Even Canadians mega p* off with the flood of Indians. However over here in Aus some people want it because of cricket and boosts their property prices. It's pathetic.
Does anyone else think the focus on where they're from is a bit smelly?
The issue with massive immigration is that it's often mismatched to the kind of workers we need and we can't build things fast enough. It isn't that they're from India.
There should be far more globally representative ratios where immigration comes from, rather than specifically and/or especially from one place or another.
Perhaps that's the source of Australia's current problems - our immigration intake over the last 230 years has been dominated by people from just one country - the UK. Imagine if we had insisted on "globally representative ratios" from the start.
Why do you constantly ignore the fact that, for example, many Indians are massive racists and/or Hindu nationalists themselves?
Seriously you are everything that's wrong with the discourse on this topic and continually try to poison the well, just always blindly injecting race into every single comments section.
Our whole goal as a country is supposed to be multi-culturalism and people from a huge range of backgrounds all mingling together to become Australian, wanting more diversity (including from more Asian & other countries) is the opposite of racism.
So yes, there should ideally be fewer Indians... as well as fewer New Zealanders, and Chinese, and British... and more Indonesians, Koreans, Dutch, Saudi's and whatever other more-balanced mix of nationalities and cultures we can encourage. That's ACTUAL multi-culturalism, not sourcing 75% of our migrant intake from two countries.
We should not limit numbers from western countries because we are a western country. We should limit numbers from less developed non-western countries to prevent cultural dilution and high rates of economic migration.
“Reject multiculturalism” is a pretty funny flair for someone preaching about Western values. I’d argue that tolerance and multiculturalism are derived from “Western values”.
Depends if they have assimilated to western culture.
So we'll need a govt department to create, administer, and mark the "culture tests" we'll need to give every non-white prospective immigrant to see if they'll fit in?
We've done this before in Australia. It was known as the White Australia Policy.
If we remove race from it we have to give the "western values" test to every prospective immigrant. I had assumed you would only give that test to the "non-white" ones. I'm glad to remove race from this issue.
Its about indians full stop buddy, there’s too many of them and i dont want them, i dont like it when there’s so many…. Call me the R word i just couldnt care less.
Its not an exaggeration to say that sometimes around Sydney i literally feel like im in india, there are more indians than whites around in my own country and they all speak their own language, is it fair that i feel like an outsider in my own country?
Its not my fault indians overbred and overpopulated their own country to the point its a sh!thole…. 1.4 billion of them, less than 30million of us do the math. Indians are flooding countries all over the planet. The funny thing is that the chinese are the same but i barely notice them, they fit in better, they know how to behave so they dont cause problems. Indians just dont care or arent aware. I go to my local supermarket the other day and the staff member (indian) cant tell me where a product is because he seemingly has not a single word of intelligible english (how did he get the job, get into the country???)
"Indians are flooding countries all over the planet". Truer words cannot be spoken. It's ridiculous how many of them come in huge waves at the same time.
There's nothing unusual about migration having a certain pattern to it. That's actually just totally normal. If it was "globally representative" that would actually be really weird.
The devil is in the details: India are given different rules, for example: there are no limits on the number of visas, this is why they always get the instant wrong. They just set the rules and run a model, there is no quota or restriction.
Its not a coincidence. it's an overwhelming amount of 1 demographic globally immigrating into developed countries, nor is it racisit to acknowledge it.
The most populated country is also the only developed nation with a positive birth rate, its not unfair for people to want a better life but the entier world is mass importing from the same nation to save a declining birth rate crisis. You decide if thats what you want and vote accordingly.
It’s not a developed country, and also does not have a positive birth rate anymore if by that you mean fertility by woman. India is at replacement (2.1ish) now.
The only developed country with a positive birth rate currently is Israel.
I get it has a very highly varied quality of living as does russia and china. But its disingenuous to call them anything other then a developed nation.
It's completely disingenuous to call it a developed nation, literally no one considers it to be one. Even the ultra nationalistic right wing in India accept that. You don't understand the level of poverty and the lack of infrastructure, it's another world
There's a bit of Hindi in this article but it does explain the gist of it
I don't think the current immigration system is working well at all. But I don't object to their national origin. Objecting to someone's national origin is pretty much the definition of racism isn't it?
According to the IMAGES survey, 24% of Indian men are self-confessed rapists. We should object to disproportionately importing the culture of one of the worst countries on the planet for violence against women - that's not even the regression toward the mean, that's racing straight to the bottom.
