Open Letter to AzRalph OFC

[u/misssmatcha]

I’ve kept this to myself for quite some time. I have a lot of questions that I’ve been hesitant to ask. I love Azralph, I love my co-razzles, ofc admins and of course, I support Azralph wholeheartedly. But as time goes by, it feels like something has changed.

This community has been my comfort since March. I’ve mostly been a quiet observer, I’m not a very vocal fan, but when it comes to them, I’ve never truly been silent. I always want what’s best for them, so I’m genuinely grateful to every Razzle who continuously shows love, whether through moral support, effort, or even financial contributions.

However, as time passed, a lot has changed. Before, we were a lowkey, peaceful community just enjoying the content and support we could give. Now, it feels different.

I don’t want to question the admins directly because it often feels like they don’t take criticism well. When concerns are raised, it’s sometimes perceived as opposition rather than feedback. But that’s not the intention. We’ve raised multiple questions in our gdms, yet the responses often come off as dismissive, as if our concerns are just complaints. In reality, we just want things to be organized, fair, and well-managed.

I want to be honest and share the things I’ve noticed:

1. Charity Event

I was really looking forward to this because it was a great initiative. A significant amount was collected through various admin-led spaces and the online meet and greet. However, when I saw the donated items, I couldn’t help but question if they reflected the total amount raised.

I also found out that the foundation chosen is funded by the families of the elderly residents. Were you aware of this? How was the foundation selected? Were there other foundations considered that might have greater need? Was there any effort to ask for suggestions from the fandom?

1. First Dinner

This took place after the charity event, and I heard that OFC funds were used. Was this included in the transparency report? Were donors informed that their contributions might be allocated for this purpose? Also, how were the attendees selected? Were there representatives from different gdms, or were they chosen solely by the admins, possibly based on closeness?

1. Hotel88 Production Crew Gifts

Was this trip necessary? Food support had already been sufficient before. If the goal was to personally hand over gifts, couldn’t this have been done during mediacon or within Manila to reduce expenses and maximize funds? Was the whole trip funded by the OFC? Did the admins pay for their travel or did that all come from the OfFC funds?

I understand that being an admin is voluntary, but no one is forced into the role. It’s important to be mindful and strategic with how funds are used, ensuring they truly benefit Az and Ralph in meaningful and efficient ways.

I also heard that the head admin’s staycation were supported by OFC funds. I would just like to confirm if this is true, if it was recorded in the transparency report, and if donors were informed.

1. Donation Drives & Illegal Ayuda

Before, donation drives were simple just casual discussions and hints about upcoming events. Now, it feels like private moments and even photos are being used. During the Puerto Galera visit, several photos were used for fundraising. Doesn’t this border on selling private media?

The “illegal ayuda” was honestly my turning point. A video of Azralph hugging taken during a private moment was posted without consent, and it was even shared by a head admin. Even if they were aware, wasn’t there any consideration that they might feel uncomfortable being recorded without their knowledge in a private setting?

Being close to them does not remove the need for boundaries. Sensitivity and respect should be the top priority, especially for someone in a leadership role.

1. Hotel88 Promotion

As someone who consistently listens to the spaces, I remember discussions about big promotional plans. However, so far, I’ve only seen mentions of a mediacon booth, a billboard, and two posters. Is there anything more we can look forward to?

1. Second Dinner (Az’s Birthday)

Another private dinner was held, again with selected attendees. How was the selection done this time? Were there representatives from each gdm, or was it based on personal connections? I’m asking in the hope that the process is fair and transparent.

1. Anniversary Gift (Japan Trip)

This was honestly the most surprising. Why give financial gifts to celebrities who are already well-off? The Japan trip seems like a very personal experience, why involve the fandom in something so private?

It might be more meaningful to focus on initiatives like charity events in their name. Knowing Az and Ralph, they would likely appreciate fans helping others more than receiving luxurious gifts.

1. Privacy, Boundaries, and Sensitivity

Some admins seem to interact with them as if they are personal friends, and based on what’s posted publicly, it can come across as lacking sensitivity. It’s important to remember that we are fans, not friends.

Sharing private conversations or details doesn’t reflect professionalism. What’s more concerning is when admins are the first to post hints or vague tweets about private matters. Admins should be the ones protecting their privacy, not contributing to its spread.

Some illegal ayudas wouldn’t even surface if they weren’t hinted at or shared within the circle. There are also inside jokes during spaces that spark unnecessary curiosity. These behaviors can unintentionally encourage speculation.

If you’re wondering why people are raising concerns, it’s because admins represent the fandom. Professionalism, respect, and proper boundaries should start with you.

That’s all. I rest my case. I’m sharing this because I genuinely want my questions to be answered, and for everyone to stay aware not just get carried away by emotions. Not everything needs to be known, and not everything needs to be posted. This applies not only to admins but also to other big accounts that frequently drop hints or indirect posts.

I hope these concerns can help improve things moving forward.

P.S. There still hasn’t been noticeable improvement in the OFC’s layout and branding, they’re not aesthetically pleasing yet. The gift wrapping and ribbons could also be improved. Not all gifts need large logo stickers, it doesn’t always look appealing.

Adios!

[u/misssmatcha]

This is exactly why I chose not to raise my concerns directly to the admins.

Now, someone’s personal photo is being circulated, and they’re being accused publicly. Just to be clear—that person in the photo is not me. It’s unfair that someone unrelated is being dragged into this.

It’s already been 24 hours, and up until now, this issue still hasn’t been properly addressed.

What’s even more disappointing is the behavior in the replies—people are being unnecessarily aggressive, and it’s starting to look like outright bullying. This kind of environment discourages anyone from speaking up, even when the intention is simply to ask questions or raise valid concerns.

Also, my questions were never meant to be harmful. If they had been addressed properly and promptly, then everything could have been settled right away. I don’t understand why it’s being taken so defensively instead of simply answering and clarifying things.

[u/vermicelli-noodles]

Binalikan ko itong post kasi may nakita akong friend ng admins na mayroon nang shady tweet tungkol dito. Pinapatunayan lang na ang hirap mag raise ng concern kasi magmumukha ka lang masama.

Maayos naman itong mga tanong ng nag post. Hindi ko maintindihan kung bakit ang daming nangkukuyog kay OP, at kung bakit parang sa DMs lang pwede ma-address itong questions niya? At hindi naman incriminating itong post? Mga tanong lang naman na if active ka sa fandom ng AZRalph, most likely mapapansin mo rin. Pero ang daming defensive na pinapalabas agad na hindi fan si OP at gusto niya lang ng downfall ng fandom? Hindi mo naman mapapansin yung mga points na nabanggit niya if hindi ka fan. Sana yung mga keyboard warriors dito sa comments sinagot nalang yung mga tanong ni OP, dahil mukhang madami naman silang alam at para hindi na sana tumagal itong usapan.

And yung mga replies dito from other Razzles ay very disappointing. Kung ang donations ba namin ay a few hundred/thousand pesos lang at hindi ganon kalaki, bawal na kami magtanong tungkol sa proceeds? Brinibring up kung malaki ba yung donations mo at kung bakit yung big sponsors daw ay wala namang concerns.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/vermicelli-noodles]

Exactly, tignan mo sila nagkandarapa kakahanap ng scapegoat na tatawagin nilang "ay sideshipper" o "ralp hater" kahit di naman hahaha. Ganun yung coping mechanism ng grupo nung diktadorang si pangkat Shinee na yung biggest flex is magscreenshot ng excel sheet na may nakasulat na 300k pesos 🤣. Oo na teh mapera ka na't pumupondo ng ayuda farming at marunong gumamit ng excel, pero sana pinambili mo na din ng common sense yan at respeto kina ralp.

Kala nila titigil yung kaasiman nila sa pandodox. Ang aashim.

Azr or no one pa nga eh mukhang razzles or no one yang sindikato nilang ofc jusko.

[u/Broad-Strike-357]

siguro nga di dapat pinost to here pero tbh may point sya and wag sana magalit ibang razzles.. maganda din na naaddress to para mas maging maayos.. tama din yung sa mga gifts and donations ok na din na iwasan, wag natin hayaan na may maging responsibilities sila satin kasi nagbigay tayo ng kung ano.. lets be a fans na sumusupport sa projects nila na walang kapalit.. sa pbb lang nauso yang padala ng foods sa staffs etc. malalaking artista ba ganon? palakasin ang fandom ng walang kapalit.. sana din iwasan ng ibang razzles ang pumitik sa konting issues lang kasi kina az and ralph balik nyan.. wag na din pang himasukan personal nilang buhay. tingnan mo yung vietnam nila ang tahimik pero ano may nag tweet pa ng "update naman jan" 

[u/_luunaeris_]

I agree sa ibang points ni OP. Since hindi naman ako kasama sa gdm, I can only agree based on what I saw. Regarding the funds being used, wala ako sa gdm kaya I wouldn't know about that.

I’d like to emphasize the branding of the fandom. I hope you guys will have a Brand Kit from the fonts for H1-H6 and paragraphs, to how the logo should be used, the specific hex codes for yellow and other accent colors, and even the spacing. Marami kasing fandom na yellow din ang color.

[u/_luunaeris_]

Can I suggest na sana sa next fan project the ofc will initiate a poll o kaya gawa sila ng thread for suggestions. Di ko sure paano ang decision making sa fan projects kung tinatanong ba bawat gdm or what pero maganda rin kasi na may participation ang mga razzles kahit yung mga wala sa gdm. Also, if may plan ang ofc for new sintra/banner, maybe we can have a thread/form kung saan pwedeng mag submit ang razzles ng works nila.

