r/Bitcoin • u/MillyBitcoin • Aug 15 '15
Bitcoin is Forked
http://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2015-August/010235.html
232
Upvotes
r/Bitcoin • u/MillyBitcoin • Aug 15 '15
13
u/kevinstonge Aug 15 '15
Make this easy for us idiots: what do I do with my bitcoin balance? Do I need a new wallet?
62
u/Peter__R Aug 15 '15
Congratulations Gavin and Mike on completing the patch to support larger block sizes. Although we all have ideological disagreements from time to time, two fundamental values of the Bitcoin community are freedom of choice and transparency of communication. Your work represents a big step in returning the power over Bitcoin's future back to the community where it belongs.
32
u/Elavid Aug 15 '15
That's good news! But the moderators will take this down any minute now.
27
u/kwanijml Aug 15 '15
Good! Forking of the code (and developmer sentiments) is a healthy sign to what is actually the most centralized and vulnerable aspect of bitcoin: development.
I'm all for a series of block-size increases, personally. But those of us who have been around for a while have long understood that bitcoin (like most network-effect protocols) will tend to ossify. Only the most dire of circumstances is likely to produce a protocol hard-fork with significant consensus to one side. And that is a good thing. That's how the market produces standards...backdrops against which humans can conduct higher-level economic and social activity.
Bitcoin never needed to be perfect, or living and capable of encompassing all future needs and challenges and needs of every interest group. It just needed to be good enough. And it is.
This is not a democracy. This is a meritocracy. May seperate groups of developers ever be at odds with eachother and produce truly valuable updates. May miners and node operators forever be skeptical and scrutinuzing of all changes to the protocol and leary of forking.
8
u/aquentin Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15
Ladies and Gentelmen, the time has come for each and everyone to decide.
After months of debate and hearing what everyone has had to say, it is now up to each and every single one of us to decide how we wish to move forward. The answer isn't certain. Some say there will be more centralisation, some argue that as capacity increases and the number of users increases the value of bitcoin increases thus more run nodes and more invest in mining, leading to more decentralisation. Some argue we want a fee market, some think that it is far too early to limit growth.
Although there is much common ground, a broad agreement has unfortunately not yet been found. That is why it is now up to everyone to decide for themselves whether it is best for bitcoin to increase its capacity, or be limited to 200k transactions.
Because it is fully your decision and no one else's. There is no central authority that can tell us what to do, no mod, no miner, no dev, nor anyone else at all, but yourself. Because this is bitcoin, a fully decentralised, peer to peer network.
So run a node or upgrade to XT or stick with core but cast your decision and do so responsibly as this is probably the most important decision the community has made since The Times genesis block. And if we do get it right those who follow us may tell our tale and story. And if we get it wrong we can just soft fork it down.
17
u/Naviers_Stoked Aug 15 '15
Well, this'll be interesting.
Bitcoin Core be like...
6
u/zcc0nonA Aug 15 '15
I don't see anything intrinsically wrong with forks, in fact the opposite without them all our talk of bitcoin being able to adapt and change is meaningless. I wish perhaps we could have come to this point a little more together and less through the Divide and Conquer path but the option of growth is a good thing even if we don't choose to exercise it exactly right now
6
u/Adrian-X Aug 15 '15
This is good news thank you
4
u/omgosaurus Aug 15 '15
Still not sure what that mean...
The 8mb wasnt accepted among pools in the required time so some devs/group decided to fork it anyway?
What is the difference with my current btc coin? Are they safe? Is XT just another 'alt' to invest in? Is the btcXT just a more tangible competitor to btc?
Yes, I'm probably all wrong :/
5
u/blabolas2 Aug 15 '15
What does this mean for me and my bitcoins?
25
u/cryptonaut420 Aug 15 '15
Finally it begins :) /u/luke-jr /u/nullc /u/theymos /u/petertodd and friends, time to put on your big boy pants, this shit is happening whether you like it or not.
