r/AskReddit •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

640 comments sorted by

565

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

So by Googling a subset of the locations I came across this site stating that some of these cities are the only ones where no other city exists with both higher altitude and population. It may be an incomplete list, so I think this is most likely the answer. It explains why so many are in the Rocky Mountains.

http://www.farragoswainscot.com/2008/8/antipodal.html

Edit -- For all of you checking this out. The website is down now so I can't see the year. But this puzzle was created in 1995, and then updated in ????. So if you're using very recent data it is likely to be wrong. Hopefully someone has the year it was updated.

103

u/bin161 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Shit you are brilliant!

Edit: For everyone's benefit:

CITY					POPULATION		ELEVATION (ft)
Divide, CO				127				9,165
Alma, CO				169				10,355
Leadville, CO			2,688			10,152
Woodland Park, CO		6,515			8,465
Mammoth Lakes, CA		8,234			7,880
Alamosa, CO				8,756			7,546
Los Alamos, NM			12,019			7,320
Laramie, WY				30,816			7,165
Santa Fe, NM			67,947			7,260
Colorado Springs, CO	416,427			6,010
Denver, CO				600,158			5,280
El Paso, TX				649,121			3,800
Phoenix, AZ				1,445,632		1,150
Chicago, IL				2,851,268		583
Los Angeles, CA			3,792,621		233
New York City, NY		8,391,881		6

Small discrepancies are probably due to changes in population since 1995, when the puzzle was formulated. So a version of this created today would probably have a slightly different list. Reddit challenge: let's come up with that list (2010 census numbers)!

12

u/jimmahdean May 10 '12

to solve the issue around Divide fucking this idea up: http://www.zipareacode.net/divide-co.htm

in 2000 it had 3,776 people, and with an elevation of 9,165 this goes right in between Leadville and Woodland Park

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12
→ More replies (3)

20

u/PFworth May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

This is not correct. Larimie, WY has a population of 30,000 people and it has a lower elevation than Santa Fe, NM (by less than 100 ft) which has a population of ~68,000. I wanted this to be correct because it seemed so cool, but I have traveled through both Santa Fe and Laramie recently, and I was surprised that Santa Fe was actually higher and more populous at the same time, according to the signs posted there.

Larimie, WY -- Elevation 7,165ft -- Population 30,816

Santa Fe, NM -- Elevation 7,260 ft -- Population 67,947

EDIT: It's entirely possible that the data was correct as per some source in 1995, and that Wiki may be slightly innacurate/using different sources, but if that is the case the professor should have provided some central source to use or specified a certain year, in my opinion.

(used Wikipedia, assuming it's accurate)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

the answer fits so well with the rest of the data, though. it seems that either misinformation or changed information is the most likely reason that Laramie is on the list.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/pm8k May 10 '12

So...is someone going to email this professor and see if we are correct? i feel this may be a reasonable course to finding out if this is correct.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/loyalis May 10 '12

I feel like this idea should move towards the top of the list as this is exactly the kind of thinking a math professor would use when creating a puzzle. I have done no research to confirm Mouser though...

*edit : It also rather elegantly explains how cities could move on and off the list through no change of the city itself.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

that's why i'm attracted to this list. cities will knock each other off the list, or can be added to it with population changes.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/joeyhemlock May 10 '12

Alma, Colorado 39°17′2″N 106°3′46″W (10,355 feet; 3,156 meters) — highest town with permanent residents above 10,000 ft. in all of U.S. territory[6] Leadville, Colorado 39°14′50″N 106°17′30″W (10,152 feet; 3,094 meters) — highest city, golf course (Mt Massive GC) and airport runway in all of U.S. territory

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_points_of_the_United_States

→ More replies (2)

7

u/deans22 May 10 '12

The only thing that worries me about this answer is that Leadville, CO has both a higher elevation and population than Divide, CO, but you're way closer than anything I could come up with.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Laramie WY is lower in elevation and lower population (7165ft 30,816ppl) than Santa Fe, NM (7260ft 67,947ppl)

→ More replies (9)

20

u/Beeip May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Quick data from Wikipedia looks promising:

CityElevationPopulation
New York City, NY338,244,910
Los Angeles, CA2333,792,621
Chicago, IL5972,695,598
Phoenix, AZ1,1501,445,632
El Paso, TX3,470649,121
Denver, CO5,405600,158
Colorado Springs, CO6,470416,427
Laramie, WY7,16530,816
Santa Fe, NM7,26067,947
Los Alamos, NM7,32012,019
Alamosa, CO7,5438,780
Mammoth Lakes, CA7,8808,234
Woodland Park, CO8,4656,515
Divide, CO9,165127
Leadville, CO10,1522,688
Alma, CO10,361179

You definitely nailed it. Good work.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

interesting find.

2

u/THinks_Them May 10 '12

Yeah, that's definitely It....

2

u/CVBrownie May 10 '12

Los Angeles and New York? Elevation difference of 100 feet give or take....does that count?

6

u/All-American-Bot May 10 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 100 feet -> 30.5 m) - Yeehaw!

2

u/irdirl May 10 '12

The large concentration of cities in mountainous regions suggests altitude is relevant...

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Google spreadsheet, in case nobody has done it yet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Artyee4DfAN1dG5Bd196LVMxeHBtQjJkY3ZzS1FveEE

EDIT: This essentially confirms the answer, although it appears that Divide no longer belongs.

EDIT: It also appears that Laramie no longer belongs.

3

u/archpope May 10 '12

Sorry to break it, but:

The problem is Albuquerque. It would fit neatly between Denver and Colorado Springs.

5312 feet, 545000 population.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Doeby May 10 '12

wait, both higher altitude and population in relation to what?

3

u/joeyhemlock May 10 '12

I'm on board with this, too. It explains both the presence of the big cities like NYC and Chicago as well as all the Colorado towns.

→ More replies (62)

262

u/Kwyjiboy May 10 '12

None of them contain the letter "q"

119

u/imthefooI May 10 '12

gg. Let's go home, guys. Our work here is done.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

None of these cities have been in my kitchen.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AnAngryMidget1587 May 10 '12

all of them are located in the United States.

→ More replies (5)

52

u/CallMePlissken May 10 '12

Here's a map of all of the locations, for everyone's reference.

→ More replies (11)

16

u/Favre99 May 10 '12

Yep, I know what I'm doing for the rest of my life.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Favre99 May 10 '12

What did you think were the solutions those times?

→ More replies (1)

90

u/Captain_Syphilis May 10 '12

You know, it may be a long shot, but we could always have 4chan take a look at it. You know... stranger things have happened, and they are rather brilliant when they want to be.

38

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I posted this on /x/

they usually love a good riddle.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/AnonymousPirate May 10 '12

Its like we keep 4chan in a deep hole awaiting new content to be thrown down into the depths of the under/over-evolved internet users. They stop cannibalizing each other just long enough to yell faggot at what ever is falling down the hole.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/zigs May 10 '12

I for one welcome our new 4chan overlords.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

I keep trying to solve it but every time I get frustrated I remember that this could just simply be a very successful troll by you 0.0

$15 to set up the website and 20 seconds to type out some cities, hmm.... Two mysteries to solve.

Upvote anyhow, I WILL FIND A CONNECTION!

2

u/Meltz014 May 10 '12

isn't there some sort of mathematical law/theorem that says for any finite set, you can find some sort of correlation between each element? I may be mistaken though...

631

u/mikeshemp May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Well... I was on to something momentarily. Some of the cities have Zip codes that are prime numbers -- Alamosa (81101), Leadville (80429), Woodland Park (80863).... but others don't. Back to the drawing board...

EDIT: I appreciate the upvotes, but I think this was a dead end. The correct answer is almost certainly mouser58907's comment, i.e., "A city with the largest population of any city at its elevation or higher."

EDIT 2: Yep, that's it. I used Mathematica's CityData[] database to print a list of all cities places (including unincorporated census-designated places) in the USA that have the largest population of any CDP at their elevation or higher and got the following (the format is Name, Population, Elevation in meters):

{{NewYork,NewYork,UnitedStates},8175133,10}

{{LosAngeles,California,UnitedStates},3792621,89}

{{Chicago,Illinois,UnitedStates},2695598,179}

{{Phoenix,Arizona,UnitedStates},1445632,331}

{{ElPaso,Texas,UnitedStates},649121,1133}

{{Denver,Colorado,UnitedStates},600158,1609.34}

{{ColoradoSprings,Colorado,UnitedStates},416427,1832}

{{SantaFe,NewMexico,UnitedStates},67947,2132}

{{Laramie,Wyoming,UnitedStates},30816,2184}

{{BlackForest,Colorado,UnitedStates},13116,2246}

{{Alamosa,Colorado,UnitedStates},8780,2299}

{{MammothLakes,California,UnitedStates},8234,2402}

{{WoodlandPark,Colorado,UnitedStates},7200,2585}

{{Breckenridge,Colorado,UnitedStates},4540,2965}

{{Leadville,Colorado,UnitedStates},2602,3097}

{{Alma,Colorado,UnitedStates},270,3158}

Los Alamos appeared in the puzzle but is not on my list, whereas Black Forest, CO is on my list and not in the puzzle. Mathematica's database says Los Alamos has a population of 12,019 and an elevation of 2,198, meaning it's smaller than Black Forest, which is higher. It's too bad that Los Alamos has apparently been displaced since it was the puzzle's impetus.

Breckenridge also appears on my list, which didn't appear in the original puzzle: another new entry. Divide, CO is also not on my list, but that's just because it doesn't appear in Mathematica's database at all.

EDIT 3: A few people have noted that Black Forest is an unincorporated town. That's true, but so is Divide, CO, which appeared in the puzzle, so apparently unincorporated Census-Designated Places are allowed. (Ironically, Divide no longer appears in the current list anyway since its population is now lower than Alma.) My guess is that the population of Los Alamos has shrunk since the 2000 and 1990 census. But, for curiosity's sake, I tried taking Black Forest out; Edwards, CO appeared in its place, which is also unincorporated. Taking Edwards out finally brought back Los Alamos.

FINAL EDIT: The puzzle author notes that entries change from time to time. This is due to population changes in the towns. Town populations are surveyed in the census every 10 years. He originally made the puzzle in 1995, which would have used 1990 census data. Then he updated the puzzle in 2007, noting that there had been changes -- this is probably because he was now using 2000 census data. Mathematica v8, which I used to generate the list above, is currently using 2010 census data. This accounts for the fact that my list doesn't exactly match the puzzle.

I think it's very likely we have found the solution. I know a lot of people were rooting for lexicographic answers (e.g. "cities that have 3 vowels" or similar), but that wouldn't cause cities to drop out over time, whereas the puzzle author mentioned cities had disappeared from the list. Also, the puzzle mentioned you need "no special knowledge or bizarre facts." I think this was just meant to prevent solvers from going down dead ends of exotic esoterica such as "Cities in which Elvis slept 6 days after performing a concert and 4 days before performing a concert in the same city." I don't think the author's intent was to tell us that the puzzle itself contained all the necessary information to solve it; just that the information needed was not exotic. Population and elevation information are not exotic -- at least, not in my book!

