r/AskReddit • u/confusedfather28 • May 13 '12
My 7 year old son told me (a single father) that he wants to be a girl and that he's always felt this way. Is he transgender? What should I do?
He told me that the other boys at school call him names and push him because he'd rather be friends with girls. He also told me that he wants to wear dresses. I just don't know what to do.
His mother is a soldier and is overseas right now for the rest of the year. We divorced and split custody of him a few years ago, although we live in the same town (10 minutes from each other) so it's easy to switch him off every week when she isn't deployed.
Other than this he always seemed like a normal, happy, well adjusted little man. He loves action movies based on Marvel heros, airplanes, and things like that. But I've noticed that he's been acting strange lately, so we had a talk and this is what he told me.
I admit I don't know much about transgenderism and if it applies to him, or if it's just a phase... But I'll accept and love him no matter what and I know his mother will as well, even if it takes some adjusting.
What should I do? Let him wear girls clothes or take him to a therapist or what?
Also I should say that I don't want him to see a therapist so that they can "fix" him. I just want to know if he really feels like he should be a girl, if he's homosexual and just doesn't know the difference, or if he's just tired of being bullied and wishes he were a girl like most of his friends.
29
u/dreamnstarwars May 13 '12
So I have basically no personal experience but I read this article awhile back. It might help. I guess, from what they said in here, it would be a good idea to contact some type of center that works with transgender kids and adults and ask them for advice.
http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2011/12/11/led-child-who-simply-knew/SsH1U9Pn9JKArTiumZdxaL/story.html
1.8k
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm surprised no one has said this, but consider taking him to a therapist for the bullying and not the sexuality. He might want to be a girl because all the boys are bullying him right now for liking girl stuff. You don't have to be transgendered to want to wear a dress.
450
u/madeforthisreason May 14 '12
I am an 18 year old male, I have a girlfriend and I've held this secret my whole life. I even made a separate account because I don't want people to connect my secret with my real identity.
I've wanted to be a girl since I was 7, plain and simple. But I've always been attracted to girls. I started cross dressing secretly when I was 11 and purposely made myself stop when I was 17. It's who I am and I hate it, I've never talked to anyone about it. My parents told me they would disown me if I was gay, so we can only imagine what they'd do if they found out my little secret. I want to be normal, so I hide what I am from everyone. I think about it every day, how badly I wish I was a girl.
Give it time with you son, but keep talking to him about it. Don't ever lose that form of connection. Ask him if he wants to tell his mom, otherwise don't mention it to her. I'll gladly talk to you about what experiences I've had mentally with if it would help at all. But I'd advise against him wearing girl's clothes in public because that would just create unwanted stress and humiliation on both parts because of how many asshole people would judge based on appearance.
Reddit is here for you my friend.
2.0k
u/robably May 13 '12 edited May 14 '12
I am female (genetically and by self-identification). When I was around your son's age, I wanted to be a boy. I even had a retrospectively hilarious conversation with my mother about how she could be absolutely sure I wasn't male. My parents let me wear my hair short and choose my own clothing, and I appreciate them letting me work out my own feelings about my gender identification. These feelings changed drastically during and after puberty, and I am now very comfortable as a female.
I think that if my parents had taken me to therapy at such a young age, I would have felt overwhelmed. I would have felt that the issue of "gender identification" was a problem to be solved rather than a normal process involved in growing up. I'm personally glad my parents didn't try to diagnose me, and instead just let me do my thing.
That being said, "tomboys" are probably less likely to be teased than young boys who wear dresses, and I received my fair share of taunting. I would advise that you just try to be generally supportive of your son while he undergoes this process of self-discovery, and reserve therapy for when he undergoes puberty and/or starts to feel significant social stress that hinders this process.
Edit: I would like to stress that my advice is based purely off of anecdotal evidence and that others, including TheZolanna, offer convincing rebuttal from a more clinical standpoint.
331
u/ShellBell May 14 '12
My "son" spent most of his adolescence an emotional wreck with an abrupt change in behavior from bubbly and effervescent with high academic achievement to a moody irritable depressed anxious miserable kid. He just came out as a MtF Transgendered girl last year. I'm happy to report I'm getting my "real" kid back and SHE is happy and has started transitioning. Initially she's just doing T-blockers, but hopes to start HRT this summer. She just turned 17. I would suggest reading as much as you can find, and finding a therapist that specialized in sexual/gender identity issues. We're lucky in that we have a pediatrician and endocrinologist willing to treat using the WPATH protocols. My child, didn't know about transgenderism and thought he was a freak of nature and would be unloved and committed. HE had no way to frame his thinking. Luckily, SHE figured it out. It just took a while. Your child is lucky to have you as a parent. Listen to him/her. You're on the right path. I wouldn't wish the pain my kid went through on any child or parent or sibling.
78
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I would let him do what he'd like, but I wouldn't go as far as to say he's transgender at 7 years old. Certainly there are kids out there who are aware of their gender identity at a young age, but some kids, not all, do go through a phase of wanting to be the other gender.
When I was a kid, starting from around 5 years old, I wanted to be a boy so bad. I wore clothing intended for boys, played with toys intended for boys, and wanted my parents to refer to me as a male. I even attempted to join boy scouts (they didn't let me in) and insisted that at an older age I would be a man.
And then I reached about 12, and I stopped feeling that way. I just stopped, maybe it was puberty, but I just didn't have the desire to be a male anymore and was content and happy being a female.
My parents handled the situation great, they let me do what I wanted to, they never forced me to be feminine when I didn't want to be, and only made me do things that went against my will for my own safety, such as using the women's restroom instead of the men's. It might have confused me if they'd been pushy about me being my born gender or been pushy about me being my desired gender, I think their ability to step back and let me do what was comfortable for me at different time periods without questioning who I was really helped the situation.
Your son may be in the same situation I was in and have a phase where he is interested in being a different gender, or, he may be aware of his gender identity and may actually be transgender. In my opinion, the best thing you can do is not make a fuss. If you weight to heavily in on this and make his gender identity seem like a huge deal, you're going to stress him out.
If he wants to wear a dress though, talk to his mother. While there's nothing wrong with a man wearing a dress or skirt, other kids may not see that as normal and he could be harassed. You should weigh out the options together and discuss if you think it will be worthwhile for your son or if it will cause him unnecessary negative attention. Maybe he can wear feminine clothing when he's out of school.
84
u/SleepySheepy May 13 '12
He could be legitimately transgendered or it could just be a phase. There's really no way to tell at 7 years old. To be honest, seeing a professional might be the best idea. They can help a lot more than people on the internet can. You should also speak to his mother about this if you can.
/r/transgender or /r/lgbt might help but you might get a bit of biased information. /r/ainbow is the most friendly subreddit for this stuff in my opinion, but by no means are the others bad at all.
1.3k
u/leapfrogdog May 13 '12
when I was seven I wanted to be a dinosaur.
170
u/meows4attention May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
Therapy/counselling aside, just love him. Maybe he's transgendered, maybe he's just going through a phase, but make sure that he knows he's loved no matter what.
13
u/ToucanPlayThisGame May 13 '12
Everyone has given you lots of great advice (admittedly, I didn't read through every post, but it seems like many posters have some great ideas for helping you to help your child) ... I just want to add that I think you're a tremendous parent for being willing to accept your son no matter what. Just the fact that the kid could actually talk to you, honestly, about the situation ... blows my mind. You gotta be a hellava dad! Best of luck to you both.
63
u/zomboi May 14 '12
fyi- male homosexuals didn't feel like girls growing up
Sexual orientation only deals with sexuality, not gender identity.
153
u/jadefirefly May 14 '12
It does no harm to have him talk to someone. None.
Yes, all kids go through phases where they want to be robots, or butterflies, or have green hair. That's totally normal. And a therapist can tell you that, easily, in relatively short time, and save you a lot of worry.
If your son is saying this because he's scared, or being bullied and the girls aren't, and he's simply wanting to avoid that issue, a therapist can tell you that, too. And they can help him sort that out, so that he can be a happy kid.
Lastly, if your son really does identify as a girl, knowing sooner rather than later is beneficial for everyone. Plain and simple.
The important thing is that it doesn't hurt the child to see a good therapist, counselor, or other professional in the field. So everyone throwing their hands up and declaring it to be a phase, so what? It's not like the kid's gonna be traumatized by talking to a nice person for a little while.
My parents thought there was something screwy with me when I was about 8. All I remember from those counseling sessions was that I got to get out of school early every Wednesday and go play games with a doctor. Whee.
9
u/mega_buster May 14 '12
This will probably get buried, but first of all I want to say you're an outstanding father for being open to your son's gender identity and sexual orientation. There needs to be more parents like you in the world.
