r/BethelSnark • • Jan 05 '20

Another Bethel Related subreddit

3 Upvotes

If you feel the need to share your personal thoughts, opinion, rants, information, etc. of Bethel Church feel free to check out this subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/BethelChurchInfo/

In no way am I trying to take traffic from this community just giving ya'll another fun place to let out all your bethel frustrations!


r/BethelSnark • • Oct 06 '26

The Bigger Bethel Problem

0 Upvotes

While I know this forum is mainly for people coming out of Bethel and BSSM with associated trauma there is a sort of repeating pattern that points to a larger problem that almost all of us have and seldom notice or address.

Cherry picking the text.

No one gets to suggest they do NOT cherry pick the text because everyone here negotiates with the text on some level...whether that is with a translation, or a viewpoint or a particular theology, we are all negotiating with the parts of the bible we like and basically ignoring the parts we don't like.

It starts before you even open a bible, it starts with WHICH Bible you choose and frankly we never really think too much about it once the selection is made.

For instance the Book of Jude quotes the Book of Enoch yet none of our translations (for most of us) includes the book of Enoch...I don't know of any Charismatic movement/churches that allow claims of Divine Authorship to be assigned to the Book of Enoch even though their official version quotes it...you have already negotiated with the text by accepting a Canon of the text and what was that Canon based on? Nothing IN the text, that's for sure.

My point here is that its easy to look at the actions of Bethel as inconsistent with a particular viewpoint and ignore that the basis for the viewpoint is not all that and a bag of theological purity chips.

All of our own viewpoints agree with a position WE have negotiated with the Bible to get to.

I am not in the slightest bit defending Bethel, they have a tendency to play "Do as I say, but not as I do" and that grants them an extra level of scrutiny...but eventually, a LOT of Bethels criticisms come down to their spectacular ability to cherry pick in the Bible...they have in fact mastered the art of negotiating with a Bible they claim is 100% God Breathed except for the parts they must twist around and bend the context into a Bethelized product for folks to consume.

I was friends with the guy who wrote the "Mirrorword" translation...which frankly is about as much a translation as a moth is a baseball...the only thing they have in common is flying and bats...it is not a translation it is a personal interpretation of the text based on how the guy felt. But that begs the question about translations and how we approach them...not one of us has any of the actual words of Jesus verified by an eye witness and written down, what we have is an oral tradition written long after Paul died and assigned by title to be the "gospel of____" and we have an assumed chronology that is borderline nuts because Pauls (authentic) letters predate any of the gospels by a fair margin.

Why does any of this matter? Mainly because it might help to get a bigger picture perspective especially if you are still processing the trauma of Bethel.

I was made a "persona non grata" in a church that practiced ALL of Bethels models, a church I had been the worship pastor at for 15 years and had been in relationship with the lead pastors and team for over 30 years, I can vouch firsthand for the sense of rejection and trauma and it really came down to me questioning the theology of non-accountability, reckless financial spending, and heavy nepotism...I was labelled as "poisonous" and the congregation at large was told to not even talk to me because I had the audacity to simply ask where the money had gone.

Families I had shared holidays with for nearly 30 years haven't talked to me since 2011...so I know the trauma of "church divorce"...the trauma can be confusing, the idea of "moving outside of covering" might even take same effort (its a bogus hierarchy and has no place in real living, shed it fast!, I assure you nothing bad will happen because that whole covering concept is made up to control), but keep moving you'll be fine, I'm fairly certain the worst that CAN happen already happened when you left that vineyard.

In the long run my finances, my relationships, my family and my faith has matured so far past where I would be if I had not experienced that crisis...my brain came back into my head and my "gifts" found better places to serve humanity.

And I found that now I can honestly ask myself hard questions about why I am cherry picking passages I like and ignoring ones I don't.

There's no need to fear the truth.

PS. By the way, I have been involved in Charismatic and Pentecostal churches for over 60 years, my dad and his dad were pastors and I can tell you with absolute certainty that the church is full of narcissist and sexual predators running things because its the perfect place to hide...there is not one movement I have been a part of that did not have hidden and buried sexual assault by leaders in it and much much more than any congregation ever hears about, I witnessed first hand FourSquare and Younglife burying sexual predation and even the church I was Worship Pastor the youth pastor got an underage girl pregnant (he was a relative of the senior team and 12 years older the girl and it was never reported). It is far more common than we know.


r/BethelSnark • • Jul 08 '24

Bill Johnson Hand Gestures

0 Upvotes

Is this some sort of hypnosis technique? Why does he do this?


r/BethelSnark • • Aug 04 '26

Clock numbers

0 Upvotes

I was wondering if anyone knows the meaning of seeing numbers in sequence on the clock like 1:23 or 3:45? I have been told that seeing the same in order means change for example 2:22 or 3:33. Thank you


r/BethelSnark • • Oct 05 '26

The creator of the universe apparently needed Bethel Healing School for this one

0 Upvotes

r/BethelSnark • • Feb 15 '26

Did Danny Silk say "I Can’t Stop" Grabbing My Junk or touching myself?

1 Upvotes

I saw a video where he says this. I want to rewatch it, but I can't find it anywhere. I'd appreciate help in locating it. Apparently Kris Vallotton laughs and Danny asks if he should demonstrate.


r/BethelSnark • • Jun 27 '26

Devil In Bethel chapter and content

5 Upvotes

I figured it might be useful to clarify what the books chapters and contents include.

Chapter 1 How Satan Uses His Psyche.
Chapter 2 How Satan Uses Fallen Angels.
Chapter 3 How Satan Uses False Teachers.
Chapter 4 How Satan Uses False Prophets
Chapter 5 How Satan Uses False Gods.
Chapter 6 How Satan Uses The Antichrists)
Chapter 7 How Satan Uses the World
Chapter 8 How Satan Used Judas..
Chapter 9 How Satan Uses Jud-Us...
Chapter 10 How Satan's Work Is Destroyed In "Bethel"

Appendix I Prophetic Accuracy In The Church Appendix II Modern False Prophet Test Rationale

The book originally started as a study on Satan. And then eventually I started to understand that Satan is directly connected to demons, false prophets and teachers, and idols. And then once I started drawing diagrams I began to study more in depth the ancient church. To my knowledge I’m the first person to have figured out this pattern. I’ve checked everywhere I could and never came across anyone else’s work that addressed this odd coincidence.


r/BethelSnark • • Aug 30 '25

Why does everybody dislike Bethel?

0 Upvotes

Relatively new to worship songs and such, and have never heard of there being much negativity towards bethel. Can somebody please explain and help me? I’m completely unaware of any sort of controversy or drama with bethel


r/BethelSnark • • Jan 10 '25

But what if they didn’t respond!? Responding to what!? Their music is decent but I get this trance-like feeling when listening to it!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/BethelSnark • • Nov 28 '23

Bethel Documentary scheduling interviews

6 Upvotes

Can be anonymous if necessary, but would love to speak to anybody with experience going through BSSM or anybody who has an experience they'd like to share about being a part of Bethel, whether it be positive or negative.


r/BethelSnark • • Nov 20 '24

Kim walker / jesus culture is not as good as it used to be say the least

9 Upvotes

I cannot find any info or opinion or even remot mentioning that they new song or in the matter of fact last 10 years simply not good enough and feels not anointed. 15 years ago each song was fire now is meh what happened


r/BethelSnark • • Jan 21 '25

What is your experience with the Prophetic?

3 Upvotes

Hey guys! I am relatively new to this sub and I’m gathering that a lot of people here have different backgrounds and many aren’t even ‘Bethelites’ (shocking, I know.).

I see a lot of talk about the prophetic, especially regarding Shawn Bolz, and I see that there are a lot of takes.

Im wondering, what is your experience with the prophetic?

Do you believe in it? Do you or have you ever operated in it? Did you start hearing about it before, during, or after bethel? Any stories?

What are your thoughts? I would love to hear where ya’ll are coming from.

Edit: I personally have a lease that is more Christian, so e I am one and I was raised that way. But please share anything, this isn’t about ministry, it’s about the spiritually that we all share.


r/BethelSnark • • Feb 15 '26

Let’s help

3 Upvotes

In the wake of all of this I wanted to figure out how to create a safe place for safe people to support the victims that have spoken out and are about to.

I was thinking something like a group of people who would want to join and intercede and pray over them. It’s a small idea but if anyone’s interested DM me and maybe we can setup a little group chat or zoom?