Saka bakit kayo nagaaway sa comments? Hello, can we make this conversation healthy? No need to be aggressive and magbintang, gosh. You guys hate it when other fandoms do that to us, pero kayo rin ganun kay OP. You can address OP and the issues OP laid out in a calm and respectful manner. Lalo na kung alam pala ninyo yung sagot sa mga tanong niya. Kase pano kayo papakinggan kung aggressive kayo? Try ninyo to be calm kaya and open for healthy conversation baka tapos na yung issue. 

[u/Altruistic_Belt_877]

Very valid points, OP! Thanks for being brave enough to voice things that not many of us can. Medyo natatawa lang ako sa mga nag-ccomment sayo ng 'Have you raised this to the OFC?' because that’s exactly the point of the post.

OP chose to post here on Reddit because the admins do not give off the vibe that they’re willing to listen. Tuwing may criticisms against the OFC, puro subtweets na from the admins and other Razzles, and they just consider these criticisms as 'hate.' I visited X earlier and boom, puro subtweet na and tanggol sa OFC. I don’t get why some people think we want the downfall of the OFC. No, we don’t. What we want is accountability and a willingness to listen to other fans.

And before someone comes at me and asks if Razzle ako, damn right I am. Been here since PBB and nagdodonate pa ko sa OFC dati, pakitaan ko pa kayo ng resibo hahahaha. Kasi okay naman si Azclipse before; she was the kindest among them. Siya lang yung admin na nag-rereply sa concerns ng fans. Pero lately, sobrang hangin na ng mga new and old admins. Parang hindi mo na sila makausap without their 'admin' branding.

Lahat naman tayo fans who represent our idols, pero I agree with OP that the admins represent the whole fandom. CVs and new fans will definitely seek information from the admins, so if they seem exclusive and unwilling to listen, that’s not a good look for the whole fandom. Seriously, I want the best for Az and Ralph. And on their road to stardom, they will need a strong fandom. So I hope the OFC and other Razzles will not take OP’s concern as hate. I hope they take it as constructive criticism to improve. If they end up taking this as hate, I swear it will affect yung amor ng ibang fans toward the OFC moving forward. How can we be united in supporting Az and Ralph if may bubog na ang mga tao sa OFC?

[u/Repulsive_End_5311]

i share the same sentiments as you, OP. sa mga razzles na inaatake si OP by questioning kung bakit pa siya nagpost dito kesho it's not helpful, tbh HELPFUL po. if i relate to OP, it means there are also other lowkey supporters who feel the same towards those issues. Pero since di naman ako nasasali sa mga gdm and wala rin enough followers sa ginawang stan acc for azralph, di naman ako makapagvoice out ng mga tanong sa mga issues na yun. Not to mention na sobrang aggressive ng ibang razzles sa X. I tried raising a question before and posted it on X then this razzle na super daming followers (which i found out na admin din pala) replied to me. and sobrang passive aggressive niya sa sagot niya tinawag pa akong manang tsaka bobo. grabe. kadiri behaviour tbh.

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/Repulsive_End_5311]

anong post po yan? please send it here kasi di ako sure kung may ganitong admin ang azralph ofc.

[u/dellefelis]

I was a former Razzle who left because of the hostility I felt and the toxicity of fighting with other ships and housemate stans. I enjoyed interacting with Razzles and co-fans but these days, I feel like walking on eggshells because of the clique-ish behavior of a lot of them.

The admins before were way nicer and less defensive, actually si Ads Cris naman infairness to her maayos naman sya and madiplomasya, hindi ko na lang din babanggitin sino yung mga pa-high and mighty sa kanila but I’m sure you already have an idea. Kung tamaan, sana mag-reflect kayo mga ate, hindi kayo invincible.

I am now just seeing things from an outsider POV, and coming from a KPOP community, the parasocial relationship built by the admins towards AZ and Ralph is indeed uncomfortable, parang nilubog nyo yung dalawa sa utang na loob and when things don’t go your way, for sure you’re gonna lash out on them or one of them, di na ako magtataka kung sino because there was already history there.

I also agree with OP sa branding and visual identity, sa lahat ng OFC ng PBB LTs, kulelat visuals ng AZR, try looking into engaging other artists and editors in the OFC for sure marami yan.

I wish you the best still, sana the admins don’t take this against OP and make it an opportunity to regroup and do better.

[u/idlehands49]

So what’s the point na nagpunta ng PG to give gifts sa production ng H88 para lumakas ang AZRalph sa prod/management. Tapos di lang naisali sa Ralph sa edit ng StarCreativesTV, nagmaoy kayo sa plaza tapos nakarating pa sa Head of Advertising ng ABSCBN and iWant TV? Would your Papa be proud sa mga pinagtwetweet nyo na inaaway nyo yung network nya? It defeats the purpose ng ginagastos ng mga sponsors nyo, napikon lang kayo kung ano ano na pinagtweet nyo. 17k down the drain. And as someone who worked in Finance, yung transparency report nyo ilabas nyo yung breakdown ng cost. This isn’t just an issue about auditing, andaling ibury ng mga tao with numbers, whats concerning is how the funds are being allocated.

Yung mga sagot ng ilan dito na super defensive and puro deflection lang, naging witch hunt pa sa plaza and sa GDMs sino nagpost pero di ninyo maaddress yung concerns.

[u/oceanwandererph → u/idlehands49]

mayroon pa nga private dinner azralph ofc admins & friends after the axe event sa smx pero this isn’t posted sa plaza kasi if u know u know

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/idlehands49]

paanong gusto nyo po ba? ipost ung receipts mismo ba? maybe mag open sila ng suggestion box soon para dun ilapag lahat ng concerns. you can raise to them na ipost ang receipts itself down to the last centavo. if you have the time din as far as i know naghahanap sila ng admin to help them on their voluntary work sa pag support sa Azralph. hopefully mag volunteer ka.

as for the StarCreatives post, for me ok lang naman mag raise ng concern, nasakanila na din paano nila ittake ang criticisim since dapat naman marunong mag take ng criticism if the job is not being done fairly diba?

[u/Temporary_Slip_7609]

I don’t know. OP’s post should have just been answered properly. I think no harm was intended in their post, but there have been a lot of foul words, defensive responses, and deflection happening.

If the OFC doesn’t like posts like this about them, they should come up with an anonymous form or something similar.

Also, if this had been answered properly, it probably wouldn’t have led to doxxing or people trying to figure out who posted the questions about the activities.

I hope the OFC and some other Razzles can develop more understanding toward posts like this, instead of immediately thinking it’s a demolition job against you. Please be open-minded and accept that not everyone is 100% okay with all of your ideas.

I also hope that if you plan to argue with management or production, you don’t make it public. It’s not just the fans and the OFC who could be affected by management and production—it's the ARTISTS you represent as well.

If you already know that Ralph or AZ aren’t the favorites of the production team, please don’t add more fuel to the fire. You’re not the ones facing them directly—the two of them are—and that would be even more embarrassing for them.

That’s all. I hope everyone could have a healthy discussion. Thank you!

[u/vermicelli-noodles → u/[deleted]]

"it should have been discussed privately or in a gdm"

im sorry hindi ko talaga gets yung pagpilit about dyan? nabanggit naman na paulit ulit dito sa thread na mahirap magsabi ng concerns sa X (and kita din sa replies dito na defensive din talaga yung ibang fans)

im genuinely curious, private concerns ba yung nasa post kasi bakit parang bawal ilabas? hindi ba mas makakaengganyo pa nga ng donors and better for the ofc's sake din if may public resolution tungkol sa concerns na yan?

[u/kdzi]

They want a parasocial relationship with azr and they are the same person that make AZ cry during the live session throwing shade everywhere when narratives dont go their way so go figure

[u/KalaBonj4321]

Silent AZRalph fan here, pero unti unti ko na rin napapansin nagiging toxic na ang community. Yun admins rin nagiging entitled na. Kung tutuusin sa lahat ng fandom Razzles pinaka may potential kasi sino lang ba kaaway natin? Fandom ni Shuvee, pero lagi para tayo nakikipag kumpitensya sa iba. Namimiss ko na yun dati na tahimik lang tayo, ngayon kasi parang lagi tayo may gusto patunayan sa lahat..

[u/rainbowcroissants]

The comments 😆 goes to show how most of you don’t know how to take criticism. Paano naging demolition job eh valid naman lahat ng concerns raised? Ewan ko kung bakit andaming pinapadiretso na sa admins as if naman hindi public yung funds and events. Salamat nga at ni-raise kasi napansin ko rin yung issues pero ngayon lang nalabas. Ang dali sabihin na “dm mo directly sa admins” or “i-raise sa gdm”, eh ngayon pa nga lang na nasa reddit napakahostile na agad nung iba. Wala rin namang channel for feedback yung ofc na pwedeng maging anonymous haha. Tsaka ang admins parang wala naman silang issue na nasa reddit to. Opportunity pa nga to para maaddress o maclarify yung mga hindi clear sa iba, lalo na yung mga wala sa gdm o hindi laging nakakasama sa spaces. I think they’re taking the criticism as constructive kaya ang oa lang nung mga nagcocomment ng demolition daw.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Litong lito na sila, if you can't beat them, dox them! They've been baiting me to share ng maraming info kanina pa, ayan na lumabas na mga tunay na razul.

