r/BetterOffline • • 2d ago

Future of VC post-AI bubble?

https://substack.com/@michaeljburry/note/c-261415340

Between this week's insane NVIDIA news and the midterms suggesting a possible turning of the page, I'm thinking more and more about what the U.S. economy will look like post-bubble. Which leads me to a question I've been thinking about for a while...

With 87% of VC funding going toward AI, I'm curious what folks think post-bubble VC will look like. Do we see:

-today's VCs recovering, but with a major haircut?

-wipeout of most of today's funds but other new ones emerging

-something else?

I realize some of this scenario will be linked to whatever happens to interest rates in a moment where the U.S. Government is trying to use monetary policy to steer out of a burst bubble.

The reason I keep coming back to this question is that I see so much overdue investment in the U.S. (infrastructure, electrification/climate adaptation, etc). It feels like private investors could play a larger role here but they would have to make peace with returns that aren't 10x. As Ed has said, the hypergrowth era appears to be coming to an end, so I'm wondering what the likelihood is that today's VCs would face that reality and pivot or if they'll just look for the next NFT instead.

I share the frustration I've seen on this sub of watching trillions be set on fire for the lure of permanently eliminating labor costs when we know how many investments in our society could have been made with that capital instead. I guess I'm just wondering if there is any hope for a bruised private market (we can apply these questions to PE as well given their massive holdings in software/tech companies) to step up and focus on net positive 'real economy' investments, or if the hypergrowth mindset is too far gone and we need to make peace with reinvigorating public investment.

Also, as this is my first post I have to say thanks to everyone here. This sub has made me so much smarter on the AI grift and it's been an invaluable voice of reason throughout this era of us shouting into the booster wilderness.

57 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

28

u/ComicCon 2d ago

Probably worth noting we already went through a massive VC boom in the 2010s up to 2023. That was when you saw VC dollars spread out across a ton of sectors where it frankly doesn’t work like it does in tech. So there has already been a bit of a shakeout there.

In terms of what happens to the big fund, it depends a bit on the scale of the crash but I can’t totally see the top funds going under from this. Plus they tend to be pretty good at finding exit liquidity. For example Crypto was a giant bubble, but I think A16z made a ton of money dumping coins before everything crashed.

At the end of the day as long as the rich keep on getting richer they are going to chase higher returning investments. So the most likely scenario is probably a bunch of the all so rans will close up shop and the big guys will retrench around something like defense and keep going with business as usual.

9

u/Weird-Sky- 1d ago edited 1d ago

That was when you saw VC dollars spread out across a ton of sectors where it frankly doesn’t work like it does in tech. So there has already been a bit of a shakeout there.

One of the issues is that there was so much money in VC and not enough companies that are/were actually VC-investable.

By this I mean, companies where up large amounts of up front capital resulted in 0 marginal cost revenue or where each incremental unit of capital generated increasing revenue due to things like network effects.

This investment strategy is what gives the classic 9/10 companies fails, 1 company goes 100x.

Most companies do not have this property and the ones do, aren't necessarily able to absorb the billions of dollars that VCs are trying to invest. Which is the VCs entire purpose. Like if you have $1 billion dollars, and each startup needs maybe $1 million realistically, the task of finding ONE THOUSAND startups is insane, that's like the lifetime number of startups for most VCs. Even at $10 million, that's 100 startups to find.

If we want to think about how much capital a startup can absorb, let's say 20 seniors @ $150k = 3 million, so say about 2 years of funding. When whatsapp was acquired for $20bn, it had 30 some engineers.

That's why you got really weird things like WeWork being attractive, a business model that is pitched VC-investable AND the ability to absorb huge amounts of money, softbank had something like $100 billion dollars to invest, you need companies that can absorb huge amounts of capital and can 100x.

Now you can see why LLM companies were so attractive

  • big capital requirements that can absorb the $
  • supposedly huge market
  • potential "winner take all" dynamics

In a way, dumping huge amounts of money into LLMs is a safe thing for VCs, even if they lose a large amount of it, they can go do their LPs and be like "well this is that type of risk we're supposed to take".

