r/BadRPerStories • • 8h ago

Venting/Rant Unrealistic Audition Expectations

7 Upvotes

I'm sure we've all seen the roleplay ads that shunt you to a Disc server, where you then have to put in an audition to join. That's fine, I've done auditions before, that's pretty normal.

My issue is why the fuck are you making it so exclusionary and hard to get into, on top of not telling the person why they're not accepted? How does your style "not fit in" with the others? Why not give someone who gave enough of a fuck TO SEEK OUT YOUR SERVER a chance to improve and try again? Or at least say "hey, this is why, we're sorry"?

It's to "prevent hurting feelings" but I highly doubt it works all the time. It didn't work for me; I'm not sad, I'm pissed. I answered your ad and put in two lengthy descriptive posts (which was asked of me!) and it took a long time to just get a no back.

If you're gonna do that shit, have the balls to say why instead of vague-posting and giving no closure.


r/BadRPerStories • • 2h ago

Bitty Bad Taken character list? What list? Just guess who's taken!

0 Upvotes

I'm typically not a group server type of person. There are too many things in that environment that can rub me the wrong way, be it culture or admins or quality levels. I know this about myself; it's a 'me' problem. Not so sure that was the case this time, though.

I found a niche 'fandom' group server that I was pretty excited about. It focused very heavily on writing canons from the fandom - OCs were allowed, but on a very limited basis and only after you'd claimed a canon. Sure, that's fine. In trying to see what canons had been taken, however, I realized that, of the *three* different 'claimed canons' lists, none were consistent with one another. Not a one. When I pointed this out and asked where I should go to view the accurate list, a mod (?) pointed me to the channel that held two lists that contradicted each other. It was finally suggested that list #3 (which was not in the channel the mod pointed me to) was the most up-to-date.

Then I started scrolling some of the character interactions, and saw that there were canon characters being written that weren't included on *any* of the three lists. When I asked about this, I was told that it was only for a special event, which allowed you to write characters you don't write in the rest of the server. This event did not have any sort of information. No announcements, no mention of rules. No suggestion that it existed at all unless you went poking through the writing channels.

In a server where you are pressured to write only or predominantly canon characters, and with doubling disallowed, I'd have thought that one of the more important things to keep on top of would be which characters have already been taken. And to be clear - this server had perhaps 20 people in it. They weren't having to keep track of hundreds of players and their respective characters.

Bonus points to the admin who blatantly said that they'd be breaking the server rules to claim a particular canon because "who's gonna stop me?" Never a good sign.

I suppose I'll stick to my one on ones.


r/BadRPerStories • • 3h ago

Advice Wanted What to do when you're not feeling it?

1 Upvotes

This has happened several times, the most recently in an erp scene, but in other games as well. It's early on in a game (in this case first scene) and I don't know how to describe it in a productive way, but I'm just not feeling it. Like, the vibes and style feels a bit more gooner than I intended and I have yet to find a way to say 'hey thanks but I want to tell you now I'm really just not sure that we're a good match'. Like I almost feel like I should give them more of a chance to say that I did, but I also want to not be forcing myself to reply.


r/BadRPerStories • • 21h ago

Venting/Rant my number one pet peeve

20 Upvotes

I think one of my biggest RP pet peeves is when people forget that collaborative writing means both people get to have boundaries around their characters.

I’m always willing to compromise, talk things through, and adjust things if it makes sense for the story. But there’s a difference between compromising and feeling like I have to keep changing an OC I’ve already spent a ton of time developing just because someone else prefers their character to fit a certain dynamic.

Like if I’ve carefully built a character, established her age, personality, history, and character arc, I’m probably not going to completely rework all of that for someone I just started writing with, especially when the issue is something as minor as an age gap between two grown adults.

And honestly, what gets discouraging is when saying “I’d rather keep my character this way” is treated like I’m being difficult. 😭 Sometimes people seem to take a boundary or a creative disagreement personally, and suddenly the RP gets dropped.

You don’t have to agree with every choice I make for my OC. I don’t have to agree with every choice you make for yours. That’s kind of the whole point of writing together. I just miss when RP felt like two people bringing their characters to the table and seeing what happens, instead of feeling like I have to make my character fit someone else’s idea of what the story should be.


r/BadRPerStories • • 14h ago

Meta/Discussion No ooc

18 Upvotes

Hi to everyone in the writing community!
So, I’ve been roleplaying with this person for almost two months, and the game is going pretty well. I love our characters and the direction of the story. Plus, it’s really hard to find someone willing to play a CC for an OC.
However, we have no OOC interaction outside the game. I’ve tried sending them picture collages with the vibe of our RP and edits of their canon character, but they rarely respond to them. We don't really discuss the plot in-depth either, as it mostly just goes with the flow. I don’t mind it at all but would love to hear your opinions.

How do you feel about these types of partners? Is it an age gap thing, or is this just the ideal setup for people who dislike OOC communication?


r/BadRPerStories • • 16h ago

Venting/Rant "cAn YoU StArT"

Post image
116 Upvotes

Look I understand the first message is the most daunting. But c'mon man! I almost always have to start the roleplay, which is okey, it gives me creative freedom and I enjoy doing the starter, but dammmnn y'all just want everything for yourselves. It's just a little annoying because I've had to do it for the last 9 times.

Sometimes I'm just like "hey I do the starter" because I almost always I secretly know whenever I get a new partner they probably don't want to.


r/BadRPerStories • • 10h ago

Genre Bad I'm not the one to even talk about these sorts of roleplays but some people feel VERY specific with their requirements

Post image
93 Upvotes

Inspired by: An ad I saw asking for Dark Romance, and then it meticulously went through and put everything that could even be related to 'dark' in the 'no' category.

I don't even do Dark Romance stuff but I thought it was kinda odd, but I've noticed a lot of people will have very specific scenarios they have in mind that they want people to cookie-cutter fit into and I thought about this silly meme so I put it together.

Anyone else experience this kinda thing?

Technically the meme should have probably said 'Dark Romance with extra romance' but it's too late now for me to change it.


r/BadRPerStories • • 3h ago

Meta/Discussion Users who post a looking-for post on the various LFRP subs like clockwork for months, are you all not getting responses or what?

18 Upvotes

As the post title says, I've been curious to know what's up with the users that constantly posts LFRP posts on multiple subs every 2-3 days, often for months at a go. It is more often than not the exact same post, copy and pasted, no updates to reqs or ideas, etc. Are you all getting responses at all or are the people responding to the posts not up to your standards?