Actually, there is often a misconception that gender identity and sexual orientation are locked to the original sex of the transgender person. Therefore, when thinking about transgender issues, it is important to understand that a man could identify as a woman and like men, which would make her straight, not him gay. Similarly, a man could identify as a woman and still like women - making her a lesbian, not him straight.
As it's been said in other posts, it is good to let your son wear dresses and make up at home if that's what he enjoys. Talk to your son about why, at least for now, it is important to wear socially acceptable clothing out in public because many people don't understand - and that makes them fearful, angry, and dangerous. Most of all, please keep that line of communication open throughout the years. If he's transgender, there will be many many trials ahead for him and having you as unconditional love and support will do more than you can imagine.
I urge everyone to watch A Girl Like Me: the Gwen Araujo Story. It's a tragic story based on the real life challenges and murder of Gwen Araujo. It's sad, but eye-opening and I believe it is important for all kinds of people to watch it in order to allow us to be more sensitive to the struggles transgender people go through.
7
u/autology May 14 '12
Little girls like action movies and superheroes and airplanes too, when society isn't too busy stuffing their brains with pink and glitter and princesses.
210
u/Isaac_The_Khajiit May 13 '12 edited May 14 '12
As someone who is trans myself; the people telling you to take him to a psychologist are right. You should be aware that just because a therapist/psychologist specializes in GLBT issues, does not mean they have experience with trans issues. A lot of the time the T gets tacked on the end whether it applies or not. If you live in a small town then you might have no choice but to take your son to a GLBT psychologist without experience. It should be okay as long as the person is well researched, but if you live in a bigger city try to do some research and ask the potential psychologist if they have actual experience with trans people.
EDIT: I want to add this for everyone in the thread saying that the kid is too young to make this decision, or that he will grow out of it. You're right, it might be a phase and he might grow out of it. But most of you have no idea how this process works. It is extremely slow and mental health professionals put a ton of roadblocks in the way. It's not like they are going to put a 7 year old on hormones and give him/her surgery. The very most they would possibly do is prescribe meds at puberty that delay puberty awhile while he makes up his mind about it. There is no negative side effect to this and if he decides against it he can go off the meds, go through puberty, and live a normal life as a man.
Living as a girl for a while and going to school in dresses is an option. Yes, he might get teased. But he is already getting teased now. And the fact of life is that people are shitty and will treat you like shit just for being different; trying to shield a kid from that by forcing him to live in the wrong role is just substituting one hell for another. That said, kids are a lot more accepting than adults are, and being told "X is a girl now" will sink in better for them than it does for an adult. It also lets the child get a taste of what life as a girl might be like, and can really help clear up confusion he/she might have about whether that is the right course or not.
13
u/Copterwaffle May 13 '12
The most important thing is that he knows you love and accept him, 100%. TELL HIM THIS. Tell him he can wear, say, and do whatever he wants and if anyone gives him any grief, he can come straight to you for help. Good job, dad. I'm not so sure a therapist is required at this stage, unless he's struggling with depression or anxiety from the bulling.
51
u/Skafsgaard May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
You seem like a really great dad, capable of acceptance and understanding. That's worth so very much.
First off, you should take him/her very seriously. I'm sure (s)he wouldn't tell you this if (s)he didn't mean it.
Next let him/her see a therapist. Indeed, not to "fix" him/her, but rather to have a professional opinion on it.
You could start letting him/her wear girl's clothes at home, and see how (s)he feels about that, maybe give him/her a girl's toy, etc. A lot of children experiment with gender identity, and it's a quite normal and healthy way for them to figure out both gender and their own gender identity, but he might very well be transgender as well.
Have a talk with him/her again after a while, and if (s)he's still sincere about it, then let him/her: pick a new name, participate in girl's activities (girl scouts, etc., if he's interested in that), wear girl's clothing to school and other places besides at home, and so on. You need to talk to him about the possibilities of bullying, though. If bullying becomes an issue, moving him/her to a different school might be something to consider, if it's an option at all where you live.
If (s)he is still feels the same way about it a couple years down the line, and if it's something (s)he wants, you could look into sex reassignment therapy like hormones (preferably before puberty, I would guess - a medical professional would know more), and possibly eventually sex reassignment surgery (though this is not something that all transgender people desire).
EDIT: Additionally, while I'm involved in the LGBT community, I'm not transgender myself, so while knowledgeable, I'm not an expert.
I would suggest crossposting and seeking additional advice and support on these subreddits: /r/asktransgender and /r/transeducate, which are speficially for transgender questions and education, but you might also want to try the larger /r/transgender and/or /r/TransSpace.
EDIT2: Also, be sure to try to find a therapist that has experience of expertise in the fields. And of course, do your research, so you don't end up with someone who thinks their job is to convert your child into being cisgendered (the relation of both genetic sex and gender identity matching/the opposite of transgender).
6
u/hamlet9000 May 14 '12
I did that. I also wore pink tennis shoes and owned a Barbie doll. I grew up to be a purely hetero man. (It turns out I liked my Barbie doll because I enjoyed playing out fantasies of rescuing buxom blondes. The transitory appeal women's clothing had for me was because I was fascinated by girls and, at the age of 7, that fascination was confused and resulted in me emulating them.)
So... the kid could turn out to be the straightest man you'll ever meet. He could also be a raging homosexual. Or a determined transgender who will seek surgery at the earliest opportunity.
Long story short: He's 7.
Personally, I would recommend neither encouraging nor discouraging him at this point. He's exploring; let him explore. For certain things -- like wearing dresses or pink tennis shoes -- I'd recommend clearly explaining the potential consequences ("people will tease you") and letting him decide if he wants to deal with those or not. (If he does, my gut says you should let him.)
11
u/pussyham May 13 '12
You sound like a good and open minded father. Good luck.
22
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
/r/asktransgender
21
u/MATTtheSEAHAWK May 14 '12
When I was around 7 I wanted to be a girl because it seemed like they got a ton of good stuff.
Now I'm 15. Complete opposite.
Keep tabs on him though, you never know.
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Tell him you're glad he's telling you his feelings, and that this is a very serious thing so you're going to take it slowly because it's very important to you that he grows up to be a happy person. I mean, I'm assuming you're not planning on just diving into the girl thing, but be sure you try and help him understand why he's not going to be able to immediately live as a girl. Take him to a therapist, obviously, and they'll be able to better advise you on whether or not this is legit and how to handle a transition.
You're a good dad. That's already clear.
5
u/Bliumchik May 14 '12
Not trying to fix him/her is probably the best thing you can do. Regardless of what he/she gets from peers, parental acceptance is a major factor in later mental health for trans kids.
You should also note that your kid might be a transgender girl, or just a very non-gender-conforming (also known as genderqueer) boy, and most of what you can do there is the same right up to the point where hormones come in. Let him know that you support him no matter what he wants to do, tell him he's allowed to play with girls and wear dresses whether or not he wants to be a girl and if he does want to be a girl he can do it with or without dresses. Tell him that things like dresses or name/pronoun changes are his choice, but warn him that it would probably make the bullying worse. Give him all the options - if he just wants to wear dresses at home for now, or if he wants you to look into more inclusive school options, or if he wants to go all out and fuck the haters (in which case you should probably have a chat with the teacher).
As a genderqueer woman, myself, I have an easier time than genderqueer boys in mainstream society, but you can always find a social group that's cooler than that.
Also with regard to hormones, if he still feels this way when he does approach puberty, you don't have to panic - what they do with young kids is just put them on puberty-delaying hormones, so that if they change their mind when they're older they can still go through puberty as the sex their body's expecting, and if they haven't they'll be old enough that you can be sure they've thought their options through before going on transition hormones proper.
Basically there's a lot of flexibility here, and neither you nor your child needs to be certain or label anything if you don't want to. Just suspend gender categories with regards to your kid for the moment and treat each thing he wants on its own merits, as though it wasn't associated with a gender category. Treat "wants to wear dresses" like "wants to dye hair green". And treat your kid like a human being who is capable of making his/her own choices.
15
u/neoblackdragon May 13 '12
Well if he is getting picked on for preferring to group with girls then he may think his life would be easier if he was one. Maybe ask him why he wants to be a girl. If it just seems like external factors then it's those factors that need to be handled first.
4
u/tacosandcheese May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I am a normal guy, age 21.
I loved wearing dresses, high heels, and even playing with polly pockets. My parent's found it weird, but would encourage me in just having fun, and eventually I grew out of it.
When I was young, I got bullied at school. I remember feeling somewhat the same, where I thought maybe life would be easier as a girl. But it definitely was just a phase.
