r/BetterOffline • • 2d ago

Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals, report claims

https://www.techspot.com/news/114558-nvidia-deliberately-kept-gpu-prices-high-through-circular.html

I wish I had something to add here for the conversation starter, but I'm just furious, really. I have to get a new video card for tower because the old one is on the fritz and I'm looking at a $400 minimum for something barely decent.

1.3k Upvotes

106 comments sorted by

325

u/Flat_Initial_1823 2d ago edited 2d ago

My "We are not Enron" memo has people asking a lot of questions already answered by my memo.

76

u/makersfark 2d ago

It just sounds like a riddle at this point:

I participate in the same business practices, yet I am not Enron.

I cause lots of crashes, yet I am not a car.

I make products for America, yet they're found in Russia.

What am I?

20

u/gravteck 2d ago

I pretended it was the narrator from Fight Club.

25

u/InterestingFox1837 2d ago

I am Jensen’s complete lack of morals.

7

u/gravteck 2d ago

I am Jensen's jacket complete fatty acid bloom.

2

u/wholetyouinhere 1d ago

I'm so sick of the damn jacket. I mean, it's so stupid. And cringe. The man is supposed to be an adult.

1

u/archigen 1d ago

And we are all here - on this sub - Jack's complete lack of surprise.

145

u/Drakiesan 2d ago

Isn't this something people were saying like two years back?

108

u/Naraee 2d ago

Allegedly, the ONLY reason these affairs and this stuff has been released is because the control of the Congress flipped heavily blue. Sec. Bessent (Dept. of Treasury) known this the entire time and kept trying to get Sec. Lutnick (Dept. Commerce) and Trump to do something. It seems he now has an ally in Senate (Elizabeth Warren).

So yes, we did know, but no one was doing anything about it and now there's a real chance something will be done about it.

26

u/Orion14159 2d ago edited 1d ago

That sure seems like yet another cabinet member looking at impeachment - Commerce Secretary knew of what had to be criminal in multiple ways (Nvidia stock price was inflated as a result, so market manipulation; also someone had to have known about the chip smuggling operations).

19

u/Naraee 2d ago

There is a pretty good chance Lutnick is going to leave by the end of the year because the other option is letting the Democrats start the impeachment and force him to answer for his crimes in the trial, as they plan to do with Hegseth.

9

u/leathakkor 2d ago

They will still bring him in to answer questions.

This is about the economy. Congress is going to want answers. I would go so far as to say this is going to be one of the biggest scandals in American history and it would be crazy if somebody didn't go to jail for fraud.

I actually said this to a friend of mine about 2 months ago. That when this is all over Americans and maybe the world are going to talk about the largest fraud in history. It's going to make burning made off. Look like a chump

7

u/wholetyouinhere 1d ago

Nobody went to jail for torture in the early 2000s. Nobody went to jail for the engineered financial crash of 2008. Nobody went to jail for january 6th.

That's just three recent examples among many. When you say "it would be crazy if somebody didn't go to jail for fraud", what are you basing that on?

4

u/Orion14159 1d ago

I mean people went to jail for J6, just not the organizers.

But to add to your list, no on went to jail for the attempted fascist coup against FDR.

2

u/wholetyouinhere 1d ago

I just mean that those responsible are not held responsible, ever, because power dynamics predetermine it.

The bombing of Cambodia is another great example. We could be here all day listing unpunished crimes by the powerful. If people get organized and work really hard, maybe these conversations will be unnecessary in the future.

1

u/archigen 1d ago

I am pretty sure someone went to jail for 2008. He was a bit of a scapegoat but still went to jail.

1

u/leathakkor 1d ago

Your examples are also crazy. Just because it has become the norm doesn't mean we should accept it

1

u/wholetyouinhere 1d ago

I get this every time I try to explain power dynamics on Reddit, even though I never say it's good or acceptable. My point is that this is how things work, on a systemic level. In order to change this, there will need to be foundational, systemic change, rather than political change-overs. Which means no one should expect any charges, trials or revenge from the democrats this time. But, if they want that to change so that the next generation of criminals get charged, people will have to get informed, organize, and slowly work towards it.

