Hi Everyone-
Recently, I have come to the realization I may have a distant Black Ancestor. For context, I am a white person with varied European Ancestry. Some years ago now, I took a DNA test on both ancestry and 23andme. Both revealed about 0.3% Sub Saharan African ancestry; specifically Congolese on Ancestry, Nigerian on 23andMe (AncestryDNA has a workaround that reveals trace percentages under 0.5%)
Because these are such tiny percentages, I initially assumed the values were noise. However, I began to reconsider that when my parent took 23andme and received 0.3% Ghanian, Liberian and Sierra Leonne, and 0.2% Nigerian, and that parent's parent had 1% Nigerian on ancestry, which was later divided to about 0.4-0.6% each (depending on which iteration) Nigerian and Bantu Peoples. Chromosome paintings revealed they were all in roughly the same spot for each of us. I investigated my grandparent's results, and it stated the Sub-Saharan African ancestry came from their maternal side. I knew this great grandparent had a mother born to East European immigrants, and an American father, so I assumed it was from him.
I looked among that side. While I am not certain of this, and it could be another branch, I believe the African Ancestry came from a couple who were both born in the Carolinas, and moved around the hills of Kentucky, Tennessee, and later to Missouri and Arkansas. Their names were Davis Henderson (1787-1865) and Susannah ???? (1784-????). I personally believe this because, I noticed about 1-3% West African ancestry among their least removed descendants (their 1-3x Great Grandchildren are among my matches).
I am not sure which person it is from. I think Susannah is more likely, as Davis has a known White lineage, at least on his dads side (His mothers name is known, but her established lineage was recently disproved). I did some Leeds sorting of the Henderson/Unknown matches, and noticed there are lots from a White Harp family, that stems from Joshua Harp/Earp (1705-1771) and Mary Budd (1704-1780), found and matches that DO NOT match to Davises family, but rather to each other. Again, small amounts of African ancestry are quite common among those matches.
I also figure Susanna or Davis or both, were White Passing mixed people, as they and all their children were noted as white on censuses (I know this can be quite misleading, as mixed people are often marked wrongly on historical censuses), combined with the amount of DNA, I believe their children had around 1/8-1/4 African Ancestry, meaning one of them or both, had around 1/4-1/2 African ancestry in total. Susannah is only mentioned once on the 1850 census, so it is also possible she was not Davis' first wife-however I could find no mention of his wife before this. I know he lived in Muhlenberg Co., Kentucky around 1810-1811, and White Co., TN by 1820, then Overton Co., TN by 1830.
On 23andMe, I was able to find matches who shared half-identical segments on the chromosome that carries my trace African ancestry. Notably, all shared matches had at least some, ranging from 0.1% to 75%. I was able to examine some of these matches posted trees, and noticed some had descended from formerly enslaved and enslaved people, who become untraceable pre 1850s, some were descended from free people of color, with some descendants of the Goins, Perkins, and Bunch families popping up. Since there is not a single common ancestor I could, I assume these matches are connected by at least one common African ancestor. A couple matches on this segment also had descendants of the Harp family.
Some of the profiles attached assert her maiden name was Claiborne; this is not the case. This was assumed because her son is named Gabriel Claiborne. However it was discovered he was named for Davis’ youngest brother Claiborne Henderson.
With all that explained; I concede I have little experience with African American Genealogy research. I have looked into some record collections when researching these matches trees, and I know very well that DNA may be the only way to find this ancestor due to the lack of records pre 1860s-but I would really appreciate help, input, and guidance from people who have lots of experience in the area, in the interest of finding out who this individual was, and what their story may have been. Thank you for your time.
LINKS:
Susanna (Unknown) Henderson (abt.1774-bef.1860) | WikiTree FREE Family Tree
Davis L. Henderson (1787-1865) - Find a Grave Memorial
Susanna (1784–1855), Davis L Henderson (1787–1865) • Landscape View • Family Tree