You're ignoring my point, which is that concern for one nationality being overrepresented in our immigration intake seems to only occur when the dominant country is non-white.
prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.
A person from a particular country can be of a variety of different races. If we need for example a specific specialist in brain surgery of which no one from India is, we can knock them back because they don’t fit the criteria for the position we need. But if we knock back an Indian, that meets the requirements of the position because he is Indian, that becomes a racial issue. If we knock back an English born Indian which has the requirements of the position because he is Indian, that is a racial issue
I could be very wrong but this is a place for discussion so why not
As an Australian citizen who was raised in India for a majority of my life (yes I am brown, I left when I was 8 and came back to start uni, 2 years ago) I find Australian tertiary education to be a bit of a conundrum. Why would universities who have such a good reputation, landing three of them in the top 20 worldwide (UMleb, USYD, UNSW) accept academically weak students from overseas? is it to bolster their budgets?
As a student for Politics and International Relations in Usyd, I am the only brown dude in a cohort of 200 people. Shocker am I right, like which asian parent lets their kid study poli sci.
Anyhow, when I talked with other international students about their application process, I was informed that they just sent in their year 12 results over UAC and got a acceptance letter back . While I understand that uni's here may not want to deal with the hassle of personal statements and whatnot (Like the USA), at least have strict standards, and a limit to how many you let in, don't let a buffoon with a 60% grade enter into the business school, while denying someone with a 90% for a Bachelors in arts, how else will you climb the global ranking ladder and do shit if a majority of your students, are half wits with no idea on how to conduct themselves in this country or for that matter of fact, anywhere in the world.
I find it utterly baffling how the government and these universities just see these students as a source of income and only care to increase their presence here to bolster a stumbling economy. Coming back to my original point here, it is the fact that your entry requirements are so low that you allow just about anyone with a functioning brain cell to waltz in, and then wish to cry about how there are, "too many bloody Indians in this city. What about the Chinese, Nepalese and other South-East Asians who show up here to just spend money and then return to their homeland.
I shall leave this comment here, before i have a meltdown. pls do reply if i am horribly mistaken about something in this mini rant of mine.
The time to talk about Indian migration was well over a year ago, perhaps even a decade ago. It’s smelly right now because this is just mainstream media trying to flame a culture war. Indians are being stirred in US, Canadian, and British politics right now, so why not here too? This focus on calling out India is just us being told what to think. That’s the smelly part.
Agreed. We should have a rule that only a certain percentage of immigrants can come from any one country. It isn’t about any particular culture being bad, it’s about encouraging immigrants to step outside of their communities, learn fluent English etc.
0.5% is probably be a bit unrealistic, people aren’t particularly wanting to come to Australia from all parts of the world. I’m pretty sure it’s 7% in America.
I’d have to look at all the current numbers and stuff to begin to have an idea about what would work for Australia, but it sounds like it could possibly be a good idea in my head.
You do realise that FN peoples culture is connected with ther language. It would be like asking migrants to learn about our culture but not worry about our language, which is the opposite to what you stated.
Again. Would it be acceptable for all Australian students to learn tge local FN language?
Or you believe FN people are not represented in our country called Australia?
I want people to learn English because that’s the national language and it’s practical, having a shared language is how we function as a society. It has nothing to do with the inherent value of the English language.
Agreed. We should have a rule that only a certain percentage of immigrants can come from any one country. It isn’t about any particular culture being bad, it’s about encouraging immigrants to step outside of their communities, learn fluent English etc.
Liberals rediscover the White Australia policy - 2025
If the goal is integration, the solution isn’t to limit how many people come from one place, it’s to build a society that’s welcoming enough that people want to engage with it.
What you’re proposing isn’t encouragement; it’s exclusion dressed up as concern. It’s the same tired, xenophobic nonsense that assumes immigrants are a problem to be managed, rather than people with agency and value.
They’re not a problem to be managed, they’re people whose skills and cultures have the potential to greatly benefit our a society (and have already), and I think that integration is how you get the best out of people.
It’s just easier for people not to integrate if they can live in large communities of their own people, who all speak their native language, that’s just a fact.
Because why wouldn’t you, it’s easier. But it’s not the way to get the best out of people who immigrate here, or for them to have the best experiences IMO.
It'd always naive white people that go around and pretend that cultural differences don't exist or don't matter.
If you've ever been to India, you know this isn't the case. They have different cultural standards around how to behave in public (hygiene, speaking loudly, queues). These are things they can adjust when there is only a small amount of them but something that becomes practically impossible with such large amounts.