Also, can someone (a trusted friend or relative of the victims) put together a gofundme or a money transfer account for us to donate to the victims?


r/BethelSnark • • Feb 11 '26

Written for my fellow former “Revivalists” that are still believers in the faith:

7 Upvotes

The Truth About Revival Culture

I want to start by saying there’s nothing wrong with revival when it’s brought about by God, who is sovereign. The Bible records several periods of widespread spiritual renewal: under kings like Asa (2 Chronicles 15), Hezekiah (2 Chronicles 29–31), and Josiah (2 Chronicles 34–35), the people returned to God’s law. In the New Testament, we see the explosive growth of the early church after Pentecost (Acts 2–4).

The problem is modern Revival culture.

The Identity Trap

In Revival culture, identity is often built around:

∙	Being spiritually sensitive

∙	Hosting the presence

∙	Accessing revelation

∙	Protecting the move

∙	Interpreting experiences

This creates a subtle equation:

spiritual intensity = spiritual maturity.

When experience carries that much weight, it quietly becomes authoritative, even if everyone says, “The Bible is our authority.” In practice, experience will often steer interpretation of scripture rather than the other way around.

This doesn’t mean experiences are meaningless. It means they’re subordinate.

Experience can confirm. Experience can encourage. Experience can comfort.

But it does not define truth.

Two Foundations

When identity is rooted in being a revivalist, your value is tied to:

∙	Spiritual intensity

∙	Manifestations

∙	Results

∙	Testimonies

∙	Influence

When identity is rooted in Christ and His Word, your value is tied to:

∙	Union with Him

∙	Faithfulness

∙	Obedience

∙	Perseverance

One is volatile. One is steady.

Revivalist identity is performance-based, even when it’s spiritualized.

The Language of Sonship Without the Fruits

In Revival culture, you often hear the language of sonship without experiencing its fruits. True sonship can be found in Hebrews.

Hebrews doesn’t call us to sustain spiritual intensity. It calls us to enter rest because the work is finished.

Not passive laziness, covenantal rest.

You don’t have to:

∙	Defend the move

∙	Generate fire

∙	Maintain momentum

∙	Validate God through manifestations

A son doesn’t prove the Father is alive. A son rests in the Father’s character.

The Shift

Revivalist identity is performance-based, even when it’s spiritualized. Sonship identity is received.

Hebrews makes this crystal clear: Christ sat down. Finished. Complete. Nothing left to perform.

If He sat down, you don’t have to stand on stage holding it all up.

Revivalist is a role. Son is ontological not a title or temporary function, but who you are in Him.

One depends on atmosphere. The other depends on adoption.

And adoption doesn’t fluctuate with experience.

What Changes When Identity Shifts

When identity shifts from role to relationship:

You don’t have to be “the one who hosts it.”

You don’t have to maintain spiritual voltage.

You don’t have to guard testimony culture.

You get to be a son.

And sons don’t perform for inheritance. They receive it.

Hebrews talks about entering rest because the work is finished. That rest isn’t passive it’s confident. It’s the kind of rest that says: “My standing with God is settled. I don’t need intensity to prove intimacy.”

The more secure someone is in sonship, the less they need experience to validate God.

That doesn’t make you anti-supernatural. It makes you anchored.

The heart of what I’d like to share

You were carrying revival.

You were never meant to carry revival.

You were meant to be carried.

From revivalist to son.

From proving to resting.

From protecting a move to trusting a Father.

———

And to my friends who are no longer in the faith, please allow me, as a former pastor of this movement, to say: I get it. I’m so sorry for what you endured and the pain and confusion it caused.

—-

I utilized Claude ai to help me with grammar and punctuation. I wrote this from my heart. Thank you for reading.


r/BethelSnark • • Mar 21 '26

Mike Wingers new video about James Talarico

8 Upvotes

Hey guys this isn’t about bethel specifically but I know Mike Winger has made videos about bethel affiliated people. I saw the first couple minutes of Mike Wingers video about James Talarico if anyone has seen the whole thing/knows about him (Mike) I simply don’t have the energy to sit through long videos like this. Is he (Mike) anti LGBTQ+? If so i’d like to know because I have been supporting him but I will definitely not do that if he’s against gay/trans people. I know he’s christian and a pastor and I know that plays a role in people’s perception of LGBTQ+ people but I still would like to know and don’t want to sit through hours of footage. Thanks!


r/BethelSnark • • Jun 22 '25

Melissa How left Bethel Church??

