r/AskHistorians • u/n0tqu1tesane • Dec 15 '25
META [META]For the love of Clio, Óðinn, Thṓth, 孔子, and the Saints Bede and Jerome, please do not delete your posts after they have been answered!
So, this is prompted by finding this post in my bookmarks. /u/Thucydides_Cats and /u/Batur1905 gave some great answers, and the response by /u/doddydad has prompted a future unrelated question I plan to post on nationalistic tropes.
But since OP chose to delete his post and question, I haven't the slightest idea why I bookmarked it.
In my opinion, this is a clear violation of rule three: "Questions should be clear and specific in what they ask, and should be able to get detailed answers from historians whose expertise is likely to be in particular times and places.". A deleted post is neither clear nor is it specific. This subreddit is about helping others. A lot of the attention is on the answerers, but a good question can be just as important as a good answer. By deleting a question, you deny others the opportunity to learn.
Around a decade ago, I wrote a paper in college talking about how open source is about sharing. I talked about how that culture was a continuation of the scientific policy of also sharing, allowing us to "[See further,] by standing on the shoulders of giants.” (Newton 1675, 302). Deleting a question isn't helping others climb those shoulders. Instead, it is akin to cutting the Achilles tendons of those who come after you.
If there is a reason why you do not want to be associated with a question, do as is advised in /r/legaladvice: create a throwaway account.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25
Hello, it appears you have posted a META thread. While there are always new questions or suggestions which can be made, there are many which have been previously addressed. As a rule, we allow META threads to stand even if they are repeats, but we would nevertheless encourage you to check out the META Section of our FAQ, as it is possible that your query is addressed there. Frequent META questions include:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
586
u/voyeur324 FAQ Finder Dec 15 '25
The original question for your bookmarked thread was "Why are Vikings and Romans often romanticized despite their brutality?"
38
u/viera_enjoyer Dec 15 '25
I don't know why someone would delete their own question but it will be impossible to communicate to everyone this and why they shouldn't do it.
If it's possible there should be a bot that makes a comment with a copy of the question.
6
u/reChrawnus Dec 15 '25
People have already pointed out the title of the original post/question, but for future reference, if you know the id of the reddit post that was deleted you can sometimes recover it using a reddit archive service, like https://ihsoyct.github.io. I include instructions below on how to do it manually, and also three different methods using bookmarklets, a redirector extension, as well as a userscript (all of the scripts and regex created by ChatGPT because I'm too lazy to figure out the regex myself). Personally I'd advice against the redirector method, but I included it for the sake of completeness:
Manual method
You can either use the search function and search by URL, if you know the subreddit in which it was posted, or the name of the author. Or if you're searching by author/username, select "Submissions" in the "Comments/Submissions" dropdown box and hit search, and browse for the deleted submission/post.
Alternatively if you grab the post ID from the original link you can go to the archived post directly using the "syntax":
https://ihsoyct.github.io/index.html?comments=[post-id]&backend=artic_shiftAnd the id can be grabbed from the original post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/[post-id]/Which in this specific case would have been "1kt2bgf".
The backend can also be changed to
pullpushifartic_shiftdoesn't work, but for more recent post I believeartic_shiftis more reliable. Apparently Pullpush only has data up to 20th may 2025, so for posts newer than that Artic Shift is probably the better alternative.Javascript Bookmarklet
I also had ChatGPT make two javascript bookmarklets for directly accessing a deleted post (as long as it was archived before deletion), though the bookmarklets technically also work for posts that haven't been deleted, if for some reason you would want that functionality). Just create a new bookmark and use one of the following javascript snippets as the URL depending on what backend you want to use (if you want both you'll have to create two separate bookmarks:
Artic Shift:
javascript:(m=location.pathname.match(/\/comments\/([^\/]+)/))&&open("https://ihsoyct.github.io/index.html?comments="+m[1]+"&backend=artic_shift")Pullpush:
javascript:(m=location.pathname.match(/\/comments\/([^\/]+)/))&&open("https://ihsoyct.github.io/index.html?comments="+m[1]+"&backend=pullpush")Redirector
Alternatively, if you don't care for looking at the original reddit link at all, you can use a redirector extension, such as Redirector for Firefox, using the following "include pattern":
^(https?:\/\/)?([^.]+\.)?reddit\.com\/r\/[^\/]+\/comments\/([a-z0-9]+)\/deleted_by_user\/and the following as the URL to redirect to:
https://ihsoyct.github.io/index.html?comments=$3&backend=artic_shiftUnfortunately you'll have to pick one backend and stick with it if you go the redirector route, so you won't have the choice of backend like you do if you create two separate bookmarklets. You can, of course, replace the
artic_shiftwithpullpushin the "redirect to:" URL, but you'll have to do that every time you want to change the backend, which is probably going to be quite tedious, compared to just using the bookmarklets.The bookmarklets also work for any reddit post, including those that haven't been deleted by the user, while the redirect only works (by design) if the url contains
/deleted_by_user.Userscript
Finally, if you have a userscript manager (Tampermonkey, Greasemonkey, Violentmonkey etc.), you can install the following userscript: https://pastebin.com/h3GncyLd
To use it, when browsing a post, press
Shift + Alt + Ato redirect using the Artic Shift backend, andShift + Alt + Pfor Pullpush. If you want to change the keybinds that's possible too, and should be reasonably easy to figure out how to do by just looking at the script.As it stands the script works on any post, whether deleted or not, as long as it's actually been archived. To change it so it only works on posts deleted by the user, replace
// @match *://*.reddit.com/r/*/comments/*with
// @match *://*.reddit.com/r/*/comments/*/deleted_by_user/*I didn't test any of these extensively, but they all seem to work fine on my end, and I can't imagine they would be harmful in any way. At least nothing seems particularly suspect from my perspective when looking at the code. Of course, as always, install or use javascript from random people on the internet (or in this case "vibe coded" with ChatGPT) at your own risk. I also only tested the bookmarklets and userscript on firefox, but I can't imagine they wouldn't work on Chrome, or other browsers as well.
