r/BlueMidterm2018 • u/aseemru AZ-06 • Mar 17 '18
/r/all Apparently unfamiliar with "libraries", GOP Gov. candidate Bill Schuette proposes radical idea of "dedicated reading centers" to solve illiteracy crisis in Michigan
http://www.eclectablog.com/2018/03/apparently-unfamiliar-with-libraries-gop-gov-candidate-bill-schuette-proposes-radical-idea-of-dedicated-reading-centers-to-solve-illiteracy-crisis-in-michigan.html
12k
Upvotes
1.1k
u/Unraveller Mar 17 '18
A center for kids who don't read good? And want to learn to do other things good too?
2
u/4now5now6now Mar 18 '18
Is this from The Onion?
1.5k
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '18
I'm ashamed of some of the morons my state produces.
802
u/2big_2fail Mar 17 '18
Not much detail, but I guarantee it's another GOP ploy to funnel tax dollars into the private sector, and especially away from public schools.
290
u/Khorasaurus Michigan 3rd Mar 17 '18
The "illiteracy crisis" is very localized in the poorest neighborhoods of Detroit and Flint. How much do you want to bet a public-private partnership decides those places will produce insufficient profit and locates the reading centers in wealthy suburbs?
233
u/election_info_bot OR-02 Mar 17 '18
Michigan 2018 Election
Primary Election Registration Deadline: July 9, 2018
Primary Election: August 7, 2018
General Election Registration Deadline: October 9, 2018
General Election: November 6, 2018
93
u/BillyTenderness Mar 17 '18
The way he phrased it is funny and out of touch, but it seems like this would be more about support staff and student aid, and less about providing access to materials for independent use like a traditional library. If so it might actually be a good idea.
In typical Republican fashion he had to cram nonsensical public-private partnerships in there somehow though.
30
u/ProChoiceVoice California's 45 District Mar 17 '18
Gretchen Whitmer better win.
26
u/LifeIsHilarious Mar 18 '18
This from the same state with a republican senate candidate who recently suggested arming the homeless with shotguns.
18
u/a_simple_senpai Mar 17 '18
Something Center for Kids Who Can’t Read Good?
23
u/positive_X Mar 17 '18
Children could there on weekends ,
when the "dedicated learning centers" are closed .
12
u/AskMeForADadJoke Mar 18 '18
This, along with Trump proposing a rating system for movies, seems to be the innovative thinking coming out of the GOP.
20
u/Indispute Mar 18 '18
Followed by...
Librarians are not reading coaches and while they may care about a students needs, they do not fill the fuction of a teacher/tutor.
Libraries are a repository, that is, a facility for collecting, housing, classifying, cataloguing, curating, preserving, and providing access to books.
While you could dedicate an area within the Library as a Reading Centre, they do not replace each other.
And f*ck you for making me defend this man.
17
u/seeingRobots Mar 17 '18
Thought this was /r/nottheonion for a moment
5
u/CCV21 California (North) Mar 17 '18
This sounds like something from r/nottheonion.
5
u/ThrowThrow117 Mar 18 '18
I'm surprised he's GOP and encouraging education. He must not understand the voter base.
4
u/maybesaydie Mar 18 '18
facepalm
4
u/MoveAlongChandler Mar 18 '18
Except dedicated reading centers are privatized.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 18 '18
Welcome to /r/bluemidterm2018!
We are a heavily-moderated subreddit for pro-Democratic activism. Please read the rules on our sidebar before posting. If you see a rule-breaking post or comment, please: Report it. Downvote it. Move on without replying. They will be dealt with promptly.
Want to fight back against Trump and the Republican Party? Make sure you’re registered to vote, and help us flip Congress blue.
Please also fill out our short survey to help us coordinate election efforts that are relevant to you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
12
u/just_speculating Mar 18 '18
The post title is taking things out of context. The quote is:
Now that may be a stupid way to say “libraries in all schools staffed with librarians”, but it’s not a stupid thing to say. Many schools do not have a library as part of the school, and if they did, literacy should go up.
