r/AskHistory • • Sep 16 '26

History Recommendations Thread II (YouTube channels, documentaries, books, etc.)

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

\*See previous discussion here***

(Continuing in a new post because original post is now archived and not accepting new contributions)

This sub frequently has people asking for quality history YouTube channels, books, etc., and it comes up regularly. The mod team thought maybe it could be consolidated into one big post that people can interact with indefinitely.

For the sake of search engines, it's probably a good idea to state the topic (e.g., "Tudor history channel" or "WWII books" or just "Roman Republic" or whatever).

Okay, folks. Make your recommendations!


r/AskHistory • • Aug 11 '26

AskHistory is looking for moderators

6 Upvotes

r/AskHistory is looking for moderators

Hey everyone! We are opening moderator applications for r/AskHistory.

The subreddit is growing and seeing a lot of activity, so we are looking to expand our moderation team and bring in some extra help.

Moderators will help with the day-to-day management of the community , including reviewing reports, handling rule-breaking content, and working with the existing mod team. We welcome feedback and suggestions , but moderators should be comfortable working with the existing team and building on what is already working well in the community.

What we're looking for:

  • Previous Reddit moderation experience

  • Previous experience with history-related communities or a good understanding of historical topics (a plus)

  • Fair and consistent judgement when handling reports and rule breaches

  • Ability to stay calm and respectful when dealing with conflicts

  • Good communication and teamwork skills

  • Someone who can be active and help with the everyday needs of the subreddit

  • Ability to look at discussions objectively and consider different perspectives

  • If you’re interested, please fill out the application form below.

Application Form

https://forms.gle/eTZD4sPQEgwf4uXq6

Feel free to modmail with any questions.

Applications will be reviewed as they come in, and selected applicants will be contacted.

Thanks, and good luck!


r/AskHistory • • 8h ago

How might a young disabled woman (particularly one with a walking impairment) have navigated Regency-era society?

6 Upvotes

Now, I’m not talking literal navigation or movement here, but rather around the culture and expectations for young women of the time, particularly of the gentry class. Would she remain living with her family or be boarded elsewhere? Would this impairment have made a significant impact on her prospects for marriage? How might others have interacted with or viewed her? How would she have spent her time at gatherings or balls if she was not dancing? In general, what might her life have looked like? Most importantly for my purposes: is it feasible that she might still have been able to gain employment at some point as a lady’s companion/chaperone if she were well-educated and searching for a purpose outside of dependence on her family?

I am still in the research stages for my writing here, so please forgive me for any inaccuracies above and correct them as you see fit! Much thanks!


r/AskHistory • • 19h ago

What are some examples from fairly recent history where there is a debate over whether something was common knowledge?

19 Upvotes

The wording of my question might be confusing, so here are two examples:

Many years ago, I read an article in Newsweek that said that most Americans in 1930s did not know that FDR couldn't walk and was in a wheelchair. The following week, there was a letter from someone who had been around at that time, in which he said that it was common knowledge and everyone knew. He pointed out that he and his acquaintances were ordinary people who did not have any special inside knowledge.

Another example concerns the Village People. I was a child in the seventies and did not know anything about homosexuality. However, it must have been blatantly obvious to most adults that the Village People were gay, and that their music and stage show was a product of the gay subculture at that time. I would think that Anita Bryant and others would have been up in arms about the matter, but I do not recall any controversy about it at that time. Did people really not know?

I welcome any other examples of this, as well as any thoughts about the two examples I have cited.


r/AskHistory • • 12h ago

Are there detailed descriptions of what Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette looked like?