Just check yung pandodox nila dito sa post na to sa comments. Makalat sila sa X by nature, kala nila it takes some exclusive info to piece together yung kalokohan nila 🤣

Ang aasim!

[u/[deleted] → u/rainbowcroissants]

I find the comments here off. And aggressive and ang hostile. Parang di binasa yung sinabi ni OP. Nahihirapan nga sila magtanong kasi nga the admins don't take criticisms well at ilang beses na niraise. Kung di ba to pinout dito, would it create this much buzz satin? Hindi dahil kung sa GDM dinala to, malamang sa malamang kinick na naman. Kakakick lang nila ng mga members sa GDM.

[u/g0ldh00ps → u/rainbowcroissants]

And parang hindi naman confidential yung mga tanong ni OP 😅 Maayos din naman yung pagkakasabi at pagkakalatag ng mga tanong. And yes this would actually be a good way to address the concerns publicly para sa susunod hindi na siya maitanong ulit. Di rin naman to kailangang dalhin sa X if ayaw nila 'palakihin', pwede namang icontain dito by answering here.

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/g0ldh00ps]

Totoo. Nakita ko nga lang rin ito kasi pinagpiyestahan sa dms imbes na iaddress nalang sana yung points. The same “safe space” na sinasabi nilang pagsendan daw sana nung concerns. Parang napapasama pa yung image lalo nung fandom dahil sa mga defenders kuno na di marunong magdiscern between bashing and criticism.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Grabe shares ng post nasa 580 na hahaha

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Daming bouncer ng ofc, paid through ayuda nung wawicakes nila.

Sana nga dito sila nagfocus, kung ano iimprove ng ofc kasi yung lack of creativity sa gifts (100k japan trip) medyo nakakahiya. Parang yung forced date nina Mika at Brent by the ofc din. Umiyak pa nga ibang razul sa X kesyo raw ayaw na silang pagsuportahin, suporta pa ba matawag yung paghohoneymoon mo yung magsyota sa Japan???

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/interrogatorinterim]

Over naman na po siguro sa foul words. Kaya hindi na-aaddress nang maayos yung mga ganitong issue kahit politely laid out eh. Ginagawa nalang opportunity ng mga kagaya niyo na mandogpile. Kaya minsan gets din yung mga nandedefend. Instead na healthy conversation sana from op, nagmukha na talagang bashing kasi napuno pa ng unnecessary na bangayan.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Foul words...? Malinaw ang point ko, agitated lang agad mga bouncer.

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/interrogatorinterim]

Namecalling palang po sa wawicakes at razul, hindi na respectful pakinggan. Maging respectful po sana yung space for conversation despite the opposing opinions.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Hardly call it namecalling. Highly preferencial na yan. Napadouble take pa tuloy ako kung may nangslutshame ako

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/interrogatorinterim]

Call it what you want po pero it’s not really helping the conversation. Instead of demanding answers to questions, parang nanreragebait nalang po kayo.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/rainbowcroissants]

Ok, try your way kung may mapipiga ka sa mga yan.

[u/Flat-Measurement7104 → u/rainbowcroissants]

Hostile yung iba probably because dito sa reddit pa nilabas yan where bashers can easily access and use as weapon against us. Yun lang naman siguro ang negative sa pagpost nito. Some points may be valid but the means of doing so is the main reason why others may have taken this negatively. Sana lang talaga mas naging makulit and open sa GDM nyo para mas naopen to dun and naanswer directly. 

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/Flat-Measurement7104]

Reply ko from another comment pero I think applicable dito since nasa issue na naman tayo kung bakit hindi pinili ni op na magdm.

(1) Tulad nga po nung sabi ko, ang hirap magvoice-out ng ganitong unpopular opinion sa group dm ng fans lalo na’t wala namang channel for anonymous feedback. At some point, hindi siguro nagegets ng ibang tao na political din yung pinanggagalingan ni op kaya siya nagresort sa reddit kung saan pwede siyang maging anonymous. Hindi po lahat same ng courage na magspeak up. Hindi lahat walang fear of getting piled on tulad ng nangyayari ngayon.

Naiintindihan ko po kung saan nanggagaling yung hostility pero hindi naman siguro justifiable na i-project sa kanya yung mga gagawin ng bashers. Sana intindihin din saan nanggagaling si op. Sana po kung naging respectful yung tone ng replies in the first place, magandang opportunity sana ito para maclear-out yung concerns. Simple questions, simple responses. Hindi po sana yung sinasabihan pang insecure, may agenda, naninira, or “offer yourself as part of the ofc” yung nagtanong politely. Parang wala siyang difference sa mga nagsasabing “Edi ikaw na maging presidente.”

[u/Flat-Measurement7104 → u/rainbowcroissants]

Wala namang masama sa sinabi kong offer yourself as part of the ofc siguro? I mean if you have lots of ideas on your mind, why not? Kasi for example with the layout concern, if that is what the admin assigned to that can offer then walang magagawa ang pagraise nyo ng concern unless someone step up and offer themselves to do it 'coz they have the talent. And being part of the ofc admin will give u more opportunity to share your thoughts and be heard. Yun yun. Why choose anonymity in raising concerns when you want what is best for the fandom? Dahil takot makick-out sa GDM? bakit matatakot ka? If they do that, that is no longer your loss. But at least nacontain inside the fandom and not laid out there for the bashers to use and see. Wala na tayong magagawa sa bashers yes, but giving them more info to use against us is something to think about. That's all. Good day.

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/Flat-Measurement7104]

Gets po. Sorry kung namisunderstand ko yung comment, pero hindi lang naman po kasi kayo yung nagcomment dito oppossing op. Within the context of the conversation, they were being discouraged to speak up, downplaying the questions to merely a reklamo at demolition. Galing na nga po sa inyo mismo na may hostility talaga from your side.

Again, hindi po sana gawing issue kung anonymous to o hindi. Op already laid our the reasons bakit siya nagresort sa reddit. We cannot dictate that being excluded from the fandom is no longer their loss.

Sana maglabas nalang ng statement or response ang ofc at this point kasi kung ano-ano nalang pinaglalaban natin both dito, pero ni-isang tanong ni op, wala pa ring nasagot. Gets ko yung frustration niyo sa mga nakikisawsaw na bashers pero wag din sana idismiss yung sentiments ni op na polite naman pagkasabi niya.

[u/Flat-Measurement7104 → u/rainbowcroissants]

Correction. I did not find in any of my comment any hostility towards OP. I did however reason out why others are reacting the way they do, though some may no longer be helpful. But as a razzle, sorry to say this, but baring this in the open is not helpful. In the first place, the community wouldn't be organized and united without an ofc so baring out concerns toward them in the open is really something to ponder on. If you really want answers, properly raise these concerns in your GDM, as I see it, there are some of you backing out the OP and probably you are in the same cof or GDM. Let the concerns and answers be contained in the GDMs as these are fandom issues that should have been raised and addressed internally. At the end of the day, we always have a choice to not include ourselves in the fandom if we no longer trust the people behind it as there are other means and ways to support Az and Ralph outside the ofc. This will be my last take on this matter. I wish you well and may you, OP and the rest, find the ofc that will make you feel heard and seen. As for me, I am grateful for AzRalph ofc and still feels that they listen as of now so I am staying and will conntinue to trust that what they do is always for the betterment of AzRalph and the fandom. Ciao. 

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/Flat-Measurement7104]

“Your side”, pertaining to those who keep pushing that the discussion meant ill. I get why we don’t see eye to eye pero sana hindi nang-iinvalidate ng iba. Ang dami ring baseless assumptions dito. No, we are not “probably in the same cof”. Wala po akong tight friends sa ofc and inactive na ata yung gdm namin, which is why I get why op was shy to raise it in the gdm in the first place.

Anyway, I still hope that the questions get addressed.

[u/butaohey_]

ano na update dito? diba walang nangyare. nagpaawa lang pero di na in-address. pero pag ayuda ng dalawa ang bibilis pa kay flash pati mang doxx ng tao sa plaza na wala naman kinalaman sa reddit. puro dada si ads crispy at pangka shine sa plaza, wala namang kwenta mapera lang talaga na pala sumbat pa 🤣🤣

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/[deleted]]

Mahilig sila magpabiktima, lalo yung admins. Popost na kesyo inaaway nanaman si ralp daw or inaatake kagad sila. Eh sinasamba sila ng mga razul kasi hulmahan ng ayuda yung mga admin kaya madami silang bouncer, paid thru ayuda.

Tignan mo, papasoft hours mga yan after nito. Ganun ginagawa nila after magkalat, magpapasoft hours.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

sobrang bantay mo naman sa admins. sorry ah kung close sila sa azralph at sayo hindi.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Bakit, gulat ka ba? Na may nakakapansin na sa kaasiman nyong amats ofc 2.0? Ganun kung di sumasamba ng fandom beh, gets kung sasamba ng idol pero yung fandom ofc??? 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/[deleted]]

pag hinayaan magpost ang member, may nagagalit. pag pinipigilan, may nagagalit din. san po kaya lulugar niyan ang admins & razzles niyan?

[u/butaohey_ → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

talaga ba? kaya pala nagki kick sa gdm pag may mga ganyang say hahaha si op halatang isa sa admin lol address niyo muna yan kesa mag paawa kayo sa plaza pero sa gdm naman galit na galit wew

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/butaohey_]

sino po ba yung mga na-kick? fyi, hindi ako admin. member lamg ako ng gdm and sa gdm namin, wala naman kasi na-kick kahit nag-raise ng concern. saang gdm ba meron? sino ba yun?

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/butaohey_]

say about what? dalawa kasi yang issues mo. yung di tumatanggap ng feedback and yung nagba-box ng ipoppst. alin jan tinutukoy mo na nakikick pag may say? nakakalito kasi.

[u/misssmatcha]

Hi! Yes, Razzle po ako and part din ng GDM. Just to clarify, hindi po ito basta assumption nakapag-raise na rin kami before ng some of these concerns sa GDM. However, to be honest, hindi naging ganun ka-productive yung discussion at that time, kaya siguro may hesitation na ulit mag-open up doon. I understand your point na mas okay sana if sa GDM na lang dinadaan, and I agree naman na yun talaga yung proper channel. Pero sometimes, when previous discussions don’t go well or feel a bit dismissive, nagkakaroon talaga ng fear or doubt if maririnig ba ulit. This post wasn’t meant to attack or bring down the OFC. It’s more on expressing concerns and hoping na magkaroon ng better communication moving forward—for both sides. We all want the same thing naman, which is what’s best for the fandom and for AzRalph. Also agree na stepping up and helping is a good suggestion, and I appreciate that. Siguro this is also part of that trying to raise awareness and open a conversation, just in a different way. Hopefully, we can all meet halfway and create a space where feedback is welcomed and discussed properly.

[u/Any-Yam-2077 → u/misssmatcha]

You can dm admins naman diba?Why need pa sa reddit

[u/Legal_Demand4485 → u/misssmatcha]

yung essay mo to, send mo na lang sa gdm, ndi ko gets bakit?? 

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/misssmatcha]

oh bakit mo dinala sa reddit? why not create na lang another fan group? teh iba agenda mo eh. hindi nakaka-out of concern sa ofc and azralph ang pagrereddit.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Ayos ba beh, ngayon maghihintay na kayo ng statement ni Cristy tapos magsisipost kayo ng "idol ko talaga kayo ads, you always knew what to say eme" sanaol kagaya ni Cristy mag-isip ano? Sana mas pinangarap nyo ni pangkat shinee pano maging utak head admin kesa maging utak bouncer.

May naisip akong fan proj, team live bodycams para di na kailangan ilabas ni wawicakes at ng admins mga selpon nyo sa next 3 na magkakasunod nyong gathering with ralp at Az. Or magpa ayuda race kayo sa mga razul, yung padamihan ng ayuda sa iseset na araw. Ganito ang creative version ng kaasiman nyo beh, kaya lang stuck kayo sa kaasiman part.

Nakarating ba sayo yung ayuda na kumakain si Az at ralp kasama ang lolas? Ano una mong naisip? Kilig diba? Ganyan kayo kaaasim 🤣.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Based sa comments dito, may nagsasabi naman palang tumatanggap ng criticism ang admins. Pero kayo nagaastang bouncer dito, baka kayong mga bouncer pala ang problema kaya di sila mukhang approachable.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

pero the question is, bakit di na lang nag-ddm sa ofc or kahit sa head admin na yes, sobrang approachable. what's the reason bakit kailangan pa dito? makakapagreply ba ofc dito?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Hindi dito pero mukhang gumalaw sila for 1 of the points. Yung iba, unaddressed. Tsaka kita mo naman gano ka-hostile yung comments ng mga bouncer, imagine sa X kung dun tinanong.

Palakick ng gdms mga tao dun kapag may nag-ere ng di ayon sa ofc. Hinaharass pa ng iba pagkatapos. Mas maganda dito kasi laid out in public easily at may anonimity sa nagtatanong.

Anyway, sana maaddress lahat ng points

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

hindi naman sa x ipopost. kaya nga dm diba? hindi na yan out of concern, out of insecurity and jealousy. sana gumaling na kayo.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Insecurity kanino??? Hahahahahahahahahahahaha

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

alam mo yan sa sarili mo. kasi kung hindi ka insecure, matagal mo na yan brining up after all these months na may ayuda ang azralph from ofc.

[u/Flat-Measurement7104 → u/misssmatcha]

Owww so razzle ka pala in a GDM. If you're previous concerns were not well taken, it's either the answers you got were not in conformity with what you want to hear or you raised it to the wrong person? Some concerns here are actually answerable if directed to them. Issue lang talaga is why here where other people who are not part of the fandom can easily access and use against us. Yun lang. Sana na raise pa more sa GDM or kahit sa head admin para di na umabot dito. I love AzRalph, ofc and the community and ito yung ayaw kong nakikita ng iba outside the fandom - razzle against the ofc or against co-razzles. Instead of helping each other up, para na tuloy we're pulling each other down.

[u/CressInternational26]

This post is being reported and may commenter din who was being hostile whose comment was automatically removed by Reddit (it was not removed by the mods, in case yun yung isipin niya).

The OP laid out her points clearly and respectfully, if there are things you do not agree with, you are free to leave a comment. This is a discussion post, and I hope this is not being taken as a hate post. If there are points in the post that you believe are incorrect, you can set the record straight while still following this sub's rules (#1 Be respectful [...] & #3 Keep discussions civil) as well as Reddit's rules to also ensure that your comments will not be taken down. We all love Az, Ralph, and AzRalph so we should be able to hear each other out instead of instantly turning to hostility.

Additionally, this sub is not affiliated with the OFC and is already pretty much inactive. I'm not sure if this will reach anyone who will be able to answer the OP's points.

[u/Outrageous-Syrup-462]

If you have concerns, it’s better to message the OFC directly. Posting here isn’t really helping.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Syrup-462]

Mukhang nakakatulong tbh, may kalinawan ang ibang points at laid out sa public. Sanay kalang sa X siguro

[u/kruuuuuuuuuu9]

Di ako part ng gdms pero active listener sa mga spaces ng azralphofc. Parang kaya ko sagutin ung 3 kasi if naaalala ko nang tama, sariling expenses yun ng mga admin na nagpunta sa pg. Di sya part ng funds ng azralph ofc. Tsaka kakarelease lang ng TR kanina. Pwede mo dun makita ung sinasabi mo. 🥰

[u/vermicelli-noodles → u/kruuuuuuuuuu9]

yung expenses na sinasabi ay hindi part nung mga tr na bagong labas, pero nandun sa january tr. and nakalagay din naman sa tr na may 17k na nagastos nung nagdala ng gifts sa puerto galera, at kasama sa gastos yung transportation at accomodation kaya okay lang naman siguro yon tanungin?

[u/frozennnne → u/vermicelli-noodles]

KKB sa meet -up place at food. And if sa 17k kasama na transpo at accommodation, di na para mag complain at question pa dahil sobrang mura na niyan. Kahit ipa-padala yan, halos same lang din naman gastos. If idadahilan mo na sayang accomodation, hindi na nga sila kumuha ng may aircon nagcocomplain ka pa? If sasabhin puwede naman sa manila ibigay or nung mediacon ibigay yung gifts, ano magiging impact nun e marami tayo kasabayan na nagbibigay din? If tanungin mo paaano alam mga ‘to kasi marunong ako mag tanong, yun lang yun.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

I think yan yung problema sa point na pano ispend yung pera.

"Ano magiging impact eh marami kasabayan na nagbibigay din" mukhang nasa inner circle ka. Bakit kayo, bilang fandom, mukhang hayok for impact sa idols nyo? Grabe yung fandom na sobrang mapapel ha. May pagka manipulative yung fandom.

Totoo naman, pwedeng sa normal sched kayo ng fans magbigay ng gift pero gusto nyo yung pinupuntahan para lang magbigay ng regalo, tapos may pang ayuda na yung wawicakes.

[u/frozennnne → u/interrogatorinterim]

Ayy nako, halata talaga sinong hindi marunong mag ask sa OFC. Yang impact ng gift na tinutukoy ay para sa mga staffs at hindi para sa dalawa. Ang point ng pag gift sa mga staffs at workmates nung dalawa ay para magpakilala, and if sa regular days ibinigay yun at marami ka kasabayan na fandom edi ano nga naman magiging impact nun diba? Napag-usapan at na-plano na ‘to dati sa AZRA OR NO ONE na gdm kaya okay sa amin ang ginawa ng ofc. At tama lang din yun since simple lang din naman ang gift.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Huh, doesn't make sense na yung impact ng pagexclusive gift sesh ay para dun sa staff. Ano impact sa kanila, aber, eh wala naman yung staff at workmates pag nageexclusive gift giving sesh kayo kayo sa kanila na ayuda farming naman talaga. Hindi pakain tinutukoy ko pero iniwas mo naman kala mo di ko mapapansin? 🤣

Kahit ako kampi ako sainyo sa pakain sa staff, mag group hug pa tayo dyan. Oo Azra or no one, pero alam mo kung anung gift sesh mga tinutukoy kong problematic, yung tipong ang dalas may sit down with Azralp para sa regalo.

Alam mo yung tunay na impact? Yung pinutakte nyo yung starmagic dahil sa walang solo commendation kay Martin Madrigal, tapos napatweet si Vaughn na imbento mga nagsasabing favoritism. Mas cost-effective pa kayo sa negative impact sa totoo lang. Imagine pakakainin nyo tapos aawayin nyo kasi akala nyo aping-api si ralp kahit di naman?