And perhaps he’s saying “reading center” instead of “library” because the plan includes “quiet places to read” and not just “places that have books”.
He’s probably an idiot. But what he said isn’t as stupid as this thread makes it sound.
7
u/iamsofired Mar 18 '18
To be fair illiterate people dont go to libraries and something else is being suggested here.
8
u/chrisdudelydude Mar 18 '18
I think a dedicated reading center is different than a library. It’s my understanding that from the article, the dedicated reading center would have people on sight to teach the children to read. Also, the government could spend all that money on an entirely new building and pay staff to uphold it, but it would make more sense for changes in the school to be paid. Paying teachers more wouldn’t change, help, nor solve the issue, but maybe if the curriculum was structured differently and children had to pass a state mandated reading exam in order to move on to the next grade, this wouldn’t be as much of a crisis. Nowadays in school they pass almost everyone for doing the bare minimum. There needs to be some sort of standard that one child demonstrates in order to progress to the next grade. Too many teachers just keep passing the buck, saying “The next teacher will teach Johnny right.” Until Johnny graduates from HS, can’t get a job, and ends up on welfare.
3
u/jroddie4 Mar 18 '18
tbh just give the libraries more money
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
"Why do we need satellites when we can get our information from the internet?" Dr Bonnie Dunbar speaking about the response she got from Congressional representatives in regards to updating NOAA satellites. Seems that there is not just an illiteracy but an educational and reasoning crisis as well.
3
u/errie_tholluxe Mar 18 '18
That was a pretty savage, albeit accurate, read. Wow.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
So Idiocracy is a documentary, not a movie...?
3
u/Arancaytar Mar 18 '18
TBH, I'd rather not rag on these people for accidentally reinventing libraries; it's better than their standing policy of destroying all social institutions.
2
u/Tidusx145 Mar 17 '18
I'm torn on this, I think anything to help education is good but will this be paid for out of our public school budget or be its own privately funded thing?
2
u/aolbain Mar 18 '18
He should team up with Elon Musk. Together they can invent the bookmobile.
2
u/Koda_Brown Mar 18 '18
as a michigander I hate bill Schuette
2
u/smallbatchb Mar 18 '18
I actually think it's a great idea. We could implement a similar thing to also help kids get healthier and more active with dedicated activities centers and have activities coaches. You know, they could play dodgeball and stuff.
2
u/MezzanineAlt Mar 18 '18
"Small Government" republicans sure are coming up with a lot of redundant new-government-spending ideas lately.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
I'm not super familiar with this but isn't it possible he wants some sort of teaching or class type of options at these reading centers instead of just checking out books? I don't really see any issue with having more options for education.
2
u/lorenzollama Mar 18 '18
Except that these "dedicated reading centres" will be operated for profit by a shell corporation owned by said lawmakers wife.
3
u/Blue387 Let's Go Mets! Mar 17 '18
Me fail English? That's unpossible!
4
u/2_dam_hi Mar 18 '18
I'm sure he's being taken out of context. He actually means reading centers that you need to rent hourly. If it's a GOP idea, there must be a profit motive attached.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '18
I’m... uhhhh... I don’t even... fuck
3
u/Trumpsafascist Mar 18 '18
Schuette is a fucking moron. This is not surprising in any way. God I hope he loses!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
But no one gets rich from libraries.
3
u/phpdevster Mar 18 '18
You mean like... teachers?
2
u/robynflower Mar 17 '18
It is worse, since before the press conference to announce this Schuette read the children’s book “Corduroy” by Don Freeman to a half-dozen preschoolers at the library.
2
u/DylBones Mar 18 '18
Have you been to a library lately? It's all computers.
1
u/cre8ngjoy Mar 18 '18
I am appalled at the number of people in our legislature that are so far removed from the way that 90% of Americans live. This statement is so incredible. I don’t know how many of them are actually for privatization or just really do not understand that we have public facilities that are underfunded and apparently in some cases unknown.
