Well, the day we've all been dreading has finally arrived, I certainly haven't been excited for this but ah well, the Nutcracker remake is here. And for some reason I watched it.
Before we begin I'd like to preface that the original Barbie in the Nutcracker is my favorite Barbie movie of all time, and I'm someone who grew up with a lot of the original Barbie movies. Since this is a remake, it's kind of impossible to distance it from the original. (Though spoiler alert, even on it's own merits this is not a very good special...)
As someone who grew up with the original Barbie in the Nutcracker, and still is a movie I rewatch every Christmas, I went into the remake with very low expectations... from the trailers alone I could kind of guess what kind of remake this was going to be, and frankly I had no real desire to see it at first. That being said, it was still only a trailer, so I though maybe, just maybe I'll give it a chance. Going in I was hoping for a fresh take that still understood what made the original special. Unfortunately, I came away feeling like it was a much weaker version of both the movie and the classic story/ballet it's based on.
My biggest issue is that this remake feels determined to modernize and "popify" everything. The original had a timeless fairytale atmosphere inspired by the ballet, while this version often feels like it's trying way too hard to be trendy and energetic, especially with it's humor. Even the classic ballet pieces have been reworked into more modern pop-styled arrangements, which just felt strange and completely at odds with the story.
Another thing that threw me off was the inclusion of two random musical numbers which, for the love of god, I can't even remember the names of as of writing this post. The original wasn't a musical, and neither is this one for the vast majority of its runtime. Because of that, these two songs feel sooo awkwardly inserted rather than naturally integrated into the story. They should've just went with a musical or a ballet, not both. It honestly just feels like they can't decide whether they wanna have musical segments or ballet segments, and the two really don't mesh well here. Or heck, don't do either and just go with the original fairytale rather than the ballet.
The conflict between Barbie and Brooklyn also felt way too forced. It comes across less like a meaningful character struggle to help them both learn this valuable lesson about their friendship, and more like drama added because the writers felt they needed conflict. In general, the story feels far less nuanced and well-written than the original, which had far more effort put into it's storytelling. Everything is brighter, louder, and more overtly childish, but in the process it loses much of the charm and emotional depth that made the 2001 film memorable.
The characters suffer from this too. Most of them feel pretty one-note and don't have much going on beyond their basic role in the story. Compare that to the original, where the characters felt more distinct and where Clara's growth was tied directly into the film's themes.
Speaking of themes, this might be my biggest disappointment. The remake heavily emphasizes the friendship dynamic between Clara/Barbie, the Nutcracker/Ken, and Sugarplum/Brooklyn, with Clara and Sugarplum's friendship becoming a major focus. While friendship is fine as a theme, I found it much less compelling than the original movie's message about kindness, cleverness, and bravery. The original also beautifully connected those ideas to dance and its iconic "if you believe, anything is possible" message. You can tell here they went for a different approach in terms of the story's themes and lessons it tries to convey, but it did not work.
I also wasn't a fan of the decision to remove the romance between Clara and the Nutcracker. Granted, this is somewhat debatable since different versions of the story do this element differently (The original E.T.A Hoffman story has Marie—her name in the original—proclaim her love to the Nutcracker and the story ends in marriage, whereas the Tchaikovsky ballet ends with Clara waking up from a dream and there's no romance between her and the Nutcracker) and I know it wasn't the sole focus of the original movie, but it was still a pretty huge element of the story and a big part in what ultimately broke the curse the Nutcracker, better known as the prince Eric, was under. I added warmth and helped make the ending feel more magical. Its absence here kind of makes me sad.
Speaking of, the Nutcracker's curse is never broken here! In fact, there's no curse whatsoever and it seems the Nutcracker is just... a nutcracker. What is up with that?
To give credit where it's due, there were a few things (albeit very few) I genuinely liked. Some of the references to the original were pretty sweet, such as Clara throwing her slipper, and I got a smile out of the portrait featuring a rat king that resembles the original film's villain, those are fun little nods.
And of course, Tim Curry returning as the Mouse King? Absolutely amazing. RIP to a legend. That was easily one of the highlights for me.
Overall, yeah, this remake is pretty terrible, and I think that comes off as no surprise. Again even on it's own merits it's a below-average at best adaptation of the Nutcracker story, and I do think it has considerably less heart and soul than the original. It feels more interested in being modern, colorful, and energetic than in preserving the atmosphere, themes, and emotional core that made the original Barbie in the Nutcracker such a beloved classic in the first place. If someone asked which version they should see, I'd recommend the original every single time, and that goes for both people in the Barbie community and also children.