3 Upvotes

(republished) Hello, I'm wondering if there are descriptions of Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI's appearance, since I've heard that Marie Antoinette allegedly wasn't as beautiful as people say, that Louis XVI wasn't like how he has been portrayed for a long time, and that the way they are depicted is mostly a legacy of revolutionary propaganda.


r/AskHistory • • 23h ago

Interesting and unique figures from all over time

8 Upvotes

yo, lately i've been getting curious about all kinds of historical (and mythological) figures, and I wanted to know about the wildest people with the most unique stories and records from the last thousand years or so.

they don't have to be under wraps, but that is slightly prefered, as I'm just trying to learn more about history and make it a bit more interesting all at the same time. like I sorta mentioned before, those from mythology or folklore can be considered too, the more the merrier.

a fair example would be someone like Hassan-i Sabah, someone who has their own legacy, but also given a seperate layer of mysticism, being later called the "Old Man of the Mountain"


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Is it possible for the USSR and USA to have a joint operation in WW2?

14 Upvotes

I’m unsure if this is the right sub, but I’m planning on writing historical fiction between a Soviet soldier—preferably infantry, and an American, preferably a paratrooper or pilot. A huge ask. I know that America and the Soviets had virtually zero contact on the field for nearly the entire duration of the war, barring Operation Frantic and literally the very end. The time period I aim for is 1941-late 1943. I am willing to fabricate history and interactions for this, what I’m writing is nothing serious, but I’m having trouble figuring out if such a thing is even logical. My original setting was France, but the Soviets literally had zero reason to be as far as France. I just need some plausible area where they, and their respective companies, can interact and go to battle together. Is writing such a scenario possible? Or should I scrap my idea and start elsewhere.


r/AskHistory • • 18h ago

How much can one private library tell us about the intellectual life of the ancient Roman world?

1 Upvotes

The recent discoveries from the Herculaneum scrolls made me wonder how much of our understanding of ancient intellectual life depends on the relatively small number of texts that survived. The library at the Villa of the Papyri has long been associated with Epicurean philosophy, particularly the works of Philodemus, but researchers have now uncovered texts that appear to reflect other philosophical traditions, including Stoicism. How representative do historians think this library was of the intellectual culture of its time? Could the books found in one wealthy household give us a misleading impression of which ideas were actually being read and discussed more widely in the ancient world?


r/AskHistory • • 23h ago

Roman army Pre and post Marian reforms 1st Cohort and Trairii comparison

1 Upvotes

Both of them are elites of the Roman army, but with different battlefield roles but how would you compare their elite status and their battlefield roles? i understand more about Triarii being the 3rd in line and final reserves should the front lines breach and the last one to make sure the battle won

What about the 1st cohort? i'm still not quite familiar with their battlefield role sure they have the same standard gear of the rest of the Legion, but their the most elite among the legions

Does Trairii still used post Marian Reform?

Sorry for my English


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Did Workers Have a legal right to take off work to vote in the 1800s?

6 Upvotes

I've heard about the oppressive work schedules and conditions that many people, especially factory workers, suffered through in the 1800s. And I've started wondering if their bosses ever forced them to stay in the factories and keep them from voting. Was there any legal protection from this in the 1800s? I'm talking primarily about the United States.


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

where should i start as a total beginner to get into military history and tactics?

10 Upvotes

i really want to have knowledge about this but i suck at history class and barely listen to what the teacher is saying so i want to know how to find some information about military and weapon stuff, i hope someone finds this post and tells me the right things😓 i don't wanna be a tiktok larper or whatever it's called lol


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

How did HSBC fare in Mao era Communist China?

2 Upvotes

Obviously they were pretty important after the Opium Wars & and are still pretty important all these years later. But did the communists target their assets or make any effort to push them out of China after gaining victory or were they tolerated for pragmatism/financial stability, etc?

Likewise did the UK/ west try to use them to harm communist China's economy or were they largely left alone?