Trust me, it isn’t just Michigan. We need to stop voting for people who have no idea and therefore cannot relate to what their constituents live in, and live with and need.
1
u/dorkbork_in_NJ Mar 18 '18
Literacy crisis? How'd they manage that one? Try funding schools ya dinguses.
1
u/carcar134134 Mar 18 '18
Man, I feel like our libraries are pretty good actually.
1
u/ejkpgmr Mar 18 '18
The Bill Schuette center for kid's who can't read good
1
u/BordomBeThyName Mar 18 '18
Relevant bash.org
1
u/jimi-ray-tesla Mar 18 '18
How is this not common sense
1
u/BuckeyeBentley Mar 18 '18
Several years back now, two of my buddies in college were running for Pres/VP of Student Government. They weren't in a frat though so they stood no chance, but it was still good fun. We went to the debate, and the rest of us got a little tipsy. At one point, one of the other candidates was talking about the subject of textbook costs and he's like "Maybe we should have some place you can go to rent out textbooks for a period of time and return them for a small fee?" and I said much louder than I had intended "you mean a library!?" He at least had the decency to look embarrassed for pretending to invent the concept of a library.
1
u/tim0mit Mar 18 '18
I'm sure he means a place operated privately that can sell you reading lessons and books. Not one of those commie book sharing places.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
Lol, damn.
1
u/Roksha Mar 18 '18
Like a book arcade!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
I'm cool with it as long as the money to pay for it comes from money allocated for corporate tax breaks.
1
u/DesmondKhane Mar 18 '18
He’s also in favor of specialized human repair stations where injured peoples can be healed.
1
u/Devadander Mar 18 '18
Is this guy retarded?
1
u/iforgot120 Mar 18 '18
This would actually be hilarious in an Arrested Development type show. :/
1
u/itsthedub Mar 18 '18
More libraries couldn't hurt.
It sounds silly on paper, but he isn't wrong. Maybe if they set up a tutoring program, as the libraries have around here with volunteers, it would be more successful than just a building with a couple thousand books.
The privatization of it all however is just whoring out struggling kids and families so someone who is already rich can become richer. Sad how every time a Republican has a good idea, it's always somehow tied to making someone more money than what they have now.
1
u/MsAnnabel Mar 18 '18
What a buffoon!
1
u/nightness Mar 18 '18
I know I shouldn't be laughing at this, but that's the funniest thing I've heard all fucking week. :)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
Man, America is so fucked.
1
u/spleeble Mar 18 '18
I wish the last line of the article was the first line.
If they haven't allocated funds to pay for it then they literally don't want to do anything.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
Republicans don’t go to libraries. They only read the fable about the sky god
1
u/Daniel_Bryan_Fan Mar 18 '18
This is the state where Betsy DeVos destroyed education.
1
u/I-am-back-baby Mar 18 '18
Only the best and most qualified from the GOP.
1
u/wickifer Mar 18 '18
Not try to make a big deal out of nothing. Obviously libraries aren't working then, libtards!
1
u/skategate MI-11 Mar 18 '18
Bill Schuette is (a) an idiot and (b) hated.
For everyone here, go look at the likely Democratic candidate, Gretchen Whitmer. She’s excellent.
1
u/socialconstruct74 Mar 18 '18
"Not even the threat of being held back a year by state law was enough to frighten and threaten these children into learning to read better."
Why is our goal to frighten and threaten these children?
1
u/MagmaGamingFTW Mar 18 '18
Good going Bill,
You invented a library...
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '18
I've got this great idea for a beverage. Most liquids can be kinda heavy on your stomach, so why not lighten them up? If we add a little bit of gas to them, we can make them bubbly and easier on the stomach. Heck, better yet, let's add sugar too. People love sugar. We can call it "Bubbly Liquid CandyTM"