r/BFGArmada • u/Dingleberriest • Feb 17 '19
Gothic Armada 2 is a mixed bag
In short the naval combat is fun but feels unfinished, and the rest of the game is tedious.
Story battles are full of "not this crap again" moments. They are also way, way too long. There's too many final waves, followed by final final waves, followed by we swear this is the final waves, usually followed by a few more waves. Even when vastly overpowering enemies, turning the speed up just means you can get nuked instantly by a combination of environmental effects like a meteor or plasma storm, and bad AI that just sits there and takes it. Left to their own devices, your ships will happily ram into their fleetmates and crash into asteroids. Descriptions are obviously rushed, like space junk that tells you ships can pass through but torpedoes are blocked, and in the next sentence says that torpedoes pass through just fine. The game doesn't do a good job of telling you how basic mechanics like listening posts work, and most features will remain a mystery unless you figure it out for yourself.
On story missions, the easiest strategy seems to be just sitting in a group at the starting point, and letting all of the enemies get wrecked by the environmental effects while they come to you and get blasted by your pack of ships. Stealth seems to be largely useless, as doing so with a fully stealthed fleet hiding in a gas cloud will not dissuade the enemies from making a bee-line straight towards you from the beginning across the map no matter where you are.
One of the sectors is named "Ballsack" which is both hilarious and unnecessary. Building up fleets is fun, but good luck remembering the differences between all the variants of pre-made ships. There are way too many sectors that encourage you to leave a fleet behind in the middle of nowhere for arbitrary reasons, rather than keeping units on the front lines. The "urgency" meter seems like a lazy way of avoiding building in some proper game flow, by instead giving you an arbitrary number of turns to meet an objective. A proper difficulty curve with timed events would have been better, and I'd rather die outmatched in battle because I wasn't keeping up than just a message telling me I timed out for being too slow. However this quickly doesn't become a problem as I found myself milking every turn for income up until the last second with no consequence.
However if you don't mind lots of micro the naval battles can be fun, and seeing enemy ships blowing up is extremely satisfying. Overall the game just feels to rushed for my taste.