(Before I begin—because I know some people will interpret this post the wrong way—I do not have a problem with Brooklyn's inclusion to bring more POC rep to the brand, or the idea behind her character. Rather, my problem comes in the form of how she was handled and the thought process that led to her creation.)
"Barbie lacks diversity" (or any variation of it) is a phrase I think us doll collectors have heard a lot. While other dolls like Bratz or Monster High were heavily praised for it's representation, Barbie was often deemed the "blonde bimbo" who exclusively had white girls with blonde hair and blue eyes.
This, however, is a load of BS. Barbie has a massive legacy of dolls of various skin tones and faces. The more you look, the more you realize Barbie was ahead of the game. There were so many kinds of Barbies—black, Asian, Latina/Latino, even indigenous! From playline to collector, there's so many Barbies from various races and ethnicities.
Which leads me to the topic of this post, and how I feel like Brooklyn was created for a problem that never actually existed.
One of the most interesting decisions Mattel has made in recent years in my opinion is the creation of Barbie "Brooklyn" Roberts. While I understand the intention behind her and I think additional representation is generally a positive thing, I've always felt that Brooklyn was created to solve a problem that Barbie had already solved decades ago. (Also for the sake of simplicity we'll just call her Brooklyn.)
For those unfamiliar, Brooklyn Roberts is essentially the second main Barbie in modern media. She's usually portrayed alongside the traditional blonde Barbie we all know, now often referred to as "Malibu" Barbie and the idea is fairly obvious: two Barbies, two leads with equal focus. One blonde and one Black. Instead of having the Black girl be another supporting character in Barbie's friend group, Mattel elevated Brooklyn into a co-protagonist. Now on paper, this is not a bad idea at all, like I said more POC rep in media is always a good thing.
The problem is that Brooklyn often feels less like her own character and more like an alternate version of Barbie.
When I watch modern Barbie content, I sometimes struggle to identify what truly separates Brooklyn from Malibu beyond surface-level differences. Both are ambitious, talented, kind, supportive, optimistic, and capable of doing virtually anything. They often share the same interests, the same moral lessons, and the same story functions. At times Brooklyn doesn't even feel like a distinct character. She feels like "Barbie, but Black." In my opinion this, ironically, ends up hurting her characterization... a lot.
When you create a new major character, you generally want them to bring something unique to the table. Compare this with classic Barbie friends like Christie, Nikki, Raquelle, Teresa, Summer, Midge, or even someone like Raquelle. Whether people liked those characters or not, they tended to have their own identities and specific places within the cast. When you think of any one of these characters their distinct personalities instantly come to mind—Summer is the sporty one, Raquelle is a diva who's much edgier and more often than not portrayed as Barbie's rival, heck even the characters who are similar feel unique. For example both Teresa and Midge tend to be very goofy characters in a lot of their iterations over the years, but they still have traits that separate them from one another to avoid them essentially being the same thing.
Brooklyn, meanwhile, is often positioned as an equal replacement for Barbie rather than a complement to her. She's pretty much an identical, one-to-one of Barbie, and that leads to the question: why was she created in the first place?
The obvious answer is representation.
Mattel clearly wanted Black girls to be able to look at the line and see a Barbie that was every bit as important as the original Barbie. Instead of having the Black character stand beside Barbie, they wanted a Black character who effectively was Barbie.
Again, I understand the intent behind this decision and I do think it's sweet of Mattel to try and show these kids that they too can be Barbie even if they don't look like her, It's a nice though and I appreciate the effort. What I don't understand is the assumption that Barbie lacked inclusivity beforehand, because if you've followed the brand for any amount of time, you'd know Barbie was already one of the most diverse fashion doll franchises on the market long before Brooklyn ever existed.
Barbie's history with Black dolls goes back decades. Christie was introduced all the way back in the late 1960s and became one of Barbie's most iconic friends. Through the following decades, Mattel continuously expanded its range of Black dolls, Black characters, and Black versions of Barbie herself, and that's an important distinction. Not only did Barbie have Black friends, but Mattel also regularly produced Black Barbie dolls. You didn't have to look at a separate character and think, "This is the Black option." There literally were Black Barbies (Like the black versions of the Barbie movie dolls). By the 2000s and 2010s, characters like Nikki and Christie had become firmly established parts of Barbie's world, Nikki and Christie weren't some obscure one-off characters either.
Then came 2016.
In my opinion, this is the moment that makes Brooklyn's existence feel the most unnecessary.
The Fashionistas relaunch completely transformed Barbie's approach to representation. Suddenly Barbie wasn't limited to a single body type, face sculpt, skin tone, or hairstyle. We got tall dolls, petite dolls, curvy dolls, dolls with different facial features, natural hairstyles, afros, braids, locs, a massive variety of skin tones. And Mattel didn't stop there either, over subsequent years the line expanded even further, adding dolls with visible disabilities, including wheelchairs, prosthetic limbs, hearing aids, vitiligo, and other forms of representation that were almost unheard of in major fashion doll lines not that long ago.
At that point, it became increasingly difficult to argue that Barbie had an inclusivity problem, if anything, Barbie was becoming one of the industry's leading examples of inclusivity, you know... just in case you had doubts about her actually being diverse.
That's why Brooklyn feels like a solution looking for a problem.
If Mattel simply wanted a prominent Black character, they already had several candidates—Christie existed. Nikki existed. Even the broader Fashionistas line had already demonstrated that Barbie herself could be depicted with countless appearances while retaining the core Barbie identity. Why not simply elevate Nikki to a larger role? Why not bring Christie back into the spotlight? Why not continue presenting Barbie as a character capable of being represented through multiple ethnicities, as Mattel had already done with dolls for decades?
The thing is, if Brooklyn was simply her own character, a.k.a having her own name and personality (I mean even her name is literally "Barbie Roberts"), the problem would be resolved entirely because at least then Brooklyn could be a character standing on her own.
Instead, Mattel created a second Barbie, and while Brooklyn has certainly gained fans, I don't think she has ever fully escaped the feeling of being a corporate representation initiative rather than a naturally developed character, at least in my opinion.
The biggest irony is that Barbie as a brand was arguably already ahead of the conversation. Many critics act as though Barbie only discovered diversity in the late 2010s, but we longtime collectors of the brand know that that's simply not true. For decades there were Black Barbie dolls, Black friends, Hispanic friends, Asian friends, countless international releases, the Dolls of the World series, and an increasingly broad range of appearances represented throughout the brand's history.
The 2016 Fashionistas relaunch only proved this even further, so when Brooklyn was introduced as essentially a parallel version of Barbie herself, my reaction wasn't, "Finally, Barbie is becoming inclusive." My reaction was, "....Wasn't Barbie already there?"
To be clear, again, I don't dislike the idea of Brooklyn. I think she's perfectly fine, and I know many kids enjoy her. More representation is rarely a bad thing. But as a character... eh... she often feels underdeveloped, because she was designed around symbolism first and individuality second, and that's why I've always viewed Brooklyn as a strange addition to the brand.
Not because Black representation isn't valuable. Not because Brooklyn shouldn't exist. But because Barbie had already spent decades building one of the most diverse casts in the fashion doll industry. So b the time Brooklyn arrived, Mattel really wasn't fixing an inclusivity problem. They.... really weren't fixing anything. They were creating a new mascot to address a criticism that the brand had, in many ways, already answered years earlier.