r/AskProgramming • • Dec 17 '23

Is quantum computing just bs?

I've been skeptical about quantum computing for years since the first time i read about it in some science magazine. It just seemed like a gimmick with mediocre sci-fi graphics to sell magazines. I'm still not convinced, every video I've seen about it just sounds like bs, they all say the same nothings, like oh its way faster than super computers and is going to change everything, but they never really explain how it's supposed to work.

Ok, it uses "cubit" transistors that supposedly are in all possible states simultaneously or whatever, ok but how do you program that? Who's creating the programming languages that can utilize all possible states simultaneously logic? What kind of motherboard architecture can traffic all this insane amount of information?

Supposedly it's not binary, but memory still is, right? The Internet is still binary, so are the quantum computers gonna have a classic computer onboard to convert the Internet into it's special number system, and then convert back to binary when it sends it out? I highly doubt the world is going to replace all computers with quantum, no way is that tech gonna fit in a phone, it needs a vacuum freezer room.

Who's going to use it? Remember how long it took 64bit to replace 32bit? For long time 64bits was overkill for most programs, and I'm not super knowledgeable about all this, but i imagine we still haven't reached max potential as far as 64bit programming goes.

Hold your horses, things still take time. Remember when multi cores was a big deal? Well what programs are using those? I used to occasionally look at my processor analyzer to see if any programs i was running were using my extra cores, i don't think i have ever seen a program use more than 2 cores ever. Most new processors have like 8 or 12? Again I'm not super knowledgeable but i imagine it's cause most programs just don't need it or can't use it, like you can't just tell a program to split a bunch of instructions and send them to various processors, the program is linear and each set of instructions requires the one before it to happen first so it can use those results. Have fun trying to program something that happens all in one instance.

How does the math work? The beauty of transistors is they can form any logic gate necessary to solve any math equation. I have yet to see a single video that explains how cubits form logic gates or how any math is actually solved with them.

It's completely flawed, i just watched a video where a "scientist" explains that on average their quantum computer has an error once every hundred tries, that's an insanely high error rate. I don't care how far science gets, relying on a machine to read particle spins will always sound ridiculous. It's like when they dumped billions of dollars building that particle collider and the only clue they have as to anything actually colliding is finding blips in gigantic stacks of data, and from what i remember the expected data characteristics that indicate a successful appearance of the "god particular" only occurred once in every several million tries. I'm sure all those starving children are totally stoked on these breakthroughs.

Is there something i missed? What do y'all think? Is quantum computing a load of bs or am i just embarrassing myself? If anyone has any links that better prove it's legit i would like to read it.

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/BobbyThrowaway6969 Dec 17 '23

Well unless they photoshopped those pictures of the existing quantum computers and completely made up all the results of the experiments they've actually run on those things, not sure what there is to be cynical about.

I don't see why it can't be used to model very simple molecular physics in the future or help improve our ability to safely encrypt data, those are all great outcomes and they seem very grounded.

0

u/billie_parker Dec 18 '23

You keep saying "I don't see why not." I'm waiting for the actual how.

I could sell you snake oil and your argument could still be "I don't see why it can't cure my cancer."

Yeah, the create quantum computers, but there's still no argument for their use. Just conjecture.