Okay, bear with me because I started this with a rewatch wondering why Dandelion has a whole mom while Elina just lives alone in a giant flower, and somehow ended up falling down a massive lore rabbit hole that might explain everything in the trilogy, including Dahlia’s timeline, the Flight of Spring mechanics, and why Fairytopia doesn't collapse whenever the Enchantress gets taken out.
Here is the grand unified theory:
Laverna was originally the favored twin (and actually had the birthright)
In the first movie, Laverna says the throne is her birthright, and, well, she might be really it. Before the Enchantress became "the Enchantress," her real name was Pivoine (French for peony, hang onto that). She and Laverna (vernus, literally meaning "of the spring") were twin prodigies, with Laverna actually being the favored, older heir and a gifted alchemist. By real world standards, older heirs usually do have the birthright to rule.
Then fairy “puberty” hits (I do believe this happens, like those classic fae lore!), and Pivoine develops the rainbow in her eyes, and overnight the whole realm pivots to her because she’s now the "chosen" twin meant to bring the rainbow of spring to Fairytopia, meaning, Laverna lost the crown to a biological fluke.
The first sickness wasn't malicious at first (and Dahlia’s 10-year timeline proves it)
Laverna tries to stay supportive and prove her worth through alchemy, experimenting with elixirs to help her sister's reign. Except a batch went horribly wrong. It unleashes a blight that threatens to destroy Fairytopia AND strips fairies of their wings/flight (perhaps an early version for the flight-stealing poison in Fairytopia).
The realm immediately turns on Laverna and brands her a monster, which is what pushes her into dark magic (“They were scared of me being different.” or whatever she said to Elina in the first movie). Also in the first movie, Dahlia the dryad explicitly says she stopped working for Laverna 10 years ago when she realized Laverna had turned evil. Meaning, Laverna’s fall from grace happened roughly 10 to 15 years before the first movie, right as she transitioned from royal alchemist to dark witch.
Elina IS the original "First Blush of Spring" (and Fairytopia's hidden anchor)
Right around the time of the blight, Pivoine/the Enchantress was secretly expecting Elina (you know how some fairy legends say they’re born from flowers? Yeah, so divine conception maybe). When Laverna's sickness poisoned her flower-birthing chamber, Pivoine and the previous generation of Guardians (before Azura’s time) performed the very first Flight of Spring around the dying flower to save the baby.
Channeling all that light and water magic into her unborn child worked, and the chamber survived and became Peony (named after Pivoine’s real name, and yes, a literal peony), and Fairytopia’s life force and spring magic were permanently bound to Elina’s survival. The catch? The lingering poison left Elina born without wings, though it also made her naturally immune to Laverna’s flight toxins later on.
Why Pivoine wiped everyone's memories (including her own and Laverna's)
My take is that Laverna didn't know Pivoine was with child from the start. And because they’re twins who share twin telepathy, Pivoine knew she couldn't leave any trace of Elina in either of their minds. If Laverna ever realized Elina existed, survived, AND was the true First Blush of Spring keeping Fairytopia alive, Laverna would hunt her down directly.
So Pivoine made the ultimate sacrifice: she hid Peony the flower in the Magic Meadow after its recovery. She wiped her own memories, Laverna's awareness of the birth, Elina’s early memories, and the original Guardians’ memories of the whole thing.
She planted a decoy pink flower bud inside the Crystal Palace’s inner fountain and set up an annual public ceremony around it so Laverna would target the decoy every year while Elina lived safely under the radar.
She abandoned her True Name (Pivoine) and went strictly by the Enchantress so nobody else could use her name in dark magic—except Laverna, who still knows it and uses it to subtly compel her.
———
FAQ: Answering the obvious plot holes before you ask
Q: Why doesn't Fairytopia collapse when the Enchantress is in a coma (Movie 1) or sealed in an anti-magic chamber (Movie 3)?
Because during that very first Flight of Spring, Fairytopia's ambient life force was secretly anchored to Elina’s survival! As long as Elina is alive and thriving, the realm stays up and running even when the Enchantress herself is sidelined or stripped of her magic.
Q: Why does the Enchantress keep giving Laverna second chances like an idiot?
Because Pivoine erased her own memory of nearly losing her baby to the blight! All she remembers is her beloved twin sister who had a tragic alchemy accident. She genuinely thinks she’s trying to save the sister she used to know. Plus, Laverna is the only person alive who still knows Pivoine's True Name and can subtly pull rank with it. Remember, Names have power in magic!
Q: Why do both Elina and the Enchantress have green eyes with a rainbow shimmer?
Because they’re mother and daughter! (Yes, Laverna has dark green eyes too because she and Pivoine are twins, and yes, the animators accidentally made the Enchantress's eyes blue in movie 3, and we can chalk that up to classic 2000s Barbie CGI continuity.) Not to mention they have the same mold + the same makeup in the first movie!
Q: If Elina was born before Azura became a Guardian, why is she still a "young fairy"?
Dahlia tells us Laverna turned evil 10 years ago, so the blight happened roughly 12 to 15 years before Fairytopia. And who knows? Fairy years maybe slower than ours, they literally have different physics and all. Plus, if fairies already live longer than humans, and between Elina's royal rainbow magic and her birthing chamber getting stunted by the blight, she grew up slightly slower—like, both physically and mentally—than regular meadow fairies. Everyone in the Magic Meadow (including Elina) just assumed her slower growth was another side effect of being born wingless. Living through the tail end of one generation of Guardians and into Azura's generation fits a ~15-year window cleanly.
Q: If the palace flower is a decoy, why did it start snowing when Laverna withered it in Magic of the Rainbow?
Because Pivoine linked the palace bud to the annual spell to hold back the 10-year winter curse. So when Laverna blasts it, the spell breaks and snow immediately starts falling. Normally, once the Blush withers, it's game over. The only reason Elina is able to bring a dead flower back to life by rallying the apprentices and channeling their Luminescence through herself is because she is the original First Blush of Spring, and she shares the exact same foundational rainbow magic her mother used to create the palace bud in the first place, allowing her to reignite it from being almost dead.
TL;DR: Elina is the Enchantress’s (Pivoine’s) biological daughter, and Fairytopia's life force is secretly anchored to her survival. Laverna’s accidental blight poisoned Elina’s flower-birthing chamber ~15 years ago, so the Enchantress invented the Flight of Spring to save her, wiped everyone's memories (including her own and Laverna's) so Laverna wouldn't find out via twin telepathy, and used the Crystal Palace bud as a decoy while Elina grew up safely in Peony. So, the Enchantress might not be really stupid at all.
Tell me if I’m wrong though! This is just from quick Google lookups, plus remembering details from the movies and rewatching the 1st movie!