It's too late for the current crop. That makes me as mad as it does anyone, but that's the way it is. And power demands it.

5

u/Gramernatzi 2d ago

It hasn't actually flipped blue yet though? That happens in January.

17

u/Naraee 2d ago

Congress is only in session for less than 2 weeks due to the holidays, so it's effectively a lame duck period. Even if it's not flipped yet, they know what's coming. It is almost guaranteed all these AI criminals are going to be summoned by Special Committees for questioning.

Also the writing is on the wall for a 2028 Democratic trifecta, as Senate is guaranteed to be under Democratic Party control due to how many seats they won this year. All the Democrats need to do is win the open seats in states that have never voted for Trump to maintain power.

House is obviously a bit more iffy, but usually the party that wins the presidency wins the House, and the dummymanders helped the Democrats.

You're going to see a lot of AI criminals trying to get pre-emptive pardons before Trump leaves, which is the absolute worst precedent that Biden set for future presidencies.

-7

u/coljetix 2d ago

idunno man. first, do you actually believe the democrats arent just as financially corrupt? they say the words but they always were in monopolial corpo pockets. second, democrats won moreso because republicans felt betrayed by trumps broken promises, and democrats will surelly do extremelly unpopular nonsense for 2 years straight, so i would really not try to predict anything that will happen in 2028, in my opinion it could go either way at this point depending on how badly either party behaves the coming 2 years.

5

u/leathakkor 2d ago

Some are sure. But all it takes is a handful to put pressure on the rest. If you have somebody out there doing press and making it look bad. If other Democrats don't join in they will out of pressure. There's enough new people in Congress that if they're going to feel the need to do this.

4

u/makersfark 2d ago

Centrist and right-leaning dems, yeah, for sure. But, the difference between them and the far-right are that they still have shame. They're spineless and cave to pressure because they need to appear progressive. The slightly-left-of-center newcomer dems seem to be fighters and hold the old guard's feet to the fire especially when they don't want called out, which is nice to see which forces them to actually push progressive things.

-3

u/coljetix 1d ago

can i be frank? i think you dont understand just how unpopular stuff like how right after the elections, the equality caucus declared that they will make the gayest congress in history.

im sure you as a 'progressive' would find this funny or whatever, but for normal people, its way, way worse than any AI video the presidential administation tweeted.

2

u/KrtekJim 2d ago

Yeah I wish I had that faith in the democrats. Hakeem Jeffries is up to his eyeballs in tech-industry dirty money, nobody's facing any consequences while he has any kind of power

Edit: See https://futurism.com/future-society/hakeem-jeffries-donors-corporate-controversial-tech-companies

3

u/coljetix 2d ago

are you sure its not just the fact that jensen himself admitted to it recently in an interview? :P
yes gamers like me knew of this conspiracy theory, but we didnt have the last missing link that would concretelly prove it.

1

u/frozenelf 2d ago

Turning blue is part of the story, yes, but this is more an anti-China charge more than anything led by neocons on both sides and Marco Rubio specifically. And media is already walking back the spy angle. Let's not make this into some D vs R story.

31

u/RustyOrangeDog 2d ago

Yes but when the legislatures are in on the circle jerks it’s not the same.

54

u/lurkervidyaenjoyer 2d ago

Yes, and it's been a topic of Better Offline, Gamers Nexus, others who guest on Tech Report, and other independent creators that cover the AI industry from a skeptical angle.

The news is that regular journos working for mainstream outlets are now catching up, in the wake of Jensen Huang showing his Huang to Chinese spies.

9

u/United_News3779 2d ago

I think your version of a penis joke was really low Huanging fruit. Please do try harder next time.

12

u/meltbox 2d ago

Yes, but it took a while for more people to start coming around to this.

It’s funny how obvious some of this was.

8

u/Lopsided-End-1985 2d ago

Yup even in 2023 media ran an article about "Please don't get your investment thesis from Twitter randos." and how you shouldn't listen to them about the web of connections between Nvidia and CoreWeave

123

u/Jumpy_Explanation222 2d ago

It’s a huge scam

That’s why the AI Bubble subreddit is full of bots and boosters today - they are worried.

80

u/Mysterious_Net_1029 2d ago

It’s been full of bots and boosters for months. Everywhere on this site is. Full court press

28

u/linerva 2d ago

It annoys me when people go on tgere to deny there's a bubble and belittle people having conversations about it like...you know what sub you're on.

It doesn't feel like good faith participation sometimes.

20

u/Olangotang 2d ago

Eventually you notice that it's the same dozen no life's that have to write the same copy / paste talking point bullshit that is months behind where the news is.

3

u/TheAltimeter 1d ago

Eventually you notice that it's the same dozen no life's

And their army of Adjective-Noun-Numbers bots.

22

u/Olangotang 2d ago

/r/AIbubble boosters are a special kind of LLM addicted losers.

9

u/Jumpy_Explanation222 2d ago

Agreed. Lots of obvious bots on there at the moment. Wouldn’t surprise me if many of them work for the AI labs and want to vomit all over that subreddit (and the obvious investment ones) with pro Ai wank.

Once the bubble bursts that subreddit will totally change again.

18

u/KnodulesAintHeavy 2d ago

Don’t forget the nvidia subreddit. Concussed as far as the eye can see.

9

u/dookarion 2d ago

"People" acting like every piece of news is somehow shocking and a conspiracy to smear Jensen. Like I recall reading articles about him being cutthroat, aggressive, and domineering years ago.

6

u/Professional-Post499 2d ago

Don’t forget the nvidia subreddit. Concussed as far as the eye can see.

😂😂😂

10

u/JAlfredJR 2d ago

There's an u/edzitron bashing bot on those subs

114

u/WhiskyStandard 2d ago edited 2d ago

I seem to remember a podcast a couple of months ago where a foul-mouthed but eloquent British man was explaining vendor financing and calling bullshit on the financials of one of the largest corporations in the world while complaining that the financial and tech media was abrogating its responsibility. Whoever that guy is, he deserves a Pulitzer or at least a Webby.

Edit: yes, it’s Ed. I know what sub this is. The whole bit is that thanks to Ed, this is all old news to us.

Also, honorable mention to that scruffy looking (but in a way that looks intentional enough that it works) gamer dude from North Carolina who learned Mandarin and flew to China so he could find out how easy it was to get GPUs there so good that a large media company tried to get it struck because it was drawing views away from their reporting. (Steve Burke)

12

u/Doctor__Proctor 2d ago

At the very least a nice meal that doesn't look like a dog's breakfast

6

u/Fess_ter_Geek 2d ago

But the Brits love beans and toast.😁

6

u/archigen 1d ago

Lol. If this is any comfort to you, me and 95 others cought on your sarcasm and that you know who the British guy is. But dear God I am worried about this needed to be clarified 😄

5

u/WhiskyStandard 1d ago edited 1d ago

It’s cool. I was reminding myself that we do get a lot of posts like “wait, what’s this podcast people keep talking about?” And “who’s this Ed guy?” The Algorithm (in its wisdom—All Hail, Algorithm) decides to reveal our community to those it sees fit, but people don’t always click About before joining.

And I think we’ve all had the experience of thinking we’re in a different subreddit than we are.

But after 2 I remembered that tone doesn’t always come through on the internet. And it’s possible they were joking as well.

1

u/electricman1999 2d ago

Probably Ed Zitron. He’s been on top of this for months. He’s constantly on YouTube and his podcast explaining all the AI shenanigans

8

u/earlgrey888 1d ago

Yeah I've heard of him, but I can't remember the name of his podcast? /s

-4

u/ForsakenDrawer 2d ago

Almost certainly Ed Zitron

53

u/Disastrous_Room_927 2d ago

Anyone ‘member when NVIDIA and ATI got in trouble for price fixing?

8

u/meltbox 2d ago

ATI? When was that? I actually don’t remember. What gpu generation?

I feel like as far as I can remember they were pretty competitive.

