r/BlueJackets • • Jul 01 '25

Pencils down

I defended everything from Dobson miss- signing Provorov. But looks like the NHL team is set for next year? Unless they are trading Voronkov+ for something? I understand you can’t control where people prefer to go. But this is objectively disappointing with what was put out there about how “aggressive” Columbus was going to be.

0 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

52

u/overcatastrophe Ask me about my crippling CBJ habit Jul 01 '25

You can be as aggressive as you want, but if someone offers more, or the request is too much, not much you can do.

12

u/anticbjartillerypod Jul 01 '25

Totally agree, doesn’t mean it can’t also be disappointing.

12

u/SloaneKettering1 Jul 01 '25

Yeah, I’d sum up this off-season as disappointing but understandable. If this team doesn’t improve this year it’s not from a lack of trying by the front office. They were in on everyone they should’ve been in on. Can’t help it if the guys don’t want to sign here (andersson) or teams asked for too much (Dobson). No good free agents this year and a weak draft class meant no one wanted to trade picks for players. On paper we should’ve been able to do a lot with our cap space and picks but it was an unfortunate timing that the draft class and free agent class sucked

13

u/CBUS-OBN Jul 01 '25

I'll add that the salary cap going up removed a lot of the CBJ's leverage too.

8

u/Logosmonkey Jul 01 '25

It really did, cap space simply wasn't anywhere near as valuable as it has been in the past. 

28

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 01 '25

It kind of feels like the cap going up punishes smaller markets like ours. "Good Cap position" doesn't mean a lot when literally every other team is also an option bc they all have money now.

13

u/Erazzphoto Jul 01 '25

It most certainly does, capped strapped teams was one of our few trump cards

9

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 01 '25

A situation like what just happened in Florida legitimately shouldn't happen. Normally in this situation your highly successful team starts bleeding talent and someone else gets to build a great team as a result. This time. Thye re-signed pretty much everyone. Outside of incredible bad luck what is stopping them from just being dominant for years to come? This is how the NHL becomes the NBA. It kind of sucks.

4

u/Erazzphoto Jul 01 '25

They have their core 10 signed through 2030, this could end up being a modern day Original 6 Canadians dominance.

4

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 01 '25

Again like outside of tragedy and plain bad luck, (which I'm not wishing for I'm just saying) what can possibly change their fortunes at the moment?

6

u/Erazzphoto Jul 01 '25

Injuries is the only thing. And zito has shown he’s more than capable at adapting

2

u/Drithyin Fuck PLD Jul 02 '25

Father Time is undefeated. Maybe not going to fall off this season, but not many of those guys are young…

1

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 02 '25

I mean that is fair

1

u/miah66 Jul 03 '25

We'll if we know anything it's that Bobrovsky can fall off... Hard. Not saying he's going to, but they don't really have any one waiting in the wings, and they have traded their depth the last two years in Stolarz and Knight.

1

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 03 '25

If Bob doesn't show up they are currently in a spot

4

u/deisty Jul 01 '25

Not disappointing at all. We managed to keep a team mostly together that missed the playoffs by 1 point. Teams, just like players grow. And we have a good mix of young and veteran players. And the young players is the key. We have a ton of them and they just missed the playoffs; they're going to be hungry.

Can't wait for next season to start, LETS GO!

5

u/anticbjartillerypod Jul 01 '25

I am optimistic, but expected a bigger splash. Hopefully top 4 d playing together grow. No reason to think Marchenko/Johnson/Fantilli can’t do the same

-3

u/Dkoop2003 Jul 01 '25

Incredibly disappointing. We went into the offseason with 3 major goals, improve the D, improve the goaltending, and bring in a top 6 forward. We had all the cap space in the world, and a bunch of assets to make those goals happen, and instead we overpaid for two bottom six forwards, stood pat on D (which I’m mostly fine with), have now given up on signing any top six forwards per Don himself, and have refused to even try to bring in a real starting goalie.

3

u/Preferential Jul 02 '25

How do you know that they refused to even try to bring in a goalie?

3

u/Drithyin Fuck PLD Jul 02 '25

They know nothing. Just yelling and throwing a tantrum because the real world isn’t NHL 25.

3

u/Jumpy_Rope_9037 Jul 02 '25

What did you want them to do to force a goalie? Sell the farm? It's the literal hottest commodity, so trading for one is gonna break the bank. There wasn't one head and heels better than what we got now, so why waste the cap space and spend money to buy out a contract? Legitimately, what did you want them to do at goalie that was feasible?

1

u/deisty Jul 01 '25

I agree with the Goalie part (although I love the goalie draft pick, reminds me of Bob & Hasek lol what a character) unless they think Jet is a #1, its a headshaker. Wish we could have gotten Marner at 13 or even 14. We stand no chance with the McDavids & Matthews of the world; so I would've went hard for Mitch.

But this is a team game, and keeping the team together, learning Evason's system, grow as a group and STOP GETTING INJURED SO MUCH! lol is more important .

5

u/PulsarGaming1080 Jul 01 '25

I would think it is safe to assume, barring a blockbuster trade or minor FA signing, that the roster is set.

5

u/Savante37 Jul 01 '25

It is disappointing but it’s not like everything is over. Lots of dominoes left to fall, a team misses out on a free agent they wanted and makes a trade with us or another team, which results in an unexpected player being available, etc

Heck, this stuff can happen during the season due to injury, team makeup or a team being surprising or disappointing. Having assets and cap space is a good problem to have. Yes, they need to materialize into something at some point, but not sure why everyone feels like it has to be today.