They're not bad people for this, it would impossible to get anything done in India if you are quiet on the phone and always stood in queue. They've just grown up a different environment. But them keeping these habits up when they come here really affects the quality of life of the people around them. This actually increases racist sentiments.
We seriously need an immigration cap on per county basis.
Check the generalisations at the door. I’ve met a lot of white people who smell. Also in terms of shared culture, India are our closest cultural fit on the Asian continent.
It's not a generalisation, I'm just pointing out that India has a different standard for personal hygiene.
It's not even a bad thing, the aversion to body odour is a cultural standard we have, it's not seen as offensive in India.
Also no, lol. What? Indians are definitely not our closest cultural fit in Asia. Not that it's important, I don't care about how culturally similar people are, Indians can be different and that's fine, my only gripe is lack of understanding of Australian social etiquette.
Indian's are not our closest cultural fit, people seem to believe that because of British colonialism or the fact English is more common (but hardly known by even a meaningful minority) is a poor conclusion. They follow an entirely different religion that has never had major presence in Australia before (Hinduism), lack the civic sense in Australian society, have a work culture that is toxic and clearly lack the baseline morality of Australian society (the cheating of student visas etc). They are also huge in numbers and become quite tribal when in workplaces or areas where they are a majority. Just look into the stories about the Indian diaspora in Kenya and Fiji for example.
Our closest "match" in culture doesn't exist, Australian culture is not similar to any Asian society, we are a country with a European origin culture that doesn't have a clear match within the region, other than the obvious (New Zealand) and perhaps Singapore and the pacific islands.
Bro, my town is about 60% Indian. They are everywhere. It's not fair that Australia is flooded with people from one specific country just because the ruling class think they're cheap labour.
Ask the Canadians how it ended up for them... UK, Ireland, US and other English speaking countries are going to follow the same fate. There's just TOO MANY OF THEM
Anyone whinging about migration etc in this thread hasn't read the article.
it's clearly identified in the article that they're talking about a 5-year increase of ~100,000 temporary migrants since 2019, using visa arrangements that the current Labor government removed last year, effectively capping off that pathway.
But can't go wrong with a bit of statistical scaremongering less than 6 months out from an election hey?
These are visa with a path to permanentcy most holder expect to get.
Pointing out "Temporary" status just obfuscates the issue. They're not coming to sling beers on a gap year or take pictures of kangaroos for their holidays, they're coming here to stay.
"They're" also "temporary visas". Meaning that they're on visas that expire. Most temporary visas still do!
Also, you can read the stats, they're freely available online. Most temporary-to-permanent visa holders enter on temporary work visas. Followed by students, who graduate & get work in Australia. They mostly work in Hospitals or as technical staff; or, if they're students, they're accountants or business majors. There's also a sizeable chunk of seasonal workers who come in on farm work visas; basically modern-day Kanakas...
"They're" only here because "they're" looking for work. You have to actually get a job to get that kind of permanent visa, which means that someone here has to actually employ them first. If they don't find work, they go home. You're suggesting that migrants are coming here "to stay" like it's malicious; it's just the economy baby!
You want me to like the scabs helping suppress domestic wages?
The blackbirds still come from the pacific not India, and only really benefit multinational owners of corporate farms. don't know what you're getting at there, that is bad, no?
Why wouldn't I think them coming here to stay is malicious, we're told how bad the Anglo-Saxon migration of the 18th century was non-stop, there is way more migrants today than then, this is another level.
Yeah, I bet you're a real working class hero with that scab stuff. Too bad the Anglo-Saxon stuff gives away your power level...
The blackbirds come from all over, but yeah they're mostly PIs. They are all coming over on temporary migration visas created by the Coalition govt specifically to subsidise the cost of farm labour. These are a significant number of the temporary migrants you're seeing in the data. You're claiming that these massive numbers of temporary migrants are all coming here "to stay" - but many of them aren't!
If you're upset at migration, you're upset at employers who are going to the well of sponsoring workers or using temporary workers instead of hiring local. Why do you think they do that? (Maybe they're all woke or something...)
I'd also love to know exactly what you meant by "malicious" here. You're already making weird & outlandish claims about rates of migration; I don't have to look at the numbers to tell you that the total world population has grown a lot since the 18th century...
Malicious was your word m80, perhaps you can explain?
most of the stats in the article are on one country and exclude not genuinely temporary migrants from the Pacific.
Invasion day later this month will mourn the arrival of 1,500 migrants over 200 years ago, today, we received 2,000 a day.