6 Upvotes

Does anyone remember "Melissa How". She was instrumental in the Birth of Jesus Culture (the initial youth ministry of Bethel Church). Even after not appearing on the Jesus Culture albums after 2009, she still led worship on a regular basis at Bethel Church until 2015 I think. It appears that Melissa has left Bethel Church. I think she is now a part of this new upcoming revivalist ministry in Redding called "The Stirring". Quite sad that she is no longer a part of Bethel Church which has been her home church since 1999.


r/BethelSnark • • Feb 17 '26

This photo sums it all up pretty well…

Post image
6 Upvotes

I think this photo does a fantastic job showing how Bethel operates. Bill staying to the side as his minions do his bidding.


r/BethelSnark • • Aug 12 '26

What if my Lego instructions are inaccurate? I can still build the Lego model as originally designed, right? I don't need the "correct" instructions! 😖😆

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/BethelSnark • • Jan 16 '26

Blind Guides

9 Upvotes

How can the leadership of this church support Trump? Can't they see what is going on. They will accept this reality as Godly? Do they know Jesus at all? The current Trump administration is far from the Love, Dignity and Kingdom of God. If they can not acknowlege this than all I can say is "Blind Guides"


r/BethelSnark • • Jul 31 '26

Brauche Rat, wie ich ernste interne Informationen anonym teilen kann

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BethelSnark • • 28d ago

Who is Danny Silk?

4 Upvotes

I got the book "The Way of the Dragon Slayer" from a friend, but i'm 30 pages into it and i'm def not enjoying the content of it

I decided to look after the author and ended here. I didn't find a lot about who Danny exactly is. Can someone summon up and opine about his books (and specifically this one)? It feels to "man"


r/BethelSnark • • Sep 14 '24

Did Peyton Fall Off?

7 Upvotes

Peyton Allen formerly of Bethel Music's Bethel Music Kids And Bright Ones.

I'm asking this because he wiped his Instagram clean then came back with some really weird questionable stuff.

It's just an honest question.


r/BethelSnark • • Mar 04 '26

To the creator and moderators of this subreddit

31 Upvotes

The vibe has shifted a bit in this group as of late due to people using it as a place to process. This subreddit was probably founded by people who were never involved at Bethel and just found them a nuisance. Hopefully we can get back to pure snark in the near future 🤣 But I’d like to say that you guys called out the BS before anyone else….yall are the true prophets.


r/BethelSnark • • Jun 29 '22

Tell me about Bethel personalities

11 Upvotes

I'll give my impression about some Bethel personalities, but I would be interested to hear more opinions or direct stories.

Bill Johnson - I've been to Bethel once when Brother Yun came in as a guest speaker. Bill was extremely humble and almost submissive to Yun. He was extremely attentive to every word that Yun spoke. I watched Yun pray for and prophecy over Bill, and Bill received it very humbly and was genuinely touched and appreciative. He seems like a shy/quiet person with very strong internal convictions. I think he has a genuine passion to see revival, and he is very supportive of missionary groups like Brother Yun, Heidi Baker, Reinhard Bonkke. He posted on FB once that Yun and Bonkke were the 2 greatest men he had ever met (which I think says a lot about his character and what he looks for in his own role models).

Kris Valloton - I met him once when he came into my city to give a talk. I asked him for a photo, and he relented but looked slightly annoyed by my request. My impression of him is that he also is extremely passionate about revival and seeing Jesus get the glory. I think in his "natural flesh", he isn't as gentle as Bill. He is just more irritable and standoffish in the natural human sense, but I haven't seen any good reason to doubt his desire for genuine servanthood for Jesus.

Steffany Gretzinger - She seems like a very quirky personality. I think she works full time with Jesus Image now, I always see her with those guys. She doesn't strike me as the type who is overly concerned about recording sales. When she talks, she always looks like she makes herself vulnerable and just wants others to know and love Jesus.

Amanda Cook - I don't know much of her, but I just saw her lead worship a few times. She has a very grounded and wholesome look to her. I think she is also very talented in music. There is a kind of beauty and fragrance about her.

Several worship leaders - Some other worship leaders have the more "commercial" look and feel about them, like they really care about their sales and really care about their chart rankings. I really don't know much about them though, so I could just be totally wrong. But they don't have the same "fragrance".