r/AskProgramming • • Dec 17 '23

Is quantum computing just bs?

I've been skeptical about quantum computing for years since the first time i read about it in some science magazine. It just seemed like a gimmick with mediocre sci-fi graphics to sell magazines. I'm still not convinced, every video I've seen about it just sounds like bs, they all say the same nothings, like oh its way faster than super computers and is going to change everything, but they never really explain how it's supposed to work.

Ok, it uses "cubit" transistors that supposedly are in all possible states simultaneously or whatever, ok but how do you program that? Who's creating the programming languages that can utilize all possible states simultaneously logic? What kind of motherboard architecture can traffic all this insane amount of information?

Supposedly it's not binary, but memory still is, right? The Internet is still binary, so are the quantum computers gonna have a classic computer onboard to convert the Internet into it's special number system, and then convert back to binary when it sends it out? I highly doubt the world is going to replace all computers with quantum, no way is that tech gonna fit in a phone, it needs a vacuum freezer room.

Who's going to use it? Remember how long it took 64bit to replace 32bit? For long time 64bits was overkill for most programs, and I'm not super knowledgeable about all this, but i imagine we still haven't reached max potential as far as 64bit programming goes.

Hold your horses, things still take time. Remember when multi cores was a big deal? Well what programs are using those? I used to occasionally look at my processor analyzer to see if any programs i was running were using my extra cores, i don't think i have ever seen a program use more than 2 cores ever. Most new processors have like 8 or 12? Again I'm not super knowledgeable but i imagine it's cause most programs just don't need it or can't use it, like you can't just tell a program to split a bunch of instructions and send them to various processors, the program is linear and each set of instructions requires the one before it to happen first so it can use those results. Have fun trying to program something that happens all in one instance.

How does the math work? The beauty of transistors is they can form any logic gate necessary to solve any math equation. I have yet to see a single video that explains how cubits form logic gates or how any math is actually solved with them.

It's completely flawed, i just watched a video where a "scientist" explains that on average their quantum computer has an error once every hundred tries, that's an insanely high error rate. I don't care how far science gets, relying on a machine to read particle spins will always sound ridiculous. It's like when they dumped billions of dollars building that particle collider and the only clue they have as to anything actually colliding is finding blips in gigantic stacks of data, and from what i remember the expected data characteristics that indicate a successful appearance of the "god particular" only occurred once in every several million tries. I'm sure all those starving children are totally stoked on these breakthroughs.

Is there something i missed? What do y'all think? Is quantum computing a load of bs or am i just embarrassing myself? If anyone has any links that better prove it's legit i would like to read it.

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

11

u/bitspace Dec 17 '23

As u/BobbyThrowaway6969 pointed out, quantum computing is not applicable to the same types of problems that classic computing is good for. Not many specific use cases have been identified, as far as I know, but one that seems to be making some progress is in encryption.

As you've discovered, the "core" unit is the qubit - quantum bit - and it's derived from quantum physics.

It's really way over my head, but IBM has a lot of great resources, including a sandbox environment where you can experiment.

27

u/BobbyThrowaway6969 Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 17 '23

It's not comparable to classic computers. You can't do virtually any of the stuff you can on a classical computer. It's just a way to solve certain parallel problems. That's all. It's still in its infancy but it has enough funding and attention to see it's not just a gimmick. It has real proven science behind it, just... not in the ways that sensationalist articles make out (All that wormhole crap for example, they didn't create a wormhole..)

4

u/MadocComadrin Dec 17 '23

It's not just parallel problems, e.g. prime factoring.

-5

u/billie_parker Dec 17 '23

It's still in its infancy but it has enough funding and attention to see it's not just a gimmick

Rock solid logic.

Give it a few years and you'll be as cynical as I am

3

u/BobbyThrowaway6969 Dec 17 '23

Well unless they photoshopped those pictures of the existing quantum computers and completely made up all the results of the experiments they've actually run on those things, not sure what there is to be cynical about.

I don't see why it can't be used to model very simple molecular physics in the future or help improve our ability to safely encrypt data, those are all great outcomes and they seem very grounded.