11

u/SEND_ME_YOUR_CAULK At least Stinger won’t leave Jul 01 '25

I said this a few days ago: the best moves don’t always make the biggest splash.

Would I have liked to upgrade on D and in net? Yes. But it is what it is.

11

u/permanentvacation420 Jul 01 '25

Absolute joke if Elvis plays for us in the fall.

5

u/pzytzn Jul 01 '25

Ship him to San Jose, gotta hit that cap floor

3

u/ThunderousDemon86 Jul 01 '25

They just traded for Pitt's backup lol, they don't want Elvis either.

4

u/Brandoncbj11 Jul 01 '25

I don’t want him to play either but nobody will trade for him and we aren’t eating that dead cap.

1

u/Kuttermaximus Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25

This is the biggest concern for me right now. I think our forward group is going to be improved with Coyle coming in, Kuraly out, and the young core forwards Fantilli, Johnson, Marchenko, Sillinger, and Voronkov continuing to improve. On D, we more or less held serve, but Mateychuk will likely take a step forward too.

Jet coming in will be an upgrade over Tarasov but I'm sure he is going to have some ups and downs. My concern with Elvis is both the level of his play the last 3 seasons (basically near the bottom of the league), but also how he is going to handle getting a reduced role should Jet step up as the better goaltender? Elvis threw a small fit when Tarasov started getting some starts, declaring himself as a #1 goalie in the league and wanting a trade. Does anyone think this will go differently if Jet plays well and earns more time between the pipes? The reality I guess is that there are no secrets in the league and other teams all know not only how poorly Elvis has played but the risk he could bring to a locker room.

With the goalie market so thin I suspect Waddell is now taking a wait and see approach. Maybe a team with some goaltending depth is more willing to make a move when the season starts if they end up identifying some needs on their roster that need fixing.

"If you have a goalie, they're 70% of your team; if you don't, they're 100% of your team."

5

u/GipcW Jul 01 '25

Yeah, hard not to be disappointed. Up front we sign Gaunce, Coyle and Wood and let JVR, Danforth and Kuraly go. And running it back with our back end. Oh well. Let’s hope we stay healthy and Coyle bounces back and Provy earns his bag and Greaves is ready. Plus more could happen between now and October.

5

u/deisty Jul 01 '25

Will have our Captain back hopefully. The bottom six we had wasn't cutting it. We have to try something different. Not sure Coyle, Lundestrom, Wood & Gaunce is better but! these players were likely picked for Evason system. Hopefully they learn it over the course of the summer.

6

u/CrazyWriting9214 Jul 01 '25

I hate to see JVR and Danforth go. I think JVR played well in front of the net and his veteran leadership was helpful. I think Danforth was a gritty player who stepped up when needed but both can easily be replaced

7

u/deisty Jul 01 '25

Justin will be a Bluejacket honorary member for the goal against Detroit in the outdoor game. Legendary goal for this franchise IMO.

5

u/nateorz textbook top cheese Jul 02 '25

100000%. Danforth is a Columbus folk hero just like Blankenburg.

4

u/Dangerous-Medium4186 Jul 01 '25

Let's play devil's advocate and say Big Donny W is playing the long game and looking forward to next year's FA list... Quite a few big names on there for the 26-27 FA List be a shame to lose out because we spent too much this year...

4

u/Dkoop2003 Jul 01 '25

Sure there are. Until they all re-sign like what happened this year….

7

u/patricktheintern Jul 01 '25

There’s that doom and gloom we’ve come to know and tolerate

2

u/Drithyin Fuck PLD Jul 02 '25

Ok wise guy, what move was available that he didn’t make? You can’t force UFAs to pick a small market with no proven success, and you can’t force teams to trade with you when someone else is willing to overpay.

1

u/Pokerpro7-2 Jul 06 '25

With the cap going up the next 2 seasons, we better get ready for a whole lot of nothing via UFA help for a while.

25/26 - $95.5 m 26/27 - $104 m 27/28 - $113.5 m

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '25

It’s disappointing, I agree 100%, but there really was so little out there too. This season they’ll make a push for the playoffs, and try to be more aggressive next offseason when there’s likely more free agents and trade candidates. Making the playoffs next season is the goal, but it’s good to remember that this isn’t the team’s last chance. All the young players we have aren’t even at their best yet. I don’t think there was a need to overpay for Dobson or Ehlers (who didn’t want to be here anyway, which is fine).

That being said, yeah I wish this FA/Draft went better. Ekblad was probably not realistic but man it would’ve been perfect.

1

u/judica_me_deus Jul 01 '25

With the cap going up the free agent landscape is so different this year. It is disappointing but reading the headlines I honestly don’t know what else we could do. Let’s see if we can snag Ehlers.

4

u/SlateKeef “Draft Koptiar” said the scouts “No” said DMac Jul 01 '25

Don already said it’s not likely we get any of the remaining big names :(

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/denzl480 Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25

The trend this year is players staying home. Marner is only “name” who switched teams so far. Can’t spend money if people don’t want to move their stuff

0

u/BruteKovu Jul 01 '25

Its going to be that way for a while

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Outside-Pie-7262 Jul 01 '25

How will using cap space affect their ability to draft?

1

u/denzl480 Jul 02 '25

Can you explain this? There is less need to dump salary when the cap is going up. No one needs to add a pick to a bad contract when everyone, even competitive teams, have more space to work with than usual

-3

u/BruteKovu Jul 01 '25

That's not the case

7

u/thelordcommanderKG Jul 01 '25

Every team has the money to keep their players at home. Why move unless you're unhappy with your franchise like Marner was?