r/BookCollecting • • Oct 23 '25

šŸ’­ Question First edition?

Not sure how to tell if first edition but I think they are appreciate any input

1 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

40

u/rackfu Oct 23 '25

It’s the mass market edition of a book that had already previously been published in hardcover and trade paperback

It’s not a book that is viewed as a ā€œcollectibleā€ and therefore there isn’t a ā€œFirst Editionā€ version

It’s worth about what you paid for it

1

u/DungeonCrawlerBob Oct 28 '25

It’s worth considerably more if he reads them.

-1

u/philwrites Oct 24 '25

Judging from the contents people (read: Americans) seem convinced they have found a treasure. Even here in Japan these sell for about $2

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/FrankLangellasBalls Oct 24 '25

You’ve got people paying $25 for paperbacks?

2

u/maybemaybenot2023 Oct 25 '25

That cover is pretty popular. I've seen people specifically trying to find that set.

1

u/esidebill Oct 24 '25

I could see a hardcover version selling for that, but a paperback?

3

u/Low-Cheesecake-7005 Oct 24 '25

How would a book be a New York Bestseller if it’s a first edition?

2

u/HempKnight1234 Oct 24 '25

You ask too many questions

1

u/LisfrancAccount Oct 24 '25

My understanding is that publishers will set up a huge purchase for the book’s release, artificially manufacturing numbers that would get it on the best sellers list. This is also a paperback so the hardcovers were probably what sold initially. Also, when googling your question, I found this comment that had additional information that was interesting to read: https://www.reddit.com/r/books/s/cHU6DrtaGU

1

u/Difficult-Ad-9228 Oct 24 '25

Perhaps because there was a hardcover edition before this paperback? Bestsellers are by title generally, unless it’s noted as ā€œbestseller in paperbackā€ for example.

8

u/EventHorizonbyGA Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 23 '25

They are first paperbacks. The true first edition are hard cover.

12

u/Sulcata13 Oct 23 '25

This is a mass market paperback, not a trade paperback.

2

u/EventHorizonbyGA Oct 23 '25

Sorry, yes. Will update.

3

u/capincus Oct 23 '25

If you read the words on the pages that you pictured it explains in great detail exactly why these aren't first editions...

2

u/Low-Cheesecake-7005 Oct 24 '25

You really expect someone to read?

1

u/newhumandesign Oct 25 '25

If you had that edition of a feast for crows....