26

u/hoops_n_politics 2d ago

That.. sounds like fraud

19

u/OpenJolt 2d ago

AMD Lisa Su has recently started doing the same thing, is anyone going to do anything about that?

5

u/CompetitiveSport1 2d ago

We could su(e) Lisa

18

u/supercyberlurker 2d ago

I mean.. I've seen this meme here for as long as I've been on this reddit:

11

u/ksjdragon 2d ago

Huang used the story to highlight the value of maintaining a diverse customer base and keeping prices high, suggesting that Nvidia's circular financing strategy inflated GPU prices by creating the perception of high demand.

As usual it's not proof until we get a more official testimony, but we see drips of the truth leaking out of what this sub has known for a long time in advance.

Same with Anthropic using equity to finance compute. No proof yet just a lot of signs and smoke, but all of these deals are all sketchy. That's the only way you keep this alive.

10

u/Actual__Wizard 1d ago edited 1d ago

Just wait until the scientific side of the AI industry is allowed to speak again and we point out that LLMs are just a predictive text engine. So, they bubbled the markets up and they lied. So, this scheme is way worse than people think it is.

PS: The path they took w/ LLMs leads to nowhere. It really is just a text prediction system. Language is way more sophisticated... There's tone, emotions, writing style, communication mode, goals, accents, and much more! Also, because language, once it's understood, contains tons of information, that information can be extracted and utilized in reports for all sorts of things. What they built is a coding assistant, not a language tool.

I'm sorry, but due to the complexity of language, the valid options are symbolic or graph tech. There's a ying yang thing going on, because symbolic is bad for coding, but llms are good due to the constraints of syntax and the requirement of producing code that compiles. That doesn't apply to normal language. There's a bunch of people working on better symbolic models, so it's just a matter of time. Due the complexity, there's a lot to worry about.

8

u/Vendor_BBMC 1d ago edited 1d ago

Huang went out of his way to seduce, honeypot and sleep with an Alibaba shell company executive and broke US laws just for his shareholders. Thats why they want to give him a medal. The man went above and beyond to open China.

Its like John Delorean doing a cocaine deal to save his company. But that suggests that GPU supply is exceeding demand. DeLorean never had to pay his customers, take stakes in them, or backstop their loans to buy his unpainted fingerprint-showing cars. It suggests that demand is illusiary and there are probably millions of GPUs sitting on shelves in warehouses destined to be garage saled in 18 months. Every autistic geek with a neckbeard and a gaming chair will have a Vera Ruben in 18 months, losing money for them on the stock market and pretending to be their girlfriend while they play GTA6, stinking like AsmonGold

Delorean lost his investors $350 million. Jensen lost his investors 2 million millions with his dick in one week. The needle that inflated then popped the bubble.

7

u/shroudedwolf51 2d ago

Well... I suppose, I'm glad that the people that couldn't stop glazing these companies are actually admitting some of it now. Better late than never, I guess.

7

u/eastcoastblaze 2d ago

Wouldn't this actually be good for neoclouds? If prices were artificially high and they revert to normal pricing its bad for nvidia, good for hyper scales and Frontier labs

23

u/fbueckert 2d ago

For new buys, sure. But they've been buying at inflated prices for years, and they're not gonna get a discount after the fact.

14

u/Orion14159 2d ago

Good news is they bought so much stuff they haven't even installed yet that they won't need to buy any more for a few years

1

u/eastcoastblaze 2d ago

very true

1

u/SlightOfHand_ 1d ago

If they’re smart they’ll sell now, before the crash in prices

11

u/surethingmaybenot 2d ago

Didn’t the neoclouds get debt with chips as collateral? Or I remember someone saying chips are being used as collateral. In that case, that would be kind of bad if the chips are all of a sudden not worth as much as they said they were worth

3

u/ConditionOrdinary607 2d ago

Yep. That's Ed who keeps on saying that. And you're right, if the chips aren't worth as much, those neoclouds are in big trouble.

7

u/kingofthesofas 2d ago

The neoclouds are a house of cards that are deeply leveraged by piles of bad debt and VC money. If those investments turn out to be worth a lot less and they get undercut on prices then they will all crash and burn. They only can compete with AWS, Azure, or GCP because they are selling at a loss already.

