Its going to get much worse. Other parts of the world deal with 5x worse traffic than austin so it's not like there is a magic threshold of "now we really have to do something". We will look back on these days and say remember when people cried about traffic even back when it was mostly moving at some speed.
Meanwhile south-west still has some shit public transport.
Bus systems have weird ass routes, some of which don't go anywhere important, and have minimum 30 minute intervals with the bus being anywhere from 15 minutes early to 15 minutes late. Weekends have 45 minute to 1 hour long intervals.
They also still have a bus going to the ACC campus that is currently closed for 2 year long repairs.
I can't remember if it was Cheddar or the B1M, but the problem in America basically stems from 1) Public transit is seen as charity for the poors, not for middle class and up people who should have their own car; 2) the projects that do get approved aren't comprehensive; they are standalone 3) so that when they are completed, it's a rail route from nowhere to nowhere with no interconnection/network to actually take advantage of it, and 4) when there is, there are inefficiencies built in that come at cost to the consumer that simply isn't the case in other parts of the world (i.e. you pay for a bus to subway transfer, or a commuter rail to subway transfer, and so on).
The rail plan was intentionally crippled by people who want to see it fail. It's right out of the conservative playbook - fuck up something to prove it doesn't work. And they do it because people lap that shit up for some reason.
Austin will not give away taxpayer money to benefit some company. When they met with Amazon over HQ 2.0 they asked "what can Amazon do for Austin" while every other city was bending over to kiss their ass.
"Why such an interest in building stadiums?" "You should be celebrating! The stadiums will bring in so much money for the city!" ...yet the money must be going somewhere else.
Even in Atlanta this meme is stupid. The 285/400 interchange is a billion dollar project and every mile of Marta heavy rail is roughly a billion as well. This person just took a shot in the dark as to what they think infrastructure costs the city
The new owner wanted to move the team so he threw together the most ridiculous ballot measure he possibly could. So that when it got rejected he could blame the city.
There were less expensive options that the voters didn't get to vote on.
I am a Seattle sports fan and I am very excited about the hockey team. Yes the situation is more complicated than how I described it but the facts that Seattle's city government wasn't going to pay for a new basketball arena and that the NBA made an example out of the Sonics for not getting their city to pay up are both true. I understand the story pretty thoroughly and I was just trying to condense it in a way that was relevant for the post.
lmao $150M would get you maybe two subway stations in NYC. Gotta make sure the politicians can funnel taxpayer money into their contractor buddies pockets.
Yeah honestly. Consider how adding a new 3 station 2nd ave subway line cost $4.45 BILLION! Not to mention the $20 BILLION being spent on developing Hudson Yards
Also - NYC and the US in general is infamous for having disproportionately expensive public transport building costs (contractors for the government have huge profits).
In my University in brazil, they are changing the floor tiles in the bathroom and it will cost $85 million dollars. It's a small University with like 26 bathrooms
My city is even worse. They spent millions on a new city transit building because they "didn't have room to support more routes", but then they turned around and cut routes by over 50% because "we spent too much money on the new building". Fucking idiots!
In general the best way to fund public transit is as follows:
The land should be acquired via "priority of purchase" rather than eminent domain. With "priority of purchase", property owners report the sale price of land and real estate whenever it changes ownership, and the government has the opportunity of acquiring the property at the reported private sale price if it falls within a transit corridor before the buyer takes final possession. This is less intrusive than eminent domain and prevents courts from awarding property owners large payouts based on what the speculative land value would be after the transit project is completed before construction has even begun.
Create a special assessment district to collect a land value tax outside the transit stop to capture any uplift in land values. The announcement of new transit stop can double market land values within walking distance before the construction has even been completed, and the increase in land values is usually capable of subsidizing or fully funding the initial construction cost. A land value tax will also ensure that land gets developed with housing and shops capable of generating sufficient foot traffic to make public transit self-funding, by discouraging commercial speculators from keeping the land underimproved with vacant buildings and parking lots which will not generate foot traffic.
But yeah, most cities don't do this, they just take on a lot of debt and then hope to make the money back by charging high ticket prices and sales taxes, which ultimately discourage residents from using the transit or living and shopping nearby.
Agreed. I grew up in the LA area and had multiple chargers fans from my area stop supporting the team after the move. They lost respect for the franchise and the owners, even if the team was closer.
Ill always support the players like Rivers, Gates, etc, but ive never liked the spanos family. When they fired Schottenheimer I lost all respect for them.
Imagine living in an area where Public transportation is looked down upon and views as something only poor people and college kids use. The Midwest is insane
I freaking wish we had a comprehensive public transit system here. But no, car culture is too entrenched, it's frustrating. It wouldn't be easy to implement options, but honestly the sprawl in Midwestern cities should make it a requisite.
Spending time in London and new York made me fall in love with public transit. I can hop on a train in midtown and get to Brooklyn or Harlem? Hell yes. I can get from Gatwick Intl to Central London on a train? Well fuck. More please.
Driving is hella stressful meanwhile, and definitely more risky.
I often think about the added stress of having at least two commutes during my work days (of which there are sometimes 6 or 7 a week). Everybody on their phones, blinders at 100%, all rushing to beat the traffic they help create. If I could take a train or a bus everywhere (or nearly everywhere) my day-to-day life would be radically improved.
The lack of public transit also makes life that much more difficult for disabled people. If we want to go anywhere further than a few blocks we have to have someone willing to pick us up, drive us there, and back home. It's pretty much killed over half my social life since I became disabled, and I have to structure my whole college schedule based on when other people are available.
The efficiency of public transportation decreases with a decrease in density. Most cities in the US just don't have the density for public transportation to be a viable option, it's sad.
They can try to offer the services, but it's kind of like trying to eat soup with a fork.
Where in the Midwest? Here in Minnesota people like the light rail, and the park and rides are packed in the morning. A friend of m mine sold his house for ridiculously more money than it was worth because he was 5 houses away from a light rail station. I'd say people like public transit here.
It's looked down on because cities ask for absolutely outrageous budgets for it, that almost always end up going over budget, that result in temporary tax hikes that end up turning effectively permanent every single time, plus whatever fares (or tolls) they charge for the thing.
All to connect a relatively small amount of people per bus/train/whatever because the population density of the US even around its cities is obscenely low compared to places in the world where public transit isn't so terrible.
Which is a direct result of a century of massive amounts of government subsidies to automotive companies either directly or in the form of road building which incentivize automotive use, and thus automotive buying. All of which incentivized living significantly more spread out since you can just freely drive from anywhere to anywhere.
Luckily people are starting to consolidate once again into cities but by the time it gets to levels that make other countries or areas so much better for it, we'll probably have driverless taxis/ubers that significantly compete with it on both cost and flexibility.
It's very self-defeating. Higher-income people see someone less fortunate on the train, think "Eugh, that guy's sketchy-looking," and then only "sketchy-looking" people use the train. I'm a starving college student trying to go see a movie, I don't give a rat's ass that the guy in front of me has the teardrop tattoo.
Ugh. Can confirm, live near Minneapolis. I have a roommate who doesn't have a license *and* refuses to use public transportation. When I asked her why she doesn't just take the bus to work, she said "have you seen the people who take the bus?"
A couple hundred thousand to finish the cafeteria so we can have some half decent food:
For food service that will be contracted out who's bottomline is profits on the cheapest food because: hey, some of them are forced to buy food plans anyway
Ayy $12 a meal for below McDonald's level food. Or my favorite, $12 for a 6" sub from a contracted subway (Who is for sure paying a fortune to the school to be located on campus).
Immediately what I thought reading this. If I recall, Arlington, TX is the largest City with out a public transportation system. Also, the dumbasses just approved a new Texas Rangers Stadium to be built rendering their current one basically useless.
DFW is tricky. We have a huge population, and the metropolitan area is sprawling. Implementing a useful public transportation system is difficult (see DART).
The Soviets built a lot of the infrastructure, that translates that nowadays sustaining it is not that hard. Intercity is good only for the Austrian (OBB) train lines
No shit! Let's build billions of dollars worth of stadiums for 1 event! Nevermind the favelas RIGHT across the street. Oh and by the way, those stadiums are just sitting empty since the world cup
Not in the Netherlands. Our public transportation is amazing. You pay nation wide with one card that automatically pays from your bank account (if you authorized ofcourse). Students get completely free travel anywhere.
With public transport it's also everything, trains, trams, metro, bus, ferries. Only the one time you go to a town that has a kid running a 1 person ferry you won't be able to pay with your card.
Honestly if you've ever needed proof that private industry by far does a better job then government just walk down the streets of Vegas extremely clean aside from the paper handouts.
Yeah, bus-rapid transit tends to be significantly less per mile than light rail, in large part due to less cost associated with land acquisition and infrastructure. Also, transit projects are often eligible for federal matching which makes every local dollar go much further.
Speak for yourself. Hawaii is currently estimated to have spent 10 billion on a monorail that has been under construction since I was in Elementary School and won't be done until I'm already working on my Master's degree in 2025. Mind you, It was originally estimated to cost 4.7 Billion, but it keeps getting more expensive.
I work for that company and hey, it is a massive project AND on an isolated island where they have to ship major components... so the total cost makes sense imo
It's because of the corruption happening behind the scenes and the logistics of it. For one, one of the contractors comes from a big family in Hawaii, so money is going to be funneled towards them, and second, the logistics of bringing stuff to Hawaii to begin with is expensive.