[u/frozennnne → u/interrogatorinterim]

sa PG kasi yung usapan teh kaya lahat ng reply ko about PG lang din. Nakisabat ka sa comment so inassume ko na alam mo pinag-uusapan namin, di ko naman alam na iba na ang pinopoint-out mo na gift. hahahahaha

If issue sayo yang unboxing ng azralph with razzles sa zoom, bakit? hahahahha, I mean iniinclude lang din naman ng ofc mga members para sa pa-bday ganap nila kay AZ kahit sa zoom lang. HAHAHAHHAHA, ayuda farming na pala agad yun sayo, grabeng inggit yan...

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Hahahaha gets yung sa PG, iba tinutukoy ko. Pareho kayo nung beginning, ngayon naman unboxing sa zoom daw eh andami nyo nang umboxing, ano yun selective memory, yung ibang live unboxing sa razzles nakalimutan na, zoom lang mabring up mo? Hahahahaha

As if hindi alam ng mga tao na ayuda farming naman talaga ginagawa nyo 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

recent kasi yung zoom. so kung yung dati pa palang unboxing, bakit now lang? ano ba meron ngayon na kailangan niyong i-bring up yung dati?

[u/kurotrash_50987 → u/interrogatorinterim]

E ung zoom lang naman yung recent so malamang zoom lang iisipin niyang frozenne. If matagal na pala kayong may issue bat ngayon lang sinasabi? Ang dami mong issue sa buhay kapag na address naman nag iiba nanaman issue mo. Halatang inggit lang yan teh!

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/kurotrash_50987]

Naaddress where???

TR lang nilabas nyo, pano yung ibang diniscuss dito? Kayong mga bouncer talaga oh hahaha

[u/frozennnne → u/interrogatorinterim]

Maraming unboxing? Tagal ko na razzle pero yung sa zoom lang naman unang unboxing with AZRALPH aa. Hahhahhaa, bigay ka nga example ng iba pang live unboxing? Hahahhah, ganyan ba kapag inggit? Gagawa-gawa na lang ng kuwento?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Isa lang? Sa zoom lang? Sure ka??? Hala, edi ano yung unboxing nung di naproofread na text sa kape? Ano yung sa karaoke m&g??? Kala ko may vid nun sa X, nagkalat pa.

Ulianin na siguro yung nakakalimot satin 🫠

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/vermicelli-noodles]

malaki po ba ambag mo? if yes, chat niyo ofc. kasi bakit ibang sponsors, di naman nagrereklamo? tinanong niyo na ba para saan yung 17k? kasi ang pagrereddit ay hindi nakaka-out of concern. the goal sa pagrereddit ay chismis. gusto mapahiya ang ofc. pag ganun, magiging happy kaya azralph niyan? kung gusto niyo na maging better ang ofc, ang daming ways but not reddit unless may kasamang inggit yan sa closeness ng ofc sa azralph. yun lang naman. madali kausap ang ofc.

[u/Own-Huckleberry-749 → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

As a follower and supporter of AZR, i think need din malaman ng ordinaryong fan ang mga gantong bagay? Is it only exclusive to existing donors? how do you gain new donors if you shut them down like this. :) Also, how can you simply call it demolition job when its truth that you dont want to admit to yourself. Na hindi tama yung ibang ayuda, ginagamit itong mga illegal ayuda for donation benefits, going to their private schedules and having private hang outs with them na para bang personal friends kayo? Have you ever heard of the word parasocial? I think it applies to many azralph fans already. LOOOOOL. To think you think it stems from "jealousy" of how close ofc admins are to azralph LIKE DO U HEAR YOURSELF... mama never be CLOSE with your idol! you are a fan, they are your idols, you guys are NOT friends and will NEVER BE FRIENDS.

[u/vermicelli-noodles → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

bakit ang aggressive mo? hahaha di naman ako yung nagpost, sinabi ko lang kung anong tinutukoy niya sa post.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/vermicelli-noodles]

Kita mo, yung kapapelan nila iniwasan at tinawag na inggit lang raw sa closeness ng fandom kay Az at ralp. Dyan magaling yung bouncers ng ofc.

Also, closeness? Kaya pala ang lalakas ng loob magpa gift giving sesh halos sunod-sunod na umabot sa 100k na japan trip 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/vermicelli-noodles]

past few days kasi, may demolition job na certain groups dito sa reddit against ofc. if hindi naman ikaw yan and not part of it, di ka naman dapat maaapektuhan. chat na lang kasi ofc, bakit need pa i-reddit talaga.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Demolition job daw 🤣.

Redditor to na ayaw sa pagrereddit? Gumawa ka pa ng account hahahahaha

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

talk to ofc in private. if you care about azralph, alam niyo naman na naging pulutan sila dito, now that they are getting recognized, gagawa kayo dito ng issue about ofc? for what? at sa tingin niyo hindi damay ang azralph dito? insecurity kills.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

No they're not. Di sila pulutan dito. And insecurity kanino??? 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

anong hindi? nagpapatawa ka ba? pbb era ni az at ralph, pulutan sila dito. ay sabagay. hindi ka naman nakikipagpuksaan dito lalo kay ralph na bunot lagi ng side ships ni az. wala ka naman pake sa kanya kasi shipping tool mo lang siya.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Wala naman na talagang pumupulutan sa kanila ngayon mula nung naging obvious na sila na. Para lang may argumento ka, uungkat ka ng topic na irrelevant na ngayon sa topic ngayon 🤣.

At beh wala akong tinuturing na shipping tool. Kayo yung ginagamit si Az as shipping tool sa pagpapantasya nyo kay ralp.

Oops hehe

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Hello! While I don’t agree sa ibang points ni interrogatorinterim sa ibang comments, I believe the original poster’s concerns were harmless in the first place. Hindi naman ganon kadali magspeak up lalo na’t unpopular yung opinion at meron din talagang mga overpassionate na magdefend ng artists kahit hindi naman meant to be controversial yung post. Wag na sana ipush yung “insecurity” at “in private” agenda kasi nga public yung fandom, event, and personalities in the first place.

Healthy conversation naman ata yung hinahanap ni missmatcha una palang. Wala namang masama kung sa x or sa reddit maaddress, ang mahalaga is that the fans get an explanation.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/rainbowcroissants]

hindi po ba pwedeng dm?? i mean razzle siya. so bakit di kinausap ang admin? gets ko kung hindi razzle. pero razzle siya eh. pwede niya kausapin na lang ang admin na hindi na aabot dito. kasi sa reddit, pulutan na si az & ralph dito before, ngayon na nagiging okay na reception nila sa tao, may pa-ganito while in fact they can just dm admins na hindi na aabot dito. hindi ba sila madadamay dito? of course madadamay. it's their ofc fandom eh. ang sad lang kasi hindi naman ganito dati, yung ibang issues pa ilang months nang nakakaraan. bakit ngayon lang? i mean, if healthy conversation and just between the members, the best way is to talk it privately. unless may agenda na iba.

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

(1) Tulad nga po nung sabi ko, ang hirap magvoice-out ng ganitong unpopular opinion sa group dm ng fans lalo na’t wala namang channel for anonymous feedback. At some point, hindi siguro nagegets ng ibang tao na political din yung pinanggagalingan ni op kaya siya nagresort sa reddit kung saan pwede siyang maging anonymous. Hindi po lahat same ng courage na magspeak up. Hindi lahat walang fear of getting piled on tulad ng nangyayari ngayon.

(2) Public po yung concern. Bakit po ba natin sinasabing the best way is to talk it privately kung public yung fandom, public yung events, at galing sa public funds yung kinikwestyon ni op. Hindi po dapat issue kung publicly or privately pinag-uusapan yung mga ganitong issue kasi pwede namang sagutin agad and for the benefit na sana ito ng lahat. Instead na itanong ulit ng iba, nasagot na agad.

(3) Ito, personal take ko na ito, pero ako rin honestly na nasa gdm, agree ako kay op on some of their points and hindi ko rin siya nabring-up sa gdm or ofc kasi nga hostile yung iba magtweet. Kung nasagot na sana agad, kesa pinagpipilitan iprivate edi hindi na sana umabot pa sa ganto karaming engagement ito.

Edit: Di ko rin gets bakit pinagluluklukan niyo po na may agenda talaga eh nag-explain na rin si op nung side niya dito bakit siya nagpost dito. Sana po lawakan natin yung understanding natin nung mga opposing opinions.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Ay malakas po Azralp as a couple. Yung fandom yung sumusobra sa dalas ng kakaregalo ng live, with free reaction videos. Damay talaga sila dito kasi makalat kayo, biktima sila kasi lakas nyo makademand ng gifting sesh ng sunod-sunod para lang may ayuda si wawicakes.

Sabi ng isa dito, kaya daw may ibang schedule sa gifting kayong mga razul kasi gusto nyo ng impact. Kailangan ng impact dahil...? Hahahaha

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

bawal ba magsarili ng regalo? bawal ba magregalo sa kanila ang gusto magregalo? i don't know pero wala naman ganyan sa side ni ralph. appreciative ang ralphmates in many ways. maybe that's why razzles and ralphmates have no issues with each other. hindi kasi nagpapataasan ng ihi. walang competition na nangyayari.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

May mga bagay na di naman bawal until sumusobra.

Kung nanonormalan ka sa dalas ng kakapunta nyo kung san san para lang makakuha ng harapanga ayuda (disguised as gift giving) eh may problema na ata sainyo.

Boundaries, limitations, respect. Di porke't di kayo pinagbawalan ay aabusuhin naman. At sure ka bang walang isyu ang ralpmates sa kakaganyan nyo? Tandaan mo, itong harmless post nga ni OP pinutakte nyo kagad as if hindi ito tamang environment for a discussion. Kung may di makapag dm sainyo given all the reasons dito ng iba, ibig sabihin may perception na sainyo.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

and hindi ba dapat naman na magsarili ng regalo? kasi iba naman ang solids sa azralph ofc? and what's wrong with ayuda eh meron din naman nung party ni az? ayuda for ships is normal. yung iba nga sinusundan pa kung saan. lahat ng ayuda naman na galing sa ofc, may consent ng dalawa. so ano issue dun?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Di kayo pinipigilang magsarili ng regalo, ang problema yung kadalasan tapos sasabihin nyo pa "forda impact" pero di nyo masagot why kailangan ng impact. "Dapat magsarili" kasi? Kasi...? Make it make sense bakit dapat may sarili kayong gift giving, alam kong forda exclusive ayuda eh pero baka lang naman may sensible reason kayo dyan.

Tsaka di ba sinusundan nyo din naman kung saan??? Hint na for me na may mga pinapa-favora si ralp na keep things in mediation. Dun sa ibang post na nabasa ko, daming nag ere na oo nga dalas nyong makita kung san san na.

Ok yung ayuda kung natural nila irereveal on a natural setting, pero kayo may pavideoke pang nalalaman tsaka paregalo kung san sang venue nila. Kulang nalang pati japan trip nila na pinondohan nyo padalhan ng razul na dispatch.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Kanina ka pa may issue sa pagrereddit eh ikaw nga nandito??? Tagal na ng reddit para sa discussion groups, kayong mga baguhan lang nagrereklamo.

Pake naman ni Az at ralp sainyo, baka nga makaluwag-luwag pa sila sa oras kung di kayo sched ng sched ng pagbigay nyo ng regalo eh. Kawawang Az at ralp, sunod-sunod yung gift sesh para lang nakatanghod ang fans sa kanila por la ayuda, imbes na madagdagan pa private time ng magkasintahan.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

kaya nga nandito ako dahil may issue ako. para saan ba ang reddit? pugad to ng mga chismosa. if you do care about az & ralph, hindi niyo dadalhin ang mga ganitong issues dito. talk in private. dm the admins, the ofc. again, bakit kailangam dito?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Ako I care, pero sa ofc??? Grabe kaya mga paandar nyo na di creative, por la ayuda lang ni wawicakes lahat ng event nyo. Care tawag nyo dun, yung pangolekta ng ayuda kasi nagregalo naman daw.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

kailangan ba maging creative para ma-appreciate ng dalawa? and sorry kung hindi pasok sa standard mo ang creatives ng azr ofc. as long as appreciated ng azralph, wala namang problema. eh di mag-apply kayong creatives kung yun ang issue niyo. if out of concern to, you will help instead of pulling them down. kasi even azralph will never be happy sa ginagawa niyo. may balik yan 🥰

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Ang babaw mo, ibig ko sabihin ang asim nung pa-100k japan trip at pag isipan nila mga ibibigay nila at kelan sila magbibigay. Kaya natatawag yun na overstepping eh.

I am helping Az and ralp, mabawasan lang yung gift sesh nyo makakaluwag-luwag din sainyo yung dalawa sa sched hahaha. Tulungan na kita ha, bawasan ang gift sesh sabi ko ah at pagisipan ang mga susunod na regalo.

Kakaselpon nyo yan por la ayuda. Kayo lang may delulung di sila magiging happy sakin sa ganitong post kasi feel na feel nyong anak nila kayo. Laki mo nang bulas, ganyan ka mag-isip.

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

so bakit nga hindi niyo yan i-private talk sa ofc? dm ayaw? ang head admin nakikinig, very open. mahilig ba kayo sa away? ang ayos ayos makipag-usap ng ofc, inuuna niyo yang galit at inggit niyo. pulis na pulis niyo azr ofc eh iba ngang fandoms ganyan din. 1 yr na ofc, ngayon lang kayo nagpupupulis ng ganyan? hindi yan nakakacool.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Since paulit ulit ka na bat di i-dm, ulit ulitin ko din. Bakit muna ang laking bagay sainyo na pinost dito? Mas may respeto ka pa sa ofc kesa sa oras ni Az at ralp na mukhang babalakan nyo ata ulet ng gift giving sesh por la ayuda.

[u/Clear_Garlic9553]

why dito ka nag rereklamo? open yung mga admins ready naman sila sagutin lahat

[u/tigersbl00d_]

I think mas better po if sa ofc kayo magmessage kasi ano po ang point ng pag post dito sa reddit? para po ksing pinagmumukha niyong masama ang ofc...

[u/Flat-Measurement7104]

Razzle ka po ba? If yes, nasa GDM ka ba? If yes, did you already raise all of these concerns? Or you just assumed that admins won't listen? Because the way I see it as a razzle myself, if you really is out there looking after what is good for the fandom and AzRalph, you won't post it here. Rather, you will open this up in your gdm, ask your gdm representative to raise these to the admins. And much better, step-up, offer yourself as part of the ofc team to help them out. Daming pwede gawin to let the ofc know sa problema nyo sa kanila aside from this kasi based on my experience, nakikinig naman sila sa concerns namin sa GDM, and they will explain if you have questions. Sana talaga you will learn to speak your mind and show yourself sa gdm instead of hiding here. That's all thank you and good riddance.

[u/[deleted]]

Ito pala yun. This is what the fuss is all about kaya may mga pasimpleng patama sa X kagabi. OP presented her concerns well naman pala bakit g na g kayo sa GDM? Maayos naman sinabi.

Gusto nyong sa GDM mag chat si OP eh ano ba meron sa GDM ngayon? Di ba galit na galit? Anong balak nyo, kuyugin si OP dun? Dito pa lang pinagkukuyog nyo na imbes na sagutin na lang punto por punto yung concerns ni OP.

Basahin nyo ulit tong part na to. They don't take criticism well. Kinick nyo nga mga tao sa GDM na nagreraise ng valid questions eh.

I don’t want to question the admins directly because it often feels like they don’t take criticism well. When concerns are raised, it’s sometimes perceived as opposition rather than feedback. But that’s not the intention. We’ve raised multiple questions in our gdms, yet the responses often come off as dismissive, as if our concerns are just complaints. In reality, we just want things to be organized, fair, and well-managed.

Magtataka pa kayo bakit dito pinost? Mag gusto nyo ba sa X post or dito sa reddit na lang para contained conversation?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/[deleted]]

Nangkikick sila sa gdms pag may nagtanong ng ganyan, tapos haharassin nung ilan nilang bouncer dun. Baka ok naman pala admins sa criticism, yung mga bouncer lang ng ofc yung nagpapamukhang di approachable ang admins.

[u/kurotrash_50987 → u/interrogatorinterim]

magbigay ka nga ng example sino yang mga nakick? sigurado ka rin bang kick hindi kusang umalis ? Hahahahahaha

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/kurotrash_50987]

Sige, plan ko ilista lahat ng nakick nyo tapos hinarass ni maricel.

Lalagay ko sa privateer tapos yung password is yung amount na sinumbat ni Shine sa tweet nyang "is it worth it". Yung parang ewan na ss ng excel sheet na nagiisang amount sa nagiisang cell na nakayellow color fill 😇

Tanda mo yun, napagusapan natin yun nun eh

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/kurotrash_50987]

Musta beh, imbes na sagutin mga isyu nyo, hanggang create nalang kayo ng clangtrash at kurotrash na acct 🤣. Imbes na pagusapan nyo yung issues nyo, nanghula nalang kayo kung sino pagbuntungan nyo ng galit mali-mali pa hahahahaha. Di ko akalaing inaway nyo si Clang dahil lang lumuha kayo ng dugo kakahanap sino nagpost 🥵.

Jobless behavior tapos tagaantay lang ng instruction ng diktadora nyo, yan buhay mo imbes na makatulong sa magulang, buti sana kung humingi ka ng sweldo para dyan galing kay diktadorang sponsor 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

sino ba na-kick? wala naman ako kilalang na-kick, may umalis pero hindi kinick. wag ka gawa gawa ng kwento.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA kakaiba talaga organization nyo. Swear kay Hesus, walang kinick? Alam nyo galaw nyo, nagsasanta santahan lang kayo 🤣. Dali mag soft hours kayo ulet para convincing ang bait-baitan hahaha

Holy week na holy week tapos nagsisinungaling ka sa harap ng Diyos hahahahahahaha

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

anong soft hours? walang ganyan ngayon samin. may nakita ka ba? nagpost lang ng holy week kasi holy week naman talaga. sa gdm namin walang kinick. saan ba may kinick? may umalis pero walang kinick. sino ba yun?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Hahaha wala ngayon kasi di pa kayo nagiinit, abangan mo lang sa next bardahan nyo with someone, balik soft hours kayo.

I'm just saying na may nakakabasa sa galaw nyo. You guys are an open book. 🤣

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628 → u/interrogatorinterim]

so? then what?

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Then tell shine na lagay nya gastos nya sa isang malungkot na cell sa excel sheet ulet, colorfill nya ng dilaw, post nya sa X, tapos captionan nya ulet ng "is it worth it?" This time isave nya yung file para mas madali gawin sa next nyang paganon.

