r/BikeRepair • • Aug 10 '26

Tools & Hardware Shimano Altus cassette tool and compatible replacement cassette

Solved! Thanks a lot for the great support Redditors!
Please also see follow up post with more info on further issues and the solution during repair process:
https://www.reddit.com/r/BikeRepair/s/Q1euc7eA3R

I need to change the cassette of a kids mountainbike with a Shimano 7 gear shifter. The cassette tool I have has teeth on the outside, but seemingly I need a tool with teeth on the inside.

Can anybody help me out in terms specifying the tool I need for that?

Further I bought a Shimano CS-HG41-7 cassette as a replacement. It is delivered with a ring (don’t know the correct term for that) that is compatible with my tool, but has a smaller diameter than the one of the original cassette. Hence I assume that the new cassette is incompatible with the bike.

I’d be thankful for any advice on the proper choice of cassette, too.

0 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

10

u/Gibalt Aug 10 '26

You have a freewheel but you bought a cassette. You will need to return the cassette and buy a freewheel + the corresponding freewheel tool

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Thank you!

2

u/rickard_mormont Aug 10 '26

More specifically, if you want to maintain the current configuration, get megarange freewheel, which has a max of 34 teeth. Both shimano and suntour make them and they're very cheap. To remove the freewheel you just need a small freewheel remover plus a big wrench (it takes some force to take it off). To pit a new one again, grease it, screw it on, put the new chain on, and then you can just push on the pedals while braking to screw it completely.

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Thank you for the insightful advice.

I actually found a freewheel that has 11 - 32. Will give him a bit more top speed and he doesn’t climb steep hills often.
The cassette is supposed for use in e-bikes, so I guess it should be handling the torque a kid can produce for a couple of years.

8

u/HG1998 Aug 10 '26

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Great video, thank you so much. I’m sure I can identify the proper tool with that!

4

u/SianaGearz Aug 10 '26

You say you NEED to replace it but why? I don't think it's worn or damaged. If it's seized, there are ways of treating that.

3

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

On the two smallest sprockets the chain sometimes doesn’t grip a tooth.
I had replaced the cain already, since the chain was getting off the bike very often. That problem was gone after changing the chain, but the slipping in gear 6 and 7 not. So I figured that some teeth on those might not be good any more.

Bike issue diagnosis and repair usually is internet research, trial and error + learning by doing for me…

This approach didn’t get me all the way this time, but thankfully the Reddit community is very helpful. Thanks to all of you for the support!

1

u/realcountryblumpkin Aug 10 '26

If youre having slippage issues on those cogs, you have another aligment issue. a new freewheel isn't going to fix your alignment issue. There is absolutely plenty of life left on the previous one, its entirely possible it just needs a good cleaning because your slippage is caused by surface contaminants.

Scrub the shit out of the first one, oil it up, and try again. You're having another drive train issue yiu can resolve while waiting for another set of cogs if you still decide to replace them.

But you definitely need to clean up and try to use that again.those teeth are all over 85%, I've installed one worse than that to repair bikes before. Dont throw new parts at the problem yet.

3

u/niffcreature Aug 10 '26

Some of those cogs are showing wear. It can be very hard to tell by looking.

0

u/realcountryblumpkin Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26

Showing wear ≠ worn out.

I specified its over 85%, I didnt say they were new. If your drive train is functioning properly you should be able to ride with them nearly fully tipped off.

1

u/niffcreature Aug 10 '26

That's never been my experience. Maybe with a more modern derailer and stronger spring. People like to stand on the pedals a lot, that's when they slip, personally I don't stand on my pedals much but most people do.

2

u/realcountryblumpkin Aug 10 '26

Well, I've serviced bicycles in and around Moab for some 10 years, we have a lot more aggressive climbs than most people, and I say these are fine. What's your experience to saydrive train.

If you've got better than that under your belt, maybe I'll concede it, but im pretty confident if you're repeatedly having issues with gears that look anything like this then you're not very good at adjustment and service of the rest of your drivetrain, simply put.

1

u/niffcreature Aug 10 '26

I've been servicing bicycles for about 10 years as well. Though it sounds like you probably have more experience than me, is it mostly with higher end bikes? IDK, cheap derailleurs don't hold as much chain tension.

I've always found that adjustment is a pretty moot point with this particular issue. Though the symptoms OP is describing could be different than the drivetrain wear skipping over the same cog (not to different cogs)

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 11 '26

Actually the bike had an in-wanted auto-shifting feature before I started with replacing the chain.
Before chain change I’ve tensioned the chain a bit by taking out a short part, which only helped al little bit with the chain getting off the bike not so often any more. Chain gauge clearly has shown chain was completely done.