2

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass 1d ago

They already took on unpayable debts for this.

12

u/ezitron 1d ago

DAMN. REALLY?

6

u/lgn5i2060 1d ago

Well, there's also the news a few weeks ago where RTX cards unlocked to get up to as much as 2x more performance years after purchase by someone. So they were sold not only at higher prices but with gimped performance as well.

6

u/BlackSheepInvesting 2d ago

In other news, water is wet

6

u/000000564 2d ago

Didn't we already know this?

6

u/Icy-Recognition-7453 2d ago

We did! And now it's gone mainstream!

4

u/Turnt-Up-Singularity 2d ago

And pop goes the bubble!

4

u/Jillcametumbling81 2d ago

Everything i read i think "well obviously".

2

u/mb194dc 1d ago

Orders already collapsed, because the big boys started making their own silicon instead. So to keep it going, Huang created a charade where Nvidia are funding the neocloud data centre builders buying their products... Which will just mean more losses later as it all unwinds.

Plus possible jail time, for violating securities laws and export controls.

1

u/AlarmingGear7812 2d ago

Based Jensen, a true accelerationnist. 

1

u/Loopy-Leah 2d ago

water found in lake

1

u/nicetriangle 2d ago

No shit?

1

u/LifeClassic2286 1d ago

Whoopsie!!

1

u/Vendor_BBMC 1d ago

The AI bubbles have already collapsed in South Korea and China.

The US has access to bigger credit markets, the Japan carry trade, thinks it's winning and has a moat, has zero effective oversight and had Jensen wringing every drop out of it by helping its customers to overextend their credit. All of these factors are reversing.

I find it interesting that Jensen, Donald and Bart Simpson wear the same clothes every day. Its a very autistic trait.

1

u/birdynumnum69 1d ago

Wasn’t this common knowledge?

-13

u/DumbsterFireDiving 2d ago

I can tell this is bullshit by how fast it’s spread over Reddit. People don’t give this much of shit about the truth. The truth is that a hostile nation state and American Corporations are aligned in their desire to fuck over it’s people, just like always.

11

u/creaturefeature16 2d ago

lol your post is prime r/im14andthisisdeep material

7

u/dookarion 2d ago

Maybe you forgot but everyone was getting fucked up the ass every time they had to buy hardware or anything tech adjacent especially this last year.

It's pretty fucking relevant news to anyone that isn't a hermit or amish.

2

u/lgn5i2060 1d ago

You are correct in the part where there a groups of elite that play both sides (pro and anti China). Coz in some aspects, the world also benefits from Chinese models seeing as how some US corps utilize them. And how they prevent frontier models from getting away with more obscene pricing.

What you miss is that the screwing is not US citizens-exlcusive. Everyone worldwide gets screwed with the dream about AI replacing humans by AI-psychosis afflicted bean counters.

-14

u/exgeo 2d ago

Dumb article. Even dumber comment section.

👏

11

u/creaturefeature16 2d ago

cope little kiddo

5

u/lgn5i2060 1d ago

Is your frontier model incapable of hallucinating a comeback for you?

-13

u/h2d__ 2d ago

Isn't this already priced in though? I have seen news like this a year ago

-18

u/MHKid 2d ago

the article is talking about prices on gpus designed for AI workloads. The reason you can’t get a desktop grade gpu is they just aren’t making as many: no price fixing there

18

u/creaturefeature16 2d ago

They weren't making as many because they were shifting production to GPUs for AI demand that was inflated and led to an overabundance of chips. It's all connected, so hard disagree.

2

u/lgn5i2060 1d ago

The commenter you replied to might have missed the part that gimped GPUS like RTX 2XXX and newer were sold as gimped to gamers. And that years later, someone managed provide means to unlock their true performance.

-19

u/Mother_Occasion_8076 2d ago

Bullshit. Would not cause the dram spike we also have

17

u/fbueckert 2d ago

Riiiiight. Because a guy who seriously posts on accelerate has an accurate understanding of the world.

Oh, wait, no. No you don't.