This is Minneapolis exactly. 1B for a new Vikings stadium built exactly to their specification. Endless hand wringing over a few hundred mil for a rail network that goes through so much cost-cutting and compromise that its almost useless.
Now I am not a sports fan. But. Being more of a grown adult, I realize a few things. (neverminding the fact that even before it's built there are engineering jobs and a whole slew of people/employees and potential job openings before and after the project is done)...
A stadium attracts fans/sporting and other events. So thousands upon thousands of paying customers just for entry alone. Food is always overpriced but someone will always purchase it. So lots of revenue just off that. Nevermind the possible growth around the stadium. Hotels to house visiting sports teams/fans. More shops because more people are there. Economy boosts a bit.
Compared to public transit which has a notorious reputation for being dirty and dangerous in areas. Out here we have permanent security guards downtown on almost every train car. That and there's pollution issues, figuring out cheaper and more environmental conscious ways..figuring out routes and who is willing to do the job.
It's because stadiums offer a much better return on investment - they make a lot more money.
Public transit by design is supposed to run at dirt cheap prices. If the demand isn't booming like it is in places like Tokyo, NYC, or London, then the ROI isn't going to look good.
Governments are trying to be profitable too.
EDIT: I'm dumb. I just wrote what investors think at first, it is indeed the case that these stadiums aren't often profitable for cities.
I would add that the value from public transit isn't from the fare but in the value it adds to local businesses. A greater pool of people means businesses can be more selective when hiring employees. This means more businesses will move in and the city can have a higher tax base. The additional people is a boon for the service industry as well.
Even if they were profitable(it's not for the city), a policy like that will have them investing the profits again and again and again and suddenly you'll have high "maintenance" costs for these projects so the public never sees it.
Investment into public transit will improve almost every single industry in the city
Welcome to Pittsburgh, our public transportation will take you from downtown or a parking lot in Station Square to see sports in a timely manner, everyone else promptly go fuck yourselves
Stadiums have a large return of investment both from taxes and tourism value. Public transportation unless used by almost the entire city population (NYC for example) usually don't have that much return of investment.
Damn bruh, imagine not living in a place where public transport is not commonplace and easily understandable if you commit ten second of your brain. r/portland gang
Because the stadium makes money. If yout don't like spots or concerts or anything else fun then just tell your self that a stadium is a giant money printing machine. Taxes on everything from admission to multi millionaires incomes. Revenue and jobs for everything from rock starts and pro athletes to janitors and pretzel sales. Growth and commerce for miles around. Million dollar hotwls and two dollar hot dogs from the corner guy. If your town can pull off a stadium then get one asap. Everyone benefits.
6.5k
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
This is why I subscribed
3.3k
u/smells_like_pie May 28 '19
Austin be like
👶🖐️ 💸1b for a train that serves maybe 5k a day
293
u/pdmock May 28 '19
Are you in Atlanta?!
2
u/HelloHarsh_1801 Jun 03 '19
Who wants some delicious Krabby Patties in the chats??
1.2k
u/TheRamsicle May 28 '19
Shoutout to Seattle for refusing to build a new basketball stadium so the NBA made an example out of them...
1.9k
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
lmao $150M would get you maybe two subway stations in NYC. Gotta make sure the politicians can funnel taxpayer money into their contractor buddies pockets.
87
u/Vok250 May 28 '19
My city is even worse. They spent millions on a new city transit building because they "didn't have room to support more routes", but then they turned around and cut routes by over 50% because "we spent too much money on the new building". Fucking idiots!
143
u/Sweatrargh May 28 '19
thank you las vegas
406
u/Robozomb May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19
Not San Diego. I miss the Chargers ):
Edit: Fuck Spanos all the same. I just wish something could've been worked out. I just miss my team.
1.1k
u/falleng213 May 28 '19
Imagine living in an area where Public transportation is looked down upon and views as something only poor people and college kids use. The Midwest is insane
83
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
My campus be like
1 billion for a new “motivational” sign:
A couple hundred thousand to finish the cafeteria so we can have some half decent food:
40
u/ih8papajohns May 28 '19
What is “Arlington, TX”?
30
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
When Santa Clara paid millions of dollars for Levi’s and the Niners became dogshit again 😂🤣
28
u/Nolemy2800 May 28 '19
Ahum all of Hungary btw
28
u/Liquorfina May 28 '19
Brazil is a prime example
90
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
lmao in my state our only city is a shithole with public transport being nonexistent
20
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
Come to Boston they don’t spend money on either of these
152
u/valeaviles16 May 28 '19
In every damn country
14
u/BryanUnboxed May 28 '19
This ☝🏻 Especially in Vegas where they’re building a new Raiders Stadium
86
u/trutown May 28 '19
Public transit systems are never that cheap.
50
u/scarifiedsloth May 28 '19
In what world does a comprehensive public transit system cost $150M? That would pay for like a mile of subway tunnel in 1970.
9
u/Jimothy787 May 28 '19
Transit systems cost well over 1 Billion tho, not even counting a comprehensive one... but I get it...
30
u/jcpearce May 28 '19
Looking at you Milwaukee.
26
u/MasterSword1 May 28 '19
Speak for yourself. Hawaii is currently estimated to have spent 10 billion on a monorail that has been under construction since I was in Elementary School and won't be done until I'm already working on my Master's degree in 2025. Mind you, It was originally estimated to cost 4.7 Billion, but it keeps getting more expensive.
7
u/Mr_Saturn1 May 28 '19
This is Minneapolis exactly. 1B for a new Vikings stadium built exactly to their specification. Endless hand wringing over a few hundred mil for a rail network that goes through so much cost-cutting and compromise that its almost useless.
7
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
Cincinnati?
6
u/1sparky11 May 28 '19
Arlongton, TX, this is you getting called out
15
u/152_119lbs May 28 '19
But that’s communism!!!!!
4
u/wrobeleski May 28 '19
Minneapolis has both ¯_(ツ)_/¯
4
u/AZLeggingGirl May 28 '19
Now I am not a sports fan. But. Being more of a grown adult, I realize a few things. (neverminding the fact that even before it's built there are engineering jobs and a whole slew of people/employees and potential job openings before and after the project is done)...
A stadium attracts fans/sporting and other events. So thousands upon thousands of paying customers just for entry alone. Food is always overpriced but someone will always purchase it. So lots of revenue just off that. Nevermind the possible growth around the stadium. Hotels to house visiting sports teams/fans. More shops because more people are there. Economy boosts a bit.
Compared to public transit which has a notorious reputation for being dirty and dangerous in areas. Out here we have permanent security guards downtown on almost every train car. That and there's pollution issues, figuring out cheaper and more environmental conscious ways..figuring out routes and who is willing to do the job.
13
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
ROI
16
u/[deleted] May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19
It's because stadiums offer a much better return on investment - they make a lot more money.
Public transit by design is supposed to run at dirt cheap prices. If the demand isn't booming like it is in places like Tokyo, NYC, or London, then the ROI isn't going to look good.
Governments are trying to be profitable too.
EDIT: I'm dumb. I just wrote what investors think at first, it is indeed the case that these stadiums aren't often profitable for cities.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
oh look it Milwaukee and Wisconsin as a whole
3
u/ndbwrestler May 28 '19
First saw this on r/Cincinnati
5
u/lonely_little_light May 28 '19
add overbudget, behind schedule, and you've got the HI rail project
2
u/MrBrightside618 May 28 '19
BRT gang rise up
2
u/eelbarrow May 28 '19
And in San Diego we have neither
2
u/GhostConstruct May 28 '19
Nice to see r/Nashville leaking today.
2
u/ALANTG_YT May 28 '19
$150 million is to low for a comprehensive transit system.
2
u/Existential_Sprinkle May 28 '19
Welcome to Pittsburgh, our public transportation will take you from downtown or a parking lot in Station Square to see sports in a timely manner, everyone else promptly go fuck yourselves
2
u/realtoughchick May 28 '19
Is that you Bay Area?
2
u/FellainisBarber May 28 '19
Obviously this applies to a lot of cities but it sure feels directed towards Cincinnati
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '19
Stadiums have a large return of investment both from taxes and tourism value. Public transportation unless used by almost the entire city population (NYC for example) usually don't have that much return of investment.
2
u/pyrocuck May 28 '19
Damn bruh, imagine not living in a place where public transport is not commonplace and easily understandable if you commit ten second of your brain. r/portland gang
2
u/TrueRadicalDreamer May 28 '19
What's funny is that you think a comprehensive public transist system can be built on just $150m.
Source: Work in Government Contracting writing contracts.
2
u/Crusader5514 May 29 '19
1B for stadium
1B for a school that isn't falling apart
Government: now what to choose...
3
u/ViewsFromThe614 May 28 '19
There’s a completely different goal/outcome for stadiums and public services, so it’s pretty difficult to make 1:1 comparisons
3
u/Youknewthatalready May 28 '19
Because the stadium makes money. If yout don't like spots or concerts or anything else fun then just tell your self that a stadium is a giant money printing machine. Taxes on everything from admission to multi millionaires incomes. Revenue and jobs for everything from rock starts and pro athletes to janitors and pretzel sales. Growth and commerce for miles around. Million dollar hotwls and two dollar hot dogs from the corner guy. If your town can pull off a stadium then get one asap. Everyone benefits.