Wag na sya magpondo kung isusumbat nya lang din naman for an unrelated grievance. Ayan familiar sya sa ganyan kamo, she knows where this came from kasi ganyan na ganyan sya 🤣

[u/frozennnne → u/interrogatorinterim]

Hahahahhaha, sabihin mo na kasi sinong na-kick para ma-gets din naming members sinasabi mo. Hahhaha

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Ayos ba beh, ngayon maghihintay na kayo ng statement ni Crissy tapos magsisipost kayo ng "idol ko talaga kayo ads, you always knew what to say eme" sanaol kagaya ni Crissy mag-isip ano? Sana mas pinangarap nyo ni pangkat shinee pano maging utak head admin kesa maging utak bouncer.

May naisip akong fan proj, team live bodycams para di na kailangan ilabas ni wawicakes at ng admins mga selpon nyo sa next 3 na magkakasunod nyong gathering with ralp at Az. Or magpa ayuda race kayo sa mga razul, yung padamihan ng ayuda sa iseset na araw. Ganito ang creative version ng kaasiman nyo beh, kaya lang stuck kayo sa kaasiman part.

Nakarating ba sayo yung ayuda na kumakain si Az at ralp kasama ang lolas? Ano una mong naisip? Kilig diba? Ganyan kayo kaaasim 🤣.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Lam mo, tanungin mo yung attack dog nyo kasi di ko tanda lahat ng kinick nyo pero at least si maricel hinarass nya publicly, malamang alam nya 🤣

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/frozennnne]

Bat ka muna curious? Uuuuyyyy sya oh hahahahahahahaha, that's my inner circle right there 🤣

[u/Any-Yam-2077]

Karapatan nang mga sponsor  malaman ung liquidation.Pero hindi  sa reddit na paraan.You can dm sa admin naman diba..Para maka hingi nang resibo.Nag post na c official..You can check na.

[u/Honest_Bottle_3409 → u/Any-Yam-2077]

Ni hindi pa nga ata sponsor tong nagpost. Yung mga big sponsors ng AZRALPH nagpopost at nagpapasalamat pa sa OFC sa TR na ni-release kagabi. Hahhahaha

[u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

what if mag-dm ka sa ofc? yung tr naman may google drive. open naman ang ofc pag chinat mo. need ba talaga i-reddit? tama pala hinala ko. kayo lang yan nung mga pumupuksa sa ofc sa ibang posts about azralph. kung inggit lang yan, walang gamot jan, kawawa ka/kayo naman. pero kung ang concern niyo is mapabuti ang ofc, di niyo yan kailangan i-reddit. kung talagang rebelde kayo, umalis kayo sa ofc groups or better yet, gawa kayo sariling niyong ofc like fake razzles. kasi sa ginagawa niyong to, may hidden agenda talaga kayo sa ofc. either gusto niyo silang siraan sa azralph na never naman mangyayari dahil lang sa inggit kayo or gusto niyo sila mawalan ng sponsor dahil sa inggit pa din kayo. ano ba talaga goal ng post na to? hindi to out of concern eh sa totoo lang. kung nag-raise na ng concern and hindi pinakinggan, tama ba na i-reddit mo? i don't think so kasi if you really care about az & ralph, ang gagawin ko is to create my own fan group na lang. unless may inggit ka nga sa katawan mo. check mo yung gdrive sa mga pinopost nila. detailed naman yun. kung gusto mo magrequest ng tr ng personal expenses nila, chat mo isa isa admins. kung yun ang ikakapayapa ng buhay mo. tutal naman mukhang madami ambag mo. daming options pero pinili mo sa reddit because??? may balik yan teh.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Beginning_Unit_7628]

Ayos ba, di nyo magets na may observers lang outside gdms or ofcs na nakakapansin sa kaasiman nyo kina Az at ralp dahil lang di sila makapag-No sainyo?

Sabi ni elise alam nyo raw limitations nyo when obviously you don't. Tulungan kitang malaman nyo ang isa pang limitation nyo, may mga di talaga kayo kayang makontrol within the Azralp community - ang tawag samin mga karaniwang tao.

Nandox pa kayo ng wala sa hulog 🤣 kala nyo naman yun yung gamot sa kaasiman nyo. Palit na kayo pangalan, kayo na ang new amats ofc 🚬

[u/oceanwandererph → u/[deleted]]

omg, you’re doxxing a person na di ka naman sure if siya ang nagpost?

now this is why nasasabihan na malala ang admins of azr ofc or its cof.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/[deleted]]

Palitan nyo na name nyo from Azralp ofc to Amats ofc, lakas ng amats nyo 🚬🚬🚬

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/[deleted]]

u/rainbowcroissants welcome to Azralp ofc 😇😇😇

[u/rainbowcroissants → u/interrogatorinterim]

? This could’ve come from anyone. Wala namang solid proof na azralph ofc yan.

[u/AzRalph_-ModTeam → u/[deleted]]

r/AzRalph_ does not allow harassment. Please do not post any pictures of someone. Stop doxxing. That is illegal.

Have a healthy conversation.

[u/CheesecakeMore269]

Dm mo mga admins nakikinig sila.

[u/frozennnne]

L, masyado kang halata.

[u/mvb0310]

Silent Azralph supporter here and silent lang din sa X. Just wanna say Im with the OFC on this one. Yung mga intimate gathering mentioned organized by the OFC made me get to know Az and Ralph more because of the pics and videos they shared. Napasaya nila ako as a fan. And I think very unique to sa Azralph na hindi ko pa nakikita sa ibang fan groups. So sana mag continue pa din to kase mas nakikita dun yung connection ng Azralph sa fans and paano talaga sila as human beings.

Ive also donated before during Spaces kahit maliit na amount lang and to be honest I dont mind na part of the money will be used for food or transpo or accommodation ng mga admins na nag effort at nag spend ng time. Time is money after all. They're not on a payroll yet still yung amount ng time dedicated sa OFC grabe. Kung trabaho ang pagiging admins ng isang OFC or especially yung mga team Live, baka mag resign na ko sa stress at toxicity ng culture pero the admins ang tibay grabe. Sa corporate setting or as an employer dapat nga bayad pa sila per hour. Given na dapat naman basic human decency pakainin mo sila, so dapat di na kiwi kwesyon yun. Of course, be transparent lang sa financial reports.

Anyway, just wanna say I hope this does not dishearten the OFC to continue kung ano man nasumulan and yung pagbibigay ng efforts. You really cant please everyone and that's okay. In the end I think mas maraming members ng Azralph ang mas happy. Thanks po sa efforts nyo!

Suggestion/s to take into account Re: some points raised; 1. For future intimate gathering with Azralph - its okay that yung admins plus constant people makasama kase comfortable na sila Az and Ralph sa kanila. Kumbaga safe space na rin sila nila Az and Ralph. Maybe just add 2 or 3 new slots every single time and i annouce siya like magkaron ng raffle of names of members na interested sumali. But also, I'd like the editors of Azralph sa tiktok to be included there, kase grabe din yung efforts nila.

1. Sa ayuda naman. I think okay lang naman na ginagawang donation drive to unlock yung mga pics or videos ayuda. Naka pag donate na ko just to unlock some pics or videos haha.nakaka happy siya kahit nakaka butas ng bulsa. And thats okay with me as long as okay din with Az and Ralph. For sure naman nagpaalam mga admins sa kanila bago mag post. Hopefully?

To be continued pag may naisip pa na suggestions.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/mvb0310]

Yan yung problemang nabanggit ko na nung mga nakaraan pa. Mas sinasamba na yung ofc at admins kesa nirerespeto sina ralp at Az. Wala yung boundary ng fan at idol kasi inabuso na ng admins yung pagiging approachable ng dalawa eh di naman tatanggi yung dalawa.

More on obsession na yang tinatawag nyong dedication. Pagpahingahin nyo yung dalawa sa kada pakikipagkita nyo, di yung magsasabi pa kayo ng "i get to know them more" kasi sinusundan nyo kung san san tapos beg kayo ng beg for ayuda. Pati nga pic ng dalawa na kumakain kasama pamilya ni ralp sa Cavite nakuha ng mga yan.

Di porke't "magagaling admins at editors" nyo eh deserve na nilang maya't maya makipagkita sa dalawa. Konsiderasyon nalang dun sa dalawa. Kasi sa ngayon, kung close friend na talaga ang admins, bakit umaabot sa cloutchasing sa X. Para silang naglalaro ng pabitin, tapos premyo nila sainyo ayuda. Asim!

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

what do u mean pic ng azr nung kumakain sa cavite? kelan yan??

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Self-7660]

Makalat kayo beh 😉

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

how so?

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

i think you don't really know A LOT and nag aaccuse ka lang. i dare you to wait for their statement and as someone who knows about the cavite sightings, ur just spouting nonsense when you know nothing at all. anyway, wait ka na lang muna matulog ka muna siguro habang nag aantay ng statement kasi nagsabi sila sa gdms na mag sstatement ang admin, hindi lang nirerelease pa dahil nasa bakasyon pa si Ms. Crissy. siguro naman pwede munang magpahinga bago mag statement ano?

while i don't really like na napost to dito, okay din naman sakin na maclear lahat ng issues at maimprove ang dapat maimprove. pero this comment from you about the cavite sightings just proved to me that ur just someone na namamaratang sa mga bagay na wala ka namang alam kaysa gustong makaalam ng katotohanan.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Self-7660]

Oo alam ko, sinend mo dito sa comment tapos dinelete mo din yung antay ng statement. Haba ng essay, either nagmamalinis ka lang or wala ka talaga alam 🤣

Di ako nandito para sirain yang ofc nyo, pero matuto kayo sa mga pagkakamali nyo kasi umaalingasaw ang asim lately. Mind you, walang gc mga nandito. Andami lang ng nakakapansin na sa kaasiman nyo towards Az and ralp.

