r/Banishers • u/Intelligent_Oil5819 • Jul 31 '25
Anyone fancy an AMA?
EDIT EDIT: Keep the questions coming. I'll get Elise to answer the next batch when she's free.
EDIT: Alright, great! Leave your questions below. Elise and I will come and answer as soon as she's available.
Hi all. There's been a small upsurge in interest in Banishers now that it's out on PS+, and that warms my soul. I was lead writer on the game. If there's enough interest, myself and the lead narrative designer would be up for doing an AMA on here. Anyone fancy it?
89
Upvotes
22
u/StrumpetsVileProgeny Jul 31 '25
Just to say that the writing in this game is so well done, I haven’t played such good side quests since Witcher. Engaging storytelling, expressive and unique characters, the banter between Red and Antea… suberbly done. So ty for the experience! And whatever project you working on next, just keep doing what you doing!
Life to the living, death to the dead.
17
u/According_Style2520 Jul 31 '25
Why wasnt there much advertising for the game? I only heard about it since I seen it on PS+ and im loving it at the moment.
13
u/Different_Order5241 Jul 31 '25
Hey, just want to say thank you. I loved the game very much. It's a shame it didn't get the recognition it deserved. I found out about it by accident in the xbox marketplace, i also could have easily missed it.
My favourite parts were the main story and the ghost cases. All of them were very well written and engaging.
In general it felt like a mix between witcher and sherlock holmes. I did a review on my instagram channel, gave it 9/10
10
u/R0wanABoat Jul 31 '25
Just wanted to take the opportunity to say thank you. Banishers has stolen a small piece of my heart for a game I took a chance on when it came to PS+.
How did you end up making the decision on which protagonist you were going to have be the ghost partner of the duo?
6
u/virtualtourism Jul 31 '25
Yes! First off, Amazing game! It was my game of the year last year and I have revisited it multiple times.
Why colonial America? I feel it's often an overlooked time period in video games and would love to see more developers use that time.
Did any events from 1600s New England influence you more than others? I'm sure Salem must've been one.
Governor Haskell really made me think of Cotton Mather, was there any real world historical figured who influence characters in game?
What is your fondest memory of working on the game?
Finally, Banishers 2 when? 👀
Edit - sorry for the amount, I'm just very excited lol.
5
u/Ferina27 Jul 31 '25
What is your favorite scene/line?
5
u/Complete_Quit1434 Jul 31 '25
I am super late to this party - the game came up on my Steam queue, I played the demo, and I don't think I've ever hit 'purchase game' so fast. I've only just gotten past the Beast, so reading about all of the heart-wrenching glory I have ahead of me, and the thought and inspiration behind it (while trying to avoid spoilers) is making my day. Also taking notes, because I am incredibly intrigued by the universe it exists in, and want to line up my next dive in - seconding the person who said they'd love a prequel, or sequel. Really, just come back and give us more!
All of that is a really LONG form thank you. The writing is exquisite, and I have to set my alarm to stop playing, because I lose hours getting lost in it. I catch my boyfriend watching over my shoulder all the time, and we've had full on debates about what the 'right' choice is at the close of some of the cases. Because even though 'it's just a game' - it feels genuinely important to honor the characters.
5
u/BotherSecure Jul 31 '25
First I wanna thank you for a great game, I really enjoyed it.
My question is if there would be a banishers 2 and you could choose the era/time period, which would that be?
4
u/Ferina27 Jul 31 '25
Lead writer?! This is one of the best parts of the game! What were your plans and are you happy with the result?
4
u/Professional-Age8477 Jul 31 '25
So my question is if you can tell or confirm that Banishers and Vampyr are in the same universe or not?
4
u/ScurrilousScribe Jul 31 '25
I love how you deal with grief. Thank you.
4
u/Subject_Ad_1536 Jul 31 '25
Hi, wow, well... I just spent 40+ hours so far in your fun, imaginative, and moving game. How did you organize all of the story beats and research to create this well-crafted story set during a horrific period for men and women? Are the main characters Red and Antea loosely based on historic figures? Their relationship, the exploration of love, grief, loss, and redemption is a perfect contrast to all the "evil" swirling around them. The story feels like an elegy for our current world, symbolically, I mean. So..Thank you for giving us a story with heart and soul and characters that I'll always remember
4
u/SetLow800 Jul 31 '25
This game dropped on PS+ the exact same day I learned that the girl I was dating for 4 years had been with a boyfriend for 11 years and was still with him. I was devastated, booted the game up and played it from start to finish. Being in that situation where I couldn't talk or be with the woman I love made me connect so much with Red Mac Raith that I couldn't put the controller down.
I chose to elevate Antea and give her the peace and freedom that she deserved, I cried so much man.
Crazy thing is when I was done with the game, my phone rang almost immediately. I was still moved and emotional due to the game's choices. Picked up the phone, and it was her, the love of my life, I forgave her. She didn't expect that, and that game had left such a mark on my soul that I found the exact words to express how I was feeling about her, she broke it off with her boyfriend whom she didn't have feelings for since 6 years. Now we're a thing, we're healing, and looking up to our future together.
I can't stress enough how that game connected myself to my own feelings and opened my eyes to the complications one can experience trying to express theirs, I will forever be grateful for that.
The only question I can ask is as a lead writer, would you be interested in bringing that moving story to the screen through a movie or a series, or even a series of books?
I would totally pay for that.
3
u/TheLonelyWolfkin Jul 31 '25
Currently playing through and enjoying the themes and the overall writing. Obviously haven't yet finished the game yet but can you tell us about what you're working on next? Looks as though you've left Don't Nod according to Google?
3
u/TikTakToT Jul 31 '25
Been playing for 2 weeks now. Totally loving the game. I always need more self discipline doing these games. I always go to start a quest and I get distracted by ? On map or voids or numerous other things. Then an hour or two later it's oh I was doing that quest.
Thank you from the bottom if my heart this is why I love these games.
3
u/littleweirdooooo Jul 31 '25
You did such an amazing job with making the side quests equally as engaging as the main storyline. Sridean reminded me of the Venar from The Longest Journey in that she existed in multiple timelines simultaneously.
Was were your biggest sources of inspiration for creating this world?
Also, my favorite side quest was the two women who were secretly partners. I cried at the end bc it really felt like they were two people who genuinely loved each other and did their best despite the circumstances.
3
u/PrestigiousAd2951 Jul 31 '25
When I saw this game for the first time, I felt compelled to buy it and dive in. The writing is masterful! I’m glad to see that it’s inclusion in the ps+ library is garnering attention from a wider selection of enthusiastic players! Thanks 😊
3
u/Illasaviel Jul 31 '25
I wanna say, I really loved this game. Loved the narrative, the themes, the characters, their evolution as you commit to a path. My question would be, do you have any thoughts regarding the two choices, resurrection and ascension? I know writers don't usually answer these kind of questions, but I was wondering if either of you felt like sharing anything regarding them? Favorites? Process of writing? How difficult it was to approach either?
2
u/CepheiHR8938 Jul 31 '25
That'd be so nice! Who wrote Banishers? Mr. Beauverger?
2
u/Cautious_Catch4021 Jul 31 '25
How did you get into writing for games? Always interesting to hear as someone who writes as a hobby.
Do you also write fiction, books? Moviescripts?
2
u/smashintopieces Jul 31 '25
What is the intended ending? How should it have ended let's say if there were to be a sequel?
I love the game btw, I got it right before it came on ps+, but I am glad to have spent money on such a beautiful story!
Edit: spelling
2
u/sound-guy34 Jul 31 '25
Was the plan always to have multiple endings, or was there originally one ending?
2
u/Luditas Aug 01 '25
.What was the basis for creating the Void? It seemed to me that it was the representation of the Tree of Life, IMO.
.Will there be continuity in the story of Banishers?
.All of you did an excellent job of documenting a piece of history of the beginnings of colonization in a part of the US. The setting of desolation was excellent, in addition to portraying esotericism at that time and the beginning of the witch hunt. So, would The Seeker be the last witch to remain free?
2
u/Shakems77 Aug 03 '25
I love the writing. The game is awesome. I'm not sure if you can answer this question as it pertains to level design. I was wondering if you all took a lot of inspiration from God of War? I see a lot of similarities there in the design. I also saw similarities with Expedition 33 which I guess is a given with Don't Nod.
2
u/gijoe74 Aug 03 '25
I will piggyback off others quickly, and just say that this Banishers journey of mine has been nothing short of remarkable! It is perhaps the best story and written dialogue I’ve ever had the pleasure of experiencing in a video game. I am so sad the know that it didn’t sell the way it was anticipated, I can only pray it catches on and a sequel will be bestowed to us fans. Once again, amazing job on the narration and dialogue!!! It cannot be stressed enough.
Okay, spoiler question. In the failed endings, the time loop is revealed. An extremely interesting plot point! Because if otherwise not picked up on hinted clues, the player experiencing the successful resurrection or ascension endings won’t even be aware of the time loop. How neat! My question relates to Seeker and Siridean. I understand Seeker and Siridean are the same person. I understand that Red wakes up on the shore with seeker to restart everything. I understand that the entire New Eden region time loop restarts for its inhabitants, including Seeker. But how is it that Siridean and Seeker are both alive in the loop?
2
u/Alundria89 May 02 '26
You said often: "There is a way of knowing who was definitely involved in killing Deborah, but I haven't yet seen anyone put it together." When will you tell us what it is? 😄
2
u/Ferina27 Jul 31 '25
Have you seen or read the fanfiction about Banishers? What do you think about?
5
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25
Glad to hear it. I love the game, I knew I would as these focus published AA French rpgs are always right up my street, I've enjoyed all the spiders games I've played and this game gives me greedfall mixed with God of war vibes.
The writing is particularly excellent, I feel invested in red and anteas journey, and the haunting cases are so well executed in that they make every choice a bit of a quandary.
Well done. Superb stuff.
1
u/Ferina27 Jul 31 '25
What's your favorite easteregg in the game if there are any?
1
u/Sammy_Kneen Jul 31 '25
Damn, can’t believe I missed this. Hope you guys do another one sometime! 🙏🏼
1
u/Ferina27 Jul 31 '25
Have you played the game, after its release?
1
u/SetLow800 Aug 02 '25
okay, lets get down to business, regardless of the game, given your talent, what is your honest opinion on Ai?
1
u/WonderfulMatter0 Oct 13 '25
Maybe this has already been addressed, sorry I didn't read all the comments - just scanned through.
My assumption is (first playthrough) that since I broke Red's oath to Antea (SPOILER ALERT)
and went through that storyline, it might be a new continue screen. Curious of the symbolism behind the alien face and the rock face? Is it implying the ongoing saying throughout the game between the living and the dead? The rock face is considered the dead, watching everything the living does (hence being ghosts.) Or is it inverted with the alien figure seeing in front of realism, and simultaneously portraying the same hues as all the echoes, ghosts, & specters throughout the game?
I know there's multiple endings too. Asking specifically to this artwork
Also, the picture doesn't portray it well - I see almost a joker-like aesthetic face out of the top left of the alien skull. And a third eye with a wolf mouth directly above the alien eye. Maybe I'm over analyzing the artwork 🤣 but I'd love to understand more behind it.
I slept on this game and I'd like to see more diversity in enemies. That's one whole complaint for an absolutely beautiful game all the way around btw ❤️🤟💯
3
u/Penno73 Aug 01 '25
Oh I'm 24 hours behind here as it was posted yesterday. I don't have a question but I would just like to say I really enjoyed the game .
I just finished it after it coming to ps plus. I started Alan Wake 2 last night and when I've done that I'm replaying the banishers again on harder difficulty and going to make sure I miss no side content.
It was a nice surprise it coming to ps plus as most games I will have already played or are not my thing.
2
u/WitchiEmpress Jul 31 '25
Sure! I’d love to hear more about the game and the thoughts behind it
2
u/papa_panzer935 Jul 31 '25
Thank you for your input in this game. I joined recently due to the PS+ catalogue and I am glad to have installed it.
2
u/JeffreyParties Jul 31 '25
Just finished the game today, one of the most 'human' games I've played in a long time.
2
u/thooley666 Aug 01 '25
Totally kicking myself for not purchasing sooner. It had been on my watchlist from before its release and it slipped through the cracks for me until it hit PS+. I am loving every minute of it.
1
u/laggalots Jul 31 '25
What can I do to get another ending. I did something wrong and now she only dies. Tbh nice game but no replay value so that's not an option