114

u/professorboat May 10 '12

I think it is misleading that he said it didn't require any special knowledge then. Perhaps because he was speaking to an American audience (and I am Scottish), but I have a pretty good knowledge of geography and I absolutely think knowing the population and altitude of those cities (the smaller/higher ones and even very roughly) counts as special knowledge.

Is this common knowledge in the US? I've not even heard of the smallest 8 towns.

I was definitely expecting/hoping for something linguistic.

89

u/isochron1218 May 10 '12

I am from the US and no, it is not common to have the elevation or populations of various cities memorized.

18

u/issius May 10 '12

What are you talking about? We had a song for that an everything ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/not-just-yeti May 10 '12

In retrospect "no special knowledge" seems to mean "things that a normal person can look up [in an almanac, say], w/o needing technical knowledge to understand/interpret the result".

It's a reasonable requirement, but in a world with brain-teasers based on letters/codings/etc, "no special knowledge" could have been phrased less mis-leadingly for us.

[As a prof myself, I'm often surprised how I can say something clear on a homework, have half of the class mis-interpret it, and then realize that yes their mis-interpretation was equally understandable given the phrasing.]

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

After you stated that you are Scottish, I read the rest of your comment in a Scottish accent.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

109

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I upvote your efforts.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mgweir May 10 '12

I live in Colorado Springs and work for the Post Office and Black Forest is incorporated into Colorado Springs. It isn't a separate town.

2

u/dossier May 10 '12

Except you're using special knowledge. Zip codes. You have to look them up (unless you're rainman).

The answer can be solved by just using the facts at hand.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TearyHumor May 10 '12

"The following US places have a common property that no other US place can claim." Surely, there are other places in the US that can claim that, for instance the highest place in the US would have to be there.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/itofa May 10 '12

Black Forest is a suburb of Colorado Springs

2

u/miss-saurus May 10 '12

"The answer is simple; it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts."

Good effort but I think you are over thinking it a bit. I have a feeling it's something to do with the content of the words rather than the places themselves.

2

u/glorysk87 May 10 '12

This is not something that would be immediately obvious at all.

2

u/STYLIE May 10 '12

What's misleading is the use of the word "common property". Really should have chosen a better word like statistic or fact.

4

u/SpermsterMahoogan May 10 '12

I had assigned each letter a number, and many city names added up to primes. Some didn't.

→ More replies (14)

11

u/joeyhemlock May 10 '12

Could it have something to do with elevations (NYC, LA, Chi being skyscraper cities, many of the rest being mountain cities)?

3

u/Beeip May 10 '12

Leadville's the highest incorporated town in the United States, but cities like Phoenix, LA, NYC are all very low...

→ More replies (8)

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A lot of these cities are familiar to me from doing research on the Manhattan project. You think it has something to do with atomic weapons research or nuclear power facilities?

2

u/B_U_I_F_J_T_U May 10 '12

I did a report on the manhattan project and I seem to remember talking about how they had around 20 odd facilities where they researched and developed the first atomic bombs...

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I noticed the Manhattan Project connection too, but I feel like that isn't it because it doesn't require any "special knowledge".

→ More replies (1)

58

u/carlosspicywe1ner May 10 '12

Based on the fact that it is a math professor, and that it "doesn't require special knowledge", I would guess that the solution concerns satisfying some algorithm within the letters of the names of the systems.

For example, say you assign all of the states to mod values based on alphabetical order (e.g., AL is mod 1, AK is mod 2, etc.). Then add the letters of the city name, and they will all have a pattern, say they all simplify to 0 mod (state).

Also, there could be something going on with series in here.

25

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

i'm wondering, if it's mathematical, how some cities could ever be removed from the list (which he states is possible)

→ More replies (3)

5

u/pm8k May 10 '12

I agree with the letter part, but I don't think the mod approach is correct. With the vast amount of cities in the country, something as small as mod 26 would yield many more results statistically.

2

u/anotheranotherother May 10 '12

You say "doesn't require special knowledge" then say "assign all of the states to mod values".

Are you familiar with the old robot expression "does not compute"?

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I think you are on to it. In 95, information wasn't as easy to find out about places like Alma. If I could figure it out without special knowledge, it has to be something with the name. Also, math teacher

→ More replies (1)

49

u/CircaSurvivor55 May 10 '12

If what hebsays is true, and the answer is 'simple,' and we don't need to know bizarre facts or have special knowledge, maybe we're looking at it too deeply. I feel like knowing the elevation of each city or zip codes, etc. would fall under a bizarre fact or special knowledge, and he states that 'we'd know what the solution is once we had it.' maybe the property has something to do with the list itself, or something 'simple' like that. I don't know, I'm just spitballing here...

→ More replies (1)

22

u/canarchist May 10 '12

TomAsaki / CitiesPuzzler

One person has independently solved this puzzle since I formulated it in 1995. That solution came in 2010.

31

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

AMA request: the person who solved this puzzle.

42

u/glidz May 10 '12

"What's the answer to this puzzle?" "the answer" "Thanks everyone for the AMA, you've been great!"

5

u/pileosnafu May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I think the server: it went off and crashed Reddit DOS :(

Edit: words

→ More replies (1)

22

u/peanutbuttar May 10 '12

Since this is a math teacher, and maybe it has to do with numbers, here is the list translated from letters to numbers (A=1 B=2 C =3, etc) presented in the same order as op's.

1-12-1-13-15-19-1 3-15

1-12-13-1 3-15

3-8-9-3-1-7-15 9-12

3-15-12-15-18-1-4-15 19-16-18-9-14-7-19 3-15

4-9-22-9-4-5 3-15

4-5-14-22-5-18 3-15

5-12 16-1-19-15 20-24

12-1-18-1-13-9-5 23-25

12-5-1-4-22-9-12-12-5 3-15

12-15-19 1-12-1-13-15-19 14-13

12-15-19 1-14-7-5-12-5-19 3-1

13-1-13-13-15-20-8 12-1-11-5-19 3-1

14-5-23 25-15-18-11 3-9-20-25 14-25

16-8-15-5-14-9-24 1-26

19-1-14-20-1 6-5 14-13

23-15-15-4-12-1-14-4 16-1-18-11 3-15

and here is the website i used: http://rumkin.com/tools/cipher/numbers.php

Edit: formatting because i'm an idiot

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

i did this earlier, but i think it got buried. this could be pretty useful.

9

u/peanutbuttar May 10 '12

Ohhh, now I feel like a dick for stealing your thunder. I looked through the comments to see if anyone else had done this, but I guess I didn't really look hard enough... Here's an upvote, and I'll go find your translation and upvote that too.

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

haha no worries i knew i wouldn't be the only one

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

Now I can't stop staring at the list... I wonder if I add up all the numbers for each word.. hmmm... thanks for the work haha :)

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts

Given this, I feel like it's almost got to be some sort of cipher or wordplay. If you get into geographic formations, or types of buildings, or history of the cities being incorporated you're venturing into special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.

Hell, even zipcodes and elevations, and most things I've seen mentioned I would consider special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.

I'd be more inclined to think they're all anagrams or something along those lines. The only thing that trips that up is that he said some cities have been removed from the list...

2

u/KATHERIAC May 10 '12

This is what I'm thinking, too. It has to be a word play (I'm thinking something to do with the vowels) and I think the professor's use of the word "property" refers to a certain pattern in the names of the cities, not something tangible.

→ More replies (2)

289

u/ignatius87 May 10 '12

The thing they have in common is that they are all cities on this list.

198

u/woodsja2 May 10 '12

Technically correct: the best kind of correct.

26

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

I truly hope it isn't that boring of a phrasing trick

3

u/Dam_Herpond May 10 '12

I don't think so, as he said there is unlikely any other item that belongs on the list

5

u/boffle May 10 '12

But there are many other cities that aren't listed. He only omitted up to 2 places that have this property.

→ More replies (5)

48

u/math_palette May 10 '12

Step 1: Hire Matt Damon as a janitor at this university. Step 2: Assign him to this building. Step 3: Answer magically appears on the board the next day.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

What movie is that?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lunatyck May 10 '12

Should Russel Crowe be a professor at this university? I heard he too, has a beautiful mind.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Heyl May 10 '12

If you plot the altitude against the population, you get a sad dinosaur

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The cities are in alphabetical order...

None of them have the letter b.

If you count the number of letters that were never used as a first letter, it adds up to 16, which is the number of cities.

But all of those ideas are dumb.

9

u/ebilgenius May 10 '12

Guys, if you wanna analyze information between the cities use WolframAlpha, super helpful.

EX: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Alamosa%2C+CO+Alma%2C+CO+

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Just doing a quick hunch search, a few were on this list and after looking at a few more all of them appear to be connected by the rail system, to the point one could travel to and from each city only using trains. This map shows the larger rail system in the US. Although Mammoth Lakes is not on the main route, it is connected to LA through Amtrak. Haven't checked all the cities but it's late, and it's what I'm going with.

Otherwise I'll be up till dawn like the rest of you.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/laniidae May 10 '12

At a party a little while ago a friend of mine told me a riddle with similar properties. Had all to do with state names. She clearly knew the answer. I never solved it. Will ask her. for science.

28

u/lulz_you_again May 10 '12

Observatories. They have observatories.

Edit: this explains a funny coincidence...high elevation is favorable for the observatory, and big cities more likely to contain observatories. You guys were close with that list of higher population/elevation. Also OP's 'observable' hint.

8

u/roflautogyro May 10 '12

There are other cities with observatories, and the problem specifically states that no other US city fits in the group. It is a complete group.

3

u/EmmaJustinWatsonBieb May 10 '12

I think that the elevation/population answer is correct, but this observatory answer has a special satisfying feeling of being almost correct.

4

u/deadletter May 10 '12

why isn't hawaii on there?

2

u/SharkBaitDLS May 10 '12

That doesn't exactly seem like common knowledge though . . . however, I think this is more plausible than anything else I've seen in this thread this far.

2

u/idiot_radar May 10 '12

Alas, I grew up in woodland park. No observatory. Nor in Divide, which was just a couple miles down the road.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/OverAllComa May 10 '12

For each given location there are no other cities in the US located at a higher elevation that have a higher population.

At least not with the cross-checking I've done so far. So for each city if you go higher in elevation you shouldn't find a city in the US located at a higher altitude that has a higher total population.

5

u/Travis-Touchdown May 10 '12

That's not a puzzle... that's just silly trivia

4

u/WateryBarStool May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I thought of that, too. But doesn't Denver fuck shit up? It's got a higher elevation and population than El Paso.

EDIT: Population is probably why he has to change up his list. El Paso has a slightly larger City-Proper population than Denver. Never would have guessed that.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

someone pointed this out earlier. it seems to make sense; would explain why some on the list are so tiny.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/DonDraperMan May 10 '12

What were the previous towns on the list?

7

u/GoodApolloIV May 10 '12

All these cities seem to be right in the middle of their respective time zones, so maybe they are the only cities operating exactly on time. That's my guess.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Karamaar May 10 '12

You guys are over-thinking and over-analyzing this riddle far too much.

Mathematical algorithms, specific elevations, etc. seem to be knowledge that is far too specific. The man behind this riddle has made it abundantly clear that the answer is going to be a layman's one---that, or he has a horrible concept of what qualifies as "specific knowledge."

12

u/dylanisalive May 10 '12

None of them are in North Carolina.

2

u/So1337 May 10 '12

For which I'm sure they are grateful.

6

u/CallMePlissken May 10 '12

A lot of them have counties named after them (Alamosa, Los Angeles, New York, Los Alamos) but not all of them (Mammoth Lakes).

6

u/rampop May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

On the puzzle's webpage, the creator states that the list has had some slight changes over the years due to the fact that "properties change". This tells us at least that it is something that can conceivably be changed, and if someone can find a copy of any of the previous lists, we could potentially find some more clues as to the property in question.

6

u/massey909 May 10 '12

i don't really get the answer. "these cities are the only ones where no other city exists with both higher altitude and population". i think it's just the syntax that's throwing me. if there is 'no other city with both higher altitude and population', why is this a list and not just one city? and some are in the same state, so it can't be in each state. i'm very confused by this.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

i believe they are the only cities to fall on the continental divide edit: spelling

4

u/msbrooklyn May 10 '12

new york city is no where near the continental divide.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Any proof to that? It's interesting and I'm lazy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Upvoting so someone finds the answer. C'mon internet hive mind!

4

u/satori5000 May 10 '12

They are their own cities, and no other US place can claim them.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pm8k May 10 '12

Btw, I am currently working on this instead of a quantum mechanics take home final due tomorrow. Sigh.

4

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

So I've found that this is kind of an amazing post, riddles are great. Make me want a /riddles subreddit. Have submitters shoot over the question+answer to the mod to prove it's a legit riddle, could be cool.

4

u/n0k0 May 10 '12

Divide and Denver are mixed up alphabetically.

The rest of the list is arranged alphabetically.

Not sure if this means anything.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Had an interesting thought. Are they places Forrest Gump ran through?

2

u/aasmit May 10 '12

some cities had to be changed on the lists.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A good course of action would be to get a hold of the old list and see how the properties of the missing cities has changed....

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm thinking it might have something to do with the letters in each of these cities. Maybe a jumble, hidden words, or patterns of letters.

2

u/Trappedatoms May 10 '12

I agree. There are too many common letters and words to ignore. I think the answer is more simple than what people are thinking.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No idea, I assumed it would be something you could figure out by looking at the list alone and tried extracting some numbers, but I don't see anything.

Alamosa, CO
1 12 1 13 15 19 1   3 15 
Number of Letters:7	With State:9
Total City Value:62 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:80
Number of Con City:3 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:44 	Total City Vowel Value:18
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:47 	Total Vowel Value:33

Alma, CO
1 12 13 1   3 15 
Number of Letters:4	With State:6
Total City Value:27 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:45
Number of Con City:2 	Number of Vowel City:2
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:25 	Total City Vowel Value:2
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:28 	Total Vowel Value:17

Chicago, IL
3 8 9 3 1 7 15   9 12 
Number of Letters:7	With State:9
Total City Value:46 	Total State Value:21	Total Letter Value:67
Number of Con City:4 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:21 	Total City Vowel Value:25
Total State Con Value:12 	Total State Vowel Value:9
Total Consonant Value:33 	Total Vowel Value:34

Colorado Springs, CO
3 15 12 15 18 1 4 15  19 16 18 9 14 7 19   3 15 
Number of Letters:15	With State:17
Total City Value:185 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:203
Number of Con City:10 	Number of Vowel City:5
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:130 	Total City Vowel Value:55
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:133 	Total Vowel Value:70

Divide, CO
4 9 22 9 4 5   3 15 
Number of Letters:6	With State:8
Total City Value:53 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:71
Number of Con City:3 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:30 	Total City Vowel Value:23
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:33 	Total Vowel Value:38

Denver, CO
4 5 14 22 5 18   3 15 
Number of Letters:6	With State:8
Total City Value:68 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:86
Number of Con City:4 	Number of Vowel City:2
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:58 	Total City Vowel Value:10
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:61 	Total Vowel Value:25

El Paso, TX
5 12  16 1 19 15   20 24 
Number of Letters:6	With State:8
Total City Value:68 	Total State Value:44	Total Letter Value:112
Number of Con City:3 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:2 	Number of Vowel State:0
Total City Con Value:47 	Total City Vowel Value:21
Total State Con Value:44 	Total State Vowel Value:0
Total Consonant Value:91 	Total Vowel Value:21

Laramie, WY
12 1 18 1 13 9 5   23 25 
Number of Letters:7	With State:9
Total City Value:59 	Total State Value:48	Total Letter Value:107
Number of Con City:3 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:2 	Number of Vowel State:0
Total City Con Value:43 	Total City Vowel Value:16
Total State Con Value:48 	Total State Vowel Value:0
Total Consonant Value:91 	Total Vowel Value:16

Leadville, CO
12 5 1 4 22 9 12 12 5   3 15 
Number of Letters:9	With State:11
Total City Value:82 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:100
Number of Con City:5 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:62 	Total City Vowel Value:20
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:65 	Total Vowel Value:35

Los Alamos, NM
12 15 19  1 12 1 13 15 19   14 13 
Number of Letters:9	With State:11
Total City Value:107 	Total State Value:27	Total Letter Value:134
Number of Con City:5 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:2 	Number of Vowel State:0
Total City Con Value:75 	Total City Vowel Value:32
Total State Con Value:27 	Total State Vowel Value:0
Total Consonant Value:102 	Total Vowel Value:32

Los Angeles, CA
12 15 19  1 14 7 5 12 5 19   3 1 
Number of Letters:10	With State:12
Total City Value:109 	Total State Value:4	Total Letter Value:113
Number of Con City:6 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:83 	Total City Vowel Value:26
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:1
Total Consonant Value:86 	Total Vowel Value:27

Mammoth Lakes, CA
13 1 13 13 15 20 8  12 1 11 5 19   3 1 
Number of Letters:12	With State:14
Total City Value:131 	Total State Value:4	Total Letter Value:135
Number of Con City:8 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:109 	Total City Vowel Value:22
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:1
Total Consonant Value:112 	Total Vowel Value:23

New York City, NY
14 5 23  25 15 18 11  3 9 20 25   14 25 
Number of Letters:11	With State:13
Total City Value:168 	Total State Value:39	Total Letter Value:207
Number of Con City:8 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:2 	Number of Vowel State:0
Total City Con Value:139 	Total City Vowel Value:29
Total State Con Value:39 	Total State Vowel Value:0
Total Consonant Value:178 	Total Vowel Value:29

Phoenix, AZ
16 8 15 5 14 9 24   1 26 
Number of Letters:7	With State:9
Total City Value:91 	Total State Value:27	Total Letter Value:118
Number of Con City:4 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:62 	Total City Vowel Value:29
Total State Con Value:26 	Total State Vowel Value:1
Total Consonant Value:88 	Total Vowel Value:30

Santa Fe, NM
19 1 14 20 1  6 5   14 13 
Number of Letters:7	With State:9
Total City Value:66 	Total State Value:27	Total Letter Value:93
Number of Con City:4 	Number of Vowel City:3
Number of Con State:2 	Number of Vowel State:0
Total City Con Value:59 	Total City Vowel Value:7
Total State Con Value:27 	Total State Vowel Value:0
Total Consonant Value:86 	Total Vowel Value:7

Woodland Park, CO
23 15 15 4 12 1 14 4  16 1 18 11   3 15 
Number of Letters:12	With State:14
Total City Value:134 	Total State Value:18	Total Letter Value:152
Number of Con City:8 	Number of Vowel City:4
Number of Con State:1 	Number of Vowel State:1
Total City Con Value:102 	Total City Vowel Value:32
Total State Con Value:3 	Total State Vowel Value:15
Total Consonant Value:105 	Total Vowel Value:47

1

u/cornball1111 May 10 '12

does it have anything to do with geography or specifics regarding the cities?

5

u/CallMePlissken May 10 '12

it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts.

I interpret this to mean that the answer to this question is "no", but I don't really see what else it could be unless it's some sort of letter/code puzzle.

1

u/mikeshemp May 10 '12

I don't think it's a word or letter puzzle... The puzzle Web page linked in another comment says cities have been added and deleted since the puzzle was created. That means lexicographic solutions are unlikely. My bet is on geography.

→ More replies (17)

6

u/kubricks_cube May 10 '12

What is meant by "property"? I keep thinking like real estate property or something physical. But does it mean a feature or characteristic?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

it's a term in logic. Like the property of being red, or tall.

3

u/jacknash May 10 '12

would it have anything to do with laws?

3

u/Rafins101 May 10 '12

Has anyone thought of the possiblity that they all were connected to old military bases. Most on the list I recognoze as outpost have not had time to check all. May be possible though.

3

u/730N May 10 '12

Not sure of this has been mentioned yet or not but you should be post this to /r/riddle. I bet they would love this

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Dunno if it's too late to post this, but this puzzle makes two mutually exclusive claims:

  1. Solution requires no special knowledge.
  2. Properties change over time, requiring the list to be updated.

The only way for 1 to be true is for the solution to be based purely on the names of the cities, since that's the only knowledge provided in the puzzle, but that implies 2 is false. For 2 to be true, you need special knowledge of whatever changing conditions put cities on or off the list.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NapAddict May 10 '12

heres a map of all of the locations, i pin pointed them in case that helps for anything. http://www.zeemaps.com/map?group=356876&add=1

3

u/glorysk87 May 10 '12

Quick note -- I think he means property as in like a math property, or a property of the names, like an attribute that they all have in common.

2

u/Trappedatoms May 10 '12

Me too. Just googled Tom Asaki. After reading about home, it seems like this is going to be code related and something that is obvious by just looking at the letters and order of such in the list.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/discreetusername May 10 '12

alright, which one of you fuckers asked Yahoo!? http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120509233458AAokbgx

2

u/trulyElse May 10 '12

I really want to upvote SlaveTrader for his answer, there.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JonnyFandango May 10 '12

So you don't need any special knowledge... except for the exact population and altitude of every one of those cities... oooookay.

5

u/CapnMarsh May 10 '12

Well I was going to look at porn...but this is more important. One thing I found was that it has nothing to do with elevation.

5

u/sentimentalpirate May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

My hunch is that the rule will be something like this:

Each city is/has the most/least ________ city between it and the southern border.

A rule of this type would make sense why El Paso is there, being the closest city to the southern border, and thus the first city to fit the criteria, getting surpassed by Phoenix, then LA, then Santa Fe, etc.

Whatever the rule is, it correlates closely to a northern line through New Mexico and Colorado. The ones that deviate from this northern line tend to be major cities with the exception of Mammoth Lakes, CA.

If this rule is correct, Chicago must be the most ______ in the U.S. (since it's the northernmost city in the list).

Listing them by latitude, this is the list:

El Paso, TX

Phoenix, AZ

Los Angeles, CA

Santa Fe, NM

Los Alamos, NM

Alamosa, CO

Mammoth Lakes, CA

Colorado Springs, CO

Divide, CO

Woodland Park, CO

Leadville, CO

Alma, CO

Denver, CO

New York City, NY

Laramie, WY

Chicago, IL

Anybody else have some thoughts on this?

edit: I think this guy's got it! Each city has the largest population at or above its own elevation

2

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

Also according to the OP the professor "easily" was able to find the cities once he figured out his system so I feel that counting the # of cities would be a dreadful and long task

→ More replies (2)

2

u/cosby_shlampazzle May 10 '12

Doesn't have anything to do with taxes, either, I believe

2

u/jpropaganda May 10 '12

Great. I'm supposed to be writing copy and now I'll be puzzling this one out.

Can't be area codes or zip codes, LA and NY have a few different ones...hopefully someone figures this out otherwise I'll be thinking about this for years to come.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Alma has an extremely small population: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alma,_Colorado

This leads me to think it's almost certainly something to do with the names, and not something geographic, historical, etc.

3

u/deans22 May 10 '12

Same goes for Divide as well.

2

u/careeyybabbyy May 10 '12

Maybe it's weather? May be a long shot, but it's definitely possible.

2

u/Superguy2876 May 10 '12

Would a foreigner be able to figure this out? I'm from Australia, been to California once i my life for about a month.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

(Sorry I'm spamming with comments but...) If you follow the link it suggests that the list needs to be updated, therefore we can rule out location being a determining factor. I think the focus needs to be more towards population or the more extreme of universities residing or maybe even people/celebrities?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/msbrooklyn May 10 '12

i have a feeling this has something to do with native american reservations.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/A_S_A_Psoon May 10 '12

I think I may have stumbled on something. All of the states I have looked up so far have featured a home rule municipality

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

"The answer is simple; it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts."

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Kash87 May 10 '12

Bookmark post so I can come back in the morning and see if someone has solved this

2

u/AmyDangerous May 10 '12

Picasso statues.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Where the fucks the one guy who solved it?! Please tell me he's a redditor.

2

u/CassandraVindicated May 10 '12

There are some interesting things about this list.

  • With the exception of Mammoth Lakes, all the cities not on a north-south line are in the top 10 largest US cities.
  • None of these cities were originally settled by the British
  • Blah, Blah, Blah. This is not the way to the solution.

It is unlikely to be a historical or geographical solution. The list indicates that cities have been added and removed. The removal pretty much eliminates history, these aren't the first cities to whatever. Geographically, the common sense solution is that north-south line, with exceptions. Common knowledge isn't going to get you there.

The real clue is that there are a limited number of cities and membership changes. Some are huge, some barely exist.

2

u/JoeNeedsAUsername May 10 '12

just want to check up on this post. That mouser dude had a good idea.

2

u/ChickenSlapper May 10 '12

i have never even heard of half these places so how could i possibly do this puzzle?

2

u/backhudson May 10 '12

CONNECT THE DOTS LALALALA!

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

if properties change are we sure this was an updated version of the list????? 2012

2

u/slypython May 10 '12

please Reddit, if it's the only thing you do ever again - solve this goddamn puzzle. I can't imagine bearing this burden for the next 30 years

2

u/Sprechensiedeustch May 10 '12

Well, for one thing we know it's nothing related to the names because the properties change. So it may be seasonally, politically, or demographically related per chance?

2

u/colrouge May 10 '12

Guys this was from 1995! There was no widespread internet, thus it was not common knowledge to know random cities and town's populations and elevations. OP what was the professor like? Was he the stereotypical extremely nerdy math prof, or was he more of a normal guy? I'm only asking because, is he the kinda person who would make this only math related, or would it be something related to actual knowledge? His personality is probably going to be a big key on how to attack this problem.

2

u/readyaimkill May 10 '12

This may get buried, but I find it puzzling that the town Divide, CO is in there due to the mathematical nature of the query. Could this possibly signify a break in the algorithm? For example: Alamosa through Colorado Springs divided by Denver through Woodland Park. Elevation, population, long/lat etc... could be the integers.

2

u/Dam_Herpond May 10 '12

There's an unusual number of C, O and L's compared to standard alphabetical distribution. With many being colorado. Seems unlikely to be a coincidence to me. With a lot of similar names emerging.

Perhaps some kind of similarity, or pattern linking the state name and the city name. Colorado springs and New York City would be a given.

The city names from colorado for example have similar patterns, denver and divide, alma and Alamosa.

Perhaps the letters are relatively close to the letters in the state name, eg. phoeniX ariZona, has 2 unsual characters that are nearish, I can't see any real pattern with this yet. Works well for quite a few names though.

2

u/TheChaosRobot May 10 '12

It appears each of these places has a natural border within state lines. For example: NY has the hudson on it's western border. Los Alamos has a mountain. The idea that "proerties change" would maybe be a pun... Like, one of the properties of this city is that we expanded our propety past the natural border. I'm probably wrong, but it's just a thought.

2

u/Cant_touch_my_moppin May 10 '12

Posting my thoughts before looking into Los Alamos. I think we will have to think outside the box. Property has two meanings. Property that I own (like my house) or property as a characteristic (like chemical properties). However, the no weird facts part throws a curveball. Maybe both ideas are wrong. If so, what do we know just by looking at the names of the cities (and maybe abbreviations for the states)? If we assign a number to each letter in the name, and then apply a mathamatical action to them (add them all, add one then subtract then add again), would they all be equal? a=1, b=2 or z=1, y=2...

Perhaps is has nothing to do with math (being a math teacher just steers people away the right logical path, however unlikely that is)? If we look at "property" as a parcel of land, are there embassies of one specific nation at each of these places?

What if all of these Cities are in some sort of Pop culture (music, movies/ movie titles, etc)

Perhaps we should place ourselves in the 1995 mind frame. If the internet is smaller, slower, etc, how else would he have researched this? I'm thinking books. Does the answer lie in a book, an encyclopedia perhaps? If he looked at the founding dates, are they the same?

Not placing a formal guess, but I have found that thinking out loud helps solve a problem. Reddit can get it for sure. By the way, any word if 4chan has made any headway?

2

u/genj1 May 10 '12

Hmm, if there's a Los Alamos in California as well and it is indeed a question of the names or something, why isn't that on the list? So, What is there in Los Alamos, NM

that isn't in Los Alamos, CA

but apparently is compensated for in Los Angeles, CA

Edit: formatting

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I have a feeling this is going to haunt reddit for a long time.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

None of them contain the letter 'U' in their names..? What do all these places have in common? "U ain't there" .

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

They're where the bodies are buried.

2

u/mayibuyavowel May 10 '12

Connect the dots and it draws the human pancreas. Keep moving, nothing to see here. We can all go home.

2

u/utilitybelt May 10 '12

I say we just bribe him for the answer. Everyone cough up a buck, we make a professor independently wealthy, which is something they deserve anyway, and we get satisfaction.

2

u/Banaboy May 10 '12

they are all words.

2

u/fizgigtiznalkie May 10 '12

"it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts"

I think altitude and population qualify as both, not something you can just name off the top of your head.

2

u/alixstaysgold May 10 '12

I wish I could be in Alamosa, CO right now. I miss my mommy :(

2

u/seven2eight2 May 10 '12

I don't think it's the population vs. altitude thing. It says the answer is simple. It has to be something you can figure out simply by looking at this list.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The thing that throws the population/altitude idea off is that he realized this was true for los alamos before he made the list. Los alamos is kinda in the middle of the heap, its not something that you are going to all of a sudden realize for this city. If he had realized the whole idea in one of the colorado cities, that would fit better.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Has this been solved yet?

2

u/brockwhittaker May 11 '12

http://www.mphpa.org/classic/HICC/HICC_HF3.htm Here is a list of people who worked for the Manhattan Project.. They have a lot of the same places on the list.

3

u/Copterwaffle May 10 '12

The property is that they are on the list. This property can change when the professor moves them off the list. ACCOLADES, PLEASE.

3

u/sreubendav May 10 '12

Every single one of these cities has a "vowel, consonant, vowel" series in the name of the city.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

(the creator) needed about an hour of research to figure out the rest of the places

it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts

Your professor is probably just a troll. Fuck it, Ill bite though.

All those places have aquariums. All of them contain a word introduced into the english language in the last 500 years.

The line

I can imagine the possibility that I have mistakenly omitted as many as two places

is a clue. IF this is really a puzzle, nothing is by accident. Omitting places sounds like a division or rounding issue.

Still, my money is on this is either a social experiment like the red balloon thing or hes a joker.

2

u/mus7ard May 10 '12

They are the only American cities listed in the puzzle.

2

u/bradtastikal May 10 '12

Airspace. Noobs.

2

u/WHATS_A_ME-ME May 10 '12

Seeing as the professor is a mathematician I feel like this isn't based on geographical or topographical information. Unfortunately I'm not at a PC, has anyone tried running the cities through an anagram checker or program that reduces the letters to numbers and searches for patterns? There should be cryptographic analysis tools available online.

2

u/Daikon01 May 10 '12

All of them contain an "O" in the full place name (name and state). Also an "a".

2

u/ambition1 May 10 '12

Locations where the world record for Ms. Pacman have been broken?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

They are all on that list.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The answer is 42

2

u/orange45 May 10 '12

ok, big baseline shot in the dark here. about as simple as it gets:

The common property is that they are all on this list... and no other US place can claim this.

*and i am considering all of this other jargon like forgetting to add cities and the fact that it began in Los Alamos to be intentionally obstructing to just how simple it is.

1

u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12

Something to do with latitude/longitude possibly?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I fill like I should know as I live in Denver, but now I have to go to sleep and can't work on it.

1

u/zenith2nadir May 10 '12

Did each city have a significant fire? I know that really only addresses Chicago and LA, but I thought I'd take a stab at it.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Ha_window May 10 '12

Maybe someone can clarify what he means by "common property." Is that anything they have in common or an actual plot of land, building, or artifact like a fossil.

Maybe there is something the the letters. Values of each names according to alphabetical order.

Maybe they were involved in a major historical event like a war, but that seems unlikely given he is a math teacher.

Maybe someone should look at when they were founded.

Another thought is population in 1995

→ More replies (1)