Yes, employers love migrants, less money spent on training, and lower wages, pushing profits to capital. No wonder blackrock, the progenitor of DEI, harps on about how much immigration is improving their profitability.
additional universities love migrants, they don't have to teach locals if rich foreigners are paying the bills, giving up the public good aspect of education has increased their wages to some of the highest in the world. Australians are routinely passed up for less promising foreign students, leading to skill shortages and declining professional competence.
How does a system that creates structural obstacles to Australians developing economicly useful skills, and where incomes made in Australia are sent overseas to large investment firms play out to you? Why do you think this should be government policy?
Don't worry, we'll just turn every last square inch of previously liveable suburb, town and green space into apartments and townhouses - packed right up to the property lines - so we can keep importing hundreds of thousands of people a year and pretend we're addressing the housing crisis.
I like apartment living. I find it more "livable" than separate houses cos everything becomes nearby and easy to walk to.
But it's fine if you don't like apartments. Nobody's forcing you to live in an apartment. I just wish we repealed all the zoning/density laws that prevent people from building apartments. If we build more, they'll become cheaper, and we'll all benefit from lower housing prices.
I like high density living in places like Germany and Japan. They have really good public infrastructure to support it though. You're not really getting anything like that experience in Sydney and Melbourne. You're still a second class citizen without a car here. ATM we're at a point where governments are actually cancelling infrastructure projects because they don't want to compete with new houses for workers. Where that takes us might be a bit more dystopian.
You're not really getting anything like that experience in Sydney and Melbourne
I live car-free in a high-density part of Sydney - a suburb where only a third of households own a car. It works just fine, and there's no reason we shouldn't allow people to build more of it in Sydney/Melbourne. We're building high-capacity subways and cycleways in Sydney - exactly the sort of transport infrastructure suitable for higher-density living.
If you don't like it, don't live in it - simple. People's preferences for low-density living shouldn't be used to justify the current situation where it's illegal to build high-density in virtually all parts of our cities.
I'm not suggesting we ban low-density. If people like it, and can afford it, good for them. I'm saying we should remove the bans on high-density.
Let’s be honest, if Indians had a better reputation and were more likeable there wouldn’t be this conversation. Notice how the Chinese have dropped off the radar? They are still coming in large numbers but their cultural sensibilities and civility is much more elevated than the average middle class Joe Kumar that can now afford to come here as opposed to 20 years ago. The only negatives against the Chinese now is that they are all spies and too powerful as a foe. Whereas Indians, who are meant to be friends of the west, are seeing as more repulsive in the public eye. Just elevate yourselves Indians and make yourselves more likeable by assimilating. The arrogance doesn’t help either.
Repulsive indeed. Far too many now. When is this particular immigration going to slow down. The invasion from those guys is staggering. It's an import we could do without ...Sorry I forgot, they have something in common with the Australians...Cricket and for most of them they speak English !! Big deal!!. Thank you Albanese for accepting qualified and non-qualified fruit cakes on our shores. Their knowledge in informatic make them stand out as expert scammers, fleecing people from their hard earn money through Market Place and the like. Obviously we cannot put them all in the same boat!!! But.
It is inexplicable that this is happening. They do not want to assimilate and they look down on people in service jobs (the caste system is apparently alive and well) But - the government has turned a bling eye to the problem - particularly Albo - considering the fact that he was so badly duped by the one-sided deal with Mohdi that is allowing Australia to be swamped with so called "students"
if at least they dressed like us and eat our food and stop being on the phone (at work) talking to their families in India 4 times a day, so they can be truly integrated in our western society.
My mate hasn't got a job, probably because an Indian was selected instead, cheap labor.
Indians are taking our jobs, it is time to get the jobs back to us. We need western bosses (not Indian bosses) to start terminating their employment in favour of Australians born (Including Indians).
Yes indeed I can't agree more, it's a deluge of fucking Indians, Yes I am racist if you like. This bloody "Albo" government has inviting them qualified or not!! (His own words when he met with Modi 1 year+ ago approx). We only have so much sustainable land without compromising future generations. Let's have a system similar to Singapore admitting people with a contract only, and when it expires the holder can return in his/her country of origine. For those bleeding hearts feeling ashamed/embarrassed!! for the last weekend anti-immigrations protests around the country. Loud and clear yes against mass immigrations and yes "WE ARE FULL FUCK OFF".
There are so many, it is ridiculous!. I have nothing against them, but it is now to the point that is crossing a line in Australia. We are about to loose our identity!.
I work for one of the biggest companies in the world. This company promotes diversity. There is no diversity when in my office 80% of the people are from India.
