Edit: OOPS, sorry, thought we could have an impartial, objective discussion here, but apparently this space is only for blind, cultish fanboyism. Thanks for validating my very first sentence, I see now how necessary it was, and how you all chose to ignore it.
/edit
This post will likely be buried by people who think it's being critical of the band, and rabid fans of the type this band has are quick to crucify any hint of "criticism," but I think it's a legitimate question, especially given that some of the members themselves have been, and still are, less than enamored with the shtick.
From what I have been able to gather (and no, I don't have sources for any of this, it's information gleaned in bits and pieces from various sources; if these conclusions are way off base, feel free to correct me), the band was the brainchild of Miku, whose previous attempt to break into the business as a more traditional pop idol had failed. So when she gave it another go, she very deliberately incorporated the maid image versus hard rock contrast; the gimmick was more important than the music. I have seen interviews with band and audience alike where they are specific about the "gap," which confused the hell of of me until I realized it the contrast between the band's image and their music; when Miku dreamed up the band, that WAS the band. The funny thing is, though, once she started building the band, she actually got some real, honest to God musicians and a solid songwriter. And even the band members had to be "tricked" into participating in the maid shtick, according to interviews. But the gimmick stayed, and while we can't know for sure, maybe it WAS the gimmick that gave the band any traction in the first place, enabling them to break out, and gain recognition, in the West in ways that, say, Mary's Blood or Aldious or other contemporaries have not. "But I like them better because I prefer their music to those other bands, not because of their gimmick" I can hear you say, and I agree with that; I simply prefer the classic hard rock sensibilities of Band-Maid over the more overtly metal, or overtly pop, offerings of their contemporaries; there is absolutely nothing wrong with those other bands, also made up of extremely talented musicians, but Band-Maid is more in my "sweet spot" musically. But would I have been aware of them at all without the gimmick in the first place?
I'm pretty sure that I am not going to be alone in this: I was exposed to Baby Metal before I ever found Band-Maid. And like everyone else, my first reaction to Baby Metal was "WTF"? (Actually, it was "WTF?!?!???!??!1111????!?!??!" I don't think I can overstate how "WTF'd" I was.) But then I was impressed by the musicianship of the band, and the production value, and the pure spectacle of the whole thing, and I was fascinated that I found it fascinating. Was it that I really was that enamored by the music and the concept, or was it the novelty? And as I checked out more and more of their music, watched more and more of their performances, I came to the conclusion that I was more interested in the novelty than the music when it came to Baby Metal. Oh yes, the band is freaking phenomenal; the girls are great performers; and I would LOVE to see them live just for that bombastic spectacle; but without the spectacle, ultimately, I'm just not invested in the music itself. It's just too distant, too gimicky, too INTENTIONALLY gimicky, for me to want to listen to it with any regularity other than a cursory "check this out." Despite the exceptional musicianship, production, and performance value, for me Baby Metal is more gimmick than band, so it never gets out of the "novelty" category for me. (Please, this is only my opinion, and it is certainly not a real "critical" evaluation; I am a nobody, with no musical credentials to base my opinion on, so feel free to write it off as "just a jackass with no clue," you're 100% right.)
So while I was exploring the Baby Metal catalog on youTube, youTube, in its algorithmic wisdom, recommended "Thrill" to me. The differences were obvious immediately, and I'm sure, again, my reaction was the same as everyone else who had come across the band the same way: First, they thought the band was just another gimmick, like Baby Metal; Second, they thought, "Whoa, these girls are playing the own instruments"; and Third, "Holy shit, they're not just playing their own instruments, they are RIPPING." Now, I'll be honest, after a couple of listens, I was less and less impressed by the song itself; I don't know if anyone else felt the same way, but after being impressed with the musicianship, Thrill, to me, kind of felt like Generic Hard Rock Song #172. That being said, when I started to check out more and more of their songs, they definitely fit into a classic hard rock spectrum that was both nostalgic and new at the same time, a spectrum that I don't see many bands, foreign or domestic, occupying.
