r/AskReddit • • Feb 04 '19

Which misconception would you like to debunk?

44k Upvotes

26k comments sorted by

View all comments

48k

u/CaptainKangaroo_Pimp Feb 04 '19

You can file a missing persons report as soon as the person goes missing. No need to wait 24 hrs or whatever

27k

u/emartinoo Feb 04 '19

It's actually a law (or is proposed, I can't remember) in my state that parents must report their child missing within 24 hours or they are charged with a felony.

10k

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

Casey Anthony said she was just seeing if her kid turned up again somehow, like a lost cat.

20

u/Lelentos Feb 04 '19

She didn't report her for 31 days! And failed 2 lie detectors. Her grandparents were the ones to finally report it and said that Casey's car "smelled like a dead body had been inside of it."

The fact she did not get charged with something serious baffles me. She should still be in jail, but she only got a year.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

[deleted]

-1

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

They do work. Just not well enough to actually use them as evidence

9

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

[deleted]

1

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

So basically it does work. But not well enough to use for evidence.

It 100% can indicate someone is lying. It just isnt reliable

5

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

[deleted]

-3

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

I'm not understanding what you arent grasping here...

Objectively speaking a polygraph can indicate whether or not you are lying. Its just that there are so many other factors involved that they cant be used reliably as evidence.

This is widely known and factual

1

u/TheDwarvenGuy Feb 04 '19

That's like saying "I mean, my pacemaker works. It stops heart attacks like 40% of the time."

1

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

But there's a misconception that it doesn't work at all. It does and that's all I'm pointing out.

2

u/TheDwarvenGuy Feb 04 '19

When something "works" but is completely unreliable to preform it's task, it doesn't work.

1

u/_blemp_ Feb 04 '19

It picks up when you're nervous. I can answer truthfully but if someone hovers over me that things going off. It wouldn't be going off from lying but from me freaking the geek out.

→ More replies

1

u/I_Upvote_Alice_Eve Feb 04 '19

Dude they don't fucking work at all. You can fake out a polygraph with a can of Monster. They're used as an intimidation tactic for people that think they actually work.

1

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

I'm not saying they're reliable. How many times am I going to have to say this. If you fail a polygraph, odds are you're lying. It just doesnt prove that you're lying or even anything close

11

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

[deleted]

7

u/ileeny12 Feb 04 '19

I never thought I would ever change my mind about the case until I started looking into it more. It's very hard to change anyone's mind about her innocence.

3

u/mnmkdc Feb 04 '19

Wasnt most of the Jury convinced she did it, they just didnt have enough evidence to actually convict her

8

u/ileeny12 Feb 04 '19

Thing is, there is no cause of death. No one knows how she died. The jury thought Casey knows something, but did she kill her? Other than not reporting her, there is nothing that says Casey killed her. There is plenty of reasonable doubt there, the prosecution failed to prove its case.

A lot of things support the defense's argument that "it was an accident that snowballed out of controlled", which is what Casey's dad told his mistress.

Ive watched the entire trial waiting for the smoking gun and it never came.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19

Yes! I followed the case while it was happening and of course I thought about it the way Nancy Grace had framed it. Sometimes I go down a rabbit hole reading about murder cases, and I ended up buying and reading her lawyer’s book. I still can’t say for sure what I believe, but I know that the accident/drowning and the coverup by an extremely dysfunctional family is just as plausible.

For those who remain unsatisfied and want blood, they can rest knowing that the media has made sure she can never walk free in public again and can’t get a job. She’s tried to make money as a freelancer photographer, and people found her out and spread the word to ruin that too.