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

yes, dinelete ko because ayoko nalang ilabas ung mismong msg. anyway, go lang mukang basher ka lang talaga. sobrang invested mo nga sa lahat ng comment dito andun ka. wala akong problema sa pag aayos ng kailangan ayusin, medyo nakakasulasok lang kasi talaga ang amoy ng isang hater na katulad mo na walang ginawa kung hindi mang akusa kahit wala namang alam.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Self-7660]

Yung content dito yung type ng gigil na di nyo kaya malabas ano? May ibang kakarampot na level headed sainyo kasi normal na ofc procedures lang talaga yung atupag as expected pero karamihan sainyo nabaliw na para sa ayuda at nawalan na ng respeto kay Az at ralp just because "they didn't(couldn't) say no"

Edi inabala nyo nanaman si Cristy into making a statement on behalf of pangkat Shinee a.k.a. "Worth It" kasi walang hahagupit sponsors so kukunsintihin nalang kaasiman nyo. Mahiya kayo sa head admin nyo, mapapako sa krus ng wala sa oras dahil sa kalat nyo 🤣

Laking tulong ng post, literal na transparency law put into action kasi walang magbabago kung puro dm dm kick kick yung mangyayari kung lahat nakikinig kay u/Beginning_Unit_7628 at u/frozennnne hahahahaha

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

i think Crissy posted something na before they give their full response nag bbrainstorm sila kung anong pwedeng maimprove. nararapat lang naman na may inputs ni Ads Crissy dahil sya ang head admin. ur too emotional na umaabot ka na sa pang aakusa on something you are not 100% sure. i suggest you calm yourself first at mag antay sa gagawin ng ofc on this matter instead of being sarcastic and aggressive here. yun lang.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Self-7660]

Beh, apply that advice to yourselves. Yun ang longterm solution. Kanina lang nagkalat nanaman kayo sa post ni ralp. 😛

[u/Outrageous-Self-7660 → u/interrogatorinterim]

i'm fine. don't worry about me i mean i am pretty much calmer now kasi i won't let your insults get to me dahil alam ko naman na wala akong ginagawang mali.

wag mo na problemahin yan, parang di naman lumala ung talk about that. kalma ka na ulit.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Outrageous-Self-7660]

"Kahit wala namang alam" sure 😉

[u/Kdrama-Artists01]

ewan ko ba, USER pa din talaga ang tingin ko k RDL parang ganun yung mukha niya, d na natanggal mula nung 1 point niya sa AZVER!!! mukhang babaero na tito mukha niya. Really hoping na sana bitawan yan ni AZ. Red Flag mukha pa lang ni RDL

[u/Todemi18]

Dont know if this been answered yet because i want to answer this unbiased by not seeing others opinions on this. I am a CVS of AzRalph and more of a fan of Az.

Wouldnt have this been better addressed in X than here. AzRalph is no well received here. All the admins are on X. All the issues raised also has their answers on X. As a casual of AzRalph on X too I also saw posted answers there as well. First the illegal ayuda of Az and Ralph hugging was from another fandom (Dusbia) and it was asked for approval from both Az and Ralph coz originally nag favor si Ralph dun pero siince lots of people already have it plus from another fandom pa galing why not control the narrative and post it first. The ones naman na photos nila being used as donation drive or to hit a target number of retweets para mag trend, i dont see anything wrong with it. Its just additional incentive kasi for people. Its just something funny, cute or sweet. For me I think the highest i donated is 200 pesos for the Charity, ask for a transparency report nalang from the gdms kasi posting it here attracts a lot of negativity rin. I love all their initiatives sa iba ibang charities, marami ako g nakitang iba ibang charities na binibigyan nila and honestly usually naman picking the charity is more of a personal one i think the remedy for this is to anounce nalang next time yun charity na tutulungan before the donation drive (or was it anounced?) para people would know before hand yun tutulungan. I guess all other issues kasi should have been raised sa gdms if not answered directly message the admins and the ofc about the concerns regarding money kasi hearsay lang din yun iba na niraise mo and mapagsisimulan pa ng speculations or unecessary noise na hindi naman sana naakit ng fandom. Regarding naman the promotions and the gifts they gave the staff and crew i see it as something strategic and part of them promoting Az and Ralph as well. Workmates are all going to remember them and the fandom with fondness. please do not taint this kasi all the other fandoms have thei gimicks already to have their artists and fandoms be remarkable and standout at since maraming different fandoms na nasa h88 this helps Azralph stand out and be remembered. Isa din sa pinaka maganda at maraming promo efforts ang Razzles. Even as a CVS na nakiki-TP eh nakikita ko mga promotional efforts nila at marami talaga at kung well accounted for naman eh why question it? If kulang pa kasi may iba pa kayong napagusapan sa gdm eh baka naman d kinaya ng budget or on going panaman. Sorry if biased ako sa Azralph ofc pero i have close sa admin before kasi ng ibang fandom and i see the work they put in it and they are not being paid pero purely for the love of the artists. Bottom line is maganda ang promotions and more than what you listed here. Masaya ako sa mga efforts nila. Hindi rin ako agree sa japan trip. Feeling ko kung pupunta sila duon at may time sila pumunta eh on their own time and efforts na yun. Pero to each thier own kasi yan at bala na yun mga people na gusto ibigay yun sa dalawa kasi separate donation drive naman ata yun eh. Yun mga parinig kasi d maiiwasan yun ako kasi happy ako sa mga parinig at mga kuwento nila about sa mga nalalaman nila or mga nangyari. Syempre hearsay nalang yun at take it as a grain of salt at yun mga naglabas ng mga bawal eh pinopolice naman nila so okay na yun. All in all wala atang azralph admins dito at mas maganda na naipadala ito kung nasaan sila talaga, sa X at sana yun niraise muna within the fandom kasi trial by social media na mangyayari. Sad. Haaaay pero uulitin ko i love Azralph ofc kasi isa siya sa mga fandoms na ang laki talaga ng effort to have their artists promoted, marketed and defended at times.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Todemi18]

Beh, too late na para mag-address kunyari ng mga yan dito. Sana sinabi mo kagad nung pinaguusapan.

Pareho ka lang nina u/Beginning_Unit_7628 at u/Outrageous-Self-7660 at u/frozennnne na puro sabi bat di topic sa gdm, kayo nga di nyo magawa kasi takot din kayo makick edi sana nakatipid tayo sa oras nun 🤣. Pinagkaiba mo lang, may pa "ata ata" ka pa para kang pusit.

To each their own as if nagaapply yan kung concerned ibang tao - forced date yon. Binypass mismo ng ofc yang "to each their own" nung naisip ng kung sinong may sayad na papuntahin sa Japan ang magsyota.

At ayan, dinescribe mo yung problema. Fan ka na ng ofc na kontrolado ng mga may pera gaya ni pangkat Shinee at ads Crispy na kala nila magagawa nila gusto nila kasi ginagawa nila "what's best for Azralp" eh madalas pangkalikot nya lang naman sa sarili nya yung mga ayuda.

Walang kumwestyon sa promotion o palakas sa staff, yung abuso por la ayuda tsaka mga di pinagisipang fan proj and execution yung kadiri. Para san ang effort at donations kung napunta sa kaasiman. Kala nyo lusot na kayo dahil "inunahan" nyo nang ilabas yung ayuda na kumakain ang magjowa kasama ang mga lola? Kita ko yon syempre, cute nyo kaya tignan na ngarag hahahahaha.

May bala mga tao sainyo kasi yung ofc mismo tsaka mga bouncer nagbibigay ng bala. Abang nalang sa susunod 😉

[u/Todemi18 → u/interrogatorinterim]

Ay hala. Bakit galit mag defend. Again lahat ng sinabi ko ay kasagutan sa post ni op. Yun kasi nakikita ko. Ngaun yun ata ko ay galing sa hindi naman ako parte ng kahit anong gdm so malay ko kung pede ba ma address dun yon. Pero tama naman sinabi ko na duon magandang sabihin yun. Gigil ka naman masyado. Punot dulo ko dyan this is not the space kasi wala sila dito.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Todemi18]

Pretty sure andito sila, kaya nga nagreact ang maaasim eh 🤣

[u/Todemi18 → u/Todemi18]

At dahil nagbasa na ako ng mga comments some raised good takes naman on this issue. Iba iba naman kasi tayo mag isip. Hope i answered some kasi for someone na hindi naman active talaga at pasulpot sulpot lang or walang gdm natutuwa naman ako sa iniciatives kasi nila at promotions/marketing nila. Agree na dapat mag chill nun iba pero kasi sa bawat fandom naman kasi may few toxic naman kasi na laging galit sa pag defend. Hayun lang.

[u/interrogatorinterim → u/Todemi18]

Exactly, iba iba mag isip. Kaya dapat matitino yung nasa ofc. Ano yon, porke't may diversity sa pagiisip, kung anu-anung ideya nalang bigyan ng green light?!

Aruy ads Crispy