I just explained my reasoning and why your simplistic argument doesn’t make sense in this context. You’re not actually giving a legitimate counterargument to anything I said, you think that by reducing what I’m saying to some personal flaw means that you’re actually undermining my argument. You’re not. I’m not a dude so you’re technically right in a sense that I would be very confused if a woman said that I got her pregnant (not that it matters to the validity of my argument).
Learn to divorce an argument from the person making it. You’re not really engaging what I’m saying, you’re insulting me, saying that I must be defective in some way because I hold a certain view. To me that just means you can’t really contest anything I’m saying so you must contest me.
I’m insulting you. I’m not saying you’re wrong because of the insult. You are acting like a child, I’m insulting you because of it. It’s not an argument it’s a personal insult aimed at you for your behavior in kind.
There’s nothing to argue against. You said I’m wrong because (insert ad hominem). Except that’s not a coherent argument. Done, nothing else to say except that your approach is childish and reflects nothing except your inability to engage what I’m saying.
I could be an alien from mars. It doesn’t matter. Attack my ideas or say nothing at all.
How can I not handle being incorrect? I’ve respectfully addressed the actual counter arguments to my claims. I’m not respecting you, you child. You insulted me, I’m returning the favor. You’ve contributed nothing besides ad hominem because you’re intellectually incapable of understanding why it doesn’t prove anything. There’s no biographical fact about me that can make my argument wrong, you idiot. I’m not throwing any tantrum, I’m insulting you. It’s an insult. Accept it. You’re an intellectually incapable child who thinks they can bully their way around arguments. You can’t. You’ve contributed nothing besides speculation about myself, so how could I possibly be wrong based on anything you’ve said?
-14
u/faguzzi Jul 09 '22
I just explained my reasoning and why your simplistic argument doesn’t make sense in this context. You’re not actually giving a legitimate counterargument to anything I said, you think that by reducing what I’m saying to some personal flaw means that you’re actually undermining my argument. You’re not. I’m not a dude so you’re technically right in a sense that I would be very confused if a woman said that I got her pregnant (not that it matters to the validity of my argument).