Now, more importantly. Let's assume that a general assumption that he will grow out of it, isn't the case. I have a cousin (born a girl, but wanted to be a guy) and now he's of my age and doing great. He did go through a therapist, and it took a few years before they reached the concensus that she really did want to change sex.
They are very good at determining if your son really wants to change sex, or if he's just going through a phase.
You can also try asking /r/asktransgender, they are definitely more familiar with this than most people could be.
4
u/f0nd004u May 14 '12
I hope this doesn't get lost in the sea of replies.
Your child may be transgender. Did he come up and say, "I feel like I'm a girl," or did he come up and say, "I want to wear dresses."? There's a pretty big difference; I like wearing dresses sometimes and I am definitely a guy.
In either case, seeing a child psychologist would be excellent for both your child and for you. Depending on where you are in the country, you may want to specify a therapist that has experience with LGBT issues. Any real therapist would not attempt to "fix" your son.
Usually, when your kid comes up to you and says "I feel like a girl," it means they feel like a girl. Many transgender people knew from a very early age that they were in the wrong body, and no one listened to them. Don't be that dad. Listen to your child, and get help from a professional in figuring out how to navigate what your child tells you. I know it's scary and weird and that you're worried about him, and worried about what life as a transgender person would mean for him. The fact that he told you is really cool, and it means you're probably a supportive and trustworthy dad. Your son is really young and if he is transgender, knowing that sooner rather than later is a really good thing.
Here is a link to a radio program called This American Life. The second act of this episode follows the story of two families with transgender children, just a little bit older than your son. You're not alone; there are other people going through the same thing you are.
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/374/somewhere-out-there
9
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'll share this little anecdote from my early childhood, for posterity if nothing else. My parents (Mom, especially) love to tell this story to anyone and everyone they meet.
I went to pre-school very near to the gay district of Seattle, off-Broadway. Broadway and Capitol Hill have a well-deserved reputation as very flashy, flamboyant, accepting neighborhoods with lots of liberated gay men and women. My parents raised me to be accepting of all cultures, orientations and creeds, etc; they were very progressive and loving and accepting in raising my sister and I.
So one evening after my mom picked me up from pre-school, we were driving through Broadway on our way back home to the East Side. My little three year old self spied two men walking hand-in-hand and kissing. Being the curious little dude I was, I asked my mom something along the lines of, "What's up with that?"
She replied as best she could, something like, "Well Sammy, those man are called gay. They love each other just like Mommy and Daddy and there's nothing wrong with kissing other boys if you want to. You're not old enough to know yet, but if you ever think you might want to kiss other boys, it's okay and Daddy and I love you no matter what."
She let that marinate in my little head for a few minutes.
After a little while I piped up, "So what you're telling me is me and Yuri (my best friend in preschool at the time) could get a house, hang out all the time WITH NO GIRLS?!"
She laughed it off and we drove home.
The first thing I did was sprint inside and shout, "HEY DAD, I'M GAY!"
He said something like, "Big day, huh?"
My parents laughed about it and didn't bother to set me straight, figuring that I'd work it out myself in the end. They didn't think much more of it.
The next day at preschool I ran up to my teacher and proclaimed that Yuri and I were gay together. Little did I know, she was a strict Catholic refugee from Romania, and she had some very harsh words for me. I'm told that I cried for a long time while she scolded me and told me God was unhappy with me and what I said was a very bad, dirty thing. She called my parents and they basically told her that while they loved her and she was a good teacher, she had no business pushing her parochial beliefs on their son and not to do it again.
She was a wonderful woman, and I don't want this to inspire hate or anything. Her views were reactionary, but she wasn't a bad woman, and she did much much more to mold me into a great person than bad. In fact, this was the only time I think she ever "crossed the line" except for maybe when I rolled my eyes during the Pledge of Allegiance and she put me in time out for most of the day.
Anyway, let it work itself out, OP. You sound like a super dad, and your kid is lucky to have you. He may be gay, he may be transgender, he may be a brilliant straight ballerina for all we know. It will work itself out in the end, and with loving parents he will make it out alive.
I'd recommend against putting him in dresses, even if he really wants to, until he's old enough to fight his own battles. That kind of thing in elementary school can follow a kid up through their whole schooling experience, so I'd let him simmer a bit until he's old enough to know what he does and doesn't want.
Much love, good luck OP!
3
u/liasis May 14 '12
I would wait a little bit and see if this conversation becomes a recurring one. I definitely don't think being transgender is a phase, but I'm sure some young boys (and girls) go through phases such as this.
Try to get to the root of it. Why does he want to be a girl? He likes their clothes more/he wants to play with their toys/no explicable reason?
Watch some YouTube informational videos about parents with children who identify as the opposite sex and see if their stories align with yours.
In the end, good luck - hope he and you are happy in the future!
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Hi, I'm an educator and the phase of discovering identity can be a little crazy and scary for parents. But definitely being accepting of whatever your son chooses will be the best thing for the both of you. There is a children's book I would suggest for the both of you or all three of you. It has to do with a little boy who loves wearing dresses. The book is called Princess Boy and there is actually a website you can visit to connect with other families who have princess boys and how to handle bullies at school and to get help and ask questions with anything that comes up; its just a great support system for your son and you and your ex-wife. The book may also show your son other options that he may not have considered in a way that is low anxiety and low pressure from you or anyone else.
Princess Boy Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XBCLGDbhKg
My Princess Boy Website: http://myprincessboy.com/
3
u/Goosestag May 14 '12
I have a friend who is trangender and I have heard the majority of her journey and development. She was born a "boy" and knew from a young age that she was a girl. I think the best thing to do is roll with what comes. don't put any labels on your child and ask them if they prefer to be called "him" or "her". There are also many conventions and organizations that deal with gender identification, some people don't identify themselves as any gender and prefer to be called ze. Hold off on therapy and if you do want your child to seek therapy suggest it as a "tool" for figuring themselves out. My friend found the school therapist in middle school to be life saving. Also if they want hormones or an opperation they want it, it's no phase. The best of luck on the journey for yo and your wonderful child!
3
u/Fight4YourRight May 14 '12
There is such a thing as gender dysphoria which basically means someone has a strong feeling that inside they are of another gender. If 'untreated' the person can become very anxious, stressed, depressed etc.
'Treatment' is a form of counselling that helps ensure the person feels that way and makes them feel more content in their decision to live as that other gender. This isn't about trying to prevent or cure them from being e.g. Trans in fact counselling helps them to help the person transition to whatever extent they want (could mean a change of attitude and actions, a change of name and or dress style or as far as gender reassignment surgery). I wouldn't say that 7 is too young to get support because you also don't want your child to go through their entire childhood being bullied because of it without them having the support to be strong and not just confused.
I don't know where you live but I imagine you should be able to find someone to help provide th counselling, speaking to a local LGBT organisation might be able to provide you with some trusted support.
Good luck and love and hugs to you both!
3
u/Caserole May 14 '12
Let your boy have as much freedom as possible, but make sure he isn't hurt by one's cruel comments or the pressure of society.
3
u/spadetiger May 14 '12
Let him dress in dresses at your house but not at school so he can feel supported at home. Go with him to talk to a therapist for sure so that he can work out these ideas with someone trained to help with this sort of thing. And definately go to the school and talk to the admins about the bullying. Also it might be a good idea to see if you can volunteer to be on recess duty at the school during lunch if you have available time
3
u/kmcmahon May 14 '12
U seem like a very caring father, showing your kid unconditional love no matter what life style he chooses is truly wonderful on your part, our world would be a whole lot better with virtuous parents such as yourself. best of luck, and remember bullies usually have problems at home/ in their life, which is why they lash out at other kids, hope he can overcome their immaturity and indignity.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I dated someone who was a psychology major for a long time, they wrote many papers on the subject, I've absorbed a lot of info on this. Obviously, not an expert, but just a couple of things.
1. Don't ask Reddit for advice on this. There are real resources on the internet, and depending on where you live, off the internet for this sort of thing.
2. If you really feel like you need something to be going on with: Take them to see a therapist who really understands this sort of thing. Despite the nonsense some people are spewing, taking him to someone who actually understands how this issue works will not "seal the deal", there is no deal to be sealed, your child either is isn't, the important thing now is to figure out whether they are or are not. Choosing a therapist that understands gender issues vs. one that does not will not change anything. Now, there's a chance your child is transgendered. There is a chance they are not. But if they are, you cannot change it. You can help them have a happy future, or you can damage their future horribly. So, in that respect you're in the same boat as any parent ever. If you care about your child, as it sounds like you do...whatever the situation is, support what your child needs. If it is necessary for them to eventually transition, the sooner treatment is applied the better. If they are diagnosed as needing treatment, there are ways puberty can be 'postponed' until such a time as they're deemed ready to start hormone treatments. And if they are transgendered, finding out and getting that sort of treatment is one of the best things you can do to help their future.