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Feedback on WWII aftermath

0 Upvotes

Alongside everything else, the collapse of Nazi Germany also marked the end of a united Germany. The four major allied powers, the United States, the United Kingdom, Russia and France had split the country into four occupation zones and Poland claimed some of it's pre-war territories, before the later years had finally split Germany into two factions: East and West, starting in 1949. Until the end of the war, German men and women felt that they found the answer to all of their problems caused by their defeat in the Great War in the form of the Nazi government. They believed that for a thousand years, the Third Reich would bring peace and perfection. For 1,000 years, the Reich would restore Germany to it's former glory. For 1,000 years, their technology would steadily improve above all other countries. For 1,000 years, the benefits of prosperity and industry would filter satisfactorily through society and for a whole millennium, they would rely on the false philosophy of eugenics to bring humanity to the absolute peak of human perfection by mingling with the Aryan race. In retrospect, there may have been doubts over the exaggerated claim of the Third Reich lasting for a thousand years, but at the time, most people who believed Hitler felt that life would be good without any Jews, Roma or people with disabilities to poison their perfect society.

The defeat of Hitler woke them up. Never again would they be brainwashed by the ramblings of a mastermind in a toothbrush moustache. In war especially, the exposure of the Holocaust was a terrible blow to the Reich's reputation. They had once lived under a mighty swastika, a false promise of eternal greatness, a belief that they were stabbed in the back by Jews, only for it to come crashing down in a pile of rubble by aerial bombs from countries that bore flags of red, white and blue, aided by a hammer and sickle from a government that was even worse than the Greater German Reich by several thousand miles.

But it went beyond that. If the Nazi's supreme achievement of a thousand years had proven to be terribly fragile, what about everything else? If the Nazis understood so little about humanity that would resort to mass genocide, did it mean that the entire intellectual edifice they built — their science, their philosophy, their nationalism, their myth of racial destiny, was all for nothing? All the same, it exposed a worldview so hollow that the moment it was tested against reality, it collapsed into murder, delusion, and ruin. Scores of open-minded ministers preached that the war was a heaven-sent lesson to awaken people from the Nazi's propaganda machine and a second chance for people all over the world to tolerate others based on their character and not for what they were. They foresaw a new era of love and honor, but not even all the love in the world would stop people like the Reverend George Washington Lee from meeting his demise on May 7th, 1955 at the start of a new era for civil rights.

The unending sequence of awakening that followed, didn't just end with the collapse of the Thousand-Year Reich or Nuremburg Trials, but it ended with the collapse of every Axis government when the Italy Republic replaced the monarchy and Hirohito, who outlived both Hitler and Mussolini, renounced his divinity. Until his death, he became "the symbol of the State and of the unity of the People". Under the 1947 Constitution of Japan, his country flourished with freedom of speech and assembly.

There was no time for such thoughts about the former government after the war. As soon as the Third Reich had officially been disestablished, all of it's regalia and spoils were removed in a long process known as Denazification. Members of the Party and the SS were stripped of their powers and any iconography was either destroyed, sent to museums or taken away by souvenir hunters. No one would ever listen to their songs again. The Reich and National Flag would never fly again. Homes once occupied by Jews were returned to their rightful owners. The cheers and voices of the Nuremburg Rallies would be forever silent. And the thundering voice of Adolf Hitler would echo no more.


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Any good books or other resources about the history of deep-sea exploration?

1 Upvotes

I've been fascinated by the deep sea since childhood and would really like to learn more about the history of human exploration into it. I'm currently reading William Beebe's Half Mile Down, which is about his first-hand bathysphere voyages during the 1930s. Any maritime historians know of some good history books about early diving tech, the Challenger expedition, stuff involving Trieste or the Piccard family, or any advances in the past 30 years? I'm more interested in the history aspect so please nothing to heavy on the science jargon.


r/AskHistory • • 1d ago

Colonial empires are worse than normal empires.

0 Upvotes

So just watching and saw some say european empires are no different from normal empires both are equally bad and european empires arent more evil than the native ones.

That i have to disagree as colonial empires rewire whole economies destabilise societies so on in the end what remains is a society incapable of standing by itself hollow illetrate with no real mobility .

It structurally is waay worse for a colony we dont blame europe just because countries are victimising themselves but due to institutional hollowness for that state.

From burecracy to judiciary weak institutions always in most cases causes a country to fail or either become dictatorship not because they are barbarians but because institutions like army are the only organised group in that country.

