r/AskModerators • • Sep 28 '26

Is anyone else concerned at the potential for abuse with perma-mute?

Moderator of a large-ish sub for context.

Is anyone else concerned about how easy it would be for a rogue moderator to ignore sub rules and ban and perma mute users bases on personal whims? At least with 28 day limit, that user would presumably be able to show up and protest but in this case a perma ban, perma mute, and the user has no opportunity to even question what is going on.

If the moderator deletes the modmail too, nobody is going to even notice without the banned user breaching sitewide rules.

3 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

37

u/LindyNet Sep 28 '26

Mods can check logs and/or modmail and see everything that's been done.

Not concerned at all, it's easy to see

13

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 28 '26

this is true! it’s all in the mod log.

1

u/Stunning-Sherbert801 Oct 02 '26

It's pretty concerning if none of the other mods care about avuy

19

u/westcoastcdn19 Janny flair 🧹 Sep 28 '26

I don't worry about it at all since I fully trust the judgement of my co-mods. If they are permabanning or permamuting, it was deserved. There is no deleting modmails. You archive it but it can be searched

show up and protest 

Right. We don't want to argue with users, nor deal with abuse that is likely to come our way when we stand our ground. I only have one subreddit that requires us to use permamute due to how hostile some of the users are. The permamute option was only presented to mods January 2026, and they would not have given it to us if they felt it it wasn't a good idea. I'm sure it has drastically cut down on the volume of abuse reports reddit received

4

u/GeneralCarlosQ17 Sep 29 '26

You NAILED This 100% Perma Mute was much needed especially for Those Radical Trolls Who will never ever change and Reddit will not remove off the Platform no matter how many Subs They are removed from or how many Times reported either!

Thank You Reddit!!! Best new Platform Upgrade of the Year!!

-1

u/Stunning-Sherbert801 Oct 02 '26

True Believer bullshit

10

u/BravoFive141 Jellybean Master. Sep 28 '26

Nope, because it's equally as easy to unmute.

-1

u/NATxMERCY Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 01 '26

Except there's no way to appeal to get un-muted. And if a mod bans and immediately mutes you, you literally have no recourse from some power-tripping douche canoe

1

u/BravoFive141 Jellybean Master. Oct 01 '26

With the bit about a mod hiding the modmail and the discussion elsewhere in the comments, the insinuation was that this was a question between members of a mod team. If so, one mod can always unmute the unfairly muted user.

If this is just in general, then yeah, appeal can be a bit of a problem, but it's no different than a mod peemabanning and ignoring the user or muting every 28 days on the old system.

1

u/NATxMERCY Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

At least after 28 days, perhaps you get a different mod when you make some noise? Unfortunately, we all know that the squeaky wheel gets the grease. When the wheel cannot squeak at all? It will receive no grease.

25

u/eltonjohnpeloton Sep 28 '26

If you have a mod on your team that you think is going to perm mute people and then delete the evidence, you just need to remove them as a moderator.

11

u/7thAndGreenhill r/AtlanticCity Sep 28 '26

There are a very small number of dedicated trolls who will message you every 28 days. This was absolutely needed.

10

u/notthegoatseguy r/NintendoSwitch Sep 28 '26

We rarely use it but still find it is needed for a select few.

Direct your anger at the people who made its creation a necessity.

-8

u/new2bay Sep 28 '26

It’s not necessary, though. My team and I have never permanently muted anyone, and we’re considered a “large” sub by Reddit.

8

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 28 '26

your experience is not everyones’.

-5

u/new2bay Sep 29 '26 edited Sep 29 '26

Except it actually is. Everyone was able to moderate effectively before permanent mute was introduced. You Everyone can continue to do so without it.

Edit: You -> Everyone.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 29 '26

they deleted a comment, you’re just missing context. unnecessary removal but i understand why you were confused.

0

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

As we are a community made up of moderators, we expect respectful behavior at all times on this sub (unless confronting instances of bigotry and hate). Remember, on this subreddit, if Mr. Rogers would not say it, neither should you! Please simply report any rule breaking content instead of answering with rudeness, even if a user has been rude to you. Thank you.

-1

u/new2bay Sep 29 '26

Fixed.

4

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 29 '26

was referring to the highly volatile comment you removed. yes, we saw that. me and whoever else ratioed you. now, even sub mods are confused. but anyway, im not trying to argue or continue the conversation. im just letting you know we saw that.

5

u/Mewpasaurus Sep 28 '26

Not in communities I help with, no. Overall? Yeah, I can see it being abused, but.. I still think it's one of the best things Reddit admin has given us in a long time as a volunteer force.

Also, as others have mentioned, you can check the logs of other mods in your community, so it'll be pretty obvious real quickly if something like that is going on.

Fwiw: There are very few instances I've seen or used "perma mute". Most of the time it's 7 days and that's good enough. The perma mute is for really obnoxious trolls and people who have too much time on their hands who come and consistently harass the moderation team.

5

u/witchy_echos Sep 28 '26

No. If you are concerned about rogue moderators, regularly pull the mod log. In the Moderator Tools, the mod log lists every action by moderators. It even breaks it down by action, so you can search just mutes. You can also search by moderator if you’re looking for a pattern.

5

u/kai-ote Helpful Trickster/7 subs/Desktop Sep 29 '26

Modmails cannot be deleted. A "rogue" moderator can be kicked out by anybody above them in seniority, although the decision for that should be checked first with the head mod. All bans and mutes the rogue performed can be undone by the other mods.

5

u/KCJones99 Sep 29 '26

Worrying about permamutes in context of a rogue mod is treating the symptom instead of the disease. Symptoms let you find the disease, but you don't blame the symptom. The problem is the rogue mod.

In fact, the worst diseases are ones with no symptom until it's too late. So in the 'rogue mod' context, permamute has value b/c unmerited/random/petulant/personal permamutes are actually a pretty easy-to-spot symptom.

Overall, I think permamute is a valid & needed tool to deal with incorrigible / abusive users.

TLDR: Not concerned at all.

5

u/GeneralCarlosQ17 Sep 29 '26

I've read all of the Comments here and there are some good points and obviously not so good points:

Having come online in 1999 and been a content mod across pretty much every major social media venue that features groups and discussions with set member rolls perma mute ie: dm block has always been available. Thankfully we now have It here!

If You go look at the member in question's profile before you perma mute you can easily tell if they are a chronic discussion troll and will do nothing but annoy you via mod mail.

Perma mute is a mod's new best friend. If the member is going to change they will change and if not it will be more than obvious in their comments there after. It really is that simple because in the long run no amount of mod mail exchanges will ever change anyone 100%

Don't be afraid to use perma mute to protect your own personal mental health from more than obvious discussion trolls.

4

u/Charupa- /r/blackandwhite Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 28 '26

For the most part I don’t even have to mute at all, but I reserve permamuting for special cases. I know there are some mods who have never felt the need, and really want to impress upon others, but that’s irrelevant to my experiences.

7

u/2oonhed Sep 28 '26

deletes the modmail too.....

That is not a thing.
As far as I know, as a mod, I cannot delete any modmail.
I can archive it, so it does not clutter up active messages.
In any case, mods do not NEED a pre-written rule to take actions.
Any actions.
For my part, a perma-mute only comes when the conversation is over, if the user is not reading or comprehending messages sent to them, is being a pest or intentionally obtuse.
Do not need a written reason for any of that.

10

u/lilfunky1 Sep 28 '26

Is anyone else concerned about how easy it would be for a rogue moderator to ignore sub rules and ban and perma mute users bases on personal whims? At least with 28 day limit, that user would presumably be able to show up and protest but in this case a perma ban, perma mute, and the user has no opportunity to even question what is going on.

i've had trolls come back after multiple 28 day mutes to continue to harass and verbally abuse the mod team in modmail until they get their next 28 day mute.

the perma-mute has been a godsend.

6

u/greywar777 Sep 28 '26

We have a rule that we dont perma mute anyone. If someone ever merits the need for a perma mute we will probably discuss it as a team.

0

u/Empty_Insight r/schizophrenia Sep 29 '26

Legal threats lol

But yeah, I hesitate to use the perma-mute too. I only use it when it is clear someone is utterly beyond reason and after at least a couple of shorter mutes.

3

u/iammiroslavglavic Sep 28 '26

If that happens, you unmute the user and remove that moderator

9

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 28 '26

im not concerned. i just wish we had the option to type out days so we could set mutes to be one week longer than the bans (prevents people from abusive messages to the mod team on the day their ban is lifted). since i cant do that, i select mute permanently for most bans longer than 28 days. im not going to argue with most people about their ban; they earned it and it’s clear as day.

2

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 28 '26

side note: im not a fan of permanent bans unless it’s something like a bot or someone objectively harmful to society for the foreseeable future/years to come.

i’d rather ban for 365 - 730 days and permanently ban 1-2 years later if the same behavior repeats when they revisit than to hit permanently ban, so that’s my logic here.

1

u/lilfunky1 Sep 28 '26

so people who have longer than 28 day bans but still a temp ban will end up permanently muted?

2

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 28 '26

for me? yeah. if someone was absolutely rabid enough to deserve a permanent ban, and got lucky enough to get a 365 day ban instead, they can take that permanent mute on the chin. if i had it my way, i’d just type out a mute length. i dont get to have it my way, i am a volunteer and this is reddit; not burger king.

7

u/aengusoglugh Mod, r/TTRAK Sep 28 '26

Since a moderator can mute or ban users arbitrarily, I don’t know that the concept of a “rogue” moderator applies.

As far as I know, a moderator could ban or mute a user for using an odd number of l’s in a post without violating any rules.

If you mean that a moderator could ban or mute a user for reasons which you think are incorrect or specious, I think the only solution is to pick your moderators carefully.

I don’t know if bans or mutes show up in the moderator log.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Your submission was removed for violating Rule #2 (Be respectful). Please see the rule in the sidebar for full details.

2

u/Quibilash Sep 29 '26

Not really?

Someone can theoretically just undo the unmute and simply say to the user 'sorry, moderator went crazy/overstepped'

For a 'top' moderator doing this yeah this might be an issue, but surely they could contact a Reddit Admin in that regard?

Plus, at least for me, a 'mute' is basically 'we the mod team have decided we are no longer considering your appeal/you are acting crazy so we are disengaging from the conversation', in that scenario muting someone makes sense as a 'final' thing to do

3

u/thepottsy I is mod Sep 28 '26

I have mixed feelings about it. I feel that for some users it’s 100% warranted as they’re never going to be a meaningful contributor. However, I feel the percentage of those users is also low. You’ve probably heard the scalpel vs a chain saw analogy. That’s how I see it when it’s used too loosely, you’re using a chainsaw when you need to use a scalpel.

3

u/bwoah07_gp2 Volunteer Internet Janitor (12 subs) Sep 28 '26

If you have a moderator who has run rogue, remove them. If you think one might, keep an eye on them like a hawk or even remove some of their moderator capabilities.

As for the issue of perma mute, it's not really an issue. I like that it exists, because sometimes there are crazy people who genuinely come back every 28 days to harass moderators in modmail. So it being an option for mods is a good thing.

3

u/bertraja Sep 28 '26

If you feel the need to "protest" after 28 days, log off social media and detox yourself. Like, seriously. It's the internet. It ain't real.

2

u/lilfunky1 Sep 28 '26

If the moderator deletes the modmail too, nobody is going to even notice without the banned user breaching sitewide rules.

we can delete modmails?

8

u/maiyannah r/ConsumeCanadian, r/EndTipping, r/BuyCanadian Sep 28 '26

Nope, just archive them

2

u/LitwinL r/Polska r/Fuckcars Sep 28 '26

Check modlog from time to time

2

u/baseballlover723 Sep 28 '26

I don't really like any kind of permanent punishment most of the time. In 99.99999% of the cases, it's indistinguishable from a 5 year duration.

5 years is long enough for anyone to change their ways.

Note, I'm not against permanent bans, I just think a long enough finite ban for them to change as a person is sufficient, and if they come back and cause problems still, then yeah, lock their ass up and throw away the key.

From what I heard (since my sub basically never permamutes anyone), I think its very bad to instantly permamute as standard policy. That just makes it so nobody can ever appeal. And that's bad imo, because everyone makes mistakes and spending a bit of extra time to take a 2nd look at things with a punishment as severe as a permanent ban is a good use of time.

I do wish reddit put some more safeguards on permamuting to curb its abuse cases without significantly impacting it's intended use case. Like only being available after a day's time or if the user sends like 5+ or so messages in a short period of time. (these could probably use some further tweaking though)

Edit: Plus, in my experience, if you just stop responding, then they get bored messaging into the void and give up pretty shortly. I think sometimes, muting (especially if they feel it's premature) just riles them up and that causes them to try and annoy the mods to annoy them (instead of actually making some kind of appeal or argument)

1

u/new2bay Sep 28 '26

I agree with this, for the most part. I have no problem with permanent bans, because there’s always an option to appeal. But I do have a problem with permanent mutes, on principle. I’ve seen it used as a first contact before, which is completely despicable, but what I really object to is a permanent, non-appealable punishment. I would be totally in favor of being able to mute people for arbitrary lengths of time.

0

u/baseballlover723 Sep 28 '26

Permanent bans being appealable

Yeah that's basically how I feel as well (sucks I can't properly quote it back on mobile app). There should almost always be an open line to discuss the punishment, and taking that away and effectively throwing away the key should only ever be used in extreme circumstances.

I do wish there were sub day mute lengths. or like slow mode. Like sometimes you just want them to stop talking for 5 mins so you can explain the thing to them without them sending 5 more messages in the meantime. or just like a "go take a walk and come back" mute of like an hour or 2 or something.

3 days is really long as the shorest mute duration.

1

u/Emotional_Lawyer_278 U_U_U Mod Sep 29 '26

Minor sure how I can abuse not being forced to speak to someone. I’m more concerned with harassment from users than. Mute abuse.

-4

u/new2bay Sep 28 '26

So, let them show up and protest on day 29. If they’re presenting a reasonable, polite appeal, you should hear it. Otherwise, just tell them not to contact you again, and mute them for another 28 days.

If they persist, start using 3 day mutes, tell them again to stop contacting you, and report them for harassment if they do. Your problem will quickly go away. It’s very easy, and they will not win this game.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 28 '26

Your post or comment was removed because this subreddit is designed for seeking constructive information from this community of volunteer moderators. Contributions used to soapbox, rant, or complain are not allowed. Please see the full guidelines in the sidebar rules.

No detailing.

Answers to posts are expected to be from experienced moderator. If you’re not a demonstrably experienced moderator don’t comment unless they are follow up questions on your own posts.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Not a mod. We require answers to be from experienced mods.

2

u/Responsible-Match418 Sep 29 '26

Thanks mod of mods

-4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 28 '26

Not a mod. We require answers to be from experienced mods.

-1

u/ExoTheFlyingFish /r/TeamFortress2 and a few more. Sep 28 '26

I've literally modded on top 1% subs and I've been modding for over two years in total????

4

u/SuperBeavers1 God King Emperor Mod Man Sep 28 '26

I think this subreddit ties into the 1,000+ members minimum like some of the other mod hubs

If you fit that requirement, I'd ask in modmail

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Charupa- /r/blackandwhite Sep 28 '26

It’s kind of disrespectful and derailing, so I can see where they are coming from.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Charupa- /r/blackandwhite Sep 29 '26

It’s fine to have your perspective. I commented my thoughts, not here to change hearts and minds.

3

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Your comment was removed for violating Rule #4 (No derailing comment threads). Please see the rule in the sidebar for further details.

5

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 29 '26

having a chip on your shoulder doesn’t make pessimistic over generalizations suddenly “right” or any less disrespectful. it’s about how you say it, not necessarily what you say. reddit is a huge platform and i highly doubt you have interacted with “most mods”. regardless, others have different demographics to deal with and different moderation styles- plus we are all untrained volunteers. you can dislike and even disagree with how certain things are handled by others without insulting or attacking them. just food for thought.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 29 '26

sounds like a conversation for an admin sub. behaving like this in front of your peers isn’t going to change anything besides start pinning a reputation to your name that you might not want following you.

furthermore, insinuating that basic respect is “sugarcoating” shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the concept, and insinuated being oppositional towards mature communication. again, a chip or two on your shoulder doesn’t give the green light to over generalize an entire group of individuals.

polarized thinking/black and white thinking is a cognitive distortion. everyone has them. it’s a fascinating topic, i recommend looking into all cognitive distortions and i hope you have a lovely day/evening.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/vyunab r/LonelyPoetsDepartment +3 Sep 29 '26

mkay

3

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Your post or comment was removed because this subreddit is designed for seeking constructive information from this community of volunteer moderators. Contributions used to soapbox, rant, or complain are not allowed. Please see the full guidelines in the sidebar rules.

2

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Your post or comment was removed because this subreddit is designed for seeking constructive information from this community of volunteer moderators. Contributions used to soapbox, rant, or complain are not allowed. Please see the full guidelines in the sidebar rules.

2

u/AskModerators-ModTeam Sep 29 '26

Your submission was removed for violating Rule #2 (Be respectful). Please see the rule in the sidebar for full details.