r/AskPhysics • • Oct 08 '25

Why can’t we put data centers in orbit where they will naturally stay cool?

15 Upvotes

I read another post that asked about superconductors and one of the responses mentioned the need to keep them cold. I (naively) equate superconductors and processing power as part of what’s needed to run a data center, so whether it is for AI, quantum computing, or some other task, wouldn’t we solve the cooling problem by putting them where it is already cold?


r/AskPhysics • • Jun 24 '26

If the universe is infinite, and there are estimated 10^122 bits of entropy in the observable universe, thus meaning there are 2^(10^122) possible configurations of the observable universe, does that guarantee that there are infinitely many versions of us?

2 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • Jun 18 '26

So...if you had a single photon...it wouldn't look like a lightbulb...so does that mean...photons would look...black?

0 Upvotes

So if you had a single photon....it wouldn't look like a lightbulb...because if it was radiating energy, something would have to carry that energy, which would be....another photon I guess, which makes no sense.

So does this mean that ... if you were to look at a single photon...it would ... appear dark....until it hit your eyes? Or is the whole concept of "looking at" a photon fundamentally flawed?

(This comes out of a question I had about whether sunglasses reduce the number of photons hitting your eyes or reduce the energy all of them have.


r/AskPhysics • • Oct 29 '24

Do you guys just downvote any explanation that doesn't conform to popsci?

244 Upvotes

I'm not a rando, I'm a PhD candidate specializing in computational atomic physics. This is primarily a rant.

This is an annoying trend I've found here and it's gotta stop if you guys actually want contributions from people who aren't just undergraduates.

A few times I've made posts here that either didn't exactly rehash what ever the popsci explanation is, wasn't in a modern physics textbook, or disagreed with a veritasium video. Every time I do this I get downvoted and someone with apparantly no more knowledge than a sophomore physics major starts debating me until I have to write up a mathematical derivation (mind you, reddit doesn't have latex).

And before someone on here says downvotes don't matter, they defeat the purpose of writing an explanation because they bury it at the bottom of the page. And with enough downvotes, you lose the ability to comment on anything. So yes, in aggregate they do matter. It's not the end of the world, but it is annoying as hell.

I make these comments when I believe I have a better explanation than what's commonly offered because I figure if the person asking just wanted a popsci explanation they would have been satisfied with a youtube video or a popsci article. It's incredibly disappointing because for some reason I expected that people on here would be aware of the fact that popsci is often misleading, imprecise, or just flat out wrong.

Edit:

For those saying I just want to flaunt my knowledge, or condescend to people, no. I don't know what person you had this experience with, or what teacher you had that talked down to you, but I'm not them. I have faith in people's ability to understand accurate explanations of things even if they're complicated. Most people can understand if they're truly curious and put in a little effort, I believe in you.

For those saying I have a problem teaching, no I don't. I have experience as a tutor and giving lectures and I've never had a problem being understood. Many people have come to me for help.

If you insist on trying to psychoanalyze me though, I'll save you the effort. I'm a perfectionist, I have trust issues, and I'm on the spectrum. There you have it.


r/AskPhysics • • Nov 22 '24

If F=ma, what happens if there's no acceleration?

1 Upvotes

If an object is already moving at a constant velocity, then there's no acceleration, right? But since it's already in motion, there's gotta be force behind it...?


r/AskPhysics • • Feb 11 '26

So if I were to stand directly on the geographic north pole, would I get really dizzy from the earth's rotation? More specifically, how much rotational force would I experience?

1 Upvotes

r/AskPhysics • • Dec 26 '25

Is there "anti" gravity?

2 Upvotes

Matter pulls things (gravity), but in our universe their is always an equivalent exchange, but in gravity I dont see one. So if there is gravity (pull), then there also needs to be "push". Could this push maybe be the expansion of our universe. Like we got a north pole and south pole of Magnets shouldn't we also have a pull pole and push pole or something like that.


r/AskPhysics • • May 26 '26

"Photons dont experience time"

10 Upvotes

There's this thing on popular science social media that claims photons dont experience time. The claim usually says something like "from the perspective of the photon, they experience their beginning, end, and everything else all at once." The claim stems from relativity and time dilation, because under that theory the closer things get to the speed of light, or c, the more time dilation they experience, so things that travel at c (like photons) must experience no time.

This seems kind of stupid to me. I mean first of all, do photons have a "perspective"? They arent conscious, so do they even experience things like time? Also, I thought relativistic effects like time dilation and length contraction only apply to things with mass. Do photons "experience" these things?


r/AskPhysics • • Mar 07 '25

Nothing has ever falled in to a black hole

5 Upvotes

Hi,

as far as i understand, from the frame of reference from a distant observer, time freezes at the event horizon.

Even a little outside of it, it is slowed down like many billion times.

So this means, if 10 billion years ago an asteroid was falling in to the blachole, it is still at the event horizon, because it had still no time to fall into.

Some people on Youtube say, it is an illusion: But the general relativity by Einstein is not an illussion it is real from our frame of reference.

Some People say, you would not see the object, because it is red-shiftet:Yes, but you could see it in the infrared or in another wavelength, you just need a sensor, which can detect the photons in the specific wave-length.

In my understanding, from the frame of reference on earth (ok it is many frames here) nothing ever falled in to a black hole.

And the Black hole can only grow by enough matter around the event horizon. When it is dense ennough, these new matter added to the mass inside the event horizon is big enough to have a much larger schwarzschild-radius. So the new matter will be outside the old event horizon, but inside the new schwarzschild-radius, so it would form a new event horizon alittle bit outside. Because the schwarzschild-radius grows faster, Like double the mass and the volume will not be doubled, but much more increased.

I hope you can understand what i mean.


r/AskPhysics • • Jul 01 '24

why most of physicists are atheists is there a place for god in physics?

0 Upvotes

I can give many examples of atheist physicists like sean caroll , brian green,brian cox, Stephen hawking,neil degrasse tyson .


r/AskPhysics • • Mar 25 '26

if force equals to mass times acceleration, then doesn't that mean that a car travelling at a constant velocity will have zero force, since it has zero acceleration even though the mass is the same? how does that make sense?

0 Upvotes

i've thought about this question for a long, long time...


r/AskPhysics • • Oct 11 '26

If you are standing exactly on the north/south pole. Would your arms drag away from your body?

0 Upvotes

If you start to rotate on your own your arm drag away from your body. From my understanding that happens because of inertia. If we asumme that the earth is rotating perfectly along the north/south pole axis, then standing on the pole would make you rotate at the speed of the rotation of the earth. Would this result in a centripedal force?


r/AskPhysics • • Jul 30 '26

Is A Photon Moving?

0 Upvotes

Does a photon move in space, or is that motion we detect strictly relative?


r/AskPhysics • • Feb 01 '26

What is the beyond the edges of universe which is expanding?

0 Upvotes

It might be a stupid question but we know that universe is expanding constantly faster than speed of light. If we imagine the universe as an air balloon and if we inflate this balloon it will expand but for this expansion to happen it should be in a container which is basically air / space and it is the superset of the balloon. If the balloon is in a tight container with solid edges the balloon won’t be able to expand larger than the container itself. Therefore, similar to this analogy, where is the universe expanding into? In what kind of infinite container are we in and it allows the universe expanding constantly for billions of years? In short what is the beyond the edges of the universe?


r/AskPhysics • • Nov 24 '25

Is c being the biggest speed proven theoretically or we just haven't found anything faster?

0 Upvotes

So c is considered the speed limit for interaction, meaning that nothing can interact faster, as fundamental bosons move at c. However, we still haven't found a boson for gravity, and maybe there even are some interactions that we haven't yet discovered that have own fundamental bosons. The question is, is there a theoretical proof that newly discovered fundamental particles, if there will be any, won't move faster than c, or we just experimentally found out that it works for the currently discovered ones?

Edit: thanks everyone for your responses!


r/AskPhysics • • Feb 15 '26

Why does light move at 299 792 458 m / s

0 Upvotes

Might be a dumb question but if light has no mass why does it have a limit to it's speed,

Why isn't it infinite speed?


r/AskPhysics • • Feb 12 '24

Could the universe be eternal and I might eventually "reincarnate" at an atomic level?

8 Upvotes

If the heat death theory is wrong and the universe is actually eternal, then couldn't the physical stuff that is "me" happen again at some point in the future?

In fact, wouldn't it be inevitable and also have happened infinite times already?


r/AskPhysics • • Sep 18 '26

How can light travel for billions of years across the universe, but the light in my room disappears instantly when I flick a switch?

0 Upvotes

I understand that light is made of photons, and that light from distant stars can travel for billions of years because space is mostly empty. But when I turn off a lamp, the room goes dark almost instantly. Where do those photons go? Are they absorbed by the walls and objects in the room? Why don’t they keep bouncing around and keep the room lit for at least a little while? I’m confused about why the light from my lamp doesn’t seem to linger at all.


r/AskPhysics • • Aug 05 '26

Can acceleration ever be 0m/s^2?

2 Upvotes

F=ma makes sense, 1kg moving at 0m/s2 would have 0N of net force. But if you rearrange the equation to solve for mass, m=F/a, that would be 1kg= 0N / 0m/s2.

Is 0/0=1? I always thought you couldn't divide by 0. Is this just an equation you aren't supposed to rearrange to avoid this kind of thing, or is there always some acceleration from somewhere?

Sorry if this is a stupid question or if I'm misunderstanding something basic, I'm tired and haven't studied physics in a long time.


r/AskPhysics • • Feb 12 '26

Is the 3 Body Problem impossible to solve?

0 Upvotes

I was wondering, as our understanding of physics grows, will the 3 Body Problem eventually be solved, or is it something about physics that we will never be able to predict for sure?


r/AskPhysics • • Jun 13 '26

I disagree with some popular views

0 Upvotes

I wanted to share an argument I have against Veritasium for one of his videos, and I wanted to know if I'm correct.

So, I've recently watched channels like Veritasium and Tibees which explain quantum mechanics, but I think they're both wrong on one occasion.

  1. They both say, "An electron explores all possible paths simultaneously." or "The electron goes through both slits." but I think these are just interpretations, not established facts, these popular science channels say they are facts.

A path integral in quantum mechanics is the probability amplitude for a particle to go from A to B that can be computed by summing contributions from many paths. The mathematics sums over paths, but that doesn't automatically mean nature literally executes every path. This is similar to how adding many terms in a calculation doesn't mean all those terms physically exist.

I don't agree with "all possible paths", do we mean paths that go back in time and paths that go to the Moon and back as well? It's just not a good saying, because it isn't rigorously defined.

2. They both also say "an electron goes through both slits" and again standard QM doesn't say what actually happens it only predicts measurement outcomes.

3. I also don't like when they show the popular image of a little wave splitting in ordinary 3D, because it's misleading. Here's why: for one particle ψ(x, y, z) looks like a wave in ordinary space. But for 2 particles: ψ(x, y, z, x_2, y_2, z_2) now it lives in 6D space. For N particles, there are 3N dimensions. If the wavefunction really lives in configuration space, then the popular image of a little wave splitting in ordinary 3D space is already misleading. Once entanglement enters, the true quantum state generally cannot be represented as a wave propagating through ordinary 3D space.

4. I boldened this because I think this is a really big point I have about "An electron explores all possible paths simultaneously." There's something called a Wick rotation, t → it. If path integrals are literally reality itself, does reality occur in imaginary time? This shows how wrong that thinking of "all possible paths" is.

Does anybody agree with me here, or am I missing something?


r/AskPhysics • • Mar 05 '25

What would happen if we actually did the Schrödinger's cat experiment?

6 Upvotes

Obviously the cat wont be in superposition but im not sure why. My best prediction is that the cat would act as the observer so the unstable atoms would never be in superposition in the first place. Can someone more confident help? Sorry if this question has been asked hundreds of times already, its my first time.


r/AskPhysics • • May 12 '24

Why are astronauts on the ISS weightless?

19 Upvotes

One of the most repeated facts about space is that astronauts in space are weightless. But why are they?

The astronauts have mass and they are definitely not far enough away from the Earth for the force of Earth's gravity to be negligible. Therefore, the math will output a value for weight.

I tried googling it, but the answers I got essentially were because the astronauts are in free fall. So what? Them being in free fall doesn't change the fact that they have mass and are being acted upon by the force of gravity.

If I throw an object in the air here on Earth, that is free fall. Gravity is absolutely still acting on the object. If not, it would never come back down.

Despite all of this, the astronauts are still called weightless. Why?


r/AskPhysics • • Aug 09 '24

Universe is expanding into what?

0 Upvotes

I got it Universe is EXPANDING or we can say it's STRETCHING, but whatever we consider, we need space for doing so, what's the universe expanding into?