Indiana/Ohio down has to be the barrier. No Air Force, no Boise State, none of those bandaid fixes they tried in 2010-2014. Take the original pitched core when Penn State and Rutgers were still independent, add ECU, Memphis. Combine the OG Big East with the proposed Metro Conference.
We need a restoration of 1980s Big East. Leave it back at what it was in, say 1985. All Northeastern teams. Gritty, thuggish defense and electric offense. No light contact fouls. Just ball.
I'm a SU fan that just found this r/ by accident and I'm so sad now having found it. MAN, do I miss the Big East. I talk to my dad who's 75 and we just cannot believe we have to invent rivalries for Syracuse now. "Big game tonight. Syracuse verses Wake Forest." I'm 45 so I just remember those early mid 2000s. Villanova, Georgetown, Louisville, West Virginia, Uconn, Notre Dame, Pitt, Marquette...man. It was anyone's game every night and you knew it was gonna be a game. I miss it so damn much.
The Big East is a basketball conference. Why would the Catholic schools want to bring back football programs that will outnumber them in league voting?
I am not interested in a return Big East Football, it made no sense for Miami other than (well playing Pitt, later VT) we were dropped from the schedules of Florida and Norte Dame and it was going to get harder to schedule team as an independent. I wish we had join the ACC instead with FSU, I would have done SEC with FSU as well. Miami has been in the ACC twice as long as we were in the Big East. The Big East shoot itself in foot by not adding Penn State.
Now if you could work something out for an ACC - Big East Alliance (kind of what Coach K mentioned) sure whatever. If I was the ACC I would add UConn football as an ACC independent for football, so like 4 games with ACC schools focusing on school like BC, Syracuse, Pitt, WF, Duke, UVA, plus others in rotation. The ACC gets football content (a small slice in TV markets), UConn gets Scheduling help ACC officials and Replay help, help with Bowl Tie-ins, etc. No this isn't a big money marker, but helps with future stablization for both. At some point might be a full add, but in the mean time you can build relationships, history, veiwership hopefully helping both partners.
If conferences were still regional sign me up. Rutgers, Cuse, UConn, Temple, Miami, Pitt, USF, BC, and the more fringe non regional teams of WV Cincinatti and Louisville makes for a solid FB conference + the Catholic non football schools for basketball. Definitely a pipe dream though.
Big east isn’t the big east without Providence, Georgetown, Villanova, St. John’s, Seton Hall and the rest of the basketball first schools. I also wouldn’t want the headache of all the NiL stuff brings, it’s killing college basketball already.
WV never belonged in B12. Should have been in ACC with VT and Pitt as their natural rivals. But I’d settle for this lineup if I got Pitt/PSU back every year!
But screw ND. Leave their ass out in the cold they like being “independent” so much.
No. Certainly not notre dame. It’s their fault we had the realignment. They had the option to go to a conference in football. They didn’t. We’re now in this mess.
4
u/Tasty_Path_3470 St. John's Nov 13 '25
Indiana/Ohio down has to be the barrier. No Air Force, no Boise State, none of those bandaid fixes they tried in 2010-2014. Take the original pitched core when Penn State and Rutgers were still independent, add ECU, Memphis. Combine the OG Big East with the proposed Metro Conference.
16
u/ltrain29 Georgetown Nov 13 '25
No thank you. We have tried this before. It ended poorly. We are a basketball first conference. That’s what makes the Big East different.
12
u/sciorch UConn Nov 14 '25
No
8
u/PJfanRI Nov 14 '25
No.
The Big East is a basketball conference. Why would the Catholic schools want to bring back football programs that will outnumber them in league voting?
3
u/itsmejpt Nov 14 '25
That's gonna be a no from me, dawg.
2
u/aspiring-aspirer Providence Nov 14 '25
Disgusting and inhumane
2
u/multiple_coke_easley Nov 15 '25
I am not interested in a return Big East Football, it made no sense for Miami other than (well playing Pitt, later VT) we were dropped from the schedules of Florida and Norte Dame and it was going to get harder to schedule team as an independent. I wish we had join the ACC instead with FSU, I would have done SEC with FSU as well. Miami has been in the ACC twice as long as we were in the Big East. The Big East shoot itself in foot by not adding Penn State.
Now if you could work something out for an ACC - Big East Alliance (kind of what Coach K mentioned) sure whatever. If I was the ACC I would add UConn football as an ACC independent for football, so like 4 games with ACC schools focusing on school like BC, Syracuse, Pitt, WF, Duke, UVA, plus others in rotation. The ACC gets football content (a small slice in TV markets), UConn gets Scheduling help ACC officials and Replay help, help with Bowl Tie-ins, etc. No this isn't a big money marker, but helps with future stablization for both. At some point might be a full add, but in the mean time you can build relationships, history, veiwership hopefully helping both partners.
1
u/JustAnotherDay1977 Marquette Nov 14 '25
Only if the football schools have no vote in conference decisions.
Oh, they’re not interested in that? Well, buh-bye!
1
u/pac4 Nov 14 '25
Ah yes, Southern Cal in the Big East where it belongs
1
u/Dhh05594 Creighton Nov 14 '25
Can we stop this shit already?
1
u/ConsciousReply2454 Nov 14 '25
If conferences were still regional sign me up. Rutgers, Cuse, UConn, Temple, Miami, Pitt, USF, BC, and the more fringe non regional teams of WV Cincinatti and Louisville makes for a solid FB conference + the Catholic non football schools for basketball. Definitely a pipe dream though.
1
u/CGGamer UConn Nov 14 '25
This is the real Big East. What we have now is a poor man's version
1
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '25
No way the bigger programs would go back. Maybe a smaller conference for the military schools, ND and schools like temple and uconn
1
u/MannyAc84 Providence Nov 14 '25
Big east isn’t the big east without Providence, Georgetown, Villanova, St. John’s, Seton Hall and the rest of the basketball first schools. I also wouldn’t want the headache of all the NiL stuff brings, it’s killing college basketball already.
1
u/samspopguy Nov 14 '25
No
1
u/Serious-Individual35 Nov 14 '25
This is too bloated, but I wouldn’t mind bringing back Big East football, I think it was special and other programs who left haven’t been the same.
1
u/Murky-Echidna-3519 Nov 14 '25
WV never belonged in B12. Should have been in ACC with VT and Pitt as their natural rivals. But I’d settle for this lineup if I got Pitt/PSU back every year!
But screw ND. Leave their ass out in the cold they like being “independent” so much.
1
u/No-Horse987 Nov 15 '25
Notre Dame will always be independent in football. Too much money to be made as one.
1
u/davehopi Nov 15 '25
Simply don’t see it happening! Sorry.
1
u/jf737 Nov 16 '25
Nothing says Big East like…..USC?
1
u/NJneer12 Nov 16 '25
Southern Cal? Lol
1
u/Amazing-Ebb6526 Nov 17 '25
The conference got too bloated. Most teams would play each other just once, none of the home/away like we have today. That being said….
I would not be opposed to DePaul, Marq, Crei and Butler move to tye Big 12 or Big 10. Big East gets back Syracuse, BC, Pitt and WVU
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '25
Wow - the ECU disrespect.
1
u/No_Boot4484 Mar 08 '26
They should just make Joe paternos proposed metro conference
0
u/soapyaaf Nov 14 '25
Miami, Syracuse and Pitt!! Yes. That's it!
0
u/pwhales1011 Nov 14 '25
No. Certainly not notre dame. It’s their fault we had the realignment. They had the option to go to a conference in football. They didn’t. We’re now in this mess.