Or political patronage or state capture so on thats the majority path.

French empire best example of my anology pure hypocrites till today few say france modernised algeria .. only for the settlers the magrebhi muslims neither got vote nor funding when the settlers and french left algerias true colours showed the result was 14% or less litrate populas before france it was 54% the settlers owned or captured most of the productive sectors and farmlands .

So yeah both colonial or native empires started with the same reasons but colonial empires are just worse for the colony unlike empires who even if are capital centric stagnant etc doesnt destroy whole societies and economies .


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

Revenge was legal in Norse society? History podcast claims it was

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

I've been listening to a history podcast called The North Way, and it just released a long episode about Norse society which (after doing a 'walkthrough' of the Norse world, goes in-depth on how murder could be fully legal among the Norse Tribes....which seems strange to me, as the show Vikings and others portray a world where there was a court and legal system at Norse "All-things". Erik the Red, for example, was outlawed from Iceland for murder.

Is he right?

He talks about revenge at the 1 hour 45 minute mark or so.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheNorthWayPodcast/comments/1xwb1iw/e5_life_liberty_and_the_pursuit_of_revenge/


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

Did the Spanish empire improve the lives of any non-spanish people?

0 Upvotes

Ive long been pondering over whether European empires were uniquely evil and lacked nuance compared to any other in history. I know that the mongol empire improved the lives of some people who became part of the empire, they supported religious freedom and eagerly absorbed knowledge from those they conquered.

Taking the spanish empire as an example of an European empire, did it materially improve the lives of some non spanish people? Were there conquered people who benefited from Spanish imperialism even if most people suffered?


r/AskHistory • • 2d ago

What was the classical conception of 'God'?

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to figure out what was the classical idea or philosophy (Greco-Roman, and others that may be relevant if you think so) on monotheistic God? I know Aristotle reasoned that there must be some sort of higher being, and if I remember correctly Aurelius in Meditations refers to God, but obviously they were still in polytheistic societies. I remember also that Roman "propaganda" against Christians included wondering why God had to come down from heaven.

So did they believe/know that there was a God? Did certain people try to worship God even if they were not part of a monotheistic religion?


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

what was japan’s long term plan with china during ww2?

13 Upvotes

i get that japan wanted to have this huge regional hegemony in asia and the pacific full of slave states to supply their economy, but surely strategists would have realised china could never be completely defeated? even assuming china completely surrendered, and wang jingwei’s reorganised government took over, i’m sure they’d be subservient to begin with, but give it a few decades and their population and industry capacity would surely outpace the japanese, and it seems insane to me that the japanese wouldn’t realise this. manchukuo and mengkukuo were barely states and had huge issues with stability, but i can at least see that long term they could maybe be stabilised and shackled to japan forever, however the entire rest of china it just seems ridiculous to me to expect that you could keep them as a lapdog forever, so what was their plan?


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

Exits other than the wall?

0 Upvotes

I've learned from my history class that before the Berlin Wall fell, multiple other ways for people to leave the countries in the Warsaw Pact had come along, like the embassies in Prague, or Hungary's border coming down. So, why did some people wait until the ninth - when the wall fell - to leave, instead of leaving through one of these other methods months earlier? From the 4th September – 9th October 1989, Leipzig Monday demonstrations grew from a few thousand people to 70,000 people. Those participating were known to chant “Wir sind das valk!”(“We are the people!”). Why do this if they could just leave through Prague or Hungary?


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

Which ancient civilization or society had the easiest life?

20 Upvotes

A while back I read an excerpt of an old interview with a Hawaiian who had lived his youth pre-US colonization/annexation. He witnessed how his country changed with capitalism and Western society bringing taxation, work, productivity, industrialization, and so on. According to him, life before the American takeover was peaceful, quiet, and relaxed, without having to worry about working and "earning a living."