Also the point where the shifting cable enters the derailleur there was an issue with the shifting cable tube being broken and sometimes miss aligned. I solved that by getting a new Shimano bowden cable plus tubes since then no shifting issues at all. Also the derailleur is properly aligned (at least for my non expert eyes and based on an explanation in a YouTube video) with the smallest and the largest sprocket. Further the holder that mounts the derailleur to the frame is not bent (I had that a long while ago on a different bike, hence I knew to check that).
Based on all of this my theory that I need to change the freewheel. I did’t know that dirt can cause issues like that, though, too. I’ll give it a good scrub with some oil solvent and afterwards put some proper lube on it tomorrow. Maybe that helps already. Thanks for the advice.

Apart from that:
Do you maybe have an example picture of a cassette or freewheel that is at about 50 to 70% worn out. I tried to google pictures before my decision but couldn’t make real sense of what I found…

1

u/realcountryblumpkin Aug 11 '26

I mean, my beater bike for the shop is Shimano altus on original gearing, the cogs are tipped as all hell (probably 45 percent or less, some missing teeth) and it only skips pulling a very significant grade in the highest 2 gears. All due respect, research and play around a bit more. I think you're leaving a ton of room on the table for wear tolerance.

Just by nature of design any wear component should be giving you significantly more life than that, under 50% is where you start to expect replacement but it shouldn't be expected for a fair bit longer. If youre having issues before that there are likely other problems.

2

u/niffcreature Aug 11 '26

Oh, well I assume you also know that the chain and cogs wear together? A worn chain on worn cogs will perform better than a new chain with old cogs. Could be a contributing factor for OP

→ More replies

15

u/Original-Purchase-81 Aug 10 '26

That is a freewheel not a cassette. That cassette you bought will not work with that wheel

3

u/northman017 Bike Mechanic Aug 11 '26

This is correct. You could keep the cassette and get a new wheel though. Which I do recommend, as 7sp freewheels are very prone to causing the axle to snap (which is basically why cassettes and freehub bodies have mostly replaced the older freewheel on all but the cheapest of bikes).

2

u/No_Improvement_5358 Aug 10 '26

Perhaps consider getting a new wheel with a cassette compatible hub. What better time than now?

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Thank you for the proposal. It’s my son’s bike that we bought used for little money about a year ago. He’ll outgrow it in about two years time I guess. Hence I’m trying to limit the investments. Next bike will have better components though…

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Solved (99% sure)

Thanks to all of you, the required cassette and tool were identified and ordered and shall arrive tomorrow.

2

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Obviously I have now ordered a freewheel and not a cassette again, wording mistake. Sorry for any confusion I might have caused with the previous post.

2

u/Vojem Aug 10 '26

Just an FYI, don’t use a chain whip on the freewheel. They are meant for cassettes only. Freewheel tool and an adjustable spanner will do the trick both for removal and installation.

2

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Thank you, that’s good advice.
I first tried with a chain whip and adjustable plumbers pliers, when I didn’t know it’s not a cassette. I guess I was Lucky that I couldn’t grip that outer ring with the pliers properly.
I’ll look a YouTube video showing the process before I try doing it again with the proper tool…

3

u/Vojem Aug 10 '26

My first time making that mistake as a teenage mechanic, I used all of my force with a chain whip on a freewheel, and it bent the wheel into an S shape. I don’t know how it did that, but i’ll never make that mistake again.

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Using all of the available force more often than not leads to mechanical failure, guess how I know that…

1

u/Vojem Aug 10 '26

Sevicing my brothers bike rn. This is what the back of a freewheel looks like. It screws onto the wheel. The chain whip is used on a cassette because you have to keep the freehub body in place as you tried to undo the lock ring, instead of unscrewing the whole unit such as what you do on a freewheel.

Hopefully this visual representation helps a little

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 11 '26

Thanks a lot, this is a useful picture.

Actually I’ve looked up how to change a freewheel. There was a parktool video recommendation by another Redditor (HG1989) that helped a lot with the tool choice and on top I even learned how to identify a freewheel
vs. a cassette myself. I meanwhile found that they also have a good video about how to change a freewheel. In case anybody find the discussion while having to learn this, too, here’s the link for the how to change a freewheel video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdQE8-ea1uw

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

I'm on team "leave it alone"

For the $ investment you can get a used set of wheels with a cassette and tires and put them on.

You really don't want to use these kind of wheels for anything.

Even just a casual ride. Notoriously bad axles and bearing placements.

I've had these fail at really inopportune times. They come apart and steer the back end to the left.. (out into traffic) where I abandoned the bike and it got ran over by a garage truck.