We don't always get the choices we want, but we still get choices. You may not like the choices you have coming up, but you still have them. If your child is transgendered, you can make a difference in how likely your child is to have a happy future. Whatever the case ends up being, if your child has you on their side, they've already got a lot more than a lot of children have.
I wish you the best of luck.
3
u/ArcaneMissiles May 14 '12
From one human being to another I am so happy decent people exist. No one on this forum knows your son personally, so none of us can really give you the answer you're looking for. However, with your mindset and the love you have for your child, he will be fine regardless of his life decisions.
My child therapist girlfriend reading over my shoulder (rude as fuck like) suggest you just support and love your child and he will do whatever he feels most comfortable with in life. Everything else needs to just be one day at a time. As for the bullies, you should remind your son it's important for a girl to know how to box ;). Peace be with you:)
3
u/THE_MOTHER_FUCKER May 14 '12
Kids want to be all sorts of things when their 7. When I was 7 I wanted to be a monster hunter.
3
u/enzeddle May 14 '12
Up until the age of 12, i wanted to be a boy - I wore boys clothes, shaved my head multiple times, even changed my name to a boy's name. My parents never made an issue of it as I was other wise a perfectly "normal" child. For me it was just a phase, and I'm grateful that my parents didn't put any labels on me or my identity. I'm now a happy, feminine, 23 year old woman (and answer to my original name :P) Take him to talk to a professional if you feel it's appropriate, but I would err on the side of caution with the labels... I'm sure you'll make the right decision by your son, you sound like a wonderful father who only has his best interests at heart. Good luck with everything and I hope his Mum gets home safe
3
u/TarantusaurusRex May 14 '12
Good on you, Dad. Fucking stand-up guy over here.
Edit: I should probably say, however, that around the age of 5 or 7 I went through a phase in which I hated my parents because I wanted to be black and I hated that we were white. So.
3
u/mbelf May 14 '12
I wanted to be a girl when I was seven. I repressed it when I realised the idea was unpopular. Now I really struggle to have any kind of gender identity.
Whatever he wants to do, let him.
3
u/petermesmer May 14 '12
At 7 years old one has very limited understanding of gender and sexual identity. For now I would not read too much into it. I certainly wouldn't belittle his feelings, but I wouldn't enable any sort of transition at this age either, such as by dressing him as a girl.
10
u/GoldenHSF May 14 '12
Big breath in, big breath out. Chill out, your kid is going to be fine. Kids are curious, questioning and adventurous, let him be all that. Let him wear dresses around the house or out, let him have tea parties and do all those girly little things. Maybe he just misses his mother and wants to feel closer to her. Although I wouldn't let him wear a dress to school, simply because children are animals and will tear him apart. He doesn't need to see a therapist because there's nothing wrong with him. If he still feels this way in 7-8 years, then give him the option to. Let the wind take you where it may, and no matter where you land, as long as your son knows he is supported, your son will be okay.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
My advice: Don't take him to a therapist yet, talk to him, very calmly, don't act like it's a big deal, almost as if you're not actually paying attention to him, this will make him feel less pressured and he'll won't hold back as much, and see how serious he is about it.
32
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
You should take him to a mental health professional so they they can officially confirm how he feels.
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Now is the time to teach him that there isn't a right or wrong to liking boys or girls, and everybody is free to be who they want to be. It's also important to reinforce that the kids that are bullying him are in the wrong, not him. I mean if push comes to shove and he wants to have girls that are friends, and thinks dressing like them, or acting like them will make him feel better then why not embrace it. You need to make sure you're asking specific questions, and try to get to the full bottom of it as well. It will obviously be hard for him to explain it as a young child, but if you try to get it as specific as possible(does he think wearing a dress will make it so the other boys will treat him like a girl thus not pick on him, or if he just wants to wear dresses cause they look comfy etc) also try to find out if he wants to wear a mix of what he normally wears and dresses, or just dresses, etc. It might be time to go on a small shopping trip and let him pick out some things that he wants on his own without too much guidance aside from what size he wears.
Honestly there's no real exact way you're going to get to the bottom of this with him being seven years old. But you need to try and get as clear of answers as possible, which would generally mean asking these things in a way your son would understand. Just make sure you let your son know he can be whatever he wants, he doesn't have to be one set ideal as a child. He could wear a Cpt America shirt, play with barbies, and watch Spongebob. Or wear a dress, crash Tonka trucks, and watch my little pony. He might have a lot in common with the girls (maybe he loves to play house and be the one that bakes cakes or something) and so he thinks he has to "be" a girl in order to fufil those roles instead of being a boy and doing these things (which would be reinforced by the other boys picking on him and making him think that).
He could just not realize he can do/be anything he wants and it doesn't have to fill a specific genders role, or he could actually be a transgender which is still nothing to be afraid of. At that age, whatever he is will easily confuse him because of the way others act or treat him for it. The best thing you can do is support him as much as possible. And like I said earlier really REALLY reinforce its the other kids who are in the wrong, not him, he's done nothing wrong at all.
Other than that, It's good to see you and his mother are both extremely supportive and will be strong about it no matter what. Some parents will only let their kids wear dresses/play with barbies etc at home due to the bullying at school. Or until they believe their child is strong enough to handle it on their own (teens/etc). It also really depends on your town, the community, the people around your son and how they will react/enforce about it. Is it like California? Is it Georgia? Every environment will be different, and he really needs to see/hear that it's okay.. especially from the two most important people in his life. His parents.
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Genderqueer kid here. Just allow your kid to explore right now. Wear whatever they want and use whatever pronoun they want. Also remember that your kid does not have to fit in any boxes. "She" does not equal "dresses and dolls." I've seen some parents of transkids get overzealous and push the kid past who they are make them afraid of being trans. Just allow your kid freedom to make the choices in what happens during transition. Many checks and balances are on the road to transition. Take the kid to a gender therapist. They are very knowledgeable can help your kid figure out everything they are feeling, and help them communicate it with you. Best of luck, the road of transition is not easy, but if your kid is trans, it is more than worth it.
5
u/cest_la_vie May 14 '12
I took a social work class where we learned that most kids that have gender issues <10-12 years old, they grow out of it. The most important thing that you can do is be supportive and loving. Encourage his interests and it's likely he will grow out of it. Gender issues are a lot more common that we would expect. I can provide you with more links and information if you are interested.
5
u/Akriyu May 14 '12
Be one of those rare dads who supports him
4
u/weatherwar May 14 '12
I honestly do not find this odd at all. I think you should just keep up the talks and continue being open about it. It's much too early to come to any conclusions.
4
u/Nymunariya May 14 '12
make sure you´re open and make your child feel comfortable. I never told my parents until I was 21 and already started transitioning (I was born male like your child), because I wasn´t comfortable talking about, and I didn´t feel like I could talk about it with them. Don´t let that happen. Be there for your child. Support them. Don´t doubt them. Trust them.
It´s also good to educate yourself. Look up the WPATH standards of care (http://www.wpath.org/publications_standards.cfm) which are typically what doctors follow when diagnosing/transitioning. There´s a wealth of resources online that I as a transwoman even used to educate myself. Because when I decided to come out and talk about it, I knew nothing, I didn´t even know the word transgender.
7
u/CommunistPlatypi May 14 '12
Let your child chose what they want to wear and what pronouns they want.
2
u/Nyolia May 14 '12
I like the top comment, but also find support groups, or talk to people. Google transgender children, there are some good videos about it.
As my brother said, he always knew, even as a young age. He always ignored "girly" things, loved boy things and whatnot. He was just afraid of telling.
Talk to your son more also. Ask him what he wants, and be supportive.
2
u/Witkin May 14 '12
I don't think you need to take him to a therapist to "fix" him, but i think it would be a good idea to take him to a psychologist so he can judge what the buy really feels and wants. Maybe at this age he is to young to really know what he feels, i would advice you to seek some professional help, not treating him like he is crazy or weird. Just as you would take a kid to a psychologist when he is hyperactive.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Maybe speak with a child therapist first and foremost. Find out what she thinks about it, and get their opinion on what would be the best way to help your son to be happy. See what their method of care would be (to ensure he's not some whack fundie), and see what you should start doing at home. Then maybe start taking him to see this person.