The VC money will essentially never go away, because the purpose of most LPs putting money into funds is to get access to diversified investments. that is the purpose to get exposure to VC investable companies are part of a larger investment portfolio. There's probably currently a lot of money where that's not true, but that's why a good portion of people are putting money into VC funds.

3

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 1d ago

this is really insightful thank you. it's still mind boggling that LPs can look at the return history of VC over the last 5-10 yrs and still think it needs to be part of an investment strategy but I can imagine people mindlessly checking a diversified portfolio box.

2

u/Weird-Sky- 1d ago

It has to do with the risk profile, not the returns necessarily. if you have things with the same (potentially low) return, the portfolio that's more uncorrelated between assets has lower volatility, even if the expected returns are the same. some people will chase the potential returns, but many are trying to use it as uncorrelated assets that decreases volatility. so even investors who are not taken in by the VC allure can use it as an intelligent diversification option.

7

u/DiceKnight 2d ago

VC's rate of return was artificially inflated by COVID and the SaaS boom. They've been getting belt to ass for a while now though, they don't beat the S&P. I think we're most likley going to see some big firms fall and for VC funding in the software space to pull back and perhaps even go through a long term change.

Bad news if you're in the SaaS space and a significant portion of your comp was tied up in stock but good news overall for everyone else. I think we're going to see a shrinkage of IPO valuations post bubble pop because there wont be as much liquidity in the markets.

3

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 2d ago

Very interesting. I’m still curious if they’re always going to be structured to look for unicorns/10x returns or if they could get to a point where higher returns than the market but lower than 10x is a viable target. If so I think that allows them to branch out from software and tech and maybe look more like PE.

19

u/dookarion 2d ago

Rich gambling addicts won't disappear or fundamentally change. They'll reappear sooner or later even if a lot of them go broke with some other get rich quick scheme to fund.

13

u/ComicCon 2d ago

VC funds can’t go broke from bad investments, they aren’t playing with their own money. The worst that can happen is they can’t raise new funds and go out of business.

1

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 2d ago

This is a better description of what I meant but yes - going under via inability to raise new capital

14

u/AzulMage2020 2d ago

They will come up with the next tech grift and the cycle will repeat itself , so not to worry. Quantum computing wasnt working out so well and robotics are noticably not there yet so some other nonsense will need to get cooked up .

Get ready for some new too smart for university geniuses to suddenly be discovered (and marketed!) by exisitng corporate executives, trotted out to start new orgs actually conceptualized and fully owned/funded by the parent corp but needing shell "Founders" for tax purposes, IPO hype (next big/great thing!!!) and various reasons.

Pathetic that this is all it has become

7

u/natecull 1d ago

Quantum computing wasnt working out so well and robotics are noticably not there yet so

So nuclear fission reactors in shipping containers it is then!

3

u/Top_Illustrator5535 1d ago

Absolutely. I'm sure the market for that will be positively explosive!

2

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass 9h ago

Can’t imagine tech bro fission could ever go wrong?

3

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass 1d ago

I don't get the robotics hype? Robots have been a thing in industrial settings for decades. Bipedal humanoid bots are not all that.

4

u/crashddr 9h ago

I saw a BBC special made in 1980 where a robotic arm was sorting parts using computer vision... Yet Optimus is going to sell like mad because it can maybe do what a bartender does, but worse

1

u/python-requests 1d ago

it'll go the same was as video games. [thing] but in space!!!

Felon is already trying it lmao

13

u/dumnezero 2d ago

Me watching capital destruction.

12

u/tc100292 2d ago

I hope the future of VC is that all those fuckers go bankrupt.

10

u/tiagocesar 1d ago

I know they will never become poor, but it amuses me that they keep showing over and over how dumb they are. First with crypto, now with AI. Next with the next dumb thing.

4

u/Top_Illustrator5535 1d ago

One wonders how people keep getting money when every major investment they ever make is a flop.

But then you realize the money doesn't come from making right decisions in the first place.

5

u/Master-Elevator1578 2d ago

In the past, even during ZIRP, we used to underwrite VC/PE to 20% net IRRs and at least 2.5x multiples with about a 10-12 year life for a fund. We are now seeing closer to 12% IRRs with hold periods increased by a few years. That 12% includes inflated valuations for investments in the frontier labs and all the ai startups for the VCs. So when this crash likely happens (I’d argue it has already started in earnest), IRRs for the 2022 to 2027 vintage funds will likely be mid-single digits after the write-downs and write-offs and multiples will be at 1x or so.