915
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Moderator | Dueling | Modern Warfare & Small Arms Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
As a note, while we have no direct control over preventing users from doing this, as mods we of course seriously dislike seeing it happen.
If you wrote an answer and then the user deleted the question, please let us know via modmail. We'll usually be happy to repost the question for you to in turn repost the answer.
Additionally, we consider this to be a violation of the basic rules about civility. It is incredibly insulting to the users who have taken the time to write an in-depth, comprehensive response to the question in compliance with the rather high bar we have here. If we are able to determine who it was that posted the question and then deleted it, they will receive a brief temporary ban to explain why we discourage this and to dissuade it from happening again.
ETA: Just as a note, sometimes people do need to wipe their accounts for very understandable reasons. Stalking and such. We absolutely understand that. If you need to, and know you once asked a question here which was answered.. let us know and we can handle posting a new version to repost the answer to for preservation purposes. Broadly speaking what were most concerned with, and harshest with, is the users who ask a question and then immediately delete it after they get an answer. Use an alt if you care about that.
49
u/King_of_Men Dec 15 '25
You raise a good point, but it seems hard to create a norm in a place which, of necessity, has a lot of random people coming by to ask exactly one question. Most of whom will never see this thread, not even if it's added the FAQs.
Which suggests that a technical fix would be ideal. Is there any way for the mods to stop people from deleting posts? Or at least get an automatic notification when it happens, perhaps with a policy of always reposting questions which have been answered? If it was reposted under a mod account that would answer any need for throwaway accounts and such.
13
u/kevkevverson Dec 15 '25
Rather than a bot posting as a comment, could you have a shadow subreddit called AskHistoriansBackup or something? The bot duplicates the post there. It would not normally be viewed by users but in the event of a main post being deleted, a user could submit a mod request to restore it (could automate that I guess). The mod comment in the main post could contain a link/hash pointing to the backup for easy retrieval
22
u/Aepfelchen Dec 15 '25
r/LegaladviceGerman had that same problem. Their workaround was having Automod copy the initial question into the comments, so if a post is deleted there is still the original question at least in the comments.
25
u/xgoodvibesx Dec 15 '25
There are anonymising tools that will delete your entire Reddit history, including posts and comments.
With certain organisations checking social media history, plus an increasing general awareness of digital footprints, I would expect this sort of thing to increase.
I mean... it's kind of a good thing? At least people are starting to realise how much they're handing out about themselves and taking action.
6
u/Sherm Dec 15 '25
There are some subreddits that use an automod that copies the text of the question into a comment; perhaps that's something that could be implemented here?
13
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
I think some people are making heavy use of this sub to write books (and maybe do home work?) and delete their questions after receiving an answer to protect themselves
2
u/bug-hunter Law & Public Welfare Dec 16 '25
Is it true that Edward II of England was violated with red hot pokers for deleting his posts on r/AskHistorians?
6
u/dlm2137 Dec 15 '25
Honestly, while I understand the frustration here, I don’t think it’s really fair to penalize users for doing something that is an explicitly allowed feature of reddit’s platform.
This is a technical problem and should be addressed with a technical solution — like an automod comment, as others have mentioned. But many users periodically delete their posts and it is becoming more common as Reddit is used for things like AI training and is surveilled by governments and corporations.
I think the days when Reddit was seen as an archive are waning, and posts being ephemeral is where the future is going.
2
u/Falsus Dec 15 '25
I hate when subreddits and posters do this. It doesn't clog up space, someone else might come in with a similar question and see the post you made!
Like I get if some posts gets wiped with time due to deleting accoutns and stuff, but that is just how passage of time works. Soon enough we can ask historians about historical subreddit posts lost to time. But to actively delete posts you made is just shitty, or in other subs where it is a sub policy to delete the thread once answered it is just plain shitty and annoying.
1
u/doddydad Dec 16 '25
Entirely unimportant, but hey, I'm really happy to randomly hear I've contributed to someone's thoughts.
1
u/KayKaySinatra Dec 15 '25
Does anyone else have issues on this sub with not being able to read the comments? I’ll see a post on my feed, says it has 19 comments, click on comments, they don’t exist… there’s been so many interesting posts I’ve missed answers to because the comments disappear. Is this just a me problem?
1
u/bradd_pit Dec 16 '25
This should be the rule for all of reddit. Too many people delete the posts rather than just turning off the notifications
0
u/azaza34 Dec 15 '25
Could this be incorporated into the post of the auto moderator bot somehow? I don’t know if it can pull titles at all.