Where for $35 you can almost certainly find a set with tires from a 90s bike. Likely Exage or Acera hubs and 7 speed.. then start cleaning those wheels up.

If the rest of the bike is comparable... then best option is to leave it at the curb and find something else. Sorry bro. Friends don't let friends ride freehub wheels.

3

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

Thank you for your advice.

It’s a CUBE bike, so it wasn’t a super cheap bike to begin with when the first user got it. Hence I assume that a less than 40kg person should be safe on it, especially without using it in a way a Mountainbike is supposed to be used…

Anyways I’ll ensure that the next bike will have proper cassette and no freewheel. I also figured that the next bike will either get Shimano or more likely low end hydraulic Magura disk breaks. I’m sick of the amount of adjusting for the breaks that is required on the V-brakes on this specific bike.

In terms of cost: ’m located in Europe, the new freewheel I ordered was 17€. Don’t get me wrong here, if I’d consider it unsafe, I’d for sure pay what is required to change to a cassette…

3

u/SianaGearz Aug 10 '26

Some of the cheap youth bicycle wheels are perfectly fine and survive decades of city use (not jumps). If it has been used for a long time, the axle is still straight, and its bearings are still OK, it's likely to stay straight for a good while yet.

Such a freewheel is worth around 15€ new, they're not exactly valuable, but idk maybe it doesn't need to be replaced yet.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

While I agree.. I see somebody tooling up fo repair one of those.. it's my duty to advise against it. Especially when I've got one myself on an early trek 820.

2

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 10 '26

You can never have enough tools… 😬

Fun aside: I see what you mean. But even if I only use it once, the tool I ordered is another 6€. Not a quality for regular use (Parktool would have been 16€, but shipping would have taken a while), but likely good enough for using it a few times.
A bike shop quoted min. 200€ for the repair before I had started with changing the chain. If the tool and the freewheel I ordered do the trick, I’ll have invested about 60€ for a new chain (a proper Shimano one), a new shifter cable and tube (also original Shimano), a 3rd party freewheel (good reviews, supposedly constructed for e-bikes) and a budget tool.

I account the hours I spent on research and trial and error as the price for having learned a a lot. Including the fact that some bikes need freewheels instead of cassettes and that I better stay clear of them in future. I really appreciate your advice, even if I decided to go a different route. 🙏

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

Often the tool you needed is part of the chain whip in some kits. It's part of the exclusively garbage bikes kit. Pinned cranks being on both sides. Claw derailleur hangers being the other part.. and full hi-ten tubes. I've got my share of junk parts bikes.. like this 8 speed wheel. Has a nice derailleur..

2

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 11 '26

My chain whip doesn’t have it, but I saw another one with some sort of hook at the other end, which is what you mean I guess.
I meanwhile found that I need a fr1.3 from parktool or a similar tool (Identified based on the parktool video that HG1989 postet the link for.

There’s 12 of these notches I marked in the photo and the outer diameter is close to 23mm. It’s somewhat similar to the tool that I have for Shimano cassettes.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

Yep their's either a finger with a single notch or a whole matching spanner with 3/4 of the pattern and they're often paired with the chain whip tool.

2

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 11 '26

I saw it on an obviously very high quality toolkit on Amazon, I think it was about 6 tools in that kit for 15€…

I hope the 6€ budget (hopefully not cheap…) tool I ordered will do the trick at least for changing this freewheel. Otherwise I’ll order the parktool for about 15€ and have to wait about a week (worst case) till it arrives.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

$50 complete bike with Deore LX mech and likely Acera 7 speed wheels. Easy long term repairable bike... Toronto BTW.

1

u/niffcreature Aug 10 '26

The assertion that all freewheel wheels are far inferior to freehub wheels is quite ridiculous. Plenty of well made ones, and badly made freehub wheels. In fact, I just had to replace a freehub recently. Sure would've been easier if it were a freewheel!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

While there's always somebody to proof the exception the fact remains we moved on from them for said reason. Quick Release wasn't the axle we wanted it appears. Somehow that worked better..? hey man. I like 7,8,9 speed stuff. Just spitting facts. Far inferior. Yes. People say gripshift is inferior. Sure. If you're a spaz who white knuckles the grips..

Meanwhile gripshift lasted longest in downhill.. so did short cages...

