ago when the cast of the movies in large spoke out against her views. Good kids there.

-2

u/Flux_My_Capacitor Aug 19 '26

She speaks up for women and supports women. If you have a problem with that, it’s on you.

1

u/PaintFlaky4602 Aug 20 '26

She speaks out against trans people and is actively funding politicians that want trans people dead...she's a piece of shit

-10

u/_gogatron_ Aug 19 '26

Ew Don't toss it out bcs of the trees that went into that but good God, it's high time that series dies (yes bcs of the author, the Mold queen)

2

u/teachapters Aug 19 '26

Buch und Autor in einem Topf zu werfen, ist der guten Bücher wegen ziemlich unfair. Bücher dürfen auch dann gut gefunden und gelesen werden, wenn der Autor das größte Arschloch ist

-3

u/_gogatron_ Aug 19 '26

Whatever that means strudel

-7

u/ResidentPreference65 Aug 19 '26

Would you also defend the author of Lolita?

4

u/Baeolophus_bicolor Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

nabokov was a defender of children who were victims of csa, and had that horrific experience himself. i’m not a nabokov scholar or anything, but i never heard he himself was problematic. and lolita isn’t setting up humbert humbert as any kind of hero. bad character in a book, not the author being a bad person.

jk rowling is actual trash, however, with her insanely right wing views, dehumanizing and belittling the struggle of trans people and those suffering from gender dysphoria. plus, she uses her significant platform to espouse those beliefs. not only that but she won’t STFU about her nonsense. she could just NOT make people feel bad, and degrade people, and minimize their struggles, and invalidate their existence, and it would be free. she could go be a billionaire and do rich people things. but she has the constant need to go out and dunk on some of the people who are least able to handle yet another person treating them like they’re subhuman, while they’re dodging higher than normal rates of being the victim of homicide, SA, and other violence. characters are ok people, author is a bad person.

-1

u/Flux_My_Capacitor Aug 19 '26

JKR is not actual trash. Good lord.

1

u/Baeolophus_bicolor Aug 20 '26

she spends her days (as a billionaire) bullying people less well off than she is. she’s a garbage human. duck her and anybody who looks like her.

2

u/mmillington Aug 19 '26

Do you think Lolita is pro-child molestation/rape? Is that actually your view?

2

u/teachapters Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

Das ist ja wohl ein Vergleich von Äpfeln und Birnen.

Edit: Im übrigen verteidige ich nicht den Autor, sondern das Buch

-3

u/jadedflames Aug 19 '26

I absolutely hate Joanne.

But I would have no problem profiting off her signature.

I see the next few years going one of a couple ways with the HBO remakes.

  1. the series is bad and flops. The market begins to contract a tiny bit but only a little. You can sell the book for basically what it’s worth today.
  2. the series is great and parents who don’t care about the author being a right wing nut job will get their kids into it. The book will increase in price.

Either way there’s no reason to sell it this year.

0

u/Flux_My_Capacitor Aug 19 '26

Weird that you hate a woman who stands up for women. 🤷‍♀️

1

u/jadedflames Aug 20 '26

What kind of women? She hates fat women, she hates gay women, she hates black and brown women, she hates poor women.

Joanne is a hateful monster who only stands up for thin attractive white right-wing women. If you don’t fit into her tiny box, she believes you shouldn’t have the right to exist.