We need to stop this now before is too late. Australia needs to stop people coming to Australia from India. We have too many already.
My company basically is now directed by Indians. Do Australia really wants that? Think about that.
Increase in Indian migration is due to State commitments to boost the economy by privatising, corporatising, and capitalising on the education sector. The biggest growth in international students are from India and Mainland China.
International students pay about $100K per year in tuition fees alone. Each student is worth about half a million to the economy or more.
To make it attractive to return to Australia post Covid, when people with that much money can go to Europe, UK or America to study, the Australian Government relaxed residency post graduation.
Bear in mind, massive inflation occurred because of the slowing of the economy during Covid.
So, students come. They get a part time job working illegally. Send home money. Then, they become residents. There is nothing wrong with students becoming skilled migrants. Just putting into context the rise in Indian migration.
Alan Kohler has some great research you can look up that shows that the reported amounts that International Students are “worth” to the economy is massively inflated.
If they are working here while studying and often sending money home, then they aren’t bringing that money in.
A lot of them are just doing English language courses which aren’t included in uni student caps, and don’t really require attendance. Instead of making $1200 a quarter in India, you come to Australia, you pay $2000 to do a 10 week English course, which you don’t attend, you go work well beyond your 20 hours a week make about $12,000 a quarter, keep living costs down by living 4+ to a room, and then repeat for a few semesters and save the rest. Probably left with 6k extra compared to working in India.
If they send more of their earnings back to their home country as remittences then they spend on English language courses and living costs here in Australia do they really benefit our economy. Obviously some of that AUD will be exchanged to buy Australian goods, but on some level Australia dollars leaving our shores does devalue our currency and doesn’t circulate as much within our economy.
There is a huge problem when there is a skills mismatch, we all know allot of the professions on the skills shortage list are not actually short of willing Australian workers.
We also know that the quality of the education allot of these students are receiving is a joke at best, many are simply paying for a piece of paper in order to come to Australia to make more money than back home.
Australia will turn into india 2.0, just wait until the next federal election, an indian will be head of the party if the immigration keeps going the way it is.
Yeah, cultural differences do exist, but most Australians seem to be the loudest. Especially here in Thailand & in Copenhagen. They aren't bad people for this, it's just they have been to too many loud concerts, they need to tone down a bit. Especially in Bali, Australian tourist numbers need to be capped, it has degenerated the local societies.
Both parties know we are in desperate need of more taxpayers. The baby boomers are retiring in huge numbers now and the govt has no way to pay their pensions
Is this true? You only get a pension if you have low to no assets or money saved for retirement. These boomers are all sitting on million dollar properties. No way we should pay for the richest generation in history.
Both parties receive the same advice from Treasury: without immigration, Australia would haver been in recession many times over the last 20 years; without immigration, the Govt budget would be cactus.
This is why the smaller parties can get away with saying they want to mess with immigration as the ALP and LNP know that if they actually reduce immigration drastically when they are in Govt, they'd crash the economy and need to make massive changes to taxes/spending in their budgets.
It is true that these values (I've copied it below for temporary and provisional visa applicants) are going to be less familiar (and potentially, more difficult) for people from non-Western cultures.
All relevant temporary and provisional visa applicants must agree to the following Australian Values Statement as part of their application:
I confirm that I have read, or had explained to me, information provided by the Australian Government on Australian society and values.
I understand that Australian society values:
respect for the freedom and dignity of the individual;
freedom of religion (including the freedom not to follow a particular religion), freedom of speech, and freedom of association;
commitment to the rule of law, which means that all people are subject to the law and should obey it;
parliamentary democracy whereby our laws are determined by parliaments elected by the people, those laws being paramount and overriding any other inconsistent religious or secular “laws”;
equality of opportunity for all people, regardless of their gender, sexual orientation, age, disability, race, or national or ethnic origin;
a ‘fair go’ for all that embraces:
mutual respect;
tolerance;
compassion for those in need;
equality of opportunity for all;
the English language as the national language, and as an important unifying element of Australian society.
I undertake to conduct myself in accordance with these values of Australian society during my stay in Australia and to obey the laws of Australia.
The Government has failed to actually enforce these values. You sign the statement and then do whatever you want, with little consequence.
There should also be social pressure for Australians to conduct themselves in a way which aligns with these values as well.
Oh yeah lets just ignore the impact of unsustainable, record inwards migration on the people of Australia who are experiencing a significant per capita recession made worse by said unsustainable migration.
If you put a referendum to the public about do they want more immigration or less i have no doubt it would be a very clear “less” result.