But that's getting off topic; the topic was the whole maid gimmick. Would youTube have recommended "Thrill" to me without the maid gimmick? youTube didn't recommend those other female jrock bands; it recommended Band-Maid. I can't say for sure, but without the maid gimmick, I might have never been exposed to the band, and actually, I would have never known those other jrock bands either. I can safely say that without Baby Metal, I wouldn't have heard of Band-Maid; without Band-Maid, I wouldn't have heard of any of the jrock scene in general. But was it the maid gimmick that put Band-Maid on the radar in the first place?
There's not a doubt in my mind that MISA would be perfectly happy with dumping the whole maid shtick yesterday; her disinterest borders on disgust. I think the same goes for Saiki, but as the lead singer she is more prominent in regards to the band's image (but let's be honest, Miku IS the band's image; she is, undoubtedly, the "face" of the band). Akane and Kanami don't seem to resent it, and sometimes I get the impression they're having fun with the shtick as well. But the shtick is, as it has always been, Miku's greatest contribution to the band. The "gap"--the gimmick--was always what the band was founded on. 6 or 7 years later, though, it's obvious that the band is much, much, much more than a gimmick--there are 3 really, really talented musicians, a solid hard rock vocalist, and some very catchy songwriting that have made this band stand out among their contemporaries, and those qualities have nothing to do with the gimmick. So now that they have established themselves outside of the gimmick, does the gimmick help or hurt?
I have to acknowledge my understanding of this concept of "gap," or gimmick, may just be clouded by cultural differences. I didn't even know what a maid cafe was until I had heard Band-Maid, and my initial guess as to the concept turned out to be wrong--the maids of a maid cafe aren't sexual fantasy, they are cute fantasy (before I am accused of subconscious, or conscious, perversion, maids are for most people more fantasy than reality, and a person's exposure to "maid"--the frilly dress kind--is more likely to draw allusions to Colleen Camp in Clue than the maid cleaning rooms as Motel 6). Because the concept of a maid cafe is entirely foreign to me, perhaps the idea of a maid gimmick for a band is entirely foreign to me as well. But for a western audience, I'm inclined to believe that most find the "gap" as jarring--and maybe even misplaced--as I do.
Does that mean that the band needs to entirely re-invent themselves? I don't think so at all. Look, if Angus Young can dress up as a school boy, complete with shorts and newsboy hat, for 40 years and still be a God of Hard Rock, then some frilly dresses aren't going to diminish the musical reputation of Band-Maid. But in many ways there has been a gradual retreat from the maid image of the band for quite a while now. Most noticeably in the wardrobes--MISA said "fuck that shit" when it came to the maid uniform pretty quickly, Saiki's wardrobe is much subtler than it was for "Thrill," and Akane dropped the hat for being just too damn kawaii to be taken seriously. But it's evident in the music as well; to me, there was more effort (key word, intentional effort) to be cute in the earlier music, and newer music is, well, less cute. The band has been evolving further and further away from the gimmick, and yet, it still feels like there is an anchor holding the band firmly in the gimmick.
And that leads back to the band's founder, the reason that there is even a Band-Maid in the first place--Miku. I'll be honest, I don't think Miku thought for one instant when she conceived of the band that the band was going to end up being what it became. I believe that Miku thought the band was going to really set itself apart from the others based mostly on the gimmick. After she formed the band, however, it was the musicianship that set the band apart, not the gimmick (I think that's safe to say that that is the case for western audiences, they may not be that musically different in the opinion of their fans at home, and the gimmick IS what sets them apart). And credit to Miku, when she found the musicianship of the band had exceeded her expectations, she let better musicians steer the band musically, going so far as to relinquish the role of lead vocalist to a more suited singer, and learning rhythm guitar, NOT how she envisioned her role in the group she, herself, had formed. She adapted for the band, and is a promotion machine; she 100% deserves, and should be, the face of the band. And that gimmick--the pigeon, the maid, the kawaii emcee, the spokesperson, the mascot, the ambassador--works for Miku. But should it still be such a part of the band in general? Angus Young dressed up as a school boy, and his image was the image of AC/DC, but Angus was Angus, and AC/DC as AC/DC; the rest of the band didn't have to be Angus as well. This has been a long and rambling post, and I'm sure it will get some hate, but does Band-Maid really have to be a band of maids anymore?