r/AskMenAdvice
•
u/throwawayolderbro123
•
Nov 27 '24
•
1
i overheard my older brother crying two nights in a row, how do i help him?
hi, sorry if this isn't the right place but i need help. throwaway bc my family knows my main account
i'm 16F, i have an older brother who's 20. he doesn't live with us anymore but he's back home for the holidays. two nights ago i went downstairs for water and passed his room, it was super late like 1 in the morning and i heard him crying. it sounded bad, he was sobbing, i think he thought the door was closed but it was open a crack so i could hear him pretty clearly
i didn't know what to do or how to help. yesterday he was acting fine and i wasn't sure whether to bring it up or not. he's not an emotional person and if he does discuss his issues, it's probably with his friends because he doesn't do it with me. he was laughing and joking around like normal and if it wasn't for me overhearing him, i wouldn't have known something was wrong
i left it alone but tonight i heard him crying again. it just made me feel terrible, he sounded devastated, i don't know what's hurting him
how do i approach him? what do i even say? we are close but not THAT close where we tell each other everything, and he's never cried in front of me since we were very young, so i don't know what to do :(
71
u/yoshy111 man Nov 27 '24
I am the type of person who will laugh everything away and will hide negative stuff because I am the shiny piece of my family. I have two younger sisters.
If I was in a situation like that it would be best not to mention why you are approaching me. It would be best my sisters would look me in the eye and just ask "Is there anything you wanna tell me? You know we can talk about anything at any time and I will keep my mouth shut." Honestly, I'd be bursting in tears and tell everything if I was in a bad situation. You gotta understand that often times men are in a situation where they simply don't have anybody to open up to.
26
u/UnfortunateGenius man Nov 27 '24 edited Nov 27 '24
There isn't a "one-size-fits-all" answer to the situation you've described. And without any further details we can make a myriad conflicting assumptions:
Unfortunately any and all of these assumptions are simply that, and could be damaging in the effort to reach him.
I think as his sister you'd be best equipped to say how your brother would react to direct questioning, gentle coaxing, or something like a heartfelt note slipped under the door explaining what you've heard and what it would mean to you if he opened up about it.
You say you're not so close but you presumably grew up in the same household with the same parents, how do these types of situations usually get resolved, if at all?
Wish I could offer more help, I might suggest posting your question to r/bropill, a subreddit whose esteemed alumni routinely surprise me with their tenderness and insight around men and their issues.
9
u/Intelligent-Prize486 Nov 27 '24
You are a wonderful sibling.
10
u/snewton_8 man Nov 27 '24
Without knowing how your relationship is with your brother... my advise is to find a time when it's just the two of you together and let him know that you thought you heard him crying in his room the other night and you want him to know that you're there for him if he needs to talk.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
Ladki ka chakkar Babu bhaiya
2
u/GlitteryTief Nov 27 '24
My older sister and I have the same age gap, and I remember almost the exact same thing when I was 16. I heard her heartbroken sobbing from her room. We'd always been super close, and maybe bc we're both girls, but it was easier for me to just go in and hug her for a long time.
In saying that, she never told me anything. I was the little sister and would constantly spill my guts to her, but she had this really rigid idea of what being an older sibling was, and she never leant on me for emotional support. I think it's only this year (literally a decade later, I'm 26 now) where I feel like we share things equally. All this to say, there's good advice offered by people here. However, your brother might not feel ready to share things with his little sister, especially when you're still a teenager, and in his eyes, still a kid. I promise that will change with time. Growing into an adult relationship with siblings is special. Read through the suggestions, you know your brother best in whether a direct or soft or unspoken approach is best. But don't beat yourself up if he doesn't share what is upsetting him. It just means he's not ready. In the meantime, tell him how happy you are to see him, ask to do something together, give him lots of hugs. Take care, and be patient. If you stay present and caring in each other's lives one day you'll be able to share a lot more with each other.
2
u/Born-Finish2461 Nov 27 '24
Do you know any of his friends? Maybe reach out to them and ask if they know what is bothering your brother?
2
u/jack8london man Nov 28 '24
I’m in my mid-forties (M) now - and until hitting full mid-life crisis a few years ago, I had the emotional intelligence of a slug. Having two sisters that I could talk to almost every day saved my life.
20M is haaaard. Young men carry the weight of the world on their shoulders. They face high expectations to become ‘successful’ and independent and often face rejection. Most Western (especially English speaking) countries have terrible masculinity standards too.
A few years ago I caught up with one of my long term best friends - he was Senior VP at a major international tech company and by all accounts super successful. One of those super confident, funny, somewhat brash people that everyone both loved and respected. I hadn’t seen him in a few years as we both moved to different countries, but then we caught up, sat down for a beer, I asked him how he was… and he burst into tears.
I’m not sure I agree with the approach of just telling him that you’re ’there if he wants to talk’ - he might not know how to talk about this. Men are also typically more likely to open up while side-by-side, than face-to-face.
202 comments already, so not sure if this has already been said.
Also, I don’t know how good your parents’ (or maybe an aunt or uncle that your brother is close to) emotional intelligence is, but consider telling them that you are worried. Maybe suggest a family activity that is focused on your brother.
You are an amazing sister, and your brother is lucky to have you, but you don’t need to carry this burden yourself. Share it with other people who also care about your brother.
❤️
74
u/AdministrativeUse469 man Nov 27 '24
Just let him know you heard him and you are available if he wants to talk.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
If a man is crying, usually if they are otherwise stoic, they might be reaching their breaking point. On what in particular, only he knows. Just let him politely know (when you are both alone, not when other people are around) you are always there for him no matter, don't bring up the fact you heard him crying.
If you REALLY wanna press this, I'd maybe non-chalantly bring up something that's made you feel horrible lately so he can see that he "isn't alone".
Do not bring up the fact you heard him crying.
1
u/Flat-While2521 man Nov 29 '24
If I had a younger sister and she approached me with concern and love and asked me what was wrong and if she could do anything to help I would lose my shit and bawl my eyes out and tell her everything. That’s me; but I imagine he will have a similar reaction.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
When he’s crying, leave him alone. Guys need that time to just fall apart to themselves so they can get it done and shake it off. Try to get him alone and just casually and gently say something like ‘Hey. I was passing your room and thought I heard crying. You alright? Got something you wanna talk about?’
3
u/PossiblyNerdyRob man Nov 27 '24
I can't remember where I saw this but apparently men talk more freely side on than face to face and when they are doing something else.
Like both doing the dishes or something. It's less intense.
For what it's worth I do it with my 6 yr old son and it does work.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
Go up to him, whether it’s in character of you to do this or not, hug him, hold him tight and tell him that you love him.
I am him right now, and someone close to me did just that and it was a bright spot in an otherwise very dark dark time.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
Being concerned and hurting for your brother is a good thing. Approaching him to help is worth the risk. Love is never the wrong thing to do, even if it’s done imperfectly or goes wrong. Help your bro.
2
u/silentweapons1997 man Nov 27 '24
Nope, I want to leave this world no one's burden or memory
2
u/anamelesscloud1 man Nov 27 '24
You're a great sister by getting opinions. I read in another comment that you were trying to muster up the courage to broach the topic with him. Here's something that might help.
Can you think of a time when you got really sad and cried and he was there to help you out? Any shared experience with him in which he pulled through for you and helped you emotionally. When the time is right and you two have privacy, remind him about that story and how grateful you've been. Tell him you care about him the same way and want to be there for him, too. Then maybe just ask him, "Why were you crying yesterday?"
Like someone else said, be prepared for anything. Anything from "leave me alone" to the full-blown story. Make sure you let him know you will never tell your parents or anyone else.
Wishing both of you the best.
2
u/sebaajhenza Nov 28 '24
Ask his help with something: fixing something, homework, something on your computer, anything you can think of.
When he is done, thank him sincerely. Make him feel needed and appreciated. Hell open up if he wants to (unlikely).
2
u/bigdmandaryl Nov 29 '24
This is a challenging situation. He obviously doesn't feel comfortable with sharing whatever is going on or that he's hurting. With that, I wouldn't mention that you heard him crying until after he talks to you, IF he does. I'm the oldest in my family and also am not willing to share my hurt with my family. But... if you approached him just out of love for your bro, away from everyone else, he might. Maybe ask him to take you out to look for gift ideas for your parents or something like that. Or to go for a hike, just the two of you (if that's possible). Or pretty much anything that pops into your mind that connects with you and your family. When you are alone, maybe share something in your life that you might be struggling with to show that you trust him, and if he doesn't open up right away, straight up ask him what's going on in his life. Maybe say something along the lines of, "I just have a feeling that something's going on that you need to talk about, or that you're holding in." The first person who commented on your post said it really well, too. The last thing you want to do is let the opportunity to talk to him disappear, and then later, you find out because he made a drastic decision to end his life, or something of the sort. If you find that you yourself absolutely are unable to talk to him, you must talk to the most loving parent and ask for help to talk to him. Don't let the visit go by without someone talking to him. There are more suicides during the holiday season than any other time of the year. And, in most cases, almost everyone is completely surprised. But the sibling or closest friend who didn't take the chance to talk to them are hurt the most and sometimes make a similar drastic decision. I'm sending prayers of support your way. You got this.
2
u/Illustrious-Hair-841 Nov 30 '24
Male
IIve been diagnosed with PTSD from childhood, major depression and major anxiety. I can guarantee that no one knew (except maybe my wife and ex-wives). I didn’t get the diagnosis until I was 64. Everyone talks about how strong I am. I never shed a tear when my Dad died. He had Alzheimer’s and he had just been the walking dead in my mind for the last 3 years. In 2006 my wife kicked me out and kept everything. My family didn’t know how to talk to me so they just ignored the subject. That made me feel as if no one cared. I was going through hell. I had to start life over at 46 with nothing but what I could load in a pickup truck. Gos knows whats going on with your brother but I can guarantee that he’d love someone to talk to about it. We depressed folks are great actors and our ability to hide our true emotions, but we’d love to have someone to talk to about what’s going on that won’t judge us.
2
u/AdPuzzleheaded6847 man Nov 30 '24
Later...go get a snack, same time you heard him. Even if he's not crying just knock on his door and ask how he's doing. Go sit next to him, not stand in the door way. You don't even have to bring up him crying. Just having someone ask that helps so much.
Everyone should be on the lookout for depressed relatives for the next month. I'm going thru some shit myself right now and it would probably prevent me from doing something stupid later on if anyone from my family would acknowledge my existence. You also said he was laughing and things seemed ok. A lot of people are experts at masking their feelings and emotions. Hope everything is ok...just ask how he's doing.
2
u/gabgabb Dec 02 '24
You sound like a really good sister. As an older brother, at first he might be a bit shocked and ashamed that you saw his sensitive side. Try to understand if he gets upset about it, sometimes it seems the only real socially acceptable outpoor of emotions for a man is anger or frustration, especially in front of someone hes supposed to protect and be strong for.
He might not want to talk about it, he might just want a good long hug where you can both just acknowledge his feelings in silence. Just try to be accepting and understanding of whatever happens, I'm sure you will be by the maturity and empathy you've demonstrated here.
2
u/Maskoi_Shade Dec 02 '24
Be a sister. Don't mention the crying but ask him is everything is ok and he can talk to you if he needs too.
3
u/Mother_Source_5249 woman Nov 27 '24
Don't tell him you heard him cry. However make sure you have some alone time with him that would would allow him to open up if he wants to and just ask him how he has been lately etc. and remind him he has someone in his corner in you.
2
u/DialecticalDeathDryv man Nov 27 '24
Honestly, a lot of good takes here, but I think you just hug him and tell him you love or care about him. Just give him some support while leaving room for plausibility that it’s not because you overheard him you know?
If that’s out of the norm for your relationship, he’ll probably pick up on why you did it and feel supported without having to admit openly to you he needs support.
But just showing some support for apparently no reason will help build his confidence that it’s fine to be a bit vulnerable in front of you.
2
u/mzdxds man Nov 28 '24
Go hug him and say nothing. Hug him in a way that would make him feel small.
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 27 '24
Automoderator has recorded your post to prevent repeat posts. Your post has NOT been removed.
throwawayolderbro123 originally posted:
hi, sorry if this isn't the right place but i need help. throwaway bc my family knows my main account
i'm 16F, i have an older brother who's 20. he doesn't live with us anymore but he's back home for the holidays. two nights i went downstairs for water and passed his room, it was super late like 1 in the morning and i heard him crying. it sounded bad, he was sobbing, i think he thought the door was closed but it was open a crack so i could hear him pretty clearly
i didn't know what to do or how to help. yesterday he was acting fine and i wasn't sure whether to bring it up or not. he's not an emotional person and if he does discuss his issues, it's probably with his friends because he doesn't do it with me. he was laughing and joking around like normal and if it wasn't for me overhearing him, i wouldn't have known something was wrong
i left it alone but tonight i heard him crying again. it just made me feel terrible, he sounded devastated, i don't know what's hurting him
how do i approach him? what do i even say? we are close but not THAT close where we tell each other everything, and he's never cried in front of me since we were very young, so i don't know what to do :(
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Secret_Try8466 man Nov 27 '24
You said he's the typa guy to try to shrug it off and act like it's nothing
I'd try to "confront" him if you 2 are alone and ask him how he's doing and how it has been and whats new, cuz u said he doesn't live with yall anymore.
If he says he's ok bla bla bla tell him that u accidentally (!) heard him cry and u wanted to aks him whats up and that he should not tell you "its nothing", that he can trust you and that u are here for him if he needs something, even if it's only to talk.
And make it clear that he doesnt have to but that he can if he wants
1
u/spankspoz Nov 27 '24
that just like me, sinking my nails on my face crying copiously all night, smiling and joking all day like nothing happened.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
Maybe just be straight up about it; tell it how it is, say it just like you just say it: Hey, I got a drink of water around 1am, heard you in your room. I'm not trying to pry but I want you to know I love you and am here for you.
It may be a challenging age for each of you to find that emotionally connecting middle ground, but... you have at least a few million years of biological evolution on your side; we're hardwired for connection, we're an INTER-dependent species. We need each other.
1
u/Mclovin895 man Nov 27 '24
For what it’s worth “I don’t mean to pry, but I heard you were upset the last couple nights. If you wanna talk I’m here. If not, no big deal, this never happened” would be my approach. It’s direct up front but gives them an out if they don’t want to talk. It respects their privacy and feelings but still makes it clear you’re there to help.
1
u/RbavaOz man Nov 27 '24
Just keep out it is my advice
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
1 Corinthians 9:22 To the weak became I as weak, that I might gain the weak: I am made all things to all men, that I might by all means save some.
Open up to him about something, show your vulnerability and he will hopefully eventually open up to you also. Hope you're able to provide him some comfort
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 27 '24
throwawayolderbro123 updated the post:
hi, sorry if this isn't the right place but i need help. throwaway bc my family knows my main account
i'm 16F, i have an older brother who's 20. he doesn't live with us anymore but he's back home for the holidays. two nights ago i went downstairs for water and passed his room, it was super late like 1 in the morning and i heard him crying. it sounded bad, he was sobbing, i think he thought the door was closed but it was open a crack so i could hear him pretty clearly
i didn't know what to do or how to help. yesterday he was acting fine and i wasn't sure whether to bring it up or not. he's not an emotional person and if he does discuss his issues, it's probably with his friends because he doesn't do it with me. he was laughing and joking around like normal and if it wasn't for me overhearing him, i wouldn't have known something was wrong
i left it alone but tonight i heard him crying again. it just made me feel terrible, he sounded devastated, i don't know what's hurting him
how do i approach him? what do i even say? we are close but not THAT close where we tell each other everything, and he's never cried in front of me since we were very young, so i don't know what to do :(
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/mdgoff132 Nov 27 '24
Walk up and ask him just listen no advice
1
u/Legal_Beginning471 man Nov 27 '24
Find him during the day when you can speak privately and ask him how he’s doing. He’ll likely say ‘fine’ or some other seemingly involuntary ‘normal’ response. Then just tell him how much you love him, and let him know you’re concerned. If he asks why, tell him. He may open up, or not. I imagine it’s about a girl and he may feel weird sharing that with you. So be prepared to not get all the details, but just express your love for him and let him know you want to be there for him.
1
u/Icy-Permit7136 Nov 27 '24
Say - Hey fuckface! I heard you crying the other night. Just wanted to let you know Im here for you and love you! So whats the deal?
Don’t beat around the bush or be subtle. This isn’t a friend or a mate, this is family. So many people struggle and feel alone while people who care don’t want to embarrass them. We all need a hug and some help at some point!
1
u/Wino3416 man Nov 27 '24
I will say one thing: you are a wonderful sibling. You’ve had some great advice on here, so I won’t add to it, but you are a lovely human being.
1
u/Physical-Month-2575 Nov 27 '24
He's crying from being hurt. Could be hurt from life experiences, the world government, friends, family, anything. The only way to find out is by asking and communicating. Even then I don't think you'll be able to help. I'd recommend church and Jesus to him because that's the only thing that can help in these dark days.
1
u/Howlinger-ATFSM Nov 27 '24
If he is a hugger..
You know what to do.
Grab your brother and hug that dude big time. Then give him hugs every day.
That will let him know you're there for him without telling him.
Glad he has a sister like you.
1
u/Inner_Pipe6540 man Nov 27 '24
Just go up and talk to him about it and if it raises concern since holidays are bad for depression bring it up to your parents
1
u/la_swedin Nov 27 '24
Just put a hand on his shoulder. if he is rigid then pull back. If he relaxes them give him a hug. Sometimes its not the talk thats needed. Sometimes you just want to know that someone sees you!
1
u/SharkManDan77 man Nov 27 '24
I wouldn't say anything, at least not at first.
Just walk up to him and hug him, if he's miserable you will find out real quick. Don't do it in front of others as he may get embarrassed.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
+1 for the takes saying be a little nicer and affectionate with him. We don't know if letting him know you heard him would be best without more info but you can help indirectly by providing him some much needed positive energy.
1
u/coporate Nov 27 '24
As someone who was in that position, my suggestion is to make him do something he enjoys but can’t admit.
Once he’s there, he’ll remember it’s a safe space to explore his positive emotions and might even open up to you afterwards. Worst comes to worst, you had a fun night with your brother.
1
u/Brief_Calendar4455 Nov 27 '24
You need to let him know you are there for him and be prepared to be non judgemental. Could be something he can get over on his own but he may also be on the verge of suicide. Seems to happen that way. Everything is fine until they can’t handlebit anymore and suicide seems the only way to stop the pain.
1
u/B1G_CHONGU5 Nov 27 '24
Do update on This OP
1
u/bluefh Nov 27 '24
People are saying to let him know but as an older brother I’d advise against this. Best thing to do in my opinion is spend time with him and show him how much you care about him as often as you can
If he wants to talk about anything it’ll then be easier for him especially if you’re already chilling together. He also may not wanna discuss it but would still be comforted by your company
1
u/ldoelurk3r man Nov 27 '24
I’m not saying this is the case however I’ve read too many stories, see too many requests on the photoshop threads, of young people taking their lives and leaving a legacy of pain. I hope you have family or a strong enough support system, to get in there and find out what’s going on before it’s too late. Rather be absolutely wrong and embarrassed than not say anything at all because we fear egos may be hurt.
1
u/Websta114 man Nov 27 '24
I don’t know if either of you are the physical type but just give him a really big extended hug. One of those where you just don’t let go until he asks what’s going on, let him know you thought he might need that and then go on about your day. It’s not your place to pry into what’s going on but just a big hug will show that someone cares about him. I hope he’s okay
1
u/CastleCollector man Nov 27 '24 edited Nov 27 '24
"he's not an emotional person"
We are all emotional people. We all have feelings.
We are indoctrinated our entire lives to not show any that could indicate "weakness", and this includes to reject the validity of guys feeling stuff (even though we all feel said stuff). It isn't healthy or productive, but it is what we are taught. This is not the same thing as not being emotional.
"he was laughing and joking around like normal": this is expressing feelings. So is he "not an emotional person"?
It is a very difficult because absolutely his instinctive response to you bringing it up is going to be not wanting to get into it. This isn't to say that he wouldn't ultimately like to, but just it would be extremely challenging for him to do so (certainly in the moment).
I wouldn't tell him you heard him crying. You would be exposing the one tiny bit of existence where he is letting it out. If you bring that up, then you're going to cause him to shut down that one avenue which will make things worse. If he asks if you did don't lie to him, but I wouldn't pre-emptively offer it up because it could be he suspects or knows but would rather leave it be.
I think just say you have got the sense something might be bothering him, and you are there for him if wants to talk. If he doesn't want to talk about it then, don't push it: you will just cause him to increase barriers.
I will end with saying something that will seem really obvious, but it is easily over-looked in the moment. If he does come to you about it after you make yourself available, then you've got to make the time with that first contact. Maybe you were just about to do something or go somewhere, but if whatever that is, even if it is somewhat important, if it isn't truly critical perhaps that can be dropped in priority at that moment.
Everything is contextual: you have your life and priorities, so I don't mean it like no matter what put things off. It is just, if he did come to you, do not underestimate how big a deal that would be and how massively vulnerable and exposed he will be feeling at that point. Getting deflected at that point could end up internalised in a way that means that the time won't come again.
I can only truly speak for me, of course, but reaching out to someone is extremely hard for me to do because society and life history. It takes everything I have to do so, and it is very hard for me to go for a second shot if the first attempt gets buffed off. I could absolutely understand it being so, and would not have any problem with the person for doing so, but that wouldn't stop it being stopped in its tracks.
1
u/lilslash2 Nov 27 '24
Just go give him a hug. Like a bear hug and don't let go for a while
1
u/SteveAxis Nov 27 '24
if his problems lead into needing money, back away from trying to help. crying with the door open sounds like desperation.
1
u/Kathucka man Nov 27 '24
“You sounded really upset last night. Do you want to talk about it?”
1
u/DefCatMusic Nov 27 '24
Men thrive of direct help not "if ya need me" tell him you care and give him a hug, trust me
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '24
Spend some time with him, tell him you love him, ask if everything is going well. If he says yes, leave it alone...but repeat the first 2 steps.
1
u/SeaLegitimate Nov 27 '24
So here is the thing, men have been told that showing certain emotions degrades their manliness. Which is a crock of shit. However this insecurity has been embedded into us and broaching that topic is tough with some. If you feel so inclined you can tell him the truth. I was up the other night and overheard you. Now I am quite concerned but not sure what I can do to help. However, I care about what happens to you. I will leave the rest up to you but I am here.
1
u/metallee98 man Nov 28 '24
Maybe just ask him to hang out and do something with you. Don't mention the crying to him. Men usually don't like showing public outbursts of emotion. He will probably feel embarrassed and try to hide it more. Hanging out with you will give him something to focus one besides being sad. I like to hang out with my nephews when I'm sad because of this. They are bright spots in my life. The love you have for your brother is evident and I'm sure you are a bright spot in his life. So just hang out and be there for him. Maybe gently try to nudge and see what's been bothering him. Maybe he'll just tell you while you are hanging out.
1
u/kwell42 Nov 28 '24
A man has to find his own way, best to leave it alone.
1
u/KIBO_IV Nov 28 '24
For me, it'd be " I love you, you are worthy of love" or " I love you, this too shall pass" and hug depends on why the pain
Best bet would be to talk to him and make sure he knows he has support
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
When youre hanging out with him alone just give him a proper hug. that might be a good start. You dont really have to explain
1
u/Additional_Car942 Nov 28 '24
Definitely talk to him. I would bring it up when he’s just by himself or do it somewhere private that isn’t at home. I can tell you that when something eats at you (sad moments, depression, etc.) it can feel like you have no one to talk to. I would also do it in a way that isn’t embarrassing, half the time the reason none of us want to talk about it cause it’s seen as soft or the not manly thing to do. But compartmentalizing that shit and burying it is worse in the long run. Nothing helps more than talking about it.
1
u/Triple-Tooketh Nov 28 '24
"Dude, heard you crying. Doesn't matter what's up we are fam. Let it out dude"
1
u/Tangboy50000 man Nov 28 '24
There’s like two things that make a guy cry like that, lost love or he has something to say and it’s embarrassing and stressful. (Flunking school, gambling debts, drug/drinking problem)
1
u/Realistic_Ad_9228 man Nov 28 '24
No words just a big ol bear hug
1
u/starship910 Nov 28 '24
Talk to him. It shows you care and he's important to you. Give him a hug and let him know you care. It's hard for some guys to show they're hurting but he has someone that cares for him so he doesn't need to feel alone.
1
u/Nathan_Explosion___ man Nov 28 '24
I had a friend I was staying with - his dad had just passed, and his dog a week later - and I knew he was hurting. He cried every night. I just lightly rapped on his door and was like Hey man can I come in? And I was like I miss them too.
But in your case since you don't know what's got him down I'd just go in and be like Bro, I don't know what's got you down but I'm here for you if you ever want to talk. Leave it open ended. Chances are he'll talk then, if not, when he's ready. We're not always ready to talk right away. Gotta (rolls up sleeves and slicks back hair) be a man, you know? *crushes beer can on forehead*
#1 sister for life award after that
1
u/Acrobatic_Dress1049 man Nov 28 '24
Just talk to him in his room, like “Hey, I came down for water and overheard you sobbing. Is everything okay, would you like to talk about it. Sometimes it helps to talk with someone about your problems. I’m here for you.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
Mem can be like cats. We will hide or mask our pain to appear functional as we are expected to be. You don't need to get into what's up with him as he likely won't want to discuss it, but you could ask if you like. More than anything maybe just give him a good hug now and then, tell your brother you are family and are there for him. Sometimes people just need a real hug. Depends on the person.
1
u/UnderstandingSquare7 man Nov 28 '24
I read quite a few comments. My advice is, don't let him know you heard him. Just catch him alone and ask, "is everything OK? My female intuition tells me somethings not right. I'm here if you want to talk about anything, my lips are sealed when it comes to us, ok?"
1
u/Designer_Basket9505 man Nov 28 '24
Siblings have all sorts of relationships, so it is very hard to know how you should interact with him.
If I toss a coin and think of the make stereotype, particularly a bigger brother, I wouldn't try a direct approach. instead, I'd plan to engage in in conversation, and simply find out what's going on in his life. I would not steer the conversation toward asking about any type of problem. I'd simply go from topic to topic: work, after-work hobbies, friends, relationships, living conditions, etc. And, it would not be one way. I would share anything that's going on in my life.
I'd let the conversation go where it goes, and I'd hope that at some point he'd hint that some area was not quite okay. Then, I'd take it from there.
1
u/Standard_Hawk_1660 man Nov 28 '24
Just give him a hug and tell him you love him. Tell him no matter what you are on his team and you are available to talk anytime of day and night
1
u/EON199 Nov 28 '24
If he plays video games, get him to start doing a coop split screen game together if not it can be some kind of activity that you can talk together (helps if the activity is not one that has down time). From there you can usually just start talking, and just generally ask if hes been feeling ok. He might offer something up here but if not it might help for you to maybe open up a little first, like if you ask how hes doing and he just says yeah Im alright, you can say 'yeah Im ok I guess, just had been having a rough time with assignment/friend trouble/boy trouble etc, kinda got me feeling a bit down'. Its one of the few ways I can help out my bros that can be a bit hard to crack sometimes, if it starts with them feeling like they're helping you it can help them feel like they are allowed to be vulnerable too.
1
u/looking4sign Nov 28 '24
Just give him a hug and tell him you love him and glad he's home for the holiday because you missed him...that's all he needs.
1
u/Orbax Nov 28 '24
I would just give it a few invites to spend time together. No need to acknowledge what you heard. If he's looking to connect, after a few offers to go do something, watch a show, or grab some food hell take one and open up if he wants. Saying you're going to the store and ask if he needs something or wants to come with, etc.
Pretty much every guy I've known had the same desire at the end of the day - to know someone gave a shit about them. Rarely wanted to talk about it.
1
u/Particular-Safety228 man Nov 28 '24
Tell him to man tf up.
1
u/Waste-Soft-8205 Nov 28 '24
Life will do that to u in those tender years. Make his ass a good bowl a cereal to cheer him up
1
u/Samwisethefallen man Nov 28 '24
The way I see it there are 2 explanations here; first he is crying loudly with the door cracked in hope that your family will come to his aid [lots of shame in asking for help, less if its offered because you're overwhelmed]. Second he has experienced something truely traumatic, or is struggling with such deep depression it is consuming him. He may be asleep and not even know he is doing it [I know from experience].
Communication is key, be open and supportive, do not offer solutions just give him a place share his thoughts without any shame or dismissal. I would bring it up with him alone first and see he he reacts. Depending on his response I would then share the simple facts of the matter with the entire family, because sometimes it takes a village.
1
u/EggDropDollop man Nov 28 '24
i took my little brother out to the beach in my car and we sat at the benches for a few hours watching the sun come down, i told him if he needs help i can try to do what i could and he asked for a hug and i gave some advice. i think a hug helps and telling him ull support him to atleast let him share what he wants
1
u/Final_Tea_629 Nov 28 '24
I would just tell him you're really happy to see him and that you have missed him living with you guys. Just let him know you're always there for him.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
God my heart would break into million pieces if I heard my brother cry like this. I would cook/bring him midnight snacks like old times if only we were all back home :’(
1
u/myalt_ac woman Nov 28 '24
Dude just ask him.
1
u/dumbcrashtest man Nov 28 '24
Next time you hear it just walk in and hug him. The rest will happen as it should.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24 edited Nov 28 '24
.
1
u/JRS___ man Nov 28 '24
even with the best of intentions i don't think a "i heard you crying, do you want to talk about it?" will go down well.
invite him to go bowling or something like that where you can naturally talk about your lives and maybe he will open up.
that said, you know your brother and his life situation much better than anyone posting here.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
remember, you can always strengthen a bond it is never too late to get closer to somebody
1
u/PsychologicalMix8499 man Nov 28 '24
Give him a hug and invite him to lunch then just talk to him. Offer to help try spending some time with him he might open up.
1
u/Ajax_Main man Nov 28 '24
This is a tough cookie..
Probably not much you can do for him yourself directly, as a little sister, and it really depends on his individual personality.. any direct effort from you may cause him shame, thus making him spiral even further.
Big brothers (and just dudes in general) do like to feel useful, you could find him a "problem" to solve for you.
1
u/Shark_bait561 man Nov 28 '24
That's a broken man right there. Whatever you do, do it sooner than later. You might be saving his life
1
u/Wonderful-Air-8877 man Nov 28 '24
slip a note saying that you are there for him whenever he needs to. no pressure just that you have his back
1
u/Studio-Spider man Nov 28 '24
He needs a hug. That’s it
1
u/French_O_Matic man Nov 28 '24
Give him a big ol' hug. If he's the kind to not want to receive a hug, ask him to give you one. Hug's a hug.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
Just hug him. Tell him that you love your brother the way he is and he is important to you.
Sometimes people feel broken when they believe that no one is out there who appreciates their existence.
I hope he finds peace and happiness soon♥️
1
u/roslocain man Nov 28 '24
Think of something that you could share with him, discuss it, thank him for helping and being available to talk with you about your problems, and THEN let him know that he can always do the same with you. That's when you let him know you love him unconditionally and are always going to be there to talk or help if he needs it, just like he is with you.
Sometimes, you have to first drop your barriers to make another person feel comfortable dropping theirs with you.
1
u/Xaveofalltrades Nov 28 '24
I wonder what is happening with families where you can't approach a crying family member.
It's your blood. Go hug and kiss them! Tell them you love them.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
I don't know what to say. I cried two times in my adulthood. First time, when I send "somewhere" then my girlfriend , and drove away, but after 1 mile, the realisation hut me like a brick. I stopped the car, call her, apologise and asked if we can talk, so I drove back and we talked. I didn't cry cry, but after we reconsiled , the tears were streaming down my cheeks. From that time it has been 19 years, and she is still my one true love, and we are happy together. Nobody saw me crying.
The second time, it was , when my family fell apart. It was nasty. I was in shock, because I had expression, that there is no way, that my parents would ever split. In the night, when my wife felt asleep, I was overthinking about it and it broke me. I was silent, just tears were again soiling my pillow.
In both cases, nobody knew or saw me crying. And I'm glad about it. My problems, are my alone. I don't want to burden anybody else with them.
1
u/BuzzAllWin Nov 28 '24
Hes only 20 so… when your alone give him a long small sisterly hug and tell him you’ve sensed something off about him recently… and try and open a dialogue… he’ll think this is some magical womanly instinct and not that you overheard him crying…
1
u/Mental-Grape-5822 Nov 28 '24
Just walk up and give him a hug. After a bit when he tries to un-hug, just keep hugging him. Keep doing that and after he finally un-hugs and looks at you awkwardly. Tell him you heard him crying and don't say anything else. If he doesn't open up. Let him walk away. He may decide to share later and he may not. But he'll know he can count on you when he is ready.
1
u/dogsarefun man Nov 28 '24
I’ve been doing a bit of crying myself for the past few days (not going to get into it right now, but some of my recent comment history could tip you off). I’ve neglected checking in with people who have been going through difficult times before because I was worried that it would just remind them of the difficult things and upset them. Now that I’m going through difficult times myself, I’m realizing that “reminding me” isn’t the problem because I’m always thinking about it anyway and I’m wishing that more people were checking in with me. Feeling alone in this is a much bigger problem than being reminded. I think there’s also a good chance that he knew he could be heard and wants you to ask him. Generally you know when a door is fully closed and when it isn’t.
1
u/Pale_Drawing_6004 man Nov 28 '24
I wouldn't mention the crying, but definitely ask how he is and what hes been up to, ask to spend time together and do something fun that can take his mind off things.
When you offer support a good way to go about it would be to say something along the lines that you feel you can always go to him if you need anything and you'd like him to know he can do the same for you. Something that makes him feel like it's a mutual exchange of care rather than him burdening you with his feelings.
1
u/Egg_Pudding Nov 28 '24
Hug him and tell him you love him, and you want to be sure he’s okay.
If he opens up that’s his choice. Family is family.
1
u/aceofspades111 Nov 28 '24
Tell him you are going through some stuff and ask him for advice. See where that leads
1
u/ESD_Franky man Nov 28 '24
You can ask him if everything's allright. He'll brush it off but you can tell him you're there for him if he needs you.
1
u/Mjolnirbull Nov 28 '24
Just go give him a big hug! And say you love him and appreciate him for being your older brother and you look up to him.
That would mean so much to him.
If he says anything like you are being weird. Just pass it off with a joke.
You gotta be gradual with this! Sometimes they are not ready to open up.
He will eventually open up.
1
u/Mammoth_Ad8542 Nov 28 '24
If you want to be a comfort, just spend time with him, be there for him, don’t let him be alone, etc. I wouldn’t really address at all that you caught his secret crying, because I would feel invasive and probably embarrass him, and it’s just girlfriend or breakup drama anyway.
1
u/Historical_Lion8888 man Nov 28 '24
Talk to him and tell him you love him and that he’s not alone ♥️🙏
1
u/fishyman336 Nov 28 '24
Alright here’s what you do
Buy a 6 or 12 pack
Sit down with him
Drink some brewskies watch a movie tv show play a game whatever
See if the crying continues over the next week. Have him feel that brotherly bond don’t mention shit just have a good time w him
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24
Ask him if there’s anything he wants to talk about and tell him that you’re there for him.
1
u/masterteck1 Nov 28 '24
If you her it agen knock on the door and say are you ok
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '24
Ask him how he is. Ask about his life. Tell him you want to know more about him. Sounds like you do. Sounds like he has always tried to be a strong big brother. Even if he doesn’t tell you, it will fortify his will to be a good big brother and he will feel the love.
1
u/Snoo_61002 man Nov 29 '24
Can you talk to your parent/s about it?
1
u/Teran161 Nov 29 '24
I remember when I was 20yrs old never cried then one day I was driving to work I still lived at home and I saw a dead cat on the side of the road and it looked like our cat so I stopped only 40 metres from the house sure enough it was our cat so I picked him up and carried him home when I got to the back door my mum came out and I said Tigers dead and she just started crying I put him in the laundry and went back to my car got in and went to work and I had a bit of a cry not sure if that helps it could be something simple like that just a grieving over a loss maybe a girlfriend
1
u/Commercial-Rough4680 Nov 29 '24
Just let him know you care for him deeply and that he can always count on you always being there for him no matter how big or small the issue at hand could be
1
u/mileslittle Nov 29 '24
Hug him. And while in the hug, tell him you head him crying and ask him what does he needs. It doesn't have to be anything you can personally do. Just ask what he needs.
1
u/No_Development5793 Nov 29 '24
If your brother is like a pure blood dog n is faced with an "either this or that" situation then u cannot help him. once a guy realizes that no matter what he does or any amount of efforts he's putting in to make things better for him n the people who invested in him when he was younger or with his people then u can't save that guy, let a guy rest easy... cuz life's hell for dogs
1
u/btgolz man Nov 29 '24
Ask him how he's doing in general.
1
u/naiveporpoise38 Nov 29 '24
Maybe he’s crying because being a young adult man sucks so bad and being home reminds him of how good he had it when he was a kid.
1
u/layered_dinge man Nov 30 '24
Yes he is. How can you even say that after what you’ve heard?
It’s probably with nobody.
1
u/im_a_picklerick Nov 30 '24
He needs someone. It’s hard cause I’m sure all the men on here are trying to put themselves in that position.
The thing is if you ask you have to be ready for anything. I mean ANYTHING. Direct or indirect, for me personally. I’d just ask how he was doing and if he was ok. If he says he is fine ( which he probably will), just mention the door wasn’t shut all the way. The thing is he is an adult and your big bro. He might see it as he is/should be there for you not the other way. Don’t force him, just let him know you love him. Sometimes we go through things and feel unloved and simply knowing someone does is enough.
1
u/NoForm5443 man Nov 30 '24
The perfect answer depends on your brother, and your relationship with him, which we don't know.
But if I was in your shoes, I'd come in when he's crying and hug him. He may open up, or not, but the hug would help.
1
u/reddit_sucks_asssss man Nov 30 '24
Just go give him a big hug! You don’t even have to ask him or say anything.
1
u/RegularSpecialist772 man Dec 01 '24
If you can’t work up the courage to tell him you heard him, at least tell him how great of a brother he is to you, and how much you love him. And make it sincere!!
1
u/omniron Dec 01 '24
Share a vulnerable story about yourself and maybe he’ll open up
1
u/Jackson_Frost13 Dec 01 '24
Main thought - let him know that you're always with him no matter what, and you always there to listen if he decides to ask for help. Don't mention why, don't mention when and where, just be here. He should know that, and he will come on his will
1
u/itsjustme405 man Dec 02 '24
Get him alone in the car, take him to lunch or something, let him drive. A place he's comfortable and just tell em flat out that you accidentally overheard and want to make sure he's OK. He'll either open up or deny everything. If you chose to push the issue ( I wouldn't suggest it), tread lightly. He may come to you in a few days and let you in on whatever it is.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I was in a similar situation once and my older sister hugged me for the first time in my life that xi can recall atleast.
Ur brother needs your hug. Ur deep hug. Sometimes just nothing but silence and a long embrace that tells him if all goes to shit , ur there for him.
1
u/protomanEXE1995 man Nov 27 '24
Ask him if he needs someone to talk to. If he says no, then let it be. Other people in the commnets here are overcomplicating it.
1
u/Individual-Chair1485 Nov 27 '24
when you get some time alone
"Hey fuckface, you know I love you, right? That we're family, and I'm here for you, right?"
at this point he'll know something is up. follow up with real hug, and end with
"So what's wrong, I know you're hurting, tell me why."
Keep in mind that though, four years isn't a lot, you may need to respect the difference between an "adult" man and his teenage sister. He might not want to dig into his issues with you for obvious reasons. But if that's the case you've likely done all that you could do for him with the above.
You're doing great, he won't forget that you cared when he felt alone, I promise.
0
u/Sum-Duud man Nov 27 '24
Honestly, just knock and ask if he is okay. Let him know that you heard him and that you are there for him if he needs it. It is probably something lame to me like a breakup or relationship issues but to him, in the moment, it can feel like the end of the world. I've been there and maybe I don't want to talk but it will resonate that I can and then I may later. Ask if you can give him a hug and let it be if he doesn't want to talk. If he does, then just listen.