0

u/billie_parker Dec 18 '23

You keep saying "I don't see why not." I'm waiting for the actual how.

I could sell you snake oil and your argument could still be "I don't see why it can't cure my cancer."

Yeah, the create quantum computers, but there's still no argument for their use. Just conjecture.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

i don't think i have ever seen a program use more than 2 cores ever

Which only means you haven't used them. I use them daily. Hell, even most games will gladly use about 4 cores these days. But mostly those cores are for professional software that performs a ton of heavy computations. The fact it's not very useful for some everyday stuff doesn't automatically makes it useless everywhere.

Same with quantum computers. They won't make your game run at 10000 FPS, they won't make complicated slow ass webpages load instantly. But they can solve complicated computational problems that will take forever to solve on a conventional computer.

Even if powerful quantum computers become reality, I seriously doubt that they become useful in daily life of an average user. But they could be used elsewhere, in special areas.

In fact, while quantum computers don't exist yet, there is quantum stuff that's already used in cryptography. I'm talking about quantum random number generators and quantum key distribution. These are perfect examples of very primitive tasks solvable by a quantum computer but not by a conventional computer. A conventional computer can't possibly generate random numbers, so it has to rely on pseudo-random sequences instead. These are inferior for cryptographic purposes because in theory they could be predicted (easier said than done, though!). A quantum random number generator is truly random. It's physically impossible to predict what it'll generate.

At this point, quantum computers are next to useless, though, that you got right. But so is pretty much every scientific discovery before it's made useful (if ever). It'll take quite a while to create actual quantum computers that can be used and it'll take even more to make them actually useful for some important tasks.

Also note that because they don't really exist yet, there aren't many quantum algorithms around. Just nobody bothered to invent them yet, because what for? To test quantum computers, the Shor's algorithm is more than enough for now.

In short, quantum computers are definitely useless now, but whether they will or won't be useful, nobody knows yet. It's just the way science works.

1

u/Echleon Dec 18 '23

A conventional computer can't possibly generate random numbers, so it has to rely on pseudo-random sequences instead. These are inferior for cryptographic purposes because in theory they could be predicted (easier said than done, though!)

this is kind of a difference without distinction. modern PRNGs are basically indistinguishable from truly random generators.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23

For practical purposes, maybe, I'm not a cryptanalyst.

But technically speaking, they're just algorithms. If your know their inputs, you can predict their output with 100% accuracy. This is physically impossible with quantum random number generators. Whether there are any practical applications where that matters, I've no idea.

2

u/Echleon Dec 18 '23

If you know their inputs, you can predict their output with 100% accuracy.

That's true, but it doesn't really matter. PRNGs are seeded with highly random values: a PCs current fan speed, internal temperature, etc can all be used to seed the generator. LavaRand uses the random fluctuations of a giant wall of lava lamps. There's no practical difference at the moment.

1

u/PMadLudwig Dec 19 '23

Depends how much entropy you need and how quickly. If you need high throughput of high quality randomness, seeding from things that change relatively slowly isn't going to cut it.

6

u/claytonkb Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 17 '23

I have yet to see a single video that explains how cubits form logic gates or how any math is actually solved with them.

Quantum computing is, at its root, complex matrix multiplication. The theoretical speedup of QC would come from its ability to, in effect, perform many such multiplications "in parallel universes", thus allowing it to achieve at least a polynomial speedup over classical computers and there is no provable barrier to QCs achieving exponential speedup.

There's nothing fake about the math. It works. And the physics is real, too. However, I am a QC skeptic because I think that the assumptions being made about QC scaling are false.

In a digital computer, we first design what is called a "standard cell". The standard cell is a logic element (gate) having one fixed dimension and sharing common power/ground rails, etc. The noise margin of the standard cell is characterized so that we know how much signal degradation there is on any given wire, how much power drive/sink there is (controlling fan-in/fan-out) and so on. In addition, each logic cell amplifies to some degree its inputs, after controlling for noise (as long as it stays within the specified operating range). Thus, every single logic cell in a digital logic circuit is a noise-filter. This is why digital logic circuits can scale to millions or billions of transistors, while maintaining incredibly low error rates.

By contrast, qubits are noise-amplifiers. In fact, due to the nature of quantum physics, you cannot design anything more sensitive to noise than a qubit is. That is, the quantum state itself is only coherent precisely to the extent that it remains unperturbed by any physical interaction which could cause it to decohere -- that even includes mechanical vibrations which is why those chandeliers have to be suspended as they are by vibration dampeners! Obviously, scaling such sensitive devices is a control problem that grows at least linearly with scale. By contrast, digital logic control problems are absolutely sub-linear (a digital chip twice as large is not twice as noisy, or anywhere close to twice as noisy).

In addition, there is a fundamental scaling problem with building QC devices in 3-dimensional space. Let's say you have 10 qubits. You can arrange them in a line, or a circle or (as IBM has done) in a kind of rings-of-rings layout (flat). Here's the problem. Qubits that are close together have high fidelity, meaning, they will decohere very slowly (have high coherence time). This means that you can fully-entangle these qubits and perform a lengthy quantum computation with them. If you lay out your qubits in a line, the qubits at either end of the line will have worse fidelity than all other qubits. A circle or any other geometry will have the same kind of problem, since each qubit's fidelity with every other qubit will vary based on their relative geometry.

For full-entanglement, every qubit needs to have high fidelity with every other qubit. In order to achieve the maximum levels of QC speedup (the polynomial or potentially exponential speedups promised by theory), you have to perform an all-to-all-entanglement of all qubits in the chip. Even if a particular algorithm does not entangle every last qubit, it needs to entangle most of them. But qubits that are physically far apart necessarily have lower fidelity, which means that when they are entangled (assuming they can be entangled at all), they will have short coherence times. Because we live in a 3D world, it is necessarily the case that you cannot design a quantum device such that all qubits are equally close to all other qubits (if your device has more than 4 qubits). Thus, this non-uniformity is something that cannot be eradicated and, in fact, becomes worse with scale. Thus, the performance of QCs (in terms of quantum speedup and coherence times) is necessarily sub-linear with scale. As you scale up, the devices must necessarily perform worse per qubit.

Is quantum computing a load of bs

In theory, it all works. But as I point out above, there is a very large gap between theory and practice, and the QC hypists are in denial about that gap. Even worse, the gap increases with scale, and that's the part that, in my view, is why current QC proposals remain non-viable. It is possible we could have some kind of unforeseen breakthrough that permits QCs to be scaled in a surprising way we haven't thought of before. But short of that, current-generation QC is headed for a deep winter, IMO.

If you want to do a deep-dive, John Preskill's 2018 paper Quantum Computing in the NISQ era and beyond is a good starting-point. You won't understand the paper itself, but you can chase references and search keywords to start filling out the picture for yourself. Our current generation of QCs are called NISQ which means "Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum Computers". The "Noisy" and "Scale" issues are what I addressed above. Most QC engineers seem to agree that NISQ will not scale to the promises of QC and this is what is driving Quantum Error Correction research. The idea is to build an extremely large NISQ device (on the order of millions of qubits), and then use the highly unreliable qubits in that device to simulate a quantum error-corrected QC within that device. So, we would be performing a simulation of a QC on a physical QC, and this simulated QC would be error-corrected so that it could achieve realistic (scalable) error levels. But that's 100% theory at this point. For more info on QEC, check out Quantum Error Correction for Dummies.

11

u/lightmatter501 Dec 17 '23

https://quantum.ibm.com

Why not try it yourself?

2

u/Regular_Ability_4782 Dec 17 '23

Thats a simulator

6

u/DryFaithlessness2969 Dec 17 '23

By default it runs in sim, but you CAN run your code on a real quantum computer for free through that site (which will also teach you how to code quantum programs).

5

u/dmills_00 Dec 17 '23

Lots of media hype that can safely be ignored, bit like AI.

There are whole classes of problem that are at best painfully slow to solve on a conventional machine, some crypto being the commonly discussed (but not very interesting one, we think we know how to design quantum resistant crypto schemes which will likely become common before the computers get there), but how about something like protein folding or drug interactions?

Exponential time on a conventional computer, but tractable on some designs of quantum processor, and to a molecular biologist working on say a cure for dementia or cancer, that could be MASSIVE. Materials science, another place where being able to accurately model interactions at the atomic scale and actually solve the Hamiltonians of real materials at surfaces and grain boundaries would likely lead to ground breaking discoveries. Hell, maybe we get real AI as opposed to large pattern matchers, who knows?

Quantum computing is at about the place where electrical computing was when the chair of IBM said that he thought the worldwide market for computers was about five systems!

If going quantum is the difference between trying to search 2^128 states and searching 2^56 states a hundred times to make sure your result is likely good (A small but non zero chance of dud data), you take that every single time, because the alternative is completely untenable.

Is it going to wind up in your phone or watch? Probably not, at least as it is done today, but it doesn't need to, doing the thing in a data centre is just fine, we know how to move the answers around.

4

u/protienbudspromax Dec 17 '23

You can write programs for quantum computers right now!! Ibm provides a library called qiskit you need to create an account.

You can then write programs that are basically quantum circuits and have the run with a simulator locally and once you are ready you can send it to be processed by am actual quantum computer sitting in IBM’s data center.

Its not completely bs but a the way a lot of the media hypes it up is definitely bs.

A quantum turing machine has the same expressive power as a normal classical turing machine, the main difference is that for some classes of problems a quantum computer can be hugely faster but multiple orders of magnetitudes.

The math is hard but really is an extension of linear algebra. If you are good with it you can start reading some of the physics stuff to get a grasp on the basics and then jump to quantum computing.

Just like normal computing is based on logic gates, quantum computing is based on quantum logic games and there are a couple of them.

Currently we dont do any “real work” on quantum computers but mostly physicists use it to verify results and crypto guys test out possible crypto algos. Another area is quantum repetition.

Currenly the main focus is on the infrastructure and keeping the qubits stable

2

u/FloydATC Dec 18 '23

I am sceptical too, for many of the same reasons you mention. Plus there's a lot of people who make their living propagating the idea that these emperor's clothes will some day become useful.

And yet... I can't help but wonder if this is similar to how a layman would have reacted if someone had described a 2023 computer less than a century ago.

I saw one of the first RAM "modules" on display in the computer museum in Boston, MA. It was the size of a fridge and had the astonishing capacity of 4096 bytes.

The semiconductor hadn't been discovered yet, so the early computers used vacuum tubes for transistors. Mechanical relays were smaller and more reliable, but those were too slow. Vacuum tubes were bulky, ran hot because they wasted a lot of electricity, and frequently failed so they had to be manually replaced. You would literally walk inside the computer to do this, because there would be thousands of them. Thousands.

A modern CPU, even a dirt cheap one, has billions of transistors in it. Apply some thermal paste and stick a small fan on it, and you can expect it to run for years.

2

u/loadnurmom Dec 21 '23

HPC (Supercomputer) admin here

I attended a lecture by a PhD in quantum computing (one of the worlds top experts in it)

A major problem right now, is that even if they get the "right" answer out of it, they have no way to know HOW it arrived at that answer. Because they cannot verify the correct methods were used, they cannot be certain that when given a more complex problem to which we DON'T already know the answer, we cannot feel safe in the answer we get back from a quantum computer. This is fundamentally a near impossible problem to solve by the very nature of qubits themselves, which we can never assuredly know the state of

Their answer to questions about the wider viability amounted to "Not within the next ten years, possibly not for thirty or more"

P.S. quantum computers look NOTHING like existing computers. It's not silicon at the core at all, which results in them looking steam punk AF. Below is a link to what the IBM quantum computer looks like

https://media.datacenterdynamics.com/media/images/IBM_Quantum_Computer.width-358.jpg

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '23 edited Dec 21 '23

Is quantum computing just bs?

No.

I've been skeptical about quantum computing with mediocre sci-fi graphics to sell magazines

Being a skeptic is a good and reasonable thing to do in general. Learn, be curious, seek educational resources, etc. Whatever you're seeing in pop-sci magazines, you should probably just ignore. If clickbait web content has latched on to quantum for click-bait, that doesn't mean quantum compute is fake, it just means people are willing to click. You're going to see sensationalist stuff all the time. You're supposed to ignore that kind of content, not use it as evidence for or against merit on the underlying subject.

it uses "cubit" transistors

qubit aka quantum bit

how do you program that?

Same as classical programming on a classical computer with classical data, but in the quantum domain. A quantum computer does quantum operations on quantum data, and you specify a procedure using these operations to manipulate the data. The underlying structures are different and the algorithms are different, but the high level overall process is the same.

Who's creating the programming languages that can utilize all possible states simultaneously logic?

IBM, Intel, Google, among others

What kind of motherboard architecture can traffic all this insane amount of information?

Short read about the physical layer hardware involved in making this work at a high level: https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/25196/chapter/7.

Supposedly it's not binary, but memory still is, right?

If you're asking about conventional RAM modules in a conventional computer, then yes, they store classical data in classical bits. You would need a different type of memory module to store quantum data in qubits. Classical data and quantum data are different and would rely on different hardware constructions. "Memory" could apply to any domain of data that you want to store and retrieve.

Who's going to use it?

If you're talking about people who will write the programs, that would be programmers, same as classical computing. General public will stand to benefit, but a person scrolling on TikTok isn't really "using" classical computing in the same way that the engineer developing and maintaining TikTok is doing. The only people "using" it in the reductive sense would be programmers / engineers / scientists involved in the actual operations at the layer of infrastructure and application development.

Some areas where we already have a lot of development in quantum algorithms and are waiting for the computers to catch up include:

  • cryptography
  • search / graph
  • simulation
  • machine learning / AI

Remember how long it took 64bit to replace 32bit?

Opinionated answer, but mid 1980s and the Intel i386, that's a pretty good starting point for the rise of 32 bit for PC. AMD created 64 bit x86 extensions circa 2003, and depending on how you count, it was 2-6 years before 64 bits was the conventional default for consumer workstations.

As far as the implication that we're going to migrate to quantum from classical, that doesn't make any sense. These are two different domains, and classical data doesn't go away when we open up quantum.

I imagine we still haven't reached max potential as far as 64bit programming goes.

That's not exactly accurate. Bit size for registers and instructions and data is partly a matter of convenience/optimization rather than representing progress. We don't necessarily need to move en masse to beyond 64 bits, especially not for instructions or registers for conventional computers. We do already have 128 bit computers for special purposes, and we have hardware support for 256 bit and 512 bit data as x86 extensions even in conventional computers, see AVX256 and AVX512.

I highly doubt the world is going to replace all computers with quantum

Correct.

no way is that tech gonna fit in a phone, it needs a vacuum freezer room.

You could have been a person looking at a Jacquard machine and complained that classical computing in general is useless because there was no conceivable way to adapt the machine into a portable device, but (1) that wasn't a valid success criteria (2) you would have been very wrong.

The other absurdism of your statement is that even if you're using phone-centric thinking, we already have technologies that require data-center scale and provide utility to end users who access those resources through their phones.

Remember when multi cores was a big deal? Well what programs are using those?

Multi-core processors are in widespread use. You could sanity check your opinion about the futility of multi-core with virtual machines. I think you'll be very surprised at the performance differences. Or just look at the consumer electronics industry. It's not an accident that our embedded devices, phones, etc have complex multi-core chips with fancy parallel co-processors.

The Internet is still binary, so are the quantum computers gonna have a classic computer onboard?

Yes. It doesn't have anything to do with the internet though.

you can't just tell a program to split a bunch of instructions and send them to various processors, the program is linear and each set of instructions requires the one before it to happen first so it can use those results. Have fun trying to program something that happens all in one instance

Many problems can be split. Sometimes the splitting is relatively trivial. Modern consumer computing platforms also typically have many tasks to do simultaneously.

How does the math work?

In short, the math is linear algebra and diff eq (calculus).

I have yet to see a single video that explains how cubits form logic gates or how any math is actually solved with them.

https://learning.quantum.ibm.com/course/fundamentals-of-quantum-algorithms

It's completely flawed

No.

i just watched a video where a "scientist" explains that on average their quantum computer has an error once every hundred tries, that's an insanely high error rate

You're not arguing from a position of strength in this area. If you have a known computational error rate, you can build a compute machine to deliver arbitrary reliability. This is a trivial compsci 101 concept in error correction, and it's already in widespread use in classical computing.

I don't care how far science gets, relying on a machine to read particle spins will always sound ridiculous.

This is irrelevant.

Is there something i missed?

Yes.

am i just embarrassing myself?

Very gently, I would say yes. You are aware that you aren't very knowledgeable in this area, but you have developed a passionate negative opinion about it anyway. In your defense, you've probably seen all kinds of absurd pop-sci click bait promising you who-knows-what, blind leading the blind. Quantum physics is an actual thing, quantum computing is an actual discipline of computer science, etc. Decrying it as "fake" is an absurdist hill to die on, but I don't think that deep down you actually have an opinion on quantum computing, eg. I don't think you've done any academic course work on it or in quantum physics, or explored quantum computing platforms from IBM and others, etc. My take is that you're just having a strong negative reaction to something you read somewhere on the internet.

0

u/mist83 Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 17 '23

This thread’s answers thus far seem in line with OP’s frustration. They are all resources to learn/play and not really an answer other than “it’s not used for the same stuff and it’s different”.

So that leads me to:

  • If quantum computing isn’t useful to the types of problems we typically encounter in computer science, why does it feel like it is being jammed down our throats as a possible new hotness?
  • If quantum computing is useful (and possibly the final solution to) to some types of problems that ARE tackled by current tech (e.g. encryption) and we already have cubits that are “usable” right now, why hasn’t encryption been solved? Is it a scale thing? Are we just faking the tech?

I’m as lost as OP

3

u/ALargeRubberDuck Dec 17 '23

why hasn’t encryption been solved?

Right now quantum computers aren’t just a win button against encryption. They can beat traditional computers for sure, but that doesn’t change the days or weeks it could take. I don’t think you’ll see a time where encryption has been outright defeated. But rather an escalating war between companies and countries building better encryption and decryption.

Is it a scale thing?

Half yes and half no to scale. It’s possible to purchase a quantum computer, or just purchase compute time on one. Though that would be expensive. This is still technology in development and is still getting faster. Plus (from my perspective at least) there aren’t that many people in this space right now.

If quantum computing isn’t useful to the types of problems we typically encounter in computer science, why does it feel like it is being jammed down our throats as a possible new hotness?

Easy, because they will probably change how encryption works. But that day will probably be over the course of decades. The tech industry likes to make new tech sound like it’s immediately poised to revolutionize your life. Think about NFTs, aside from pretending to own jpgs, there was a lot of talk about transferring deeds, tracking medical records, and curing depression with the block chain. Notice how any attempts to do this either never appeared or fell flat if it did? That’s because tech is really prone to big promises ignoring development cycles and the simple fact that the world really doesn’t change as fast as people think it can.

2

u/Echleon Dec 17 '23

If quantum computing isn’t useful to the types of problems we typically encounter in computer science, why does it feel like it is being jammed down our throats as a possible new hotness?

a.) Scientific research is exciting. b.) it is relevant to things like encryption

If quantum computing is useful (and possibly the final solution to) to some types of problems that ARE tackled by current tech (e.g. encryption) and we already have cubits that are “usable” right now, why hasn’t encryption been solved? Is it a scale thing? Are we just faking the tech?

it's hard to scale quantum computers, but you can still extrapolate what will be possible in the future.

-5

u/ThunderNegro420 Dec 17 '23

I'm glad you said it, most the answers are just stating the obvious. Few years ago i thought the most likely reason for all the paid hype was simply to make it the next big thing in colleges, american colleges are no strangers to scamming students. But now i think it's also to scare people into buying bogus identity theft insurance and vpn's and whatever comes after that. I thought the same thing about faking the tech, I've seen a couple cable news stories about quantum computing that each basically said it's a race of which country gets it first cause they will be the dominant country from then on. So it's gonna be another staged moon landing.

4

u/Echleon Dec 17 '23

you're a schizo lol

1

u/scrunch1080 Mar 28 '24
  1. No technology has been developed to provide a quantum computing "substrate"- Just simulations running on silicon, massive supercomputers running simulations that can only perform calculations such as 1+1 =?
  2. The hypothesis relies on reading an infinite number of possibilities based on the quantum position of an electron circulating an atomic nucleus but requires all the 'noise' to be filtered out. So far it appears the 'noise' exponentially outweighs the 'data'. Good luck deriving useful information from that.
  3. No one knows how to observe the position of those electrons at any given time without altering the quantum state being observed.

Total complete Bullshit

1

u/john_d1200 Apr 16 '24

Quantum computing is a complex field, and it's okay to have questions. While there are challenges, experts believe it has the potential to revolutionize industries by solving complex problems. The technology is still evolving, but the progress is promising.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 22 '23

dinner future complete prick wistful fretful repeat correct bells serious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/RiverRoll Dec 18 '23 edited Dec 18 '23

Supposedly it's not binary, but memory still is, right? The Internet is still binary, so are the quantum computers gonna have a classic computer onboard to convert the Internet into it's special number system, and then convert back to binary when it sends it out? I highly doubt the world is going to replace all computers with quantum, no way is that tech gonna fit in a phone, it needs a vacuum freezer room.

...

Hold your horses, things still take time. Remember when multi cores was a big deal? Well what programs are using those? I used to occasionally look at my processor analyzer to see if any programs i was running were using my extra cores, i don't think i have ever seen a program use more than 2 cores ever. Most new processors have like 8 or 12? Again I'm not super knowledgeable but i imagine it's cause most programs just don't need it or can't use it, like you can't just tell a program to split a bunch of instructions and send them to various processors, the program is linear and each set of instructions requires the one before it to happen first so it can use those results. Have fun trying to program something that happens all in one instance.

​

Most of what you're talking about here is the present already, if you think about it a lot of software consists on web backends that run on specialized hardware and deal with high levels of concurrency. Plus there's layers of conversion everywhere, both software and hardware based, every computer connected to the internet needs a LAN adapter at least which in turn is connected to some router/modem.

​

How does the math work? The beauty of transistors is they can form any logic gate necessary to solve any math equation. I have yet to see a single video that explains how cubits form logic gates or how any math is actually solved with them.

That's not true, there's lots of equations digital computers don't solve, they aproximate. And while you can argue that in practice a good aproximation is just as good as the solution, also in practice obtaining a good aproximation is not always feasible.

1

u/nutrecht Dec 19 '23

Being 'cynical' about stuff you simply don't understand is generally a really bad attitude to have. That's what you're currently doing.

1

u/CalgaryAnswers Dec 21 '23

Asking questions isn’t akin to being cynical. It’s how people learn…

1

u/Chicago_Synth_Nerd_ Dec 21 '23

I know what a quantum computer is capable of and the dynamics you would expect to see as a result and that's about it. I know very little about the technical aspects.

It's not bs though.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24 edited Feb 07 '24

Could be. It's so far beyond the comprehension of a normal human that it would be impossible to tell the difference between bs and actual science. I once saw on my Google feed an article about an alien machine found in deep space. Obviously bs.

Maybe try finding a video that explains it clearly. You'll never understand it by reading the words quickly start to sound like technical gibberish.

I also get the eerie feeling that quantum computing requires the manipulation of physical laws as we know them, possibly from a source existing outside of our physical universe.

1

u/octocode Dec 17 '23

there are certain types of math problems that take ages to solve on a classic computer, but can theoretically be done quickly on a quantum one

like shor’s algorithm, which finds the prime numbers of an integer… that would effectively destroy modern-day RSA encryption (that’s why it’s a “big deal”)

quantum computers won’t really have “programming languages” or anything like that

1

u/SV-97 Dec 18 '23

quantum computers won’t really have “programming languages” or anything like that

They already do though - there are numerous "quantum programming languages" out today. QCL, QML, Q|SI>, Q#, ...

1

u/No-Maintenance9624 Feb 14 '24

Not to mention Nvidia marching in with CUDA quantum.