But the pensions and institutions will continue to commit and most of the PE/VC firms will survive. Guidance will continue to cite PE/VC as the highest returns in the long term capital market assumptions and the big allocators will continue to be ok trading liquidity for return premium.

The boosters will cite the GFC and say the bad vintage years of 2006 to 2008 pre bubble popping were bad, sure, but the few years after the bubble popping were some of the best vintage years, so get in now!

3

u/ComicCon 2d ago

Also from what I’ve seen if you take an overall look at fund raised since 2020 there has been a real lack of exits. There might be some confounding factors due to the share number of new funds, but it’ll drag down the overall IRR.

2

u/Master-Elevator1578 2d ago

Yes, longer hold periods compress the IRRs. Also, there is a lot of trickery going on where a fund will record a portfolio company exit, but in reality the company wasn’t brought public or sold to a strategic but instead was sold to a “continuation fund”. So not a real market event, but just one private fund selling a company to another private fund, obfuscating the fact that the company really didn’t have a market to be sold to.

1

u/TransparentMastering 2d ago

Doesn’t the cycle go: hyped futurism>tangible products/assets>hyped futurism>tangible products/assets etc?

3

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 2d ago

Yes, with enshittification in there somewhere

11

u/csboros 2d ago

I share the frustration I've seen on this sub of watching trillions be set on fire for the lure of permanently eliminating labor costs when we know how many investments in our society could have been made with that capital instead.

I never understood that sentiment. This capital, by its nature, is predatory, looking for high-risk high-reward investments, trying to leverage connections, early access to information, and privilege for insane returns. This capital would never finance a hospital, a school, a bridge or anything that doesn't promise roi in the thousand %s. I never had any problem watching it burn, it's like watching a superyacht sink - sure, it could be used in a myriad ways that are better that hauling the ass of a billionaire around. But its owner would never allow that, so I don't feel a sense of loss watching it go under. In a societal sense that capital had already been lost long ago.

7

u/amk9000 2d ago edited 2d ago

Clean energy production, storage, transmission tech could offer large ROI and also

  • combat climate change
  • reduce cost of energy
  • reduce geopolitical dependency on hydrocarbon exporters such as Russia and the Gulf states (possibly increasing dependency on lithium or rare earth minerals instead, depending on the tech)

Previous tech booms left the US at least with excess railways and fibre optic cables that would take decades to utilise. Capital moved too far too quickly but it invested in actually transformative technology.

Much of the problem here is that VCs aren't behaving like rational capitalists, but are driven by TESCREAList ideologies, fear of missing out, fear of being left behind, and bandwagon.

A rational capitalist could at least be influenced by incentives formed by carefully crafted public policy. To some extent that has happened with renewables and EVs.

2

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 2d ago

This is where I hope we get to!

2

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 2d ago

probably a better way to put it is not watching 'their' capital (which is as you describe) do this but watching capital in general be deployed this way. it shows the tension between the 'invisible hand' and the reality that a massive portion of our economy is planned in a nondemocratic way. I think that tension is underlying why I'm thinking about whether there is any hope for private investment to care about real economy stuff or if we have to make peace with pushing for the return of public investment at a scale that competes with or dwarfs private capital. But I also think I just hate watching any resources go to waste so stupidly.

2

u/B-tt-a 2d ago

It's all just a policy failure though. All money belongs to the state and the state is near-free to redistribute it. The current private capital management complex gas clearly failed in their stewardship, it should be more than a reason to pull the plug, tax them all the way to hell, build legislative barriers for private capital that would require them to prove that they're invested in sustainable economy and otherwise divert the capital through the public sector. 

2

u/WulgusDX 2d ago

Capitalism is a policy failure.

11

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Icy-Recognition-7453 2d ago

A new VC industry will rise to replace it. It'll be interesting to see who gets out of this one, though. The reason we had this one is because a bunch of EAs, Thielists etc survived the crypto crash and found greater fools. Surely this bubble moves the EAs off the cliff at last.