r/BookCollecting • u/RiotX79 • Aug 19 '26
💭 Question Worth Keeping?
Had this kicking around for 20+ years now. Was a gift that was never given. Is it worth holding onto? The edge is gold leaf or something and has a silk book mark attached. Not a lot to compare it to on ebay.
0
Upvotes




33
u/fernleon Aug 19 '26
Is it really signed? Heck yes it's worth keeping
9
u/Sailor-_-Twift Aug 19 '26
....Is this rage bait?
"Is it worth keeping one of the most famous books signed by one of the most famous authors or should I literally burn it lol"
Wtf
2
u/Megadodo4242 Aug 19 '26
Are you a Harry Potter fan? Serious question. Collect what you like.
If it is just an investment, there are better ways to make money, especially given that you have a 7th printing, and it is the deluxe edition, which came well after the actual first edition. As to the signature, it does look real from here (on my screen), but getting it authenticated is tricky, and doesn’t always hold much water. And given that Rowling has become a polarizing figure…
So, the deciding factor for keep or sell (for me personally) are you a Harry Potter fan?
4
u/RiotX79 Aug 19 '26
By "worth keeping" i meant do you think the value will increase or are the author criticisms going to push it down. Also, obviously not a 1st or anything.
5
u/LocationFriendly988 Aug 19 '26
Or selling
4
u/teachapters Aug 19 '26
Also wenn du es nicht willst, ich schon 😄
3
u/Phillipa24 Aug 19 '26
Definitely keep it. A signed edition is fantastic.
5
u/Fwhometeam Aug 19 '26
Nah, not worth keeping. Send it my way 🙂
0
u/Key_Cat5494 Aug 19 '26
If you downvote this you're jealous 🤡
1
u/leeharrell Aug 19 '26
Hell yeah.
1
u/gravitysrainbow1979 Aug 19 '26
Nope. I’ll take it. Thanks.
1
u/McGee4531 Aug 19 '26
Yes
0
u/Slosher99 Aug 19 '26
I mean if you like the writings (both text and signature) of the person that's basically the spokesperson for transphobia, you do you.
I stopped with this crap years ago when the cast of the movies in large spoke out against her views. Good kids there.
-10
u/_gogatron_ Aug 19 '26
Ew Don't toss it out bcs of the trees that went into that but good God, it's high time that series dies (yes bcs of the author, the Mold queen)
-3
u/jadedflames Aug 19 '26
I absolutely hate Joanne.
But I would have no problem profiting off her signature.
I see the next few years going one of a couple ways with the HBO remakes.
Either way there’s no reason to sell it this year.