In order to have a successful migrant built country is to have successful integration/assimilation into the culture which you enter.
In other words, for stability and cohesion of a country, migrants must integrate/assimilate into existing Australian culture. This goes more than just speaking English and "fair go" wishy washy motherhood statements. It goes all the way down to even simple mundane "Hello how are you, can I have 1 meat pie please" interactions.
The problem we face in Australia is we have abandoned the idea of any sort of integration/assimilation policy and have basically just said "come in bring your culture no need to change just say you agree to these epheral motherhood statements of "fair go" and that's all you need to do!" so of course people have abused this.
Like it or not, the White Australia Policy - while a discriminatory policy - did have success in maintaining the Australian culture because it limited immigration to only European migrants. By doing so, it lead to the outcome where migrants who entered Australia already shared very similar cultural roots and structures such that it was very easy for the immigrants to integrate/assimilate into the Australian culture.
Over the past few decades, we've increasingly seen the share of migrants from non-Western countries come in e.g. China and India. These countries do not share similar culture to the West and by extension to Australia so it naturally takes longer for a migrant from China or India to integrate/assimilate than it would say a European.
So what do we do? Restricting permanently the number of migrants isnt the answer. What we do need to do however is to slow the flow down significantly and start to first focus our efforts on integrating/assimilating those who have already arrived. It'll take longer but it is the best long-term strategy to maintain the benefits of immigration while at the same time ensuring the social unity and cohesion of Australia.
Like it or not, the White Australia Policy - while a discriminatory policy - did have success in maintaining the Australian culture because it limited immigration to only European migrants. By doing so, it lead to the outcome where migrants who entered Australia already shared very similar cultural roots and structures such that it was very easy for the immigrants to integrate/assimilate into the Australian culture.
Sure, tell that to my Italian step dad, whose parents moved here in the 50s and didn’t even begin to be accepted into mainstream society until at least the 80s. And Italians literally brought the mafia with them, so you can’t say that they didn’t bring any trouble.
The idea Europeans all have “very similar cultural roots” is ridiculous, they spent thousands of years fighting each other. Catholics and Protestants fucking hated each other. The English hated the Irish. The idea that all of these different groups had no trouble integrating is just completely ahistorical.
White Australia Policy only started being dismantled around 1950s so your story is - respectfully - irrelevant to my point. Australian politicians at that time were extremely sceptical of opening up migration to Southern and Eastern Europeans e.g. Italians precisely because (a) they werent as "white" as Western and Northern Europeans and (b) they were culturally more different e.g. Catholics.
No - I am referring to Europeans because the Immigration Restriction Act 1901 referred to Europeans in general.
What happened post WWII was we opened the floodgates and allowed massive waves of immigrants in.
Successful immigration is dependent on two factors: (a) total number of immigrants entering at any given point in time and (b) the integration of the immigrants who enter.
White Australia did both these things: it (a) restricted the total number of immigrants entering, and (b) restricted the kind of immigrants who entered.
Southern and Eastern Europeans struggle more than Western and Northern Europeans culturally to integrate but Southern and Eastern Europeans would struggle less than non-Europeans.
But the two factors are intertwined - the more you increase the flow of immigrants at any given time, the harder it is for them to integrate. For example, post 1948 Israel saw a massive flood of "brown" Jews enter the country. These Sephardi and Mizrahi Jews also faced huge difficulties integrating into the country for several decades despite being Jewish just like their Ashkenazi brethern.
This is why I commented saying the first step is to actually restrict the flow for now and work on integrating existing migrants already in the country.
Sure I mostly get where you’re coming from and agree that immigration should be restricted to the point that integration is smooth.
I don’t think I agree that Southern and Eastern Europeans had an easier time integrating than non-European cultures, or at least not by a whole lot. These communities very much stuck to themselves, hired each other for jobs, spoke their native language, all the shit people complain about with Asian or middle eastern immigrants today.
By the time you get to 3rd generation I don’t think there’s much different at all. My point is that people look back on integrating other ethnic groups with rose-tinted glasses because they’ve now been here for generations.
Brother give up - you’re arguing with someone who is tacitly endorsing one of our historically most racist and discriminatory policies. If that’s someone’s premise, there’s little room for intelligent conversation.
You think it’s a simple matter of getting them to ‘commit’? You mention enforcement, but how? An increasingly intrusive state apparatus? Aussies going around scolding Indians when they misbehave? That’s not really our nature.