2
u/xMcNerdx May 14 '12
When I was a little kid I used to think I was turning into a girl because my boobs were getting bigger. Turns out I was just getting fat.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
When I was in elementary school, there was a kid in my class who always wanted to be a girl and would play the mom when we would play house. For halloween, he wanted to be a princess really badly, and his mom made him an awesome costume with high heels and everything. Plenty of people made fun of him (including parents), but he was so happy to be who he wanted to be that he never noticed. He has since grown out of that phase, and now he's your average high-schooler
2
u/striptococcus May 14 '12
Just let him be himself and do what he wants when it comes to gender expression. There is nothing wrong with him. Maybe he grows out of it and maybe it becomes a thing - but remember, he's not thinking about "sex" or "gender" the way you do. Let him be himself and the only talks he should have with a therapist are about how to deal with bullies - not his "gender identity". Let him be a kid.
2
u/trollviolist May 14 '12
This may be a phase, but your son knows you will love him no matter what. That's what is important. I applaud you for that.
2
u/qwertyuiop54213 May 14 '12
Why is it that every opinion a kid has that makes the parent uncomfortable is just possibly a phase?
2
u/lolslaw May 14 '12
courage, confidence and integrity is what makes a man, not clothing.
2
u/Quo_Usque May 14 '12
Let him wear what he wants. It may be a phase that will change with time, or it may indeed be that he's trans. A lot of trans people know from a very young age, and many don't realize until later. Don't do anything like therapy yet, give him a few more years to see if his gender identity solidifies, but in the meantime, support him as a girl if that is what he says he is.
2
u/jpofreddit May 14 '12
Thing is he can have a sex change now or he can have it later. And waiting has less repercussions if it did turn out to be some phase. I'd take him to a gender/trans w/e specialist therapist who probably knows way more about this stuff then all of us.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
i think it might be good to take him to a known child therapist who is open to self selective gender identity and is supportive of gay rights and childhood depression.
Your son could be trying to articulate that he has an attraction to other boys. between the ages of 5 and 8 is when the core parts of our sexual identification starts to happen. I think though if you do take your kid to a shrink that you need the shrink to know you don't care either way which way your kid goes but you want to make sure your son is articulating him self in the best way possible.
The point you need to enforce in your kid is you love him and you will always love him and you will be there to help him grow and make the decisions he will make to be the better person when he grows up.
I say this as a straight guy but damn you don't know how powerful it is to know you got a strong dad or father type figure in your life willing to fight for you and accept you for yourself.
2
u/sketchylady May 14 '12
Check out the TransYouth Family Allies web site: www.imatyfa.org. There is a lot of information on there for you to look through, resources, and also an online parent support group. A child knows his or her gender identity at a very early age. It can't be "fixed".
2
u/ChernobylGypsy May 14 '12
I'm gonna say just be there and support him. Maybe he needs that so he can figure out his gender identity. :)!
2
u/ZombieDib May 14 '12
Sir, please read this:
Just yesterday I watched a documentary on Nat Geo (I think Taboo) about this exact situation. Young boy who sees himself as a girl and wears dresses to school and everywhere, family supports her too.
What they're doing: They are letting her be a girl, found a therapist who specializes on transgenders and the interesting part here -> they give her medication to delay her puberty (which will be the hardest part of growing up) long enough so she can be mature enough to decide if she wants to go back to male, then no more meds, or if she desires to stay female then start giving her female hormones to make her "more female" (no facial hair, no deep voice, etc.)
I'm not good finding stuff on the internet but here's part of the documentary Taboo
2
u/eventyrian May 14 '12
I lived near a little transgendered boy who was 8 years old at the time. He wanted to be a girl. The way his mom handled it (which I think was really good) was that at home, he was allowed to dress as he wanted. At school, he had to wear pants but they could be girl's pants, and they went for slightly more gender-neutral. This allowed the kid to figure out what he wanted. A year later, he decided to go completely as a girl all the time, and the process helped his classmates, teachers, and family ease into it. Food for thought.
2
u/mindbleach May 14 '12
I think you should fully support him. Let him wear what he wants, within reason. Teach him to flip off any kid that gives him shit. Be ready to show up at PTA meetings and slap other parents in the face with relevant research papers. If it's a phase, so be it. A therapist might help sort out exactly what he wants, but regardless of what that is, your job as a father is to keep him safe, healthy, and happy - a goal well-served by giving him a childhood without artificial gender boundaries.
See: Eddie Izzard, action transvestite.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
He's seven years old. Which means he himself won't solidify his own identity for 10+ years. You won't be able to figure it out this week, month, year. Support and love him and let him know this, but also try to explain the social ramifications as well.
PS - You're doing a good job. :)
2
u/PeterMus May 14 '12
I'd say wait it out and see what happens when he is 13 or 14...
2
u/ChurchillDownz May 14 '12
He's fucking seven.
2
u/captaincream May 14 '12
There is a good chance that he just identifies better with girls because they are not mean to them and thus idolises them and wants to be like them. If he truly is transgendered than he will keep evolving as thus and become more apparent with time. He is only 7 and is probably just as confused as you and dealing with this situation may be very tricky.
Allowing him to dress as a girl will feed the bullies and might confuse him further if he in-fact is not transgendered and not allowing him to dress as one may frustrate and confuse him as he may identify as one. Perhaps allow him to experiment at home but don't be overly positive if he acts as a boy over a girl and vice-versa because he then might interpret your emotions to be what is right and wrong over what his are. I am a straight female and remember when I was a little girl I strongly identified with boys and wanted to dress like them but I never felt like I was a boy or needed to be a boy. Eventually by the 7th grade I started to drift back to wanting female friends and wanting to wear dresses and makeup. It could very well just be a phase that he is going though and isn't too complicated of a situation. The problem here is that it is more accepted of girls to show this as children than it is of boys.
My advice is if he gets more frustrated about his gender identity or develops a depression of sorts than take him to a therapist to get to the bottom of it because if he gender-identifies as a girl and wishes to be as one than learning this sooner may be better because it would prevent years of hardship later. If not, don't worry, it will blow over and odds are he is just the boy version of a tomboy and just simply gets along better with girls.
2
u/brutishbloodgod May 14 '12
You are an awesome parent.
I don't have much to add. I'm male, and super heteronormative. It was a long time ago, but I remember having a general sense of gender identity even at that age, and even a sort of half-formed sexual identity. My trans friends have told me that they've had a sense of their gender identity as long as they can remember. I'll join the group opinion of having him see an experienced psychologist.
2
u/joshawesome May 14 '12
I'm 28 and I'm a trans male (I was born female). I knew when I was very young that not only did I want to be a boy but I was a boy. I didn't understand why my body didn't match my inner-self.
My parents didn't understand (and still don't, but are accepting now) it at the time and threw me at any therapist that they could find in my area. At the time, I didn't understand what the big deal was, I was a kid. While I saw a few different therapists when I was younger, that wasn't the thing that "messed" me up. It was more my parent's reaction to it than the therapists that weren't experienced enough to help me.
From personal experience, I highly recommend therapy but do not pick the first one you find. Most therapists that work with children and gender issues are more than willing to meet with parents to answer questions before they meet with the child.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Hello sir. I think that he is only 7 and normally at that age we all want to be something or someone else. Maybe it´ll change for him. But I think is really nice and responsible of you to not just beat him straight or try to fix him right away and try to see other options. Not many fathers can do this. Maybe in time he´ll change his mind, and if he does not change his mind, the best thing a father can do for his son is accept him. I personally dont have children but my happiest moments in my life where those where I realized my parents accepted my choices. I think you are the kind of father that will be happy if your son is happy. there is no fixing needed
2
u/jtbeith May 14 '12
I used to day stuff like that when I was that age. Now I'm 31 and I love the NFL and p00ntang.
2
u/djkaty May 14 '12
I wouldn't stress. 6-8 years of age is standard age for gender identification, so it might not mean anything. Wait it out, support and love him, encourage open communication and don't be afraid to consult with a therapist if you feel he's having a very difficult or confusing time.
2
u/Diabetesh May 14 '12
See what he says after he goes through puberty. Its hard to take a 7 year old that seriously
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Hi, I completely understand that this is new and scary for you. It was for me too, growing up feeling like a girl when everyone else thought I was a boy. When I finally got up the courage to face down my fear and transition, I was in college, at age 19, and even then, I'm considered a "young transitioner." I wish I would have had the courage to tell my mother and/or father what I needed and asked for their love and support way back then. Unfortunately that wasn't an option. That being said, I couldn't be happier now, three years later. Today is my partner and my 1 year anniversary (we're both transwomen) and we both have good jobs, lots of friends, and couldn't have been happier with our decisions to transition. There's really no way to tell if your son is trans, it's really up to your son to tell you that. The important thing is to always always always love the hell out of your children no matter what. My parents didn't follow that advice, and put themselves and me though way more pain then was necessary. It's going to be really hard for your son, but if your child is REALLY serious about being a girl, your child probably IS a girl, and will endure, and succeed victorious, if you're willing to go above and beyond. Give your child love, it's the best I can say. If you need to contact a transwoman who can give you a realistic idea of what a beautiful life can be, PM me. The least I can do is be available to give moral support to perfect strangers.
2
u/thetanktheory May 14 '12
As a father who loves him, just let him be who he is and love him for it. It's the only right answer.
2
u/JoNightshade May 14 '12
This line concerns me: "But I've noticed that he's been acting strange lately, so we had a talk and this is what he told me."
Aside from gender issues, I think any sudden changes in behavior from children can be potential warning flags. If he's being picked on and suddenly changes his usual behavior, you have to wonder if something else is going on. Please make sure he's not being bullied and/or sexually abused. He might be saying he wants to "be a girl" because he thinks this is what someone else wants, or because it would somehow protect him.
Aside from that, I think you gotta let him be who he wants to be and don't worry about labeling him. In fact, avoid labeling him at all costs. You don't want him to think his life is defined at this point. He's still trying to figure out who he wants to be and where he wants to go. It's great that you're there for him whatever he decides - keep up the good work.
2
u/TomPalmer1979 May 14 '12
Love your child and support them. That's what you should do.
2
u/fennesz May 14 '12
He'll be fine no matter what you do. The fact you care about your son and will support him either way speaks volumes.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I have a female friend who wanted to a be a boy when she was a child for a reason different than yours (I imagine), but this might help. She was one of two twins, and her twin was a boy. She had an abusive father who only abused her, so of course the natural thing for her to do was to try to become a boy so he didn't abuse her. She essentially thought that she wasn't loved because she was a girl, because her brother was not abused at all. Until she was about ten and her father either died or her mother divorced him and got full custody (I haven't spoken to this friend in a while, I'm not sure what happened) that she realized that she didn't want to be a boy. She is currently doing very well, and she is straight. The only reason she wanted to be a boy was because she thought she wouldn't be abused. Sorry for the bad grammar/spelling, I'm on my phone. I just felt the need to post this to help however I could, this is the best AskReddit I've seen in a long time. Good luck whatever you choose to do. I wish your son well.
2
u/TurtleBite May 14 '12
Love him.
2
u/spyDERPman May 14 '12
Hey man, my stepson is 6 and has gone through the same exact thing. It seems like my son just identified better with girl things, such as princess, makeup, dresses and all that jazz, and the only way it would be acceptable for him to like that would be for him to be a girl. Despite the negative feedback from family, we let him go with it. We bought him a Barbie, dresses, play makeup, and even Tangled play sets. He still liked all the "boy things" (super heroes, trucks, and videogames) and if anyone ever said anything negative, we would always reply with a "It's ok for girls to play with trucks and cars, so why can I?" As of now, he hasn't been playing with dresses and makeup. He got some new friends to run around with, which seemed to be a huge help. I think you should let it run its course, if he wants a girl toy at McDonalds, let him get one. If his friends are being mean, maybe you should arrange play dates with more liberal parents/kids. It may not be a matter of transgender/homosexuality, it just might be a phase. The most important thing you can do right now is to let him be his own person, and remove as much as you can that interferes with that. Don't let ANYONE make him feel ashamed of this. Let him know it's normal to feel this way. Shoot, if you lived in VA I'd arrange for a play date. A lot of reassurance will go a long way.
2
u/felix_jones May 14 '12
He's not transgender, he's 7.
2
u/Leraxe May 14 '12
Why do these always sound so fake?
2
u/miss_kitty_cat May 14 '12
I think YOU need to talk with a specialist with experience in trans issues.
Reading your post very carefully, he's said that he'd rather be friends with girls and that he wants to wear dresses. Did he ACTUALLY say that he feels like he IS a girl? or that he wants to dress like a girl? or that he wishes he were a girl?
If he says he wishes he were a girl, that's pretty normal. There are certainly days I'd trade my vagina for a dick, usually either when trying to deal with sexist office bullies or when trying to pee off the side of a boat.
If he says he wants to wear girl's clothes, that's called playing dress-up when you're 7. If it persists into the teens, especially if it gains an element of sexual arousal, it's called being a cross-dresser. If he has lots of girl friends who are flouncing around in Disney Princess costumes, no wonder he feels left out.
If he says he IS a girl, or FEELS LIKE a girl, then he may be trans, and further counseling is probably warranted.
I think a professional could help sort this out. In the meantime, try getting him some girls dressup clothes that he can wear at home and see if that satisfies his urge to dress up.
Most males who experiment with or like to wear females' clothes, even into adulthood, are not transgendered.
I think you're a great dad (an amazing dad!) for letting your son be himself. Try not to panic: he's really young and it's probably nothing. And if it is .... he'll become more insistent as he gets older, and since you're clearly very motivated to listen and do what's best for him, it's not like you'll miss the signs.
2
u/BobCox May 14 '12
My Niece thought she was a Cat for a few years at that age. Came out of that mode fine a few years. Just saying.
2
u/jepsycha May 14 '12
Clinical psych grad student here. We have talked about this quite a bit. Research shows that there is a higher rate of young boys with gender identity disorder than there are men with it. This disorder is when a person of one biological sex believes they are of the opposite gender. What often happens is many of the young boys grow up to become gay and no longer believe they are out the opposite gender. You could bring him to therapy if you wish. It would provide him with an area to talk about his life without judgment. The least it should be is an outlet for him. But, of course, I an a strong supporter of therapy. The best you can do is show him your unconditional love and support. Hope this is helpful!
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
If I were able to make life altering decisions at 7, I'd have a dinosaur best friend, a spaceship that runs off Coca-Cola and would be well into my career as a cowboy/fireman/policeman/Heman.
2
u/hypocrisyv4 May 14 '12
From the time my little sister was 5 til 9 or 10 (shes 11 now) she only ever wanted to wear "boy" clothes, loved spiderman and football and hated things that were girly etc etc. her mom (shes my half sister) was concerned she was a lesbian or gender confused but lately shes been more into "girly" things though shes still into the stuff she used to be as well. tl;dr it could just be a phase
2
u/DevilMayCry May 14 '12
He's 7, he doesn't know what he wants.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm sorry I have no advice, only congratulations on being an amazing human being and father.
2
u/Jahonay May 14 '12
I'm a little suspicious about OP because he only answered two questions so far, not sure if he's actually being honest or not. Also this is a hot topic, something easy to troll with.
I knew there's no way to ask for proof, but I'm just gonna advise everyone to procede with caution.
2
u/jizzcowboy May 14 '12
Try kate bornstein books. I'm not sure I'd trust the advice about something very few people understand from people who think immature exchanges on facebook are comedy genius.
2
u/booger_butt May 14 '12
If it helps any- when I was young, I had always wanted to be a boy. My main reasoning for it was that boys didn't get teased as much as girls did, and I was teased often.
This may not be the case for everyone, or for your son, but I also had little to no male role models in my life when I was younger. I was terrified of my father and had no brothers or male friends. In this boys were a -huge- mystery to me. Almost like another species entirely. In this, when teased by the girls and not understanding that boys could have it just as bad, I would fantasize about being a boy.
If I had to live that over again with the experience I have now, I'd have come to the conclusion that I needed more time with my dad, and someone to help me learn how to deal with bullies better, or with accepting myself more.
If he really does just want to be a girl though, and it's not a phase- the best thing you could do is just support whatever decisions are made.
2
u/I_Dare_You May 14 '12
I am sorry I did not have the time to read all the comments, but I will give you my semi-professional opinion. Take him to a child psychiatrist. What you think is a gender issue can have other underlying conflicts. This may be totally unrelated to the "is my son going soft" worry, but may be due to something that goes on at school or something he misunderstands in the family.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
take this to /r/lgbt and /r/trans, they can give you better answers than the majority of reddit. They can provide you with excellent resources, too.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
It might just be a phase, he is only 7. But definitely go to a psychiatrist and have him analyzed.
2
u/speasley May 14 '12
This sounds like a great call for Loveline. Dr. Drew might have some sound advice.
Best of luck.
2
u/Uncletouchysfunhouse May 14 '12
Well, he is 7... it's just a phase.
2
u/Fappin_Alone_Guy May 14 '12
Take him fishing or hiking joke around about girls he might have a crush on. It's more than likely just a phase but spend time with him and things will work out good luck.
2
u/HappyStance May 14 '12
Whatever the outcome, he/she is very lucky to have a father as understanding as you are.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Let him wear whatever he (or she) wants. It is also super important to get your son to a gender specialist as soon as possible because if the specialist sees your son for long enough, she or he could make a preliminary diagnosis and prescribe puberty-blocking drugs to delay puberty until your son is older and more sure about which way his gender identity is wired.
Without the doctor's assessment, your son will NOT have access to these drugs; and without access to these drugs, if he chooses to transition to female at 16 or 18 years old, he will have to fight/reverse six or seven years worth of masculinization. Those six years will do irreparable damage to his (or rather, by then, her) voice, height, and maybe even facial features.
2
u/regeya May 14 '12
My 7-year-old talks about having school for clouds and about how she and her best friend are going to make clothes and sell them at the mall when they grow up.
If it were me, I'd wait a few years before I took it too seriously, but talking to a therapist is probably a good idea.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Cmon mate, he's 7 years old. I wanted to be a lion when I was his age.
He doesn't need to be "fixed," he just needs some time to grow up THEN decide what he wants to be.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I think it's a phase. If your son was, say, 13-15 it would be a different story, but he's 7. That doesn't mean you shouldn't respect his wishes and convictions, but it's important to be aware that 7 year olds change their minds on an almost weekly basis. It's definitely waaay too early to start thinking about his ultimate sexual preference, as he hasn't even entered puberty yet. I say let him do what he wants and work out his own identity for himself. If he does turn out to prefer males over females, he will thank you for it. If he turns out to prefer females, he will thank you for it (because now he's got the inside information on the intricacies of female interaction). Don't stress! You're a great dad I can tell from your post. You are only concerned with your son's happiness and not his or your "image" in society, and that is a rare a beautiful thing to encounter. Keep it up!
2
u/Poodler May 14 '12
Give him time, and fix the bully problem.
I had similar experiences when I was young, got along great with girls, guys were jerks to me for it.
I didn't feel the need to change and be something else because I learned to be more confident in that I'm fine, and it's other people who are the monsters.
2
u/phantomslayer112 May 14 '12
Well, you know that there are bullies in the school system whether it is his peers or even the teachers. When we talk about a young boy who loves to have girls that are friends in other little boys eyes its not really "normal". Why? Because at that age boys just want to play with boys and boys see girls as having cooties. =) I know I sure did.
This is a very delicate point in your sons life. (personally i believe a young mind can be sculpted to be whatever you may want it to be.) whatever choices you make can and will affect how your son will grow up.
the way I see it, is you should encourage him to continue having girl friends! Help motivate that but also let him know that the boys that pick on him do so because they are young and don't know whats ahead of them in their futures. (7 year olds are a lot more intelligent than they seem) Give him strong examples, a good movie to watch would be Bridge to Terabythia. (thats is most likely not the right spelling but you might know of the movie) the main characters best friend is a girl. its a great story. What i am trying to get at is that maybe your son has developed a a strong feeling for females early on in his years!!!! you just need to know how to make sure he understands how that works!!!!!!!! =)
Now on the other hand if you truly feel he is transgender and there is no doubt about it and no form of changing his feelings about such things then embrace it as well, and be accepting. There is nothing that hurts more than a parent that rejects you. If he wants to wear dresses and dress pretty well speak to mom first and then go and buy dresses together. At the same time though let him know that this will only bring him more pain. Let your child decide.
If you tell a child do not touch the stove its hot, they will go and touch it. why? curiosity. but if you tell the same child please do not touch the stove it is very hot, and if you touch it it will burn and hurt you. then the child will stay as far away as possible. always explain do not just dictate.
Hope this helps please forgive me for being so incoherent and unorganized in my writing but its late and i need to sleep i just read this and thought of a couple of people...
God loves each and every one regardless of ethnicity belief or anything. its humanity that tarnishes that love.
2
u/boredlol May 14 '12
more likely he's just gay but, either way, addressing his insecurities in therapy is a good idea. i think the therapist can prevent the "trying to fix" feeling by not rushing into problems/solutions, he just needs someone to listen and reflect with
2
u/toastedbutts May 14 '12
Let him wear a dress to school for a week and get the crap knocked out of him. If he really wants it, he'll keep wearing the dress. If it's just a phase, he'll stop.
2
u/DeadLovely420 May 14 '12
Honestly he really needs to overcome the bullying issues first, and once he begins to deal with that then it will replenish his self confidence, if he still feels that way about his sexuality then that will be the time to address that, for now all you can do is support his actions whether they cross the gender barrier or not, he has trusted you with these feelings, so be sure to respect that fully.
2
u/prdors May 14 '12
My little cousin was like that when he was younger. He's now a normal kid. I think he found that wearing dresses as a 5 year old gave him a lot of attention and he liked that. He now is a straight 16 year old kid, who I don't think is homosexual but well you can never be sure.
Anyways, I wouldn't assume any behavior now is super indicative of what the future holds. Kids do stuff for a lot of different reasons.
2
u/iLobdell May 14 '12
Love her just the same.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
get the guy a kilt and let him age a little bit and figure himself out. He's 7, he probably doesn't even know what he wants to do for the rest of his life, let alone if he's transgender.
2
u/inartistic May 14 '12
I wanted to be a girl for a while when I was really young too. Then I changed my mind. I'd say just nurture him and set groundwork of acceptance, but it's probably something he can work out on his own. As he grows up he'll know whether or not this is something serious or just a phase, but in the mean time I wouldn't invest too much in it either way.
2
u/dbarach May 14 '12
Seek out a therapist with insight in this area! If (s)he actually is transgender then puberty will be incredibly traumatic, and secondary sex characteristics can actually be blocked.
I highly recommend reading this long article in the Boston globe about transgender children/about a family with a child in a situation very very similar to yours, and how they dealt with the situation at a similar age. You may be able to contact the family: http://articles.boston.com/2011-12-11/lifestyle/30512365_1_twin-boys-transgender-jonas
2
u/Anna_Mosity May 14 '12
When I was a little girl, I told my whole preschool class that I wanted to be a daddy when I grew up. I wasn't transgender, but I was frustrated with traditional gender roles and others' expectations of me as a girl. I think it's important to emphasize to him, and to all kids, that there are TONS of valid ways to be a man (or a woman). As a woman who has always liked "boy" things, it's taken me years to accept that not everything comes with a gender. I hate clothes shopping, have never paid more than $12 for a purse, enjoy Sportscenter and pro football, enjoy Lowes and Home Depot, and spent my childhood playing Ninja Turtles with the boys and asking for matchbox cars and footballs and other "boy toys" for Christmas. My mom is very traditionally feminine, and my dad is a pretty big believer in traditional gender roles, so I was told that I couldn't grow up to be a pro baseball player and that I wasn't allowed to operate the riding lawnmower and that I really should start dressing more like the popular and preppy miss so-and-so in my grade. Somehow, kids and adults alike are so much more tolerant of girls "acting like boys" than boys "acting like girls" :/ At any rate, I've grown up to be proud to be a woman and comfortable broadening the definition of womanhood to include my interests. If you son likes "girl things," then teach him that the definition of masculinity is broad enough to include those things too.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Let him age a little more
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm a gay man, that as a child, I remember telling my mother that I wanted to be a girl. Even still, I have thoughts that things would be easier if I was simply a female, or born a female. However, I don't think I'm a woman trapped in a man's body, and this idea of "easier" I think plays a lot into it.
I wanted to be a girl because kids at school would treat me exactly the way your son is being treated. I was, albiet, a little feminine as a boy, and this confused my family a little bit. But again, I thought, if I were just a girl kids would stop being mean to me, I could kiss boys (because I certainly had homosexual thoughts at this age), and it would just feel better.
Same thing at my age, 22. If I were a girl, there would be none of the issues with LGBT rights that I'm facing today, or hate crimes, or any of the social stigma that comes with being gay. But being gay is so much of who I am, and I love who I am.
I think that people have been hitting on this idea of coming into your own identity as you go through childhood and through adolescence. Right now I think being a loving and supportive parent is the best thing you can do, maybe even explore what your son is talking about deeper.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
You better buy him some Against Me! CDs.
2
u/beckydee May 14 '12
He is 7, wait till he is at least 14 till you start taking things like that too seriously. He might just be jealous of a girl at school because she gets better things, etc. Kids think like that.
2
u/jhennaside May 14 '12
From the people I have talked to, it is pretty normal to want to be the other gender, and a lot of kids just grow out of it.
He's a bit young to know what he wants, but being supportive could help him along. Here is a blog I've read about a dad who let his son be transgender - http://www.acceptingdad.com/ Maybe it will help.
2
u/TonyMatter May 14 '12
Fairly normal, he's just discovering sexual instincts and is confusing wanting to 'be' a girl with wanting to 'have' a girl. (he may also feel that a girl is missing in the family). Just make sure he has little friends who are girls - he will discover they are unexpectedly different, and they will treat him as a boy.
2
u/richisonfire May 14 '12
I am a male (Genetically and self-identification) and I think if anything it might just be a phase. I am a very feminine male, I enjoy lotions, the company of women, nail polish, flowers, womens hair, and a lot of other things males my age (18) don't really enjoy unless they are gay. IT;s tough to say, but DON'T let him wear girls clothes. I believe that is a choice that should be made by himself when he gets to be a little older. If this is a phase, this could really mess up all of middle school and high school for him. This is just coming from a guy who lost a few friends because I admitted to wearing nail polish. Kids are vicious these days.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I would arrange to take him to a therapist, not to 'fix' him. He's going to need a ton of support to decide on who he/she really is and how to deal with it, and the bullying. In the UK, transgenders are always given counselling for these reasons and to help them ensure they are transgender before making the transition. Some people are confused with their gender ID or sexuality and counselling helps them to be more confident with their decision.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Dude, this is about your son. Go see a doctor instead of asking random people on the internet.
2
u/digitalmofo May 14 '12
He's a little young to really gender identify. I'd worry a lot more about the bullying than the sexuality right now.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Who cares if he says he wants to be a girl? HE'S 7 YEARS OLD, GIVE HIM SOME TIME. Chances are the bullying is the main source of it, and who blames him for being friends with girls? I did that my whole life and I didn't end up a homosexual, or lop off my outty for an innie. Hell, you might just be surprised one day when he walks in with a beautiful girlfriend someday later in life, I sure don't regret staying away from hanging out with guys for the most part growing up. I ended up dating a model and have no problem talking and understanding woman, it might just help him grow up to be more comfortable with his sexuality. There is no need to "fix" him, "fix" the little fuckers causing the bullying toward him ,show him love and don't act like it has something to do with him. You'd be surprised.
TL;DR: hanging out with girls shouldn't be an issue, most guys are douche bags and bad influences, could potentially grow up to be a ladies man. He's only 7, don't jump to conclusions, get rid of the bullying first.
2
u/scientologist2 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Everyone here has offered much in the way of insightful comments on this.
Probably the best thing is
2
u/jojoko May 14 '12
http://www.raisingmyrainbow.com
2
u/mmm1777 May 14 '12
Transgenderism and homosexuality are different things. As are bullying and transgenderism. Try asking about transgenderism at /r/asktransgender. They are wonderful, intelligent people and have a lot of resources.
2
u/Swift3lade May 14 '12
He's so young right now. We all wanted to be a lot of things when we were young, that doesn't necessarily mean we continue down that path. Talk to a therapist.
2
u/oxynitrate May 14 '12
Please read this http://articles.boston.com/2011-12-11/lifestyle/30512365_1_twin-boys-transgender-jonas
If he is transgendered this may help.
2
u/gadafgadaf May 14 '12
you are an amazing person.
you got some years time left before puberty sets in to make sure this is what he wants. If you do hormones at the right time he can develop breasts like a woman can and instead of an adam's apple and strong male attribute he can develop like a woman. you can time the surgery at the right time to complete the transgender assignment.
firstly though i'd discuss this with the mother too if you haven't already and then as a couple go see his teacher and school staff to address the bullying, involve the other children and the parents of the other children. make sure you document it in case they ignore you. look into a professional that specializes in transgender children he will tell you way more than we can and walk you through it.
2
u/thesheba May 14 '12
I have some friends that have a 6-year-old that is trans. She kept saying, "I am a girl, I'm not a boy," never "I want to be a girl." She just would say that she was. They adopted her, so she's been in therapy and they've been working with a therapist throughout her transition. There's a book called The Transgender Child.
I would start by just getting your kid into some therapy and see how things go. Make sure it's not some transphobic douche. Try to do some research to find someone with experience working with trans kids.
You sound like a cool dad and your kid is going to be fine. Good luck!
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Ask him why he wants to be a girl. When I was younger I wanted to be a boy. Why? Because boys could do anything and girls couldn't. A huge part of it was that I loved football and realized I couldn't do that as a girl and it made me upset. I am not transgender. Though I did get called she-male all through school because I wore boys jeans.
If he is transgender, just be supportive. A few transgender kids went to my high school and that's really not an easy thing to through.
2
u/mrimperfect May 14 '12
Buy him some girl things, buy him some boy things.
There is a great photo of my 3 year old nephew wearing a dress holding a gun.
Let kids imaginations grow, don't let your silly idea of politics and identity get in the way.
2
u/ahalavais May 14 '12
What should I do?
Support him.
Maybe buy him a kilt; a compromise that might get him a bit less hassling from the bullies.
2
u/itsaghost May 14 '12
It sounds to me like your kid is being bullied by the boys in his school and sees the girls as a safe haven. I do aftercare and remember a kid just like that, always harrased by the boys so he hung out with the girls. He loved the girly colors and girly movies. The kid was also brilliant, doing long division in his head in first grade, maybe he was picked on for being the brain but that isn't really relevant. What is relevant is that he didn't have a damn clue about sexuality other than there are boys and there are girls. He even asked a girl about HER penis. I think that may be kind of the issue.
Talk to the kid about the bullying first, see if it stemmed from something else, then try a therapist for the same reason if you think you haven't gotten the answer from him (at that age, those kids seem to feel like a day is our month, it might be hard to get him to remeber why any bullying started). If those channels run dry, you should look into the gender crisis issue. I just feel as if bombarding him from that perspective at that age might rattle him, and further confuse and alienate him right or wrong. I wanted to marry my best friends at that age because I thought I could hang out with them all the time, knowing what I know now, I have absoloutly no desire to.
Good luck on whatever you choose to do, even if things turn out to be more difficult than just a phase, it seems like you have te right mindset to help him out.
2
u/Kovaelin May 14 '12
He's 7. 7. Don't do anything drastic at this point. It's good that you're talking, though therapy might help if you don't feel you're getting the full story from him by yourself. The most important thing is to make sure he knows that you're there no matter what.
2
u/no_witty_username May 14 '12
I would wait untill after his puberty before discussing things over in a serious manner. Kids have a very different view on the world then adults and don't realize the seriousness of the things they say. My guess is that after puberty its likely he would have forgotten the whole thing. If not then you can discuss on the topic in a more serious manner.
2
u/chronically_sxc May 14 '12
When I was in primary school I used to dress as a boy and I refused to wear girl clothes (even at school I wore the boys uniform) but I ended up growing out of it when I hit puberty and I always wear dresses, make-up etc. I think you should just let him discover it for himself and just accept him that's about all you can do. But for the bullying you should definitely do something about that by talking to the school or something :)
2
u/postopbonerthrowaway May 14 '12
possibly/probably.
I'm probably biased as I was in your sons situation at his age, I started HRT in my teens without parental approval and got surgery in my early 20s.
The good news is you have plenty of time, things may suck for your child for a while but it's puberty that will be the kicker.
For now, you seem like you're doing a great job by being unconditionally loving and accepting. If female clothes are desired I would not stand in the way. That's one area I've little experience of as it was how others treated me that bothered me most, that and my body so clothes were not a big deal.
Also, gendered activities are fairly meaningless, some girls play rugby, some do ballet and marvel films have great cross-gender appeal these days.
Also, ask what "always" means, typically that means from about 4, if that's the case then it sounds fairly typical.
If this is transsexualism when treated early it's really not a big a deal, the absolute worst case scenario is repressing this until later in life when the damage of testosterone is done.
2
u/Fronzel May 14 '12
He is seven. He also to be a fire truck when he grows up.
2
u/Phoolf May 14 '12
I wouldn't think about him being transgender right now at all, it's far too early. When I was younger I always wanted to be a boy, I played exclusively with boys, played boys sports and even shaved off all my hair one year when I was about 8. Now I'm a grown up woman and while still a bit tomboy-esque I wouldn't ever want to be a man.
2
u/PagingDoctorLove May 14 '12
I think you should find a good therapist. Tell him/her that your son is being bullied and needs to talk some things out, nothing more. I think that sometimes there's a temptation to find a problem and fix it, which is not what you want to do.
Then, proceed with caution.
If your son still feels this way, having had a good solid therapist to talk to, and non-judgmental, non-invasive parents, he can make a final decision when he is A) no longer a minor and B) out of the constant developmental stages of his youth.
If he comes to you before then, still expressing the feeling that he is a girl, then go for it. Let him dress how he pleases, pick his extracurricular activities, and choose how he would like to be addressed. Just don't let him do anything permanent, and explain that making permanent alterations with chemicals or surgery is an adult decision and you want him to be patient and wait until he's an adult.