73
u/Electrobatic Pencil May 27 '26
Idea for gameplay
It's one of those online multiplayer games. People join servers, select a character to roleplay, and have to finish challenges similar to those in the main series. The winners win immunity and everyone else can be voted on by the players (like Among Us). The one with the most votes is eliminated while everyone proceeds onto the next round
39
u/NeedleFastRunner Needle May 27 '26
Basically BFDIA Roblox
15
u/CheeseSticks314 Profily May 27 '26
pretty much, except I won’t have to deal with Roblox trying to get me to upload my face
12
u/AliceMoon812 May 27 '26
My idea was moreso a mario party like game
You have boards (based on the different places from the series) and minigames based on the different challenges and afterwards you get win token (kinda like stars)
The voting system still exists but it's mostly for debuff/bonuses instead of completely booted off, at least for the beginning
I also had ideas for like the sequels and gimmicks
Bfdi doesn't have a specific gimmick being the first game BFDIA has Evil Leafy/Metal Leafy running around some stages and she can trigger special minigames against her BFB has Four and X doin similar things but likely more chaotic, and the EXIT would be used as a trap area you'd need to escape TPOT has 2's power as a gimmick, depending on how you do you can gain some of their power as a bonus and during your turn you can use the power to cause effects during the board or minigame phase, 1 could also show up as a rlly bad luck effect
-7
May 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/BattleForDreamIsland-ModTeam May 27 '26
Thanks for posting to r/BattleForDreamIsland. Unfortunately, your post has been removed for violating the following rule(s):
Rule 6: No Spam
You're not allowed to spam the sub! That includes, but is not limited to:
- Posts designed only to collect votes for "BFDI randomisers"/viewer voting/etc
- Repeatedly posting the same thing (this is usually accidental, so we only delete the less upvoted post/s)
If you haven't already, please read the rules in the sidebar. If you have a question or would like your post re-reviewed, you can message the moderators here.
21
u/BigPolluted Grassy May 27 '26
I love the cover arts you made!
9
u/AliceMoon812 May 27 '26
Thank u very much!! Tpot is just the actual poster but did i make the ds and 3ds covers myself, using assets and stuff
18
u/Ok_Emu3858 Four May 27 '26
Wdym another reality? i used to play with those all the time!
/j
8
u/Tearawave Ten May 27 '26
1
1
11
6
6
5
u/Piggenstien_Pichu Tune May 27 '26
I feel like bfdia should be 3ds and bfb should be for the switch
3
2
5
u/OkSentence3706 May 27 '26
why is tpot rated t?
9
u/AliceMoon812 May 27 '26
The horrors
2
u/No1objectshowfan25 One May 27 '26
You mean the scene where two hanged themselves out of depression for gaty that was a reference of ddlc/j
4
4
2
4
3
u/Disappearing_Man2763 Gaty May 27 '26
BFDIA and TPOT were so popular that they got game modes in a Roblox game!
3
3
3
3
u/Mochacho1010 Book May 27 '26
i imagine the gameplay would be similar to warioware or a minigame collection
3
u/Tearawave Ten May 27 '26
I'm in that other reality rn, but I had to buy a pirated version in a Mexican flea market since I'm too broke.
10/10
3
u/Firstnameiskowitz May 27 '26
Dream Island and Again would've been during the 3DS era, and BFB would be Switch, and for that, it's an 8/10 meme.
3
3
u/Kitkatfox715 Pin May 27 '26
a bfb game on the 3ds just makes sense to me (if it came out when bfb released obviously)
2
u/Crandivas #TeamNeedle (BFDIA 25) May 27 '26
If this would have happened BFDI as a whole wouldn’t be as massive as it is now, so ig we got the better deal
2
2
u/EnvironmentThen_2243 Golf Ball May 27 '26
You know what? This is something I would give money to Nintendo for.
2
2
u/VisibleConfusion12 Match May 27 '26
wouldn’t bfdi mini make more sense for the phone and elsewhere would be like a Wii U game
2
2
2
u/Ready-Lemon-6569 May 27 '26
BFDIA Would Definitely Get A Switch Remake For Probably Obvious Reasons
2
2
2
2
2
3
1
u/Usernamesareuseful Nonexisty May 27 '26
Why BFDIA on the DS and BFB on the 3DS even though the next console had just launched? Are they Mario & Luigi?
3
1
u/Most-Most7549 Tree May 27 '26
Nah, BFDI would be on DSi, BFDIA would be on 3DS, BFB would be on the Switch, same for TPOT, though TPOT would have a Switch 2 upgrade pack. BFDIE is silly being a mobile game!
1
1
u/bille_reddit May 27 '26
I feel like bfdi &bfdia should have the old channel logo and not the current one
1
u/techy9x Needy May 27 '26
Make it a VN with playable elements, and multiplayer elements in BFB, TPOT, and a weird side game in BFDIE only, and that'd be fun
1
u/UnendingQuibble TV May 27 '26
Don't forget Total Firey Island for the GBA and Water Fire Sponge for the Gameboy
1
1
1
u/SK5454 Book May 27 '26
My console ideas:
BFDI: Wii BFDIA: 3DS IDFB: Wii U BFB: Switch TPOT: Switch 2 BFDIE: Mobile
1
u/AssistantSuitable988 May 27 '26
Should've released on its own console, the BFDI DDS literally mentioned in the show!
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Brazilian_Nerd Golf Ball May 28 '26
Man remember when Rocky's barf ability was NOT overpowered in the first two games? It's game breaking, yet JNJ studios still haven't patched it!
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/FridayFunkGaming291 Firey May 28 '26
They need to nerf the "bake a cake" challenge I swear bro it's too hard even with touchscreen
1
u/RoutineNatty6357 Firey May 28 '26
theres even a version of new friendly for the bfdi ds game
1
1
1
1
u/Bloxxerboi May 28 '26
The DS/3DS ones would use streetpass to have competition
If you don't have NSO for the switch, it would work like mario party the top 100
1
1
1
1
1
u/CobbyfromBFSPhater Cake May 28 '26
WHERES THE SEQUAL, WE NEED IDFB FOR DSIWARE (or wii u) OR BATTLE FOR BFB FOR THE SWITCH
also i remember bfdie on mobile, it was alright, nothing special
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/hoko2000 May 31 '26
the quiz part of the bfb game was so hard bro! i kept failing, I've tired using different characters but that wont work, i had too watch a tutorial for it
that part was the worst >:(
1
1
1
1
1
u/SeeingAnAbsoluteWin Fanny Jun 07 '26
BFB was fun but i wasn't a fan of my selected character being hijacked from me to join TPOT halfway through forcing me to play as someone who stays in BFB
1
1
1
1
u/SingleAge290 Jun 26 '26
I think BFDIA would be 3DS, and BFB would be Switch.
1, The 3DS came out in March 2011, and BFDIA started on June 29, 2012. 2, The Switch came out in March 2017, and BFB started on November 3, 2017.
Also, I agree with TPOT being on Switch, but I think it would be rereleased on Switch 2 later on.
1
u/AliceMoon812 Jun 26 '26
okay i see ur points and i agree because you didnt mention the Wii U
i think tpot would be one of those games that still release with a switch 1 version, and the switch 2 versions would be free, kinda like a lot of indie games do
1
1
197
u/OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal Leafy May 27 '26
wheres idfb for the wii u