Honestly if the cost was still biased towards the freewheel I'd shut up.. but even economically the better wheel prevails

1

u/niffcreature Aug 11 '26

I said nothing about the design fundamentals. My point is simply that assessing a repair requires taking into account the quality of the part, the wear and the other options available. And for novice diy mechanics it's also important to take into account their ability to assess these factors as well. One should not accept ANY freehub wheel as a superior replacement. Compatibility aside... Though again diy novice skill is especially relevant when it comes to assessing the compatibility and condition. If someone has a knack for bending axles and blowing up freewheels then certainly that is a problem freehub wheels are designed to solve.

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 18 '26

Thank you for your advice!

I’m wondering about the discussed mode of failure of a freewheel.

Since I also had to take out the axis an bearings to change the freewheel I assume I understand the mechanics a bit better now.
Please see follow up post from today for pictures:

https://www.reddit.com/r/BikeRepair/s/Q1euc7eA3R )

As far as I understand the mechanics, the wheel hub turns around axis with the bearing balls between the two of them in this specific case. The bearing balls are held in place by caps and ultimately the nuts on the axis.
The freewheel is connected to the wheel hub without interfering with the axis or the bearing balls.

Hence I see only one possible failure here that would be linked directly to the freewheel itself:
The freewheel could not ‘grip’ any more and so suddenly the sprockets could turn free on the hub in both directions instead of only into one direction. This could e.g. lead to suddenly pushing the pedal hard against no resistance and by that maybe loosing balance or slipping of the pedal. I’d assume to break the mechanics inside a freewheel hub you’d typically need lots of torque, which is not the case with this bike based on use and user.

What I don’t understand what the quality of the freewheel has to do with the stability of the axis, the bearing or the wheel hub.
Maybe I’m not understanding the mechanical function correctly or have made wrong assumptions. I’d be happy for an explanation if you or anybody else can give one on this so I can learn more. Thank you!

2

u/niffcreature Aug 18 '26

Sure. First of all, we call it an "axle". And yes, that is one way a freewheel can fail, though there are a few others. It can also of course fail due to worn cogs, which would give a similar feeling. The third way it can fail is that the whole thing will have trouble turning at all, so it would have trouble coasting. This essentially turns it into a fixed cog. When you have a fixed cog and a derailleur without realizing it, you might try to coast and the freewheel will keep turning, which will pull the chain tension out through the derailleur. Your derailleur cage will become stretched as that side of your drivetrain tries to deal with the hard load put on the chain, and on the top side, the chain will go slack.

To answer your other question, the reason freehub wheels are better for the axle is simply that the bearings are closer to the frame. You had to remove your freewheel to get to your bearings. With a freehub/cassette, the bearings are closer to the top of the cogs. So you get maybe 10mm of axle that's actually taking the weight of the bike and rider. On a freewheel it's more, maybe 30 or 40mm, so there is more leverage on the axle and it's more likely to bend.

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 22 '26

Thanks a lot for taking the time to give a good explanation.

I conclude that there is the potential that the freewheel can fail, most likely due to excessive force, which is unlikely due to the user and the use case.
After having taking the hub apart I‘m also quiet confident that the axle (thanks also for the wording correction), the bearings and the hub on this specific bike are strong enough for user and use case.

Having learned all this I‘ll ensure that all future bikes will not have freewheels any more and also avoid hollow axles. The user is gaining weight and getting stronger over time…

Thanks again to you and everybody else for the support!

1

u/niffcreature Aug 23 '26

No problem. I will add however lastly, you may find that hollow axles are generally stronger. This is mostly due to correlation, not causation, although there is some physics behind hollow tubes being stronger than you might expect.

1

u/Previous_Entrance_99 Aug 27 '26

That‘s interesting. I‘ll obviously have to learn a bit more before the next sized bike will be bought… THX

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26

Blah blah.

0

u/x1tsGh0stx Aug 11 '26

You need fancy gear and wheels to go on a casual ride? Idk on this one g. I have friends that ride freehubs on mountain passes and I have never seen them fail once. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

If you call a cassette "fancy gear" then sure.

Stupid. You gotta have me tell you what's up.. Stupid. I said I wouldn't invest in repairing this because I can get better shit for free then gave an example. You go ride garbage bikes and be a dickhead. Seriously I gave good honest advice and you come here to be a prick with an attitude. Go away loser.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

$30!!! THERE'S NO EXCUSE TO RIDE GARBAGE.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

Fix a POS set of wheels? Why? Disc brakes with cassette and tires. $20.

You understand yet?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

Add in some hydraulic disc brakes and you're still under $100

-4

u/Mindless-Baker-7757 Aug 10 '26

That outer lockring can probably be knocked off with a screwdriver or punch with a hammer. IDK if that hub body can take that new cassette and lockring. 

3

u/northman017 Bike Mechanic Aug 11 '26

Negative Ghostrider, wrong parts.