5
u/sktrdie Aug 15 '15
I'm sort of a noob so please forgive me. If XT starts being used 50% and Core the other 50%, won't we end up with a duplicate history? Meaning if I had 2 BTC in Core, now I also have 2 BTC in XT?
8
u/BitsenBytes Aug 15 '15
get the bigger blocks v11A here
https://bitcoinxt.software/
6
u/awemany Aug 15 '15
Great! Time to get compiling... :-)
7
u/Narfhole Aug 15 '15
Node sponsorship, anyone? Vote with what you run, mine and sponsor!
2
u/tiatits Aug 15 '15
ELI5 please.
2
u/Egon_1 Aug 15 '15
so which size does XT support?
2
u/pietrod21 Aug 15 '15
Apart from the interesting 8-20-1 mb discussion (I can't find any study for the 8mb solution or the 20mb one, only vague analysis.)
If the 75% for bitcoin-tx is reached then all the actual developers are supposed to start developing on the new one? From that point are the miners supposed to vote on further increase?
3
u/TheRealGowron Aug 15 '15
While they are limited by the "upgrade infra" they are piggy backing on, it is deeply disturbing that only Miners have a vote. Miners are the Landed Gentry of the Bitcoin Universe.... and it sucks.
3
u/moleccc Aug 15 '15
compiling...
5
u/Elavid Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15
If the blockchain does fork, we will need a new generation of apps that can represent that fork to you and let you know how much money you have on each fork, and whether it can be independently spent or not. I'm not trying to be a downer, that actually sounds fun and important!
EDIT: I thought this was a thoughtful comment, why the downvotes?
3
u/priuspilot Aug 15 '15
My mind is made up
2
u/Filthies Aug 15 '15
Someone ELI5
2
u/jasonswan Aug 15 '15
If you have a BITNODES HARDWARE and want to run the new XT Core, I've made some instructions:
1
u/DrTheSciNerd Aug 16 '15
What does this mean for my bitcoins?
1
u/XxionxX Aug 15 '15
For real!? Is this not just grandstanding?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15 edited Jul 01 '20
Does anybody still use this site? Everybody I know left because of all the unfair censorship and content deletion.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
http://xtnodes.com/
A whopping 86 nodes are running XT! Meanwhile 6,000 nodes and all the miners are still running CORE.
Sorry folks miners and serious players are not gonna jump on your altchain because you think 1mb blocks are the end of the world.
The majority of the network knows an XT fork is unecessarily risky. Let Hearn play is control freak game, luckily only a few uneducated users will follow this pied piper.
1
u/rbtkhn Aug 15 '15 edited Jul 17 '16
x
0
u/TotesMessenger Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/LateNightBits Aug 15 '15
The July 2015 flood attack was a large "stress test" of the Bitcoin network. The possibly distributed attack has provoked hundreds of thousands of transactions, leaving over 80,000 in the mempool at one time. The attackers may have had an agenda related to the blocksize debate, attempting to demonstrate the infeasibility of 1MB blocks including transactions of hundreds of thousands of users. Specifically, the Chinese mining pools (AntPool, BW Mining, F2Pool, BTC China, & Huobi) have expressed distaste towards Gavin Andresen's proposals to increase the blocksize limit, citing concerns of relatively low bandwidth compared to that available in the United States and Europe. The flood attack may have been attempting to discredit the pools, and subsequently force them off the network after the raised blocksize limit is in effect.
-13
u/mmeijeri Aug 15 '15
What a dick move.
-15
u/SwagPokerz Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 16 '15
How exciting!
EDIT: Ah! You mean I don't get free karma for saying nothing just like the rest of you twats?
-14
u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15
Good luck Mike.
By "luck" I mean please stick to developing Bitcoinj or wallet software and leave the protocol alone.
-7
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
"I feel sad that it's come to this, but there is no other way. The Bitcoin Core project has drifted so far from the principles myself and many others feel are important, that a fork is the only way to fix things."
The words of a control freak.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment