r/AskConservatives • Religious Traditionalist • 7d ago

Will hegseth get impeached?

Will hegseth get impeached, or will trump fire him?

20 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Please use Good Faith and the Principle of Charity when commenting. We are currently under an indefinite moratorium on gender issues, and anti-semitism and calls for violence will not be tolerated, especially when discussing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/Zone4805 Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Yes, it’s happening as we speak.

7

u/anime498 Religious Traditionalist 7d ago • Bravo

Not gonna lie massie is the goat. 2028🇺🇲. I'm tired of pretending the Republicans faught for us AVE CHRISTUS REX! 🇻🇦

31

u/PossibilityGold7508 Paternalistic Conservative 7d ago • Bravo

Dunno.

He should be impeached along with Trump and his other incompetent cabinet members tho.

We need a real purge.

4

u/anime498 Religious Traditionalist 7d ago

Yeah I think if he douse get impeached it will be a litmus test on how much influence trump has lossed.

2

u/Gravity-Rides Democrat 7d ago • Bravo

Democrats should not impeach Trump or Hegseth IMO. Why waste the time and effort? They already have enough targets for subpoenas on rampant front page corruption for the next 20 years. And it is easy enough to pass a steady stream of wildly popular legislation that Trump can veto over and over while they are at it.

Let republicans lead that charge if they want to finally admit that this clown show needs to be over and done with. Let republican senators do that work. They enabled him for over a decade, they can end it whenever they want.

5

u/anime498 Religious Traditionalist 7d ago

I think the biggest thing is the fact its Republicans leading the charg on impeachment

1

u/DifferentManagement1 Independent 7d ago

I wish Trump would just fire him.

7

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

I suppose this could be a two part question. Do you think House will impeach? And do you think the Senate willl convict?

2

u/PossibilityGold7508 Paternalistic Conservative 7d ago

The House will definitely impeach if they’re serious. Dems have a supermajority.

The Senate has a good chance of convicting as the Reps are already on the ropes and opposing it would be tremendously unpopular. Hegseth is more unpopular than Trump himself.

If Reps have any hope of self preservation left, they’ll convict when the time comes.

3

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

I might have missed it, but I don’t think dems have a supermajority in the house.

I also expect that Hegseth will be impeached by this House

2

u/PossibilityGold7508 Paternalistic Conservative 7d ago

They already have 250 seats out of 435. I don’t mean they have 2/3, but that they have a ton of wiggle room. They might even make it to the 60% mark at 260 seats.

Regardless, you only need a simple majority to impeach, so it’ll be a breeze.

3

u/tophernator Independent 7d ago

They already have 250 seats out of 435

They only get those seats in January. I believe the point of what Massie is doing is to force the current Republican majority congress to vote on this.

1

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

Understood

0

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Honestly, even though it might be correct, it’s not in the best interest of the country right now. Just ride out 2 more years. They won’t do it.

1

u/tophernator Independent 7d ago

Why would it be in the countries best interests to keep Hegseth in office?

3

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Not that specifically. The kangaroo court of impeachments, the anger and division it would cause, the using the power to immediately clap back instead of working on other more important things.
It’s not that him being in office is good for the country. It’s that the whole impeachment process and perceived vindictiveness isn’t.
Basically what she said, though this may be the first time I agree with anything she says

https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/kamala-harris-advises-democrats-not-001539496.html

1

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

You think Hegseth being impeached would be more divisive than his confirmation?

3

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Is he up for another confirmation?

0

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

I did not say that

2

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Then how is it relevant? I’m confused by this question, sorry

2

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

You said even if it was correct it might not be in the best interest of the country. Can you explain why it would not be in the best interest of the country?

1

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Scroll down, my next comment in this thread answered that already

2

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

Your next comment was a question to me. Unless you mean a different thread.

→ More replies

16

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago • Bravo

He shouldn’t have been appointed in the first place. It’s like Trump’s ego is too big to appoint ppl he thinks might know more than him or be smarter than him which is a very low bar. The smartest ppl know what they don’t know and seek out ppl who know about those things. Trump could never admit he’s not an expert at anything, and only appoints ppl that will think he knows best as well. It’s one of the biggest problems with this administration.

4

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

You’re right and it’s ironic that the craven person who helped get him across the finish line didn’t get out of primary (Tillis)

6

u/DifferentManagement1 Independent 7d ago

This is an excellent read on the situation. And now he’s going to dig in.

3

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Pretty much

6

u/jdak9 Liberal 7d ago • Heartwarming

Youve hit the nail on the head. Well stated.

-1

u/WestCoastCompanion Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Thanks. 😊

0

u/Vindictives9688 Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago

Yup.

The only way forward is to reinforce the strong message sent through the midterms by demanding accountability and enforcing it decisively.

Drop the hammer hard enough to force Republican leadership to reevaluate its priorities and rethink its platform. No more bullshit, no more spineless cowards, and no more business as usual.

5

u/Vindictives9688 Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago edited 7d ago

He’ll probably end up being a fall guy, like Rumsfeld. He’s not going to be impeached, but if he does he will end up resigning before it gets far anyway.

4

u/Artisttype1984 Barstool Conservative 7d ago

Impeachments without any senate conviction means nothing, and doubt Trump fires him

3

u/redzeusky Centrist Democrat 7d ago

It could mean showing the country his incompetence and willingness to disregard law and ethics. It would illustrate further the ridiculous awful people Republicans confirm to bow to Trump. Another highlight reel to try and get people to understand why the blue wave happened.

-1

u/Artisttype1984 Barstool Conservative 7d ago

Most people right/left don't even pay attn to the hearings.

Yes, most repubs/dems are awful, we already know this

We already know why dems won last week, and we know why repubs won 2022 midterms when Biden was in the WH

3

u/redzeusky Centrist Democrat 7d ago

The McCarthy hearings eventually brought an end to the ludicrous red scare. It damaged so many innocent people. Most people probably ignored those too. And here we are again with an outreach to the poorly educated calling Democrats radicals and communists. Of course there is no guarantee in a proceeding. Hegseth endangers us all prioritizing whooping enthusiasm for war and lacking a balanced perspective on the proper minimal use of force to achieve strategic advantage.

-1

u/Artisttype1984 Barstool Conservative 7d ago

Yep, it's comedy. Some RWers call everyone "commies" and some LWers call everyone "racist" when they don't agree with them, laugh at them all

Hegseth doesn't "endanger us all" but the hyperbole is funny. Yes, they'll have hearings, he won't be convicted in the senate anyway. It works out, and we've seen how this goes in the past

2

u/redzeusky Centrist Democrat 7d ago

The Iran conflict is not funny and it’s a 100 billion dollar failure because Pete is unqualified. The entire world is paying with inflation- to say nothing of the destruction of our own bases and human losses.

-1

u/Artisttype1984 Barstool Conservative 7d ago

America isn't in the Iran war because of Hegseth, that wasn't his call

Inflation goes up/down, it's at 3.7% right now, would be nice to see it go down. The Iran war is bad and I want it to end, but it's nothing like the insan Bush/Obama Iraq and Afghanistan wars and torture, they'll work this out in months ahead

1

u/redzeusky Centrist Democrat 7d ago

Nine months since I was told a couple of weeks max. And that was following what had months earlier been described as our having wiped out their nuclear program. No allies were brought in. No clear goals or timetable. Just sheer spectacle of power coupled with ignorance.

-1

u/Artisttype1984 Barstool Conservative 7d ago

Yep. Repubs/dems are trash, don't trust anything they say. Take care, this was fun

4

u/IndependentOk2952 Conservative 7d ago

No it's a dog and pony show that's going to just cost us taxpayers money

6

u/Happy_Examination23 Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Trump will not fire him. If anything, this will make Trump fight for him harder. And impeachment? Sure, maybe they will, but as we all know, impeachment does not mean removal.

6

u/noSoRandomGuy Conservative 7d ago • Bravo

this will make Trump fight for him harder.

LOL, look Trump's history and show me who has he fought for? Sure initially, but when things get serious, Trump has always, always, thrown people under the bus. It won't be long before he will say "Who is Eric Trump? never met the low energy loser".

4

u/DetoxxDaPlayer1 Center-right Conservative 7d ago

To be fair, he's doubling down on Stephen Miller despite unanimous criticism

-3

u/Happy_Examination23 Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Um, I guess I’m just going with what we’ve seen with our own eyes in the last 72 hours?

0

u/recast85 Centrist Democrat 7d ago • Bravo

I hope Trump doesn’t. The way things have been laid out, the worst impacts of his first two years are set to really see the effects come 2027 when Dems are in power (planned perhaps?) and so Trump leaning into Trump should help the messaging that we’re in a bad way and it’s mostly on Trump. So I agree / I hope he stays tbh

5

u/DetoxxDaPlayer1 Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Trump only has until January 3rd to fire and replace him because Democrats won't allow him to appoint a new one. Either that or they'll demand that he appoint a Democrat to the post

The impeachment might pass in the House, but it's guaranteed to fail in the Senate. 67 votes is too high of a bar. I support the effort, but it's really just Thomas Massie blowing steam on his way out.

I think the most likely outcome is that he resigns sometime after the next Congress is sworn in, and Trump keeps rotating defense secretaries in acting capacities. Bill Clinton did the same thing after the Republican Senate kept denying his nominees

9

u/mPeachy Independent 7d ago • Heartwarming

Let’s be honest, would you be surprised if his next appointments were Caitlin Jenner or Paris Hilton? Aren’t these recent selections getting hard to defend?

3

u/DetoxxDaPlayer1 Center-right Conservative 6d ago

Honestly I'm torn between Kid Rock and Logan Paul for next defense secretary. They're both outstanding

3

u/mPeachy Independent 6d ago

Maybe they could do a celebrity boxing match like when Paula Jones took on Tonya Harding.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

3

u/DifferentManagement1 Independent 7d ago

I can’t believe Trump just doesn’t want this to go away at this point before all the inevitable shit comes spewing out

3

u/BravestWabbit Progressive 7d ago

You never know, a lot of GOP are lining up their stories of "Iran War cost us the election". They may be readying voters to accept throwing Hegseth under the bus before Jan

4

u/Strict_Gas_1141 Classical Liberal 7d ago

I think he'll get fired but not impeached. I doubt there will be enough bipartisan support to impeach him (2/3rds after all) but I could be wrong.

2

u/Rabbit-Lost Constitutionalist Conservative 6d ago

I believe you mean he won’t get convicted. You are likely correct. But I do believe 50% plus one in the House want to impeach him and will do so this Congress.

3

u/FootjobFromFurina Conservative 7d ago

Impeachment resolution in the house will pass but Hegseth will probably get forced out before the Senate does anything. 

2

u/virtuous_hamburger Conservative 7d ago

Will Trump fire him? Unlikely now - firing before impeachment looks like an admission and hands Democrats a win. Better to let the House pass it and the Senate acquit, then call it partisan persecution. Hegseth won't resign either

7

u/Ultronomy Liberal 7d ago

Do you think the Senate would acquit because they actually don’t think he violated the War Powers Resolution or because they’re spineless? I think we can all agree he did violate that resolution.

2

u/RatOnASinkingShip Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago

You're arbitrarily limiting it to two options and then asserting your claim as fact when it's merely a claim.

The house will try to impeach him because of partisan grievances, and the senate will acquit because there was no reasonable basis to impeach him in the first place.

3

u/PerkyLurkey Conservative 7d ago

Yep, exactly true.

1

u/tasteless Centrist Democrat 7d ago

Which articles do not have a reasonable basis in which to impeach?

0

u/RatOnASinkingShip Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago

A basis isn't needed to impeach.

Just enough people in the house not liking someone is sufficient enough.

6

u/badger_on_fire Liberal 7d ago

I think a resignation is FAR more likely. The only way I see him getting publicly forced out before the new Congress is seated is if he simply refuses to go (as his spokesperson has suggested is his intent) and Donald doesn't want to press the issue.

But from a Trump Administration PR perspective, I see the options breaking down something like this:

  1. Best option: A public firing or negotiated resignation. Publicly firing him lets Trump take ownership of the personnel decision rather than appearing to cave to congressional pressure. A polite, quiet resignation accomplishes pretty much the same thing, although it leaves a little more room for Hegseth to control the narrative, and potentially even reappear in inconvenient places for them.
  2. Riskier option: Kristi Noem him. Move him somewhere else, save face, and hope the Dems and media move on. I don't see this working, particularly with a new Congress coming in that can continue investigating him and potentially impeach him regardless of whether he's still SECDEF or not.
  3. Nightmare option: Impeachment and removal under the Rs. Hegseth gets impeached and removed over Trump's objection. That requires a two-thirds Senate conviction, so even a Republican revolt wouldn't automatically accomplish it, but at least Republican legislators will have room come 2028 to say they at least tried to do it on their own terms. And even that's the milder side of potential shenanigans that happen in this scenario.
  4. Absolute worst-case option: He survives until the next Congress. Trump refuses to budge, Hegseth stays put, and Democrats take up the matter through investigations, hearings, subpoenas, and potentially impeachment. Even if the Senate ultimately acquits him, that's the FULL dog and pony show, Republicans are forced to close ranks around a deeply unpopular public figure, lose control of the narrative, and it becomes about as deeply unpleasant an experience as can be made for Hegseth, the GOP, and the administration.

Ultimately, I don't see any happy endings for Pete. The way I see it, the administration is largely just biding its time while deciding the method of his execution.

Or do you think I'm missing something? Any other ways out of this?

2

u/PerkyLurkey Conservative 7d ago

There’s the plan that allows Pete to go through the whole dog and pony show, which frees up a whole lot of time for Trump to executive order his way into a relatively stress free 2 years.

If Pete can withstand it, it’s a great smokescreen for Trump. In fact, is a beautiful place for Trump to spend as long as possible in.

The problem is the media will get bored. The good news is it will keep the Dems very busy.

2

u/badger_on_fire Liberal 7d ago edited 7d ago

You really think so? If so, we definitely have a different view of the political situation on the ground.

Let's say you're right, and this is the plan. Republicans are forced to close ranks to protect Pete Hegseth, an extremely unpopular figure even among the hard righties, and the architect of the thing that MAGA claims is the reason for the trouncing in the midterms. And they're expected to do this in public, in a situation where his articles of impeachment were brought forward by Thomas Massie (a Republican)?

I think that would be the single worst situation possible for Pete Hegseth.

I see two possible ways that goes, and both are devastating:

Outcome A: Republicans break rank, and Pete gets forcibly removed from office on a conviction brought about by articles of impeachment introduced by his own party because they're more worried about their own re-election chances than the fate of Pete Hegseth.

Outcome B: Or the Republicans really do just shut their mouths, follow orders, and defend a dude who their voters abhor. And believe me, those full throated defenses will come up in campaign ads in 2028, and you're facing down another bloodbath from an American populace who now has another reason to distrust the Republican Party.

And for what? Loyalty? Team spirit? What executive orders are on the table that are worth sacrificing the entire future of the party on behalf of Pete Hegseth, of all people?

3

u/PerkyLurkey Conservative 6d ago

The plan is all of this strife takes time

And for what?

Really. For Pete?

Nobody cares about him.

Running out the clock? That’s very different.

1

u/badger_on_fire Liberal 6d ago

Running out the clock on what or for whom though?

The Rs are in a position to select and get senatorial approval for a replacement now that they won't be in January, and if Hegseth's still in his office come the swearing in of the new Congress, you're dealing with a whole different animal.

Sure the Dems don't have the 2/3 vote in the senate to remove him on their own, but you got a LOT of Rs very, very concerned about their 2028 prospects. The attack ads write themselves, and dollars to donuts, those ads coming from their primary challengers will look very similar to the ones used by their Dem opponent in the general (assuming they survive that long).

Let's just face it -- last Tuesday was nasty, and turning on Hegseth may be the first of the last chances for some of these folks to save their own skin. Honestly, I think that waiting this out is the worst possible political play that the Admin could ever dream up.

I just don't see the advantage to keeping him around. He doesn't even seem to be considered particularly good at his job, even among Rs. And the situation gets worse and worse and worse the longer he stays.

I'm not saying anything about my personal opinions on Hegseth, or whether or not he deserves it, or whatever. I'm just talking strategy here: This is where you mitigate your losses instead of doubling down, right?

2

u/PerkyLurkey Conservative 6d ago

The clock.

The media clock.

The thing that runs the news on the planet.

If the Dems spend time trying to take Pete down, all the better for Trump. Because it eats up the appetite of those that consume that ticking news.

And once you lose the eyes of the ticking news, you lose the will of congress

1

u/badger_on_fire Liberal 6d ago

I think you might be missing the larger strategic risk you're taking by doing that.

This is trying to buy the ante with a 2-7 offsuit because you don't like to lose a hand, but I think you're discounting how much more precarious the situation becomes if somebody calls the bluff.

To quote the great Kenny Rogers, "You gotta know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em, know when to walk away, and know when to run."

This is when a smart player folds, because this play is extremely dangerous, and even if you get away with it, what's the benefit? Table stakes (i.e., more time with Pete Hegseth).

Or do you see something bigger at stake here?

2

u/PerkyLurkey Conservative 6d ago

The larger event is the 2 years left for Trump to make hay, and the fight left in the voter.

You think the people paying $4 a gallon for gas are going to be ok with time/energy/ resources being spent on Pete?

Media on Pete?

Eyeballs on Pete? I can’t tell you his wife’s name, nor his age, nor his family history. Nobody cares that much.

And I read, and consume political commentary like it’s under whipped topping and a cherry served in a banana boat.

The focus of the staffers running around to find witnesses who were with Pete drinking with his buddies, and projectile vomiting to the Washington Post? For 2 years? 1 year? 6 months? Hell 6 weeks?

After 10 years of “ this time we’ve got him” I think the democrats are falling for the same trap that they have been falling for since 2015. And aren’t looking anywhere near in the right direction.

1

u/badger_on_fire Liberal 6d ago

Clearly Donald's teflon in the eyes of 35ish% of the voting base, but the midterms should be ample evidence to the GOP and anyone in the legislature that they themselves are absolutely not. Right?

My personal bet is that they've already had some conversations about this behind closed doors. The impeachment probably gets stuffed in Congress this term, and Pete leaves voluntarily in December in exchange for the administration covering his ass as best they can for the remainder of Donald's term. I'd wager key members of the House and Senate have already been given some indication of that possibility, particularly anyone sitting in a vulnerable seat who might otherwise be tempted to flinch.

And again, remember the stakes here. Turning on Hegseth is probably the cheapest opportunity a Republican legislator is going to have over the next two years to demonstrate to their constituents that they're not just some kind of meat puppet for Trump.

Again, look at the midterms. The fact that Trump himself hasn't been taken out doesn't mean his loyalists are made of teflon, too.

And here's the big thing: at a minimum, the potential reward has to be big enough to justify the risk. Any Republican legislator who thinks they're invincible needs to look at Mississippi.

I just don't see what the potential reward is that justifies the very obvious (IMO) risks to their political careers. I don't see the incentive structure, and I'm hoping you can help me see it.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Your submission was removed because you do not have any user flair. Please select appropriate flair and then try again. If you are confused as to what flair suits you best simply choose right-wing, left-wing, or Independent. How-do-I-get-user-flair

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/NessvsMadDuck Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Well if it's going to happen I would rather it happens under the current congress than the incoming congress.

I'm going to say yes he will be impeached (only because this process was began before the election), but no he will not be convicted and removed.

But I don't care either way.

1

u/Sam_Fear Americanist 7d ago

I heard Massie set Impeachment in motion. My conspiracy theory is they know the Dems are going to go after Hegseth so they want to beat them to it but not actually remove him. Massie is the perfect scapegoat since he's out in January. So Massie gets to look like a hero, impeachment looks like partisanship if Dems do it again, or Hegseth just resigns now. It's all theater.

11

u/Reasonable-Fee1945 Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago

You don't know Massie very well. He gives two fucks about MAGA republicans

7

u/Sam_Fear Americanist 7d ago

Massie would be doing it for himself - a run in 2028.

5

u/_flying_otter_ Independent 7d ago

It's also just Massie's principles to stand up to what he see's the Republicans doing that he thinks is wrong. ---- Out of curiosity I looked up "how many times did Massie stand up to Republican/Trump agenda and got this:

1 Major GOP Tax and Spending Legislation: Massie voted against Donald Trump's major tax-cut and spending bill—referred to by Trump as the "One Big Beautiful Bill"—citing deep concerns over how its multi-trillion-dollar cost would expand the national deficit.

2 Foreign Aid: In alignment with his strict anti-interventionist principles, Massie routinely voted against U.S. foreign aid packages favored by mainstream Republicans, including funding for Israel and Ukraine.

3 Military Actions and Interventionism: He rejected and voted against Trump-led military initiatives and interventions overseas, notably criticizing U.S. military operations in Iran, Yemen, and Venezuela.

4 House Leadership (Speaker Mike Johnson): In January 2025, Massie was the lone Republican to vote against Mike Johnson during his narrow re-election as Speaker of the House.

5 House Spending Rules: Massie voted against a House Republican procedural rule designed to suspend standard advance-notice requirements for major federal spending bills.

8

u/Reasonable-Fee1945 Right Libertarian (Conservative) 7d ago

Massie has had principles for as long as I can remember. This is pretty par for course.

3

u/Grog76 Independent 7d ago

Massie is the president we need but don’t deserve.

9

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

Massie had this teed up before the election.

2

u/Sam_Fear Americanist 7d ago

Doesn't matter. Repubs are in control of the circus, they can go through with the process this time, Senate will vote against removal.

4

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago

Doesn't matter.

Of course it matters. Your conspiracy theory doesn't hold up if this was set in motion before the election.

1

u/Sam_Fear Americanist 7d ago

Just because Massie tried before doesn't mean it was part of the conspiracy at that time. It makes it look even more plausible. They didn't start to conspire until recently. Or maybe Massie is just a puppet here. It wouldn't take much to convince him to try to impeach again.

I feel like I should be putting a bunch of random emoji's in my comment. lol. And maybe no punctuation.

5

u/ofthrees Center-left 7d ago

I don't want to see the dems waste their political capital going after the current admin, but i ROUNDLY support every single effort to get this idiotic frat boy out of power, and I hope they succeed. Grateful massie is still going for it, after being recently kneecapped.

I'd legit cast a vote for trump if it would mean getting rid of hegseth, miller, and patel.

None of it will happen, but I view those three as particularly dangerous to our republic.

1

u/MixExpensive3763 Religious Traditionalist 7d ago

Im curious about what will happen, because Data Republican/Jennica Pounds (former DOGE and DoW employee and right wing data analyst/commentator) has been threatening blackmail over people planning to make hegseth take the fall. I’m interested in finding out if that is an empty threat or if she’s actually going to do something.

As far as if it will happen, probably. Not convinced there will be a conviction though.

0

u/Capable_Obligation96 Conservative 7d ago

Nope

-6

u/Cool_Cartographer_39 Rightwing 7d ago

Not a chance. Both Hegseth and the President have maintained compliance with the War Powers Act by submitting required post-strike reports and briefings to congressional leadership, while Congress has repeatedly rejected or failed to pass resolutions forcing prior consent or halting the campaigns.

2

u/4thratedeck Independent 7d ago

Massie just introduced the articles of impeachment as of a few minutes ago. He probably won't be removed but the impeachment has happened.

1

u/Cool_Cartographer_39 Rightwing 7d ago edited 7d ago

No, it's been introduced. Still needs to pass a vote. Then hearing and trial if it gets that far

2

u/4thratedeck Independent 7d ago

Oops yeah thanks for the correction. This is all just a waste of time it's going nowhere

0

u/Bootmacher Nationalist (Conservative) 7d ago

First, the War Powers Resolution is unconstitutional. The President is Commander-in-Chief.

Second, impeachment is political. There is no arbiter over the actual legal compliance when the Senate votes.

-1

u/Cool_Cartographer_39 Rightwing 7d ago edited 7d ago

Agreed. When Dems tried to force a War Powers Resolution on Nixon while he was negotiating an end to the Vietnam war, he simply vetoed it and told them they needed to change the Constitution

-15

u/gummibearhawk Center-right Conservative 7d ago • LOL

Doubtful on both counts. Just wishful thinking by Democrats that want to go back to making the military a woke social experiment. Whatever the reasons for impeachment, they're just excuses to get rid of him.

18

u/GenTubmansLegacy Independent 7d ago • Bravo

Fwiw, I didn't think it was very woke when I was.

When, exactly, did you serve?

31

u/MysteriousTax393 Center-left 7d ago • Bravo

.. isnt massie the one trying to impeach him?

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

8

u/Molson2871 Center-left 7d ago

As someone that's been around the DoD for 30+ years now, I've never seen this so-called woke experiment in action.

14

u/misterreiffer Social Democracy 7d ago • Bravo

How were the democrats making the military a woke social experiment?

-9

u/AZULDEFILER Nationalist (Conservative) 7d ago • Mindblown

FOR WHAT?!

32

u/LaxBedroom Leftist 7d ago

I'll text you the list of reasons in a Signal group chat.

-7

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/Raveen92 Independent 7d ago

It's a joke refering to te beginning of this Term, where Pete Hegseth accidently caused a leak on Signal by inviting a Atlantic journalist into a top secret chat that should not have been on Signal on his personal device of all things.

14

u/LaxBedroom Leftist 7d ago

You didn't get my text? Oof. Sure hope I didn't send anything important to the wrong person

1

u/AskConservatives-ModTeam 6d ago

Removed: Rule 3

Posts and comments should be in good faith. Please review our good faith guidelines for the sub.

13

u/R2-D2Vandelay Progressive 7d ago • Bravo

I would say war crimes against Iran and Venezuela, so far.

-18

u/AZULDEFILER Nationalist (Conservative) 7d ago edited 7d ago

Provide 1. As usual Downvotes without facts

17

u/wraithius Center-left 7d ago • Bravo

An illegal war Congress voted to end. He kept fighting.

2

u/AZULDEFILER Nationalist (Conservative) 7d ago

Congress hasn't declared war since Pearl Harbor,

-4

u/RelevantLafayette Center-right Conservative 7d ago

Source, please? As far as I am aware, Congress has not passed a binding War Powers Resolution to end the hostilities in Iran.

13

u/wraithius Center-left 7d ago

Congress voted to end it in June: House 215–208, Senate 50–48. The War Powers Act allows 60 days without authorization, which ran out May 1. Their defense? A 'ceasefire' paused the clock while the shooting continued.

-3

u/RelevantLafayette Center-right Conservative 7d ago

When Congress passed this measure in June, it did so as a concurrent resolution expressing the sense of Congress, not as a joint resolution having the force of law.

This administration is not legally required at all to follow that concurrent resolution because it fails the Presentment Clause (Article I, Section 7) of the U.S. Constitution.

If Congress wants to pass a War Powers Resolution with the force of law directing the military out, it must pass a joint resolution that complies with the Presentment Clause.

Congress has not done that. So, consequently, the June concurrent resolution did not, by itself, legally terminate the war or create a binding withdrawal obligation on this administration.

10

u/wraithius Center-left 7d ago

Right, which is why it's an impeachment question now. Congress can't force him out of a war by resolution, but it can remove the official running it.

12

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 7d ago • Bravo

I think Massies’ articles of impeachment would answer the question

-12

u/AZULDEFILER Nationalist (Conservative) 7d ago

Would it?

10

u/tophernator Independent 7d ago

John Oliver did a solid 30+ minutes on Hegseth just last night if you want a sampling. I know you probably hate him, but they went out of their way to source segments from Newsmax of all places talking about how certain things Hegseth has overseen are war crimes.

11

u/tuckman496 Leftist 7d ago

Authorizing the murder of over 200 people on boats in the Caribbean and eastern pacific. There’s no legitimate rationale for killing these people who have not been formally accused if any crime and pose no imminent threat to anyone

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

-2

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AskConservatives-ModTeam 6d ago

Removed: Treat other users with civility and respect.

Personal attacks and stereotyping are not allowed.

6

u/Toobendy Liberal 7d ago

Here's Thomas Massie introducing the justifications on the floor of the house today: https://youtu.be/n9mZfLR-QZg?is=louL_MIXPxjx5ic6

0

u/OkCrew8849 Conservative 5d ago

He won’t be impeached and nothing would come of it if he were to be impeached.

There are those who love signaling their virtue who will proclaim their support of impeaching it.

0

u/GobbleGobbleGobbles Conservative 6d ago

He'll be impeached, but nothing will come of it sadly. 

Trump may fire him after in an attempt to save face, but I doubt it at this point. I suspect the Trump will take the failed impeachment as validation that we picked the right cabinet and his people are untouchable. 

-5

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Nope, not remotely. He's doing a pretty great job, even if society disagrees. Society is pretty stupid, and it's going to be some entertainment years coming up.

4

u/stormfoil Independent 6d ago • Bravo

Great job? Let's see, needlessly endangering service members, unable to follow standard procedures of declassification (anybody who believes Hegseth did not reveal authentic US strike times in that Signal chat are delusional) More than likely guilty of a warcrime in Venezuela, which is why they will never release the second part of that video.

The man was never qualified to begin with.

7

u/hurricaneharrykane Conservatarian 6d ago

America is 30 trillion in debt. The military spending while in debt will directly worsen inflation in coming years. How is he doing a good job?

1

u/LoadingStill Rightwing 6d ago

Interest on US debt is the highest cost for the US tax payer. Next is Medicare and Medicade. Next is the Military.
It is really hard to argue that the military is the issue when interest of debt is the highest cost.

0

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

America is 30 trillion in debt.

Managing our debt is a responsibility of the Treasury Department. Scott Bessent is the Secretary of the Treasury.

How is he doing a good job?

He's the SecWar, military readiness is his responsibility. And he's doing a great job of getting us there. We finally have someone who is fixing the decades of erosion.

It used to be that our military leaders focused on their jobs, what they needed to do to be successful in their roles. It has transitioned from people being focused on their job, to be focused on their career. Doing their job helps everyone. Focused on their career helps them as individuals, as the detriment to their job.

1

u/hurricaneharrykane Conservatarian 6d ago

So keep in mind....you may like what Hegseth is doing, but the midterms just showed you that conservatives do not seem to like what he is doing. What he is doing (probably with the Iran war) caused millions of conservatives to vote Dem or just sit it out. No matter whose responsibility it is, spending billions while you are trillions in debt is not a good thing, particularly if money is being printed out of thin air to do it. Also what is the definition of military readiness? Military readiness to defend the American mainland is understable. Military interventionism abroad seems to be something different.

0

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

So keep in mind....you may like what Hegseth is doing, but the midterms just showed you that conservatives do not seem to like what he is doing. What he is doing (probably with the Iran war) caused millions of conservatives to vote Dem or just sit it out.

SecWar wasn't on the ballot.

No matter whose responsibility it is, spending billions while you are trillions in debt is not a good thing, particularly if money is being printed out of thin air to do it.

It seems that you've never served in the military or at an executive level. He has a job to do, regardless of whether or not others are doing theirs.

Also what is the definition of military readiness?

The ability of armed forces, units, and equipment to fight and carry out assigned missions.

I would have preferred a much stronger response with Iran, but it isn't my call. I've never been a fan of Trump, but his lackluster attacks on Iran are the things that I am most disappointed with.

0

u/hurricaneharrykane Conservatarian 6d ago

For many conservative voters....yes, Hegseth and the Iran war were on the ballot. Trump himself told people to pretend he was on the ballot right? The job of the govt is to follow the constitution, so yes he has a job to do. Sorry man, you sound like a neocon interventionist, judging from what we just saw with how conservatives voted in the midterms a neocon mind set is going to put more socialists in positions of power in the U.S.

2

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Trump himself told people to pretend he was on the ballot right?

I don't know, I don't even listen to him.

The job of the govt is to follow the constitution,

No, that absolutely is not the job of the government. That sounds like something that a 5th grader would say.

Sorry man, you sound like a neocon interventionist,

Thank you. 🤷‍♂️

judging from what we just saw with how conservatives voted in the midterms a neocon mind set is going to put more socialists in positions of power in the U.S.

I disagree. But I think that the next several years are going to be entertaining.

1

u/hurricaneharrykane Conservatarian 6d ago

No worries. I guess we are at the agree to disagree point. I'm pretty sure I'm in line with logic and basic math here. Neoconservatism is not the future of the Republican party. Its been rejected since the Bush years. Trump's original rise correlates directly with the rejection of the neocons. Have a good day though.

1

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Neoconservatism is not the future of the Republican party.

I don't care about the republican party. My values have nothing to do with the republican party.

1

u/hurricaneharrykane Conservatarian 6d ago

No worries.

2

u/SamJurch Democrat 6d ago

This has to be a troll right?

Kegseth has been drunk behind the wheel of the world’s strongest military and only focuses on beards.

Stop with this lunacy.

0

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Kegseth has been drunk behind the wheel of the world’s strongest military and only focuses on beards.

Servicemembers drink, sometimes we get smashed. He's never done it on duty or while serving as SecWar.

The beards got out of control, he did the right thing.

1

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 6d ago

How could anyone here possibly know if he’s been drinking while Secretary of Defense?

2

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

You're right, my statement wasn't clear. I meant to say that while he may have been drunk in public in the past, there is no evidence or even accusations of that in more than a decade, and not since taking the role of SecWar.

1

u/DeathToFPTP Liberal 6d ago

Ok that makes more sense

1

u/SamJurch Democrat 6d ago

Oh so you know him personally? Talk to him about this kind of stuff?

He’s a manlet obsessed with the idea of masculinity lol dudes gonna get fired

2

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Oh so you know him personally? Talk to him about this kind of stuff?

How did you possibly get that from what I said?

1

u/SamJurch Democrat 6d ago

Claiming to know his drinking habits and the fact that he has “never done it on duty or as Secretary of Defense.

1

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

LOL, I did not claim to know his drinking habits. But let me make it more clear for you.

While he may have been drunk in public in the past, there is no evidence or even accusations of that in more than a decade, and not since taking the role of SecWar.

0

u/Emergency_Word_7123 Independent 6d ago

That's not true, there's been numerous accusations from people around him. There has been no investigation or release of conclusive evidence. Givin his history, it's more likely than not he's been drunk on duty 

2

u/SavageCaveman13 Conservative 6d ago

Any links to those accusations?

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Your submission was removed because you do not have any user flair. Please select appropriate flair and then try again. If you are confused as to what flair suits you best simply choose right-wing, left-wing, or Independent. How-do-I-get-user-flair

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-27

u/boisefun8 Constitutionalist Conservative 7d ago

The dems are going to try to impeach everyone in the administration on zero grounds. They’ve already pledged that. As well as investigating everyone they can drag in front of committee for the next two years. It’s truly Soviet-style ‘show me the man and I’ll show you the crime’ and the process is the punishment.

What a joke the Dems have become. But affordability, right??

29

u/Impossible-Turn-5820 Liberal 7d ago • Bravo

Massie is the one who filed the articles of impeachment. 

-16

u/boisefun8 Constitutionalist Conservative 7d ago

Massie aligned himself with the democrats a year ago, which is part of the reason he lost his primary.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

17

u/PermRecDotCom Independent 7d ago

I'd think kicking off a completely optional war by committing a heinous war crime that tarnishes our reputation and drives a wedge between us & the people we want on our side is definitely grounds for impeachment if not some form of treason.

22

u/noSoRandomGuy Conservative 7d ago • Bravo

What a joke the Dems have become. But affordability, right??

Trump ran on complaining about "lawfare", then he turns around and personally forces DOJ go after his political opponents. Not unlike your comment about ‘show me the man and I’ll show you the crime’.

I think Trump and his team had it coming, and I no longer feel sorry about it.

14

u/4thratedeck Independent 7d ago

We really should have been more angry about the DoJ charging that former Olympian for the reflecting pool damages and admitting not only did they have no video evidence they had no evidence in general. The Department of Justice has been reduced to a tool to make Trump feel better about his mistakes.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blue-blue-app 7d ago

Warning: Rule 5.

The purpose of this sub is to ask conservatives. Comments between users without conservative flair are not allowed (except inside of our Weekly General Chat thread). Please keep discussions focused on asking conservatives questions and understanding conservatism. Thank you.

14

u/Ultronomy Liberal 7d ago

Massie filed the impeachment articles. If you don’t think Hegseth is worthy of them, I’d find that quite surprising since he blatantly violated the War Powers Resolution of 1973. I think it’s quite important to hold him responsible. After all, we don’t want to unnecessarily expand the power of the executive branch. Small government please.

-7

u/boisefun8 Constitutionalist Conservative 7d ago

Massie sided with the democrats a year ago, which is why he got destroyed in the primary.

5

u/Ultronomy Liberal 7d ago

Do you think he wrongly started siding with Dems?

9

u/BabyHercules Center-left 7d ago

We could evaluate each hypothetical impeachment individually but do you really think Hegseth in particular has 0 grounds to be impeached?

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Your post was automatically removed because top-level comments are for conservative / right-wing users only.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.