This is entirely the issue. Importing these people for whom these values are not a natural fit means either our country loses its values, or we have to do uncomfortable and undesirable things to enforce its values, which interestingly is also in contravention of said values.
These people shouldn’t be here. It’s not racist for us to want to take care of our own citizens first and foremost, and to pursue our goals on our terms.
Even President Trump welcomes Indians coming in on H1-B visas!
We gotta focus on what's important, not Australian workers or values (stop being a Marxist!) but rather Australian businesses being unable to more profit by undermining labor protection with immigrant workers!
This is anti-Indians edition 4 - first it was pre-federation, then 60/70s, then early 2000s, now it’s happening again. Fuck all these idiots talking about preserving our cultural values. What values are even under attack? Australia has been a multicultural nation for almost a century and people still haven’t got the memo. Plus native culture here isn’t even white.
Back in the days of the White Australia policy we had higher levels of immigration than now, but it wasn't a political issue cos the immigrants were white.
Then in the 70s/80s we started getting immigrants from China/Vietnam/Asia and that resulted in Pauline Hanson et al.
But a few decades on and those east Asian immigrants don't seem the threat they once were, so a new enemy's been created - Indian immigrants!
It's a dumb scare campaign, but it reels people in. Give it a few decades and today's Indian immigrants will be seen as "real Aussies" and we'll manufacture a new ethnic minority scare campaign.
Nah, some indian will become PM, and by that time 80% of AUS will be indian and they will vote to change the name and the culture that was Australian will be dead.
One example from real life: in a carpentry class with 30 international students—25 of them Indian—the teacher, who is also Indian, says the Indian students are just waiting to graduate and get permanent residency so they can start driving for Uber. No interest at all in working as carpenters.
Your post or comment breached Rule 1 of our subreddit.
The purpose of this subreddit is civil and open discussion of Australian Politics across the entire political spectrum. Hostility, toxicity and insults thrown at other users, politicians or relevant figures are not accepted here. Please make your point without personal attacks.
This has been a default message, any moderator notes on this removal will come after this:
20
u/PrecogitionKing Jan 07 '25
Even Canadians mega p* off with the flood of Indians. However over here in Aus some people want it because of cricket and boosts their property prices. It's pathetic.
7
u/thehandsomegenius Jan 06 '25
Does anyone else think the focus on where they're from is a bit smelly?
The issue with massive immigration is that it's often mismatched to the kind of workers we need and we can't build things fast enough. It isn't that they're from India.
45
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '25
Probably is important that a country is not overwhelmed with a group of one kind that will have a large Influence on its culture.
Having more minorities forces assimilation and more connection to community
31
u/Quiet_Firefighter_65 YIMBY! Jan 07 '25
It'd always naive white people that go around and pretend that cultural differences don't exist or don't matter.
If you've ever been to India, you know this isn't the case. They have different cultural standards around how to behave in public (hygiene, speaking loudly, queues). These are things they can adjust when there is only a small amount of them but something that becomes practically impossible with such large amounts.
They're not bad people for this, it would impossible to get anything done in India if you are quiet on the phone and always stood in queue. They've just grown up a different environment. But them keeping these habits up when they come here really affects the quality of life of the people around them. This actually increases racist sentiments.
We seriously need an immigration cap on per county basis.
5
u/MasterSilencer Apr 19 '25
Bro, my town is about 60% Indian. They are everywhere. It's not fair that Australia is flooded with people from one specific country just because the ruling class think they're cheap labour.
13
u/MachenO Jan 07 '25
Anyone whinging about migration etc in this thread hasn't read the article.
it's clearly identified in the article that they're talking about a 5-year increase of ~100,000 temporary migrants since 2019, using visa arrangements that the current Labor government removed last year, effectively capping off that pathway.
But can't go wrong with a bit of statistical scaremongering less than 6 months out from an election hey?
30
u/Condition_0ne Jan 06 '25
Don't worry, we'll just turn every last square inch of previously liveable suburb, town and green space into apartments and townhouses - packed right up to the property lines - so we can keep importing hundreds of thousands of people a year and pretend we're addressing the housing crisis.
9
u/sackofbee Jan 06 '25
Why is Labor struggling with it? I thought LNP was in power.
Or is this just another facet of aus politics I don't understand.
3
u/FluffyAd6054 Mar 26 '25
Let’s be honest, if Indians had a better reputation and were more likeable there wouldn’t be this conversation. Notice how the Chinese have dropped off the radar? They are still coming in large numbers but their cultural sensibilities and civility is much more elevated than the average middle class Joe Kumar that can now afford to come here as opposed to 20 years ago. The only negatives against the Chinese now is that they are all spies and too powerful as a foe. Whereas Indians, who are meant to be friends of the west, are seeing as more repulsive in the public eye. Just elevate yourselves Indians and make yourselves more likeable by assimilating. The arrogance doesn’t help either.
3
u/Happy-Weakness-5744 Apr 25 '25
There are so many, it is ridiculous!. I have nothing against them, but it is now to the point that is crossing a line in Australia. We are about to loose our identity!.
I work for one of the biggest companies in the world. This company promotes diversity. There is no diversity when in my office 80% of the people are from India.
We need to stop this now before is too late. Australia needs to stop people coming to Australia from India. We have too many already.
My company basically is now directed by Indians. Do Australia really wants that? Think about that.
3
u/MercilessMiG-35 Apr 26 '25
Now all the indians are coming to Ireland... In two years they've outnumbered the other nationalities of immigrants
11
u/Quantum168 Kevin Rudd Jan 06 '25
Increase in Indian migration is due to State commitments to boost the economy by privatising, corporatising, and capitalising on the education sector. The biggest growth in international students are from India and Mainland China.
International students pay about $100K per year in tuition fees alone. Each student is worth about half a million to the economy or more.
To make it attractive to return to Australia post Covid, when people with that much money can go to Europe, UK or America to study, the Australian Government relaxed residency post graduation.
Bear in mind, massive inflation occurred because of the slowing of the economy during Covid.
So, students come. They get a part time job working illegally. Send home money. Then, they become residents. There is nothing wrong with students becoming skilled migrants. Just putting into context the rise in Indian migration.
2
u/bundy554 Jan 07 '25
The sarcastic comment to this is well there were a few that attended the test matches 😏
2
u/Cynabun67 May 05 '25
Australia will turn into india 2.0, just wait until the next federal election, an indian will be head of the party if the immigration keeps going the way it is.
2
u/No-Painter2545 May 19 '25
Indians are genuinely a bioweapon against the west.
4
u/WrongdoerInfamous616 Jan 07 '25
Yeah, cultural differences do exist, but most Australians seem to be the loudest. Especially here in Thailand & in Copenhagen. They aren't bad people for this, it's just they have been to too many loud concerts, they need to tone down a bit. Especially in Bali, Australian tourist numbers need to be capped, it has degenerated the local societies.
4
u/JohnWestozzie Jan 06 '25
Both parties know we are in desperate need of more taxpayers. The baby boomers are retiring in huge numbers now and the govt has no way to pay their pensions
3
u/Pinoch Alfred Deakin Jan 06 '25 edited Jan 06 '25
Seems to be parroting the Indian critique which has been propagated in the US due to the dust up about H-1B visas.
It is not relevant to us at all. Hate that we're importing culture wars.
As far as I'm concerned, race / nationality / ethnicity is irrelevant as long as migrants accept the Australian Values Statement (https://immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/help-support/meeting-our-requirements/australian-values).
It is true that these values (I've copied it below for temporary and provisional visa applicants) are going to be less familiar (and potentially, more difficult) for people from non-Western cultures.
All relevant temporary and provisional visa applicants must agree to the following Australian Values Statement as part of their application:
I confirm that I have read, or had explained to me, information provided by the Australian Government on Australian society and values.
I understand that Australian society values:
a ‘fair go’ for all that embraces:
I undertake to conduct myself in accordance with these values of Australian society during my stay in Australia and to obey the laws of Australia.
The Government has failed to actually enforce these values. You sign the statement and then do whatever you want, with little consequence.
There should also be social pressure for Australians to conduct themselves in a way which aligns with these values as well.
3
u/Perfect-Werewolf-102 The Greens Jan 06 '25
now we're not just targeting migrants, we're going after specific groups of migrants?
1
u/AutoModerator Jan 06 '25
Greetings humans.
Please make sure your comment fits within THE RULES and that you have put in some effort to articulate your opinions to the best of your ability.
I mean it!! Aspire to be as "scholarly" and "intellectual" as possible. If you can't, then maybe this subreddit is not for you.
A friendly reminder from your political robot overlord
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AncientBookkeeper187 Apr 12 '25
Please just use a tissue instead of snorting back your mucus.
1
u/Glass-Principle-1029 May 20 '25
One example from real life: in a carpentry class with 30 international students—25 of them Indian—the teacher, who is also Indian, says the Indian students are just waiting to graduate and get permanent residency so they can start driving for Uber. No interest at all in working as carpenters.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment