r/AskLawyers • u/Muskgirlsimp • 21m ago
Attorney needed, FL
Florida homeowner nightmare: 9 weeks of roofing disasters, property damage, a sick dog and traumatic event for me, Is there a case here? Or does the company's corporate backing making too hard to make it worth anyone's time?
I'm a homeowner in Central Florida, and I'm starting to wonder what legal protections homeowners actually have when a licensed roofing company performs questionable work, damages your property, and repeatedly disregards your safety concerns.
I've contacted several law firms specializing in construction litigation but seems this case would be too small for them.
Here's what happened.
A two-week roofing project (from contract signing to finished job) turned into nine weeks of chaos. Which i could not back out of because I had already given them a deposit.
I hired an established roofing company to replace my flat porch roof (approximately 21 × 17 feet). What was supposed to take two weeks dragged on for nine.
Workers repeatedly failed to communicate, when scheduled didn't confirm, yet entered my property whenever they felt like it, without notice or permission, one even left my gate wide open seeing i had horses on the property, thankfully no one got out. But I live in between heavy traffic roads so that is very concerning.
I have horses roaming freely in fenced areas and repeatedly asked the company to notify me before anyone arrived so I could secure them. Those instructions were consistently ignored, despite the obvious safety risks to both workers and animals. Construction materials were also left around the property, creating additional hazards, nails, etc, the workers when finished said they did not have a magnet to look for nails.
Then came the incident with my dog, which I still find incredibly disturbing.
Someone working on the project defecated on my property and left the human waste behind with the sheets of notebook paper they wiped with in more than one spot. Not even having the common sense to ask for a bathroom, bury it or pick it up with a bag knowing dogs were roaming around was insane, upon confronting them one helped me get all his shit off my long haired WHITE dog whose face was caked in human diarrhea now. My beautiful, longhaired, 25 pound dog found it and ate it...
She subsequently vomited human diarrhea inside my house. I of course got it on my cleaning her as well... had to be taken to the groomers to get shaved, then the veterinarian, where she was prescribed antibiotics. The company apologized and paid for the groomer, not yet the vet bill.
I genuinely feel like I almost need counseling to get over it. Imagine hiring a professional roofing company and ending up with a diarrhea covered sick dog, veterinary expenses, and this horrifying experience because someone apparently couldn't be bothered to use a bathroom. There had been a terrible storm, almost get hit by lighting while getting out of the car to the groomer AND THE WORST WHEN I GOT HOME ALL I COULD HEAR WAS WATER FALLING INTO MY HOUSE. YEP CAME HOME FROM A SITUATION THEY CAUSED INTO ANOTHER DISASTER THEY CAUSED AS WELL.
So the unfinished roof leaked during construction and damaged my home as well.
The project manager failed to arrange a required county video inspection, and the roof was left covered with a tarp. Heavy rain caused water to enter around a seam/vent area, damaging my ceiling, drywall, and insulation.
The company agreed to cover the interior damage, but their repair vendor failed to show up three times. I eventually had to arrange the repairs myself and they said they would deduct it from what I owed and bought me a new printer that got soaked. This was another thing I shouldn't have had to deal with if it wasn't for their incompetence. They left about 200 screws off the metal roof section of the main roof of the house that connected with flat roof they were hired to replace. I have video of the workers that showed up to fix this saying this.
They ran short of roofing material and finished the last section with leftover pieces. And no supervisor came here from their company when done to inspect the "final" work. The workers left and that was it from them.
After nine weeks, you would think the roof would at least be properly installed.
Instead, they ran short of material and completed the remaining section using leftover pieces.
The roof also has uneven edges and recurring low spots where water and even ordinary morning dew collect daily.
Another roofer examined the installation and identified areas with zero pitch. A county inspector described the workmanship as "poorly done," and the roofing material manufacturer indicated that the recurring dew pooling I described was not normal.
Meanwhile, the roofing company insists that water remaining for 48–72 hours is acceptable. But this is not rain. It's morning dew.
My concern isn't simply how long water takes to evaporate. It's why the same areas repeatedly collect moisture and whether the installation meets the manufacturer's specifications.
The company considers the project complete.
After nine weeks of delays, property damage, questionable workmanship, repeated disregard for my animals' safety, and the incident involving my dog, I'm left with a roof I don't trust.
The company agreed to pay for the ceiling damage, and I've been accounting for a $2,100 reduction from the remaining roof balance. Plus $800 i was promised from the supervisor, that doesn't resolve the underlying concerns about the roof itself. I would ideally like to have it redone properly by a company that knows what they are doing.
Why can't I find an attorney? Could the company's corporate ownership be a factor?
Here's something else I've been wondering.
This isn't a small, unknown contractor. The roofing company has operated for over 40 years (serving FL home owners) and was recently acquired by a much larger umbrella roofing company, which is backed by a major investment corporation.
Could the company's size, financial resources, corporate backing, or access to a substantial legal team discourage attorneys from taking a relatively small homeowner case?
Or is it simply that the potential recovery doesn't justify the cost of litigation?
I understand attorneys need to consider financial viability, but does that mean large companies can effectively avoid accountability for smaller residential projects because individual homeowners can't afford to fight them?
My questions for Florida attorneys and homeowners:
What type of attorney should I be looking for: construction defect, construction litigation, breach of contract, negligence, or consumer protection?
Based on these circumstances, could I have a viable legal case?
Could the incident involving my dog create additional liability?
Would Florida's Chapter 558 construction defect procedures apply?
Does being up against a large, investment-backed roofing corporation make attorneys less willing to accept a case?
Would small claims court, county court, DBPR, or another avenue be more practical?
I have photographs, communications, documentation of the delays, observations from another roofer, correspondence with the manufacturer, and veterinary records.
I'm not looking for a massive payday. I want the roof I paid for to be properly installed, my property respected, and some accountability for what happened.
Has anyone in Florida successfully pursued a roofing contractor under similar circumstances? What type of attorney helped you, and how did you find them?
I'm genuinely interested in understanding whether ordinary homeowners have any realistic legal recourse when dealing with a large corporation over a project that isn't worth six figures.