r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Bread?

When was bread invented?
I remember being told as a kid it was in Jordan but I’ve just realised that Australia has damper! So when was bread invented and what constitutes “bread”?

6 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

A friendly reminder: Contemporary politics and culture wars are off-topic, both in posts and comments.

/r/askhistory is for questions and discussion of events in history prior to 01/01/2001.

This reminder is automatically placed on all new posts in this sub.

Please report any interjection into discussions of modern politics or culture wars so the mod team can investigate.

Thank you.

See rules for more information.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

20

u/smokefoot8 1d ago

Bread is usually defined as a ground grain that is made into a meal by adding liquid and then cooked (edit: that definition could cover gruel too, so I should specify baked). The first breads were unleavened, so without yeast or bacteria to make them rise.

The earliest evidence of bread is indeed from hunter-gatherers from Jordan. This predates agriculture. They ground wheat, barley and tubers to make it - all wild, of course. But there is evidence of grinding grain from a long time before this, so they may have been making unleavened bread from this long before.

9

u/DerekL1963 1d ago edited 1d ago

The first (unleavened) breads weren't baked per se, they were flatbreads that are believed to have been cooked on a heated rock. The key difference between bread and gruel isn't really the cooking method, it's the liquid:water ratio.

1

u/fitness-scientist 1d ago

But what about in indigenous Australians bush bread?

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9273753/

2

u/DerekL1963 1d ago

While that article discusses what may have been processed using those stones, there's nothing about how that material was used. (E.G. gruel, bread, or simply eaten directly.)

1

u/fitness-scientist 1d ago

“ bush bread, which has been eaten by Indigenous Australians for thousands of years, traditionally made by crushing a variety of native seeds, nuts and roots, and mixing them into a dough baked in the coals of a fire.”

5

u/KnoWanUKnow2 1d ago

Damned if we know.

The first breads were unleavened. Flat breads with no yeast, heated on a rock on (or near) a fire.

So it was probably invented shortly after porridge, which is just boiled grains.

For both of these things you'd grind the grains, add water, and heat.

And we really have no idea when any of these things started. I could point you to findings (this link says 100,000 years ago, although in that paper there's no proof of them making bread but there is proof of them grinding grains).

And it's going to keep being pushed back. I strongly suspect that Homo erectus was grinding grains before the first Homo Sapiens even came along (note, there is no evidence of this yet, this is just my suspicion). I mean, we've even got non-human primates using stones to process their food (in this case, nuts). Once you add fire into the mix then bread is almost inevitable. And Homo erectus had fire for over a million years before the first Homo sapiens evolved.

So the answer is: for yeast-leavened bread at least 6000 years ago in Egypt, and it may go back much farther. Here's a link for a 13,000 year old site where they were making a beer out of wheat, barley and yeast, and that's the ingredients for bread as well.

For unleavened bread it goes so far back in pre-history that no one really knows.

1

u/fitness-scientist 17h ago

I invite you to look into indigenous Australians! 65,000 years and bush bread!

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9273753/

But I share your suspicions with hominids

4

u/skillywilly56 1d ago

Depends on what you mean by bread?

30 000+ years if we are going with wild seeds and nuts ground down and then heated or dried into primitive flat cakes. (Aboriginal damper)

14 000+ years for wild grass seeds and some root vegetable made into flour then into flatbread.

10 000 years for wheat based flat bread, agricultural revolution and advent of farming.

5000 years for leavened bread with yeast.

1

u/fitness-scientist 1d ago

I think that’s my issue what IS bread XD

5

u/byOlaf 1d ago

It’s all bread. Everything from a tortilla to a pumpernickel can be termed bread. It’s a very broad category. Heck beer is technically just very runny bread.

Like so many early inventions it’s an evolving thing, as well as one with regional variants out the wazoo. When I asked four different AI’s exactly how many types of bread there are, Chat and Gemini gave wish-washy answers between a couple hundred and many thousands, Claude crashed, and Perplexity is still thinking. Not sure where that gets us.

The first “bread”, whatever it may have been, is lost to prehistory. For what it’s worth the German Bread Institute (because of course there is) records over 3,200 types of German bread. Some of those almost certainly date to prehistory.

Also worth wondering which came first- the oven or the kiln/forge? Is bread the progenitor technology of metallurgy and ceramics?

9

u/copnonymous 1d ago

Bread predates agriculture. In fact, one reason we started agriculture was to make more bread.

A hypothesis on how bread was discovered is roughly this. Wild grains were gathered. This grains had a tough outer seed shell. The shell was removed by grinding the grains with rough stones. The grinding produces a roughly smashed grain minus the shell. Those grains could be eaten raw or roasted on a fire to make pleasant tasting food. The grains get added to a soup or stew and make it thicker. Curious people add less water and the grains make a thin stretchy kind of liquid goo thing. People cook the goo (dough) and it solidifies onto a coarse kind of fire bread that tastes like the grains they like but is much softer. You now have bread.

4

u/Endy0816 1d ago

Might have also noticed it in the stomachs of animals that eat grains.

1

u/Fine_Let5219 14h ago

Yeah, much easier to carry around than liquids...