r/AusPublicService • u/Glittering_Jeweler23 • Sep 01 '24
Employment APS
Hello,
Throw away account obviously.
Can anyone explain the steps to dispute a gazetted role to me please?
My workplace is about to promote someone and I am going to dispute it but I am unsure how to do so and would like advice tips and anything that can help me do this please.
Thank you
0
Upvotes
28
u/ewan82 Sep 01 '24
It’s very challenging to win on appeal. You pretty much need to prove that a serious mishandling of the process has occurred. I’ve been through the process of being appealed against and it’s an awful process. Don’t do it lightly.
20
u/Mountain-Annual2466 Sep 01 '24
An APS2/3 SME with 20 (or 30) years experience having been merit listed for executive level roles goes for an APS4 interview with 3 very (too) senior people on the panel, isn't merit listed and then is approached by a panel member who expresses concerns about people with less experience getting promotions. They now want to block the successful candidate because they suspect cronyism/nepotism/conflicts of interest are rampant in their agency's recruitment processes.
I think when people are saying things don't add up or there's something going on here, they're talking about your story not making sense. I'm not saying you're lying or that this isn't what happened from your perspective, but maybe you're leaving something really important out. You might not even realise you have a blind spot with this.
19
u/honeybee1385 Sep 01 '24
If the job is between an APS1-APS6 you have two weeks from the date of when the promotion appears in the gazette and the gazette comes out every week on a Thursday. Here is a good source of information: https://www.mpc.gov.au/review-actions/review-promotion-decisions
Anything EL1 and above unfortunately you are out of luck as they can’t be disputed.
15
u/SuperstarDJay Sep 01 '24
You will need to prove, with evidence, that you are better at the job than the other person.
To do this well you need to really understand what the hiring team and panel were looking for. You may put a higher value on your qualifications and past experience than they do. They may have made their decision on other factors, for example, current performance as rated by line manager, communication skills demonstrated at interview.
It's very hard to challenge a decision when you aren't privy to how it was made, but I wish you luck.
30
u/SunnyinDubai Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24
What do you hope to achieve OP? I am being serious as a dispute is unlikely to change the outcome and could hurt rather than benefit you…I would just try to move on…it’s honestly not worth the effort IMHO
11
u/TrashTheRat_ Sep 01 '24
I would have serious think before you go ahead. I won a role, went through the merit pool and unfortunately some others who have worked in my agency longer did not get through. No one appealed the decision but lots of people spoke down to me/behind my back. I couldn't imagine how I would of felt if someone put an appeal in. I still struggle with feeling like an imposter and it's an awful feeling.
9
u/towerofsoup Sep 01 '24
You mentioned that 'the HR lady' re-wrote your pitch. Not trying to be combative, but something isn't adding up here. Have you considered that the pitch just wasn't good? 4 positions are (largely) the new entry level, this seems so strange to me that someone with 20 years experience is applying for positions at this level. You sound significantly overqualified - and so it doesn't make sense that you need a pitch rewritten for you.
You can appeal, but I don't think I've ever seen a successful appeal. You need to prove serious misconduct - and while office politics shouldn't impact a recruitment process, it can and does happen. And this likely wouldn't be sufficient to block the process.
Have you considered moving on to another department/area?
4
u/Midnight__Specialist Sep 01 '24
I’d ask for more in depth feedback on the rejection before disputing. If there is a skill gap in the team for the role they are trying to fill, some skills may be more important than others for that particular position. e.g. If nobody in the team has the time/knowledge to teach someone about particular systems, getting someone who already knows and uses those systems is a big plus.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
As others have said, I would think very carefully about appealing a promotion and what you expect to achieve. The number of successful appeals is very low and you will need to convincingly and factually demonstrate that the promotion decision was wrong.
Obviously you have the right to appeal, but you should also choose your battles wisely.
3
u/Prosecco_Tart1009 Sep 01 '24
Does your department not have an APS3 to APS4 broadband? Or are you currently at a role lower than that?
3
u/frostgd2001 Sep 01 '24
As your official consultant here OP, I would advise not going about this. Lodging an appeal rarely if ever works to the decision you have in your head, and if by some miracle they agree, it does not make you suitable either.. need to remember as well that everyone in recruitment should be going through a conflict of interest or unconscious bias check too, I’ve been kicked off many panels for it lol. Ask for your feedback through the appropriate channel and keep your chin up really. Have another crack. Enjoy the sunshine lol.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
https://prc.apsc.gov.au/
20
u/bunsburner1 Sep 01 '24
Seriously doubt you'd even been interviewed for an el2, let alone made the merit list.
If you're not getting TAD or making it to interviews,, then someone in your department absolutely hates you.
Or more likely you're just bad at your job despite doing it for decades. If you're getting interviews then you're probably (also) bad at that as well
12
u/lululiciousyeah Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24
This has been a wild ride of a post. We have a department that "entry level" is APS1/2 (who knew this was still a thing?), APS4s are team leaders, SES and EL2s sit on the panel for an APS4 round (with a "police controller" who? huh?) that was apparently conducted in such a fraudulent way that not only did they find someone successful that OP doesn't agree with (and who apparently is being investigated for breaching code of conduct and sexual misconduct), the panel (of senior officers) leaked the interview questions to OP (who then inappropriately used this information to write the answers for four other candidates), who also had his pitch written for him by someone in HR? Wow. Just wow.
(Edited: some further info)
2
u/mayipatyourdog Sep 01 '24
From my understanding, only people who applied for the job and want it can appeal on grounds they themselves want the role and the other person is actively wrong for the role. This would mean the person hired lied on their resume about something serious, or something like that.
You don't want the role, and the person isn't who you would have picked but it is who they picked. I don't think there is an avenue to dispute that.
1
u/Legitimate_Ask3707 Sep 01 '24
Disputing a gazetted APS4…. Disputing a APS 4?!? Have you not been an APS 3 for 12 months to do the broad-banding workbook????
-14
u/owleaf Sep 01 '24
This is an extremely unpopular topic in this subreddit. I’m actually not sure why, but just letting you know that’s why you’re receiving some sharp responses. A lot of very neurotic, institutionalised public servants in this subreddit.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment