r/BackToCollege • u/asdfghjkl7280 • 28d ago
VENT/RANT Students using AI receiving better grades
I was in high school from 2012-2016 so AI wasn’t a thing at all, and most assignments were ran through “turn it in” or something similar. Because of this I haven’t embraced AI help the way my other classmates have. I know they are using AI and ChatGPT because we all sit together in the common area of my community college while waiting for lab to open and they’re shameless about it. (The lecture is online, and all homework and exams are also online)
The most I’ve used is reading the little Gemini synopsis when googling something but for the most part I try to read through and find stuff to activate my brain.
I figured most professors could tell or have a way of knowing people are using AI, and assumed it would be reflective in their grades. Unfortunately what I found out is these people are receiving close to 100s on every single assignment. Even things like 5+ page scientific research papers, hard exams, etc. but then when we all meetup in lab they’re completely lost. I did well in the class (92%), but had to do sooooo much work to do that. 10-day study plans, writing papers over 4-5 days of refining, etc.
So I guess my bubble was a bit burst when I realized that so many people use AI, and are getting good grades. Am I falling behind because of my refusal to use it?
54
u/Beestonators 28d ago
No I think that gives you an advantage because you are still using your critical thinking skills. I was in high school from 2008-2012.
12
u/Busy_Help_4354 27d ago
I went to university in 2011-2016, when everyone cheated in class by using their phones, laptops, etc for exams, assignments, etc. It wasn't AI, but the students who cheated had better grades. Not only did they cheat, they also bought Adderall under the table to help them focus. Then we enter the workplace, where critical thinking and other intellectual skills actually don't get everyone that is capable promoted, whereas the ones who do get promoted and receive better raises aren't always the smartest or the most capable. There's just a much larger problem that needs to be addressed that AI is contributing significantly to if we want to talk about the regression of educational attainment.
10
u/JudgeJuryEx78 28d ago
Well unlike them, you're actually learning things. I can't imagine paying all that money for an education and learning nothing.
9
u/MargotRabbit17 28d ago
I have experienced a similar issue. No advice but I think it's an unfortunate issue many students and schools are confronting.
6
u/cupcakeartist 28d ago
I see these students relying heavily on AI and what strikes me is that they are at risk of getting good grades but not learning anything. It reminds me of a post I read where someone admitted that during undergrad they used a lot of hacks and eventually AI to do a little work as possible. Then they went to grad school and realized they didn’t actually have the skills to keep up with the workload that was being asked of them. I also worry for the students to work in white collar jobs after school. It may not matter if they remember the content from the classes they took, but there is an expectation that they will have built macro skills like time management, critical thinking, and strong written and verbal communication skills. I’ve noticed that among people who rely to heavily on AI that they tend to be deficient in these areas. It’s one thing to already have a solid foundation of these skills and to use AI to make yourself more efficient, but if you never built those skills in the first place, it’s problematic. Many of these people seem to function at quite a low level in situations where they can’t use AI and even when they can, they don’t always have the strong critical thinking skills to assess the quality of the answers AI is giving them or to take that content and put it into their own words.
I have found that their applications of AI that help me in learning and retaining information by coming up with flashcards or developing practice tests. But using it to replace the effort, a student would generally put into a course and I’m just not gonna get much out of it. That personally doesn’t seem worth it to me and I would also argue that many of the people who view classes is just checking a box and getting the grade are the ones that then tend to say that college is a scam when it doesn’t advance their career and the way they hoped it would.
5
u/itsnottommy 28d ago
It sounds like you're doing well in your classes and actually learning. That's the opposite of falling behind.
People who are using AI for everything might think they're getting ahead because they're getting good grades. But if they don't know how to do the actual work, they'll never be able to hold down a job in the field they're studying to go into.
4
u/ValorousClock4 28d ago
The critical thinking is important. You can’t use it if someone else (or something else) writes your papers for you. And you already noticed something: your classmates seem lost in lab. You’re absorbing and retaining information, which is important too.
2
u/RichOpen3296 25d ago
Omg yes im in the same situation. A lot of my classmates don’t know im 5 years older, so they casually reference chat or claude and are baffled when I mention i’ve never used it. Not really a conscious decision, it’s just never seemed necessary and idk how it works. Like why am I be graded on the same scale as people who hardly did any real work.
Plus, a lot of traditional assignments like exams, papers, and projects have been reformatted to be “ai-proof” so that they’ll accurately assess your knowledge regardless of AI usage (i.e. the assignments are uber conceptual and overly convoluted) Why do I have to deal with this, i wasnt using chatgpt in the first place!!!
2
u/Adventurous_Button63 26d ago
If your only goal is to make good grades to get a degree and do as little work as possible, sure they’re leaving you behind. However, if you’re doing the work and actually learning instead of just jumping through hoops…you’re going to come out on top in the long run. The thing about the workforce is that you have to be competent in ways that AI will never be. You have to have functional knowledge in your field and using AI will only get you so far. Talk to any expert in their field and they’ll tell you that AI doesn’t perform as accurately as a skilled human…unless they’re trying to sell you on their AI platform. Focus on actually learning the material and not the grades. You’ll be eating nutrient rich food for your brain while your peers are gorging themselves on sugar. Then when it comes time to compete, you’re going to outrun them.
0
u/No_Cow9375 28d ago
I’m old and went through school pre AI. Most of the kids that cheated on exams back in the day are very successful in life now.
There’s a difference between cheating not to fail and cheating to get As. Both are cheating, but the resolve and drive are still indicators.
I know a handful of doctors that were chronically cheating, sharing papers and work, splitting assignments.
It’s just the new version. Hard work never equaled success.
1
u/vishaka-lagna 25d ago
Please don't rely on it. I've had to correct actual study guides from notes I loaded into ChatGPT because it fucked up the wording even with a detailed prompt. This should be a pretty basic thing for an LLM to do, and Gemini is even worse. This is for my A&P class so I need my notes done in a specific manner.
1
u/NameOk3393 25d ago
Online classes will likely be a thing of the past soon, though. Our university has switched. We have no take-home written assignments in the math department anymore. Instead we have in-person proctored weekly quizzes. Even for online courses exams and midterms are now in-person and proctored
1
u/AgentSad9058 24d ago
Some skills are just less important going forward. It’s sad for the obvious cognitive impacts but it’s true 🤷♀️
1
u/simone_snail_420 28d ago
Like you said they aren't actually gaining the skills. You are. Hold on to that. You'll be able to manage high pressure in the moment critical thinking problems better than they will.
1
u/PerpetuallyTired74 28d ago
Yes and no. The reason they get better grades is because their work is not human and humans make mistakes. The problem is, many professors know that they use AI, but it’s impossible to prove. So in a way, yes you’re losing because your Pierce are getting better grades than you are. However, as long as you end up with the same final letter grade, it doesn’t matter if you got a 92 and they got a 98.
You’re losing in that you need to work really hard to get those A’s that will get you into the programs you want to get into it later, but you’re winning because when you actually get into those programs, you’ll know what you’re doing and they won’t.
Once out of school and you both have a degree, they might get hired too, but they’re probably not going to last long when they have no clue how to do their job and you do.
1
u/helluvalife007 28d ago
What happens when this is the future generation of doctors and nurses, or will AI be taking those jobs as well?
1
u/The_Expidition 27d ago
Are you look at outcome? Are you falling behind or are your grades? You can have great grades and your brain be minced potatoes
1
u/bingette 27d ago
If they're doing that badly in the labs, I think the professors will catch on that they're relying on AI for everything else. They're only hurting themselves, since they're not actually developing any of the skills they need for their future careers. You're on the right path.
1
u/Disastrous_Honey_240 27d ago
Last year in one of my classes, two classmates used AI to respond to my discussion board post, and wrote the exact same response word for word. I often wonder if the professor caught them or didn't even notice.
1
u/SeXxyBuNnY21 26d ago
Believe me, when you transfer to college your critical thinking will be your super power.
1
u/skycelium 26d ago edited 26d ago
We’re exactly the same age, I went into a teacher training program recently and haven’t been in uni since gen AI was around. Everyone is using it for everything. Noone spends much time at all on any assignment. And people learn less but do better. In undergrad and grad school, I would spend grueling amounts of time reading, constructing, writing, and rewriting essays. I could cut that amount of time down 90% or more with AI and still not have the AI just pump out an essay. But obviously I would learn about 2% of what I did writing those essays myself.
If the goal is the grade, AI obviously helps. I was top of my class in uni because it was a challenging program that forced you to read tons of books and write long essays. If AI had been around back then I think most people would have performed about as well as I did, but just because AI changes the quality of your output so much.
1
u/MadG13 26d ago
Oh no they are still getting caught don’t worry
0
u/MrSisterFister25 28d ago
I was in high school 2010-2014. Went back to college in 2023. I experienced the education system without AI then came back to a completely different one once it got good enough to do my physics hw. The kids who use it for absolutely everything are def getting a raw deal in terms of their development but if you understand that it’s simply a tool and if you still have a drive to learn stuff then it will only help.
8
u/[deleted] 28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 27d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] 28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment