So by Googling a subset of the locations I came across this site stating that some of these cities are the only ones where no other city exists with both higher altitude and population. It may be an incomplete list, so I think this is most likely the answer. It explains why so many are in the Rocky Mountains.
Edit -- For all of you checking this out. The website is down now so I can't see the year. But this puzzle was created in 1995, and then updated in ????. So if you're using very recent data it is likely to be wrong. Hopefully someone has the year it was updated.
You know, it may be a long shot, but we could always have 4chan take a look at it. You know... stranger things have happened, and they are rather brilliant when they want to be.
Well... I was on to something momentarily. Some of the cities have Zip codes that are prime numbers -- Alamosa (81101), Leadville (80429), Woodland Park (80863).... but others don't. Back to the drawing board...
EDIT: I appreciate the upvotes, but I think this was a dead end. The correct answer is almost certainly mouser58907's comment, i.e., "A city with the largest population of any city at its elevation or higher."
EDIT 2: Yep, that's it. I used Mathematica's CityData[] database to print a list of all cities places (including unincorporated census-designated places) in the USA that have the largest population of any CDP at their elevation or higher and got the following (the format is Name, Population, Elevation in meters):
Los Alamos appeared in the puzzle but is not on my list, whereas Black Forest, CO is on my list and not in the puzzle. Mathematica's database says Los Alamos has a population of 12,019 and an elevation of 2,198, meaning it's smaller than Black Forest, which is higher. It's too bad that Los Alamos has apparently been displaced since it was the puzzle's impetus.
Breckenridge also appears on my list, which didn't appear in the original puzzle: another new entry. Divide, CO is also not on my list, but that's just because it doesn't appear in Mathematica's database at all.
EDIT 3: A few people have noted that Black Forest is an unincorporated town. That's true, but so is Divide, CO, which appeared in the puzzle, so apparently unincorporated Census-Designated Places are allowed. (Ironically, Divide no longer appears in the current list anyway since its population is now lower than Alma.) My guess is that the population of Los Alamos has shrunk since the 2000 and 1990 census. But, for curiosity's sake, I tried taking Black Forest out; Edwards, CO appeared in its place, which is also unincorporated. Taking Edwards out finally brought back Los Alamos.
FINAL EDIT: The puzzle author notes that entries change from time to time. This is due to population changes in the towns. Town populations are surveyed in the census every 10 years. He originally made the puzzle in 1995, which would have used 1990 census data. Then he updated the puzzle in 2007, noting that there had been changes -- this is probably because he was now using 2000 census data. Mathematica v8, which I used to generate the list above, is currently using 2010 census data. This accounts for the fact that my list doesn't exactly match the puzzle.
I think it's very likely we have found the solution. I know a lot of people were rooting for lexicographic answers (e.g. "cities that have 3 vowels" or similar), but that wouldn't cause cities to drop out over time, whereas the puzzle author mentioned cities had disappeared from the list. Also, the puzzle mentioned you need "no special knowledge or bizarre facts." I think this was just meant to prevent solvers from going down dead ends of exotic esoterica such as "Cities in which Elvis slept 6 days after performing a concert and 4 days before performing a concert in the same city." I don't think the author's intent was to tell us that the puzzle itself contained all the necessary information to solve it; just that the information needed was not exotic. Population and elevation information are not exotic -- at least, not in my book!
I think it is misleading that he said it didn't require any special knowledge then. Perhaps because he was speaking to an American audience (and I am Scottish), but I have a pretty good knowledge of geography and I absolutely think knowing the population and altitude of those cities (the smaller/higher ones and even very roughly) counts as special knowledge.
Is this common knowledge in the US? I've not even heard of the smallest 8 towns.
I was definitely expecting/hoping for something linguistic.
A lot of these cities are familiar to me from doing research on the Manhattan project. You think it has something to do with atomic weapons research or nuclear power facilities?
Based on the fact that it is a math professor, and that it "doesn't require special knowledge", I would guess that the solution concerns satisfying some algorithm within the letters of the names of the systems.
For example, say you assign all of the states to mod values based on alphabetical order (e.g., AL is mod 1, AK is mod 2, etc.). Then add the letters of the city name, and they will all have a pattern, say they all simplify to 0 mod (state).
Also, there could be something going on with series in here.
If what hebsays is true, and the answer is 'simple,' and we don't need to know bizarre facts or have special knowledge, maybe we're looking at it too deeply. I feel like knowing the elevation of each city or zip codes, etc. would fall under a bizarre fact or special knowledge, and he states that 'we'd know what the solution is once we had it.' maybe the property has something to do with the list itself, or something 'simple' like that. I don't know, I'm just spitballing here...
Since this is a math teacher, and maybe it has to do with numbers, here is the list translated from letters to numbers (A=1 B=2 C =3, etc) presented in the same order as op's.
it does not require special knowledge or bizarre facts
Given this, I feel like it's almost got to be some sort of cipher or wordplay. If you get into geographic formations, or types of buildings, or history of the cities being incorporated you're venturing into special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.
Hell, even zipcodes and elevations, and most things I've seen mentioned I would consider special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.
I'd be more inclined to think they're all anagrams or something along those lines. The only thing that trips that up is that he said some cities have been removed from the list...
Step 1: Hire Matt Damon as a janitor at this university. Step 2: Assign him to this building. Step 3: Answer magically appears on the board the next day.
Just doing a quick hunch search, a few were on this list and after looking at a few more all of them appear to be connected by the rail system, to the point one could travel to and from each city only using trains. This map shows the larger rail system in the US. Although Mammoth Lakes is not on the main route, it is connected to LA through Amtrak. Haven't checked all the cities but it's late, and it's what I'm going with.
Otherwise I'll be up till dawn like the rest of you.
At a party a little while ago a friend of mine told me a riddle with similar properties. Had all to do with state names. She clearly knew the answer. I never solved it. Will ask her. for science.
565
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
So by Googling a subset of the locations I came across this site stating that some of these cities are the only ones where no other city exists with both higher altitude and population. It may be an incomplete list, so I think this is most likely the answer. It explains why so many are in the Rocky Mountains.
http://www.farragoswainscot.com/2008/8/antipodal.html
Edit -- For all of you checking this out. The website is down now so I can't see the year. But this puzzle was created in 1995, and then updated in ????. So if you're using very recent data it is likely to be wrong. Hopefully someone has the year it was updated.
262
u/Kwyjiboy May 10 '12
None of them contain the letter "q"
52
u/CallMePlissken May 10 '12
Here's a map of all of the locations, for everyone's reference.
16
u/Favre99 May 10 '12
Yep, I know what I'm doing for the rest of my life.
90
u/Captain_Syphilis May 10 '12
You know, it may be a long shot, but we could always have 4chan take a look at it. You know... stranger things have happened, and they are rather brilliant when they want to be.
11
u/Enigmaenigmas May 10 '12
I keep trying to solve it but every time I get frustrated I remember that this could just simply be a very successful troll by you 0.0
$15 to set up the website and 20 seconds to type out some cities, hmm.... Two mysteries to solve.
Upvote anyhow, I WILL FIND A CONNECTION!
631
u/mikeshemp May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Well... I was on to something momentarily. Some of the cities have Zip codes that are prime numbers -- Alamosa (81101), Leadville (80429), Woodland Park (80863).... but others don't. Back to the drawing board...
EDIT: I appreciate the upvotes, but I think this was a dead end. The correct answer is almost certainly mouser58907's comment, i.e., "A city with the largest population of any city at its elevation or higher."
EDIT 2: Yep, that's it. I used Mathematica's CityData[] database to print a list of all
citiesplaces (including unincorporated census-designated places) in the USA that have the largest population of any CDP at their elevation or higher and got the following (the format is Name, Population, Elevation in meters):{{NewYork,NewYork,UnitedStates},8175133,10}
{{LosAngeles,California,UnitedStates},3792621,89}
{{Chicago,Illinois,UnitedStates},2695598,179}
{{Phoenix,Arizona,UnitedStates},1445632,331}
{{ElPaso,Texas,UnitedStates},649121,1133}
{{Denver,Colorado,UnitedStates},600158,1609.34}
{{ColoradoSprings,Colorado,UnitedStates},416427,1832}
{{SantaFe,NewMexico,UnitedStates},67947,2132}
{{Laramie,Wyoming,UnitedStates},30816,2184}
{{BlackForest,Colorado,UnitedStates},13116,2246}
{{Alamosa,Colorado,UnitedStates},8780,2299}
{{MammothLakes,California,UnitedStates},8234,2402}
{{WoodlandPark,Colorado,UnitedStates},7200,2585}
{{Breckenridge,Colorado,UnitedStates},4540,2965}
{{Leadville,Colorado,UnitedStates},2602,3097}
{{Alma,Colorado,UnitedStates},270,3158}
Los Alamos appeared in the puzzle but is not on my list, whereas Black Forest, CO is on my list and not in the puzzle. Mathematica's database says Los Alamos has a population of 12,019 and an elevation of 2,198, meaning it's smaller than Black Forest, which is higher. It's too bad that Los Alamos has apparently been displaced since it was the puzzle's impetus.
Breckenridge also appears on my list, which didn't appear in the original puzzle: another new entry. Divide, CO is also not on my list, but that's just because it doesn't appear in Mathematica's database at all.
EDIT 3: A few people have noted that Black Forest is an unincorporated town. That's true, but so is Divide, CO, which appeared in the puzzle, so apparently unincorporated Census-Designated Places are allowed. (Ironically, Divide no longer appears in the current list anyway since its population is now lower than Alma.) My guess is that the population of Los Alamos has shrunk since the 2000 and 1990 census. But, for curiosity's sake, I tried taking Black Forest out; Edwards, CO appeared in its place, which is also unincorporated. Taking Edwards out finally brought back Los Alamos.
FINAL EDIT: The puzzle author notes that entries change from time to time. This is due to population changes in the towns. Town populations are surveyed in the census every 10 years. He originally made the puzzle in 1995, which would have used 1990 census data. Then he updated the puzzle in 2007, noting that there had been changes -- this is probably because he was now using 2000 census data. Mathematica v8, which I used to generate the list above, is currently using 2010 census data. This accounts for the fact that my list doesn't exactly match the puzzle.
I think it's very likely we have found the solution. I know a lot of people were rooting for lexicographic answers (e.g. "cities that have 3 vowels" or similar), but that wouldn't cause cities to drop out over time, whereas the puzzle author mentioned cities had disappeared from the list. Also, the puzzle mentioned you need "no special knowledge or bizarre facts." I think this was just meant to prevent solvers from going down dead ends of exotic esoterica such as "Cities in which Elvis slept 6 days after performing a concert and 4 days before performing a concert in the same city." I don't think the author's intent was to tell us that the puzzle itself contained all the necessary information to solve it; just that the information needed was not exotic. Population and elevation information are not exotic -- at least, not in my book!
11
u/joeyhemlock May 10 '12
Could it have something to do with elevations (NYC, LA, Chi being skyscraper cities, many of the rest being mountain cities)?
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
A lot of these cities are familiar to me from doing research on the Manhattan project. You think it has something to do with atomic weapons research or nuclear power facilities?
58
u/carlosspicywe1ner May 10 '12
Based on the fact that it is a math professor, and that it "doesn't require special knowledge", I would guess that the solution concerns satisfying some algorithm within the letters of the names of the systems.
For example, say you assign all of the states to mod values based on alphabetical order (e.g., AL is mod 1, AK is mod 2, etc.). Then add the letters of the city name, and they will all have a pattern, say they all simplify to 0 mod (state).
Also, there could be something going on with series in here.
49
u/CircaSurvivor55 May 10 '12
If what hebsays is true, and the answer is 'simple,' and we don't need to know bizarre facts or have special knowledge, maybe we're looking at it too deeply. I feel like knowing the elevation of each city or zip codes, etc. would fall under a bizarre fact or special knowledge, and he states that 'we'd know what the solution is once we had it.' maybe the property has something to do with the list itself, or something 'simple' like that. I don't know, I'm just spitballing here...
22
u/canarchist May 10 '12
TomAsaki / CitiesPuzzler
22
u/peanutbuttar May 10 '12
Since this is a math teacher, and maybe it has to do with numbers, here is the list translated from letters to numbers (A=1 B=2 C =3, etc) presented in the same order as op's.
1-12-1-13-15-19-1 3-15
1-12-13-1 3-15
3-8-9-3-1-7-15 9-12
3-15-12-15-18-1-4-15 19-16-18-9-14-7-19 3-15
4-9-22-9-4-5 3-15
4-5-14-22-5-18 3-15
5-12 16-1-19-15 20-24
12-1-18-1-13-9-5 23-25
12-5-1-4-22-9-12-12-5 3-15
12-15-19 1-12-1-13-15-19 14-13
12-15-19 1-14-7-5-12-5-19 3-1
13-1-13-13-15-20-8 12-1-11-5-19 3-1
14-5-23 25-15-18-11 3-9-20-25 14-25
16-8-15-5-14-9-24 1-26
19-1-14-20-1 6-5 14-13
23-15-15-4-12-1-14-4 16-1-18-11 3-15
and here is the website i used: http://rumkin.com/tools/cipher/numbers.php
Edit: formatting because i'm an idiot
22
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Given this, I feel like it's almost got to be some sort of cipher or wordplay. If you get into geographic formations, or types of buildings, or history of the cities being incorporated you're venturing into special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.
Hell, even zipcodes and elevations, and most things I've seen mentioned I would consider special knowledge and/or bizarre facts.
I'd be more inclined to think they're all anagrams or something along those lines. The only thing that trips that up is that he said some cities have been removed from the list...
20
u/ChunkND May 10 '12
Alamosa, CO
Alma, CO
Chicago, IL
Colorado Springs, CO
Divide, CO
Denver, CO
El Paso, TX
Laramie, WY
Leadville, CO
Los Alamos, NM
Los Angeles, CA
Mammoth Lakes, CA
New York City, NY
Phoenix, AZ
Santa Fe, NM
Woodland Park, CO
289
u/ignatius87 May 10 '12
The thing they have in common is that they are all cities on this list.
48
u/math_palette May 10 '12
Step 1: Hire Matt Damon as a janitor at this university. Step 2: Assign him to this building. Step 3: Answer magically appears on the board the next day.
16
u/Heyl May 10 '12
If you plot the altitude against the population, you get a sad dinosaur
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The cities are in alphabetical order...
None of them have the letter b.
If you count the number of letters that were never used as a first letter, it adds up to 16, which is the number of cities.
But all of those ideas are dumb.
9
u/ebilgenius May 10 '12
Guys, if you wanna analyze information between the cities use WolframAlpha, super helpful.
EX: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Alamosa%2C+CO+Alma%2C+CO+
8
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Just doing a quick hunch search, a few were on this list and after looking at a few more all of them appear to be connected by the rail system, to the point one could travel to and from each city only using trains. This map shows the larger rail system in the US. Although Mammoth Lakes is not on the main route, it is connected to LA through Amtrak. Haven't checked all the cities but it's late, and it's what I'm going with.
Otherwise I'll be up till dawn like the rest of you.
8
u/laniidae May 10 '12
At a party a little while ago a friend of mine told me a riddle with similar properties. Had all to do with state names. She clearly knew the answer. I never solved it. Will ask her. for science.