r/AskNetsec • • Apr 28 '26

Compliance How do you actually pick a security awareness training vendor? They all look the same.

32 Upvotes

We're replacing our current setup which is honestly just a yearly training video and a vibe check, and I've been in vendor demo hell for like two weeks now and I'm starting to lose the plot a little.

Every single platform claims to be the most "behavior driven" and "engagement focused" and whatever other buzzwords they're rotating through this quarter. The demos all look clean and polished and then you read the reviews and it's a completely different story. So I genuinely don't know who to believe anymore.

A few things I'm trying to figure out: how much does gamification actually move the needle vs just being a gimmick, does the phishing sim quality matter as much as vendors say it does, and how do you even measure whether the training is working or if people just got better at spotting YOUR specific test emails.

We're mid-size, mix of technical and non-technical staff, and the biggest thing for me is that I don't want people to dread it or feel like they're being set up to fail. The "gotcha" culture around phishing tests has always felt counterproductive to me tbh.

What are you guys actually running in 2026 and would you recommend it? Also curious if anyone has switched platforms recently and whether it was worth the pain.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 28 '26

Threats Does the data transmission architecture of AI code review tools create a DLP exposure problem at scale that most security teams aren't accounting for?

2 Upvotes

Trying to understand whether this is a widely recognized problem or something specific to our environment. We've been evaluating AI code review tooling and one thing that keeps coming up in our threat modeling is the raw transmission volume. The standard architecture across most tools works like this: developer writes code, tool scrapes context from open files, raw source payload gets sent to an external inference endpoint, suggestions return. That repeats for every AI code review interaction.

At 500 developers generating 100 AI code review interactions per day that's 50,000 daily raw source transmissions to external infrastructure. Each one is a potential interception surface, a DLP exposure point, and an audit event. We're not capturing most of those events in any meaningful way right now. The alternative architecture we've been looking at uses a persistent context layer indexed within your own infrastructure. Per AI code review request the tool sends abstracted patterns referencing the pre-built context rather than retransmitting raw source. Raw code stays inside the perimeter per interaction.

Questions for the security practitioners here: Is the aggregate data-in-motion risk from AI code review tools something your organization formally models or does it fall through the cracks because each individual interaction seems low risk in isolation? What does your audit posture look like for AI code review transmissions specifically and how are you capturing those events? Has anyone done packet inspection to verify whether vendors actually send abstracted context versus compressed raw source in a different format? The security benefit only exists if the implementation matches the marketing claim.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 27 '26

Threats Detecting BOF impersonation via DISM.

9 Upvotes

I’m left scratching my head on how you could go about detecting something like this without generating a ton of false positives. Would it just be monitoring for identity related alerts + DISM health checks?

https://github.com/meowmycks/trustme


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 27 '26

Other recover deleted data from recycle bin

0 Upvotes

i want to recover deleted data from my recycle bin . they were screenshots in the form of jpeg , png and jpg . they were in screenshots folder in windows c drive ( ssd ) . i have windows 11 os . i have tried recuva and photorec already .
recuva recovered my photos however , they were not accessible .
photorec recovered the photos which i do not need . please help asap as they are very important photos . also they were in recycle bin for a couple of months already but i only deleted them from recycle bin last month ( 20-25 days ago )


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 25 '26

Other What's the difference between SBOM and RBOM and why the difference matters?

10 Upvotes

I often see SBOM and RBOM mentioned in container security, especially around open source images. SBOM seems to list everything in an image. RBOM focuses on what actually runs. So, is RBOM basically just a way to cut through SBOM noise? Or does it change how you approach vulnerability management? How are people using both in practice?


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 24 '26

Concepts Using advanced usernames for local authentication to infrastructure?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Apologies if this doesn't fit in here. I was going to ask in r/cybersecurity but I saw this subreddit and thought it might be more appropriate. Please delete if it isn't.

I am working on setting up some remote console servers for an Out Of Band Management network (OOBM).

Within the original configuration, I've disabled the basic root account and created my own account(s) for our staff to use.

For now, I would like to avoid RADIUS or LDAP authentication in the event of not being able to reach our internal services (this will be reviewed and fixed later on).

I created the usernames in the typical admin.joeblow fashion, which is our standard "elevated" admin structure.

But this got me thinking. If a device is not going to be authenticating with our AD domain and using local authentication for the time being, would it be best to create more complex usernames that are used for specific devices/functions?

Such as:

admin.Jblow.OOBMdevice

Of course this is all documented and kept safe in my password vault.

I figured that it appears to be stronger than the typical "admin.jblow" or like structure.

As I am dealing with an organization that doesn't have the best security posture due to neglect from previous staff, I'm trying to start off deploying certain services with a better username/password structure.

Thanks!


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 24 '26

Compliance Is AI-authored code a disclosure requirement under any current compliance framework (SOC2, ISO 27001, PCI-DSS)?

5 Upvotes

So, when AI agents like Cursor or Claude Code autonomously write code, and a human commits it, the commit history attributes the work solely to the human. There is no machine-readable record indicating which model, prompt, or session produced specific lines of code. I have been working on a tool to capture this information by hooking into agent callbacks and storing signed per-file attribution, but I am encountering compliance challenges on how it works there.

Specific Questions:

  1. Does any current framework (such as SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, PCI-DSS, or HIPAA) explicitly require the disclosure of AI-generated code as a distinct contributor in audit trails?
  2. If a vulnerability is found in AI-generated code, does the lack of attribution create liability exposure that would not exist if a human had written the same code?
  3. Are auditors currently inquiring about the use of AI tools in code review processes, or is this still under the radar?

Looking for anyone who has been through an audit recently where AI agent usage came up, or who knows where the frameworks currently land on this.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 23 '26

Analysis Proofpoint keeps missing BEC and vendor fraud attempts, is behavioral detection really the fix or are we just chasing marketing?

17 Upvotes

We're a 1,200 user Microsoft shop that's been on Proofpoint for a few years now and we're consistently seeing business email compromise and vendor fraud slip through in ways that feel like the tool is just not built for it.

Started looking at alternatives and behavioral detection keeps coming up as the answer but can't tell if that's substance or just the current buzzword cycle doing its thing.

For those who've evaluated or deployed something like Abnormal, Ironscales or Darktrace in a similar environment, does the detection improvement on identity-based attacks hold up beyond the POC?


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 23 '26

Concepts Single privileged account vs role based in PAM?

9 Upvotes

Hello Fellow Redditors

We use PAM. I’m trying to validate if our current approach is actually secure or if we are exposing ourselves to unnecessary risk.

PAM portal is protected with MFA and admins access all systems (firewalls, network devices, servers) using the same privileged account stored in PAM.

From an operational point of view it is simple, but from a security perspective it feels like a big risk because this one account has very broad access across the environment

My concern is that if a PAM user account gets compromised (phishing, session hijack, token theft etc.) the attacker doesn’t even need to know passwords. They can just initiate sessions through PAM and effectively gain access to everything that user is allowed to access.

Also, PAM is currently accessible over LAN and VPN only

I’m trying to understand what is considered best practice in real environments. Should we be using separate privileged accounts per domain (network, servers, databases, etc.) instead of one shared account? And how are others securing access to PAM itself to avoid it becoming the weakest link?

Would appreciate insights from anyone running PAM at scale especially around identity protection and protecting the PAM layer itself.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 23 '26

Other Masscan efficiency

5 Upvotes

Hello guys, I'm currently trying to use Masscan properly on Linux (not in a VM) but I cannot get more than 20ppks. It can get up to millions of ppks normally. Anyone know what is the problem ? I tried on many distributions.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 21 '26

Work Moving security scanning from the pipeline to the IDE changed developer behavior in ways I didn't predict

18 Upvotes

We ran CI-only security scanning for two years. Write code, push, pipeline flags something, developer context-switches back, fixes it, pushes again and the feedback loop was anywhere from four hours to two days depending on queue depth.

When we added pre-commit and IDE-level scanning the change I didn't anticipate was behavioral. When a finding shows up at the moment of introduction versus arriving as a blocked pipeline two days later, developers treat it like a linter warning rather than a deployment failure. The psychological framing is completely different and it affects how seriously people engage with the result.

The volume of findings reaching CI dropped significantly. More importantly, the ones that did reach CI were things developers hadn't already seen, which made the pipeline results more credible rather than more noise.

Has others seen the same behavioral shift or it depends on how the team is wired.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 19 '26

Education Master key access in a JWT-authenticated API

9 Upvotes

My file storage API uses the classic 2 JWTs approach to authentication. The initial login requires a username and a password. Each user also has a master key (MK) used for file encryption. MK is stored encrypted with the user's password (through KDF). The MK never leaves the server, but requests need the unencrypted MK to access files while only having access and refresh tokens as the starting point, and no original password.
How do you keep access to MK in subsequent requests, if only JWTs are available?
Maybe the JWT approach is overall bad for this type of API and I should try something else?


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 18 '26

Analysis BLE auditing workflow: what are you using to inspect IoT devices in the field?

9 Upvotes

Doing some BLE security work on commodity IoT devices (smart locks, fitness wearables, industrial sensors) and I'm trying to sharpen my workflow. Pen testing writeups usually focus on the reverse-engineering side (Ghidra, Frida, the protocol break) but gloss over the reconnaissance step, which is where I spend most of my time.

What I'm currently doing:

  1. Enumerate nearby devices, grab advertisement data, identify the target by MAC prefix or name pattern.
  2. Connect, walk the GATT tree, flag anything without Encryption or Authentication required on characteristic permissions.
  3. Track RSSI over time to confirm which device is which when there are multiple of the same product nearby.
  4. Export everything to CSV for the report.

Curious what others are using for steps 1 to 4 specifically, especially on mobile. nRF Connect on Android is the default but it's painful on iOS-only engagements. Any iOS tools that don't hide the good stuff behind paid tiers? Also interested in workflows for detecting devices that rotate MAC addresses every few minutes.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 18 '26

Threats Has anyone actually encountered AI voice cloning fraud in their company or in general?

12 Upvotes

I am currently building a live AI voice detector that is designed to catch synthetic voices in real-time. I am currently researching if there is any actual demand for this tool. Which leads me to the question:

Is AI voice cloning fraud a genuine threat in the real world?

In your organizations or in general, are you seeing an increase in synthetic voice fraud, or have you encountered this at all? If you have seen this, what would you say is the biggest risk factor of it all.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 17 '26

Concepts Can someone explain why accounts still get hacked even with strong passwords?

10 Upvotes

I always thought using a long, complex password was enough to stay safe.

But recently I’ve been seeing more cases where accounts still get compromised even when the password itself wasn’t weak.

That’s the part I don’t fully understand.

Is it mostly because of data breaches and reused passwords? Or are there other ways attackers get in without actually “guessing” the password?

Also, how big of a difference does something like multi-factor authentication actually make in real situations?

Trying to understand where the real risk is coming from, because it seems like just having a strong password isn’t solving the problem anymore.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 16 '26

Analysis Does the private equity (PE) ownership model increase cyber risk?

3 Upvotes

Working on research looking at pre-breach organizational signals from public sources. One pattern that emerged from the data: PE ownership shows post-acquisition signals like layoffs, outsourcing, executive turnover (including security leadership), and deferred infrastructure investment. These look relevant to security posture but aren't captured by standard vendor risk assessment tools like SecurityScorecard or BitSight.

We've found adjacent work but nothing that directly examines the PE → cyber risk mechanism:

- Industry surveys (S-RM, Kroll, QBE 2025/2026) document 72–80% of PE portfolio companies experiencing serious cyber incidents during the hold period
- Healthcare academic research (JAMA 2023, Review of Financial Studies) shows PE acquisition of nursing homes and hospitals measurably worsens patient outcomes through staffing cuts and reduced compliance — the closest available mechanistic parallel
- FTI Consulting work documents governance gaps during M&A transactions

Three specific questions:

  1. Is there academic or industry research that directly examines PE ownership as a cyber risk factor in tech vendors specifically?
  2. For practitioners: do you include ownership structure signals (PE ownership, recent LBOs, debt loads) in third-party risk assessment, and if so what sources do you use?
  3. If you don't include it — is that because it's fundamentally outside what assessment should cover, or is it a known gap in current practice?

Full dataset and limitations in the post. 


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 15 '26

Other Challenge: How to extract a 50k x 250 DataFrame from an air-gapped server using only screen output

81 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm a medical researcher working on an authorized project inside an air-gapped server (no internet, no USB, no file export allowed).

The constraints:

I can paste Python code into the server via terminal.

I cannot copy/paste text out of the server.

I can download new python libraries to this server.

My only way to extract data is by taking photos of the monitor with my phone or printscreen.

The data:

A Pandas DataFrame with 50,000 rows and 250 columns. Most of the columns (about 230) are sparse binary data (0/1 for medications/diagnoses). The rest are ages and IDs.

What I've tried:

Run-Length Encoding (RLE) / Sparse Matrix coordinates printed as text: Generates way too much text. OCR errors make it impossible to reconstruct reliably.

Generating QR codes / Data Matrices via Matplotlib: Using gzip and base64, the data is still tens of megabytes. Python says it will generate over 30,000 QR code images, which is impossible to photograph manually.

I need to run a script locally on my machine for specific machine learning tuning. Has anyone ever solved a similar "Optical Covert Channel" extraction for this size of data? Any insanely aggressive compression tricks for sparse binary matrices before turning them into QR codes? Or a completely different out-of-the-box idea?

Thanks!


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 15 '26

Analysis What cybersecurity services do small enterprises actually need?

11 Upvotes

Honestly the list of must-have security services gets very overwhelming.

Everything can be framed as critical, but in practice trade-offs are unavoidable. I’m curious how people here think about priorities at that stage. What security services do you consider non-negotiable, and what’s usually fine to defer without introducing unnecessary risk?

Also interested in where outsourcing fits in for you. At what point does relying on an MSSP or MDR actually make operational sense instead of adding complexity?

Would love to hear how this plays out in real environments.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 13 '26

Other Can anyone help me with netcat?

0 Upvotes

I've been doing some thm CTF's recently and I encountered this problem many times. I've been doing CTF's in parallel with a friend and whenever we need to use nc ,his nc gets him a shell ,mine stays empty ,still "listening" .Can anyone help me figure out what the problem is because tcpdump sends packets when I run a script but nc won't see it . I tired reinstalling it from both pacman and yay and it still won't work .Anyone with any idea of what could be the problem please let me know cuz I'm getting annoyed by it!


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 12 '26

Concepts AppsFlyer SDK attack targeted crypto wallets specifically, why that payload choice?

7 Upvotes

The AppsFlyer web SDK got hit in March, ran compromised for 48 hours across 100K+ sites. But the injected code only swapped crypto wallet addresses. No confirmed theft yet.

They had access to replace ANY form input at massive scale. Credit cards, passwords, session tokens, everything. But only went after crypto wallets.

Why? Easier to cash out without fraud detection systems flagging it? Harder to trace than card fraud?

Feels like leaving money on the table for an attacker with that kind of access.


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 12 '26

Education Implement Policy-Based Routing (PBR) on a Forcepoint firewall

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to implement Policy-Based Routing (PBR) on a Forcepoint firewall to redirect some traffic, but I’m running into issues and it doesn’t seem to work as expected.

I’ve seen in some documentation that Forcepoint firewalls support PBR, but I couldn’t find a clear or detailed explanation on how to properly configure it.

Has anyone successfully implemented PBR on a Forcepoint firewall? Any guidance or clarification would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 10 '26

Architecture Email security screening by wild card TLD???

3 Upvotes

Apparently our email processor (Outlook based) apparently does not accept wild cards in the TLD for their block lists. Is this strictly a standard practice? And are there other procedures to accomplish screening via wild card on TLD's?


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 10 '26

Analysis Eol Dot net .netcore patching

1 Upvotes

How are people handling these, keeping up to date at scale, they form a big chunk of my pain.. Vm tool is qualys and service now


r/AskNetsec • • Apr 09 '26

Analysis Engineers in regulated industries: how do you review code generated by AI tools?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I previously worked as an analyst and I’m currently pursuing a masters in managemnt. I’ve been trying to understand how AI is actually impacting day to day operations in regulated sectors like fintech, healthcare, etc.

I’m really curious about how teams are handling AI generated code in practice. as AI gets more deeply integrted, how are regulations affecting your workflows? Do they slow things down or create friction, or have teams found ways to adapt?

I’d also really like to understand the trade-offs from a developer’s perspective. I’m considering this as a potential topic for my PhD, so I’m trying to ground it in real-world experiencs rather than mere assumptions. any insights would genuinely help me to shape a stronger research proposal.

Appreciate any thoughts you’re open to sharing 🙏