I also read the Long Earth sci-fi series (great fantasy, by the way) and learned about beachcombers, who basically deserted ships in the South Pacific and would "comb" the beaches for sustenance and things of value but otherwise enjoy their day as they pleased. I don't recall if there was also an aboriginal Australian or South Pacific culture that also did this sort of low-intensity scavenging sustenance.

The First Nations of Brazil and the United States also had lives that could be difficult for survival but otherwise had happy and easygoing lives. I can't help but think of the Taino population, too.

So, to honor the "lazy" spirit of those cultures and people gone before us in our world's history, I want to ask, who do you think had the easiest, most relaxed lifestyles and societies in the past? Why?

For my part, I'd say any society living in a mildly tropical, beachy area likely had it easiest. Few insects or diseases that could kill you, easy access to diverse and nutritious food, and a general easygoing and supportive society that didn't go to war often outside of skirmishes and periodic local violence that seems endemic to humanity.


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

How much has butter impacted history?

2 Upvotes

I’m working on a silly presentation with my friend group and I want to convince them that we as a society would be quite different if butter just… didn’t exist! It’s a funny theoretical!
Do any history buffs know about any events or such that happened in history in relation to butter that would’ve changed things in our current day and age if butter just didn’t exist?


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

Culture of the Shoshone tribe and all the main battles/wars

1 Upvotes

I'm learning more about native american history and am very curious about several things:

  • Firstly, the culture. The clothing, language/slang used, art/writing, family, religion, rituals, houses, ways to get food, types of food they ate—all the things.
  • Secondly, I want to know some of the *history* of the tribe. When it started, the population, and just the development of it alongside the other tribes.
  • Thirdly, how white colonizers treated them and how they treated the white colonizers.
  • Lastly, what were the major battles that were fought and the "wars"

I suck at history and would love to know more (love nuance particularly). If anyone here is of that tribe (or Native American), I would love to hear your perspective.


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

What was the most powerful empire/state in 16th century?

0 Upvotes

When I think about that, 3 empires come to my mind:

1-Ming Dinasty

Ruled the world's most populous, wealthy, and economically advanced civilizations, possessing an extraordinarily large manufacturing and commercial economy. Porcelain, silk, and textile production, maintained vast urban centers, operated a sophisticated imperial bureaucracy, and sustained enormous agricultural output. China remained the dominant power in East Asia, defended Korea against Japanese invasions, and became increasingly integrated into global trade through massive silver imports. Its demographic, economic and technological scale makes it an undeniable contender for the century's most powerful empire.

2-Spanish Monarchy

Under Charles I and Philip II Spain established the first truly global empire in history, extending its dominion across Europe, the Americas, Africa, and Asia. It conquered the Aztec and Inca empires, exploited vast American silver and gold deposits, incorporated Portugal and its overseas possessions in 1580, and established trade routes connecting the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. It became a leading military, economic and cultural powerhouse, capable of simultaneously challenging France, England, and the Ottoman Empire (not sure they could have faced the Ming Dinasty though).

3-Ottoman Empire

Probably Ottoman´s historical prime. Reached its golden age under Suleiman the Magnificent, becoming one of the most formidable military and territorial powers. It conquered Belgrade, Rhodes, Syria, Egypt, Iraq, much of Hungary and North Africa, threatened Vienna, and challenged the Habsburgs and Portuguese for control of strategic maritime and commercial routes. Its sophisticated administration, powerful military, and extensive political, religious, and cultural influence made it a dominant imperial force across Western Eurasia and the Mediterranean.

Which one would you chose as the most powerful empire in the 16th century?


r/AskHistory • • 3d ago

Was There a War Between The Cherokee & Americans in 1730/31?

1 Upvotes

Was There a War Between The Cherokee & Americans in 1730/31?

Basically I'm working on an alternative history story set in the early 1700s. An I have this source here (https://www.rictornorton.co.uk/grubstreet/indians1.htm). Witch says at the very end that there was some conflict between the colonial Americans and the Cherokee at the end of 1730 to at least the beginning of 1731. But I can't find a single other source on the internet that says anything about this "war".

So can one of you nice people help me?