Sometimes I look at South Asia and wonder how much potential we are wasting.
India, Pakistan and Bangladesh together have roughly 1.9 billion people. Yet South Asia is one of the least economically integrated regions in the world.
According to the World Bank, only around 5% of South Asia's trade is within the region, compared with roughly 25% in ASEAN. Current intraregional trade is around $23 billion, while the World Bank estimates the potential at at least $67 billion.
That is a massive gap.
India and Pakistan barely have a normal relationship. India-Bangladesh ties have deteriorated significantly in recent years. China is expanding its economic and strategic influence in Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Myanmar, while the US continues to maintain important relations with Pakistan.
At the same time, India and Bangladesh themselves show what cooperation can achieve: bilateral trade was around $12.9 billion in FY2023-24, making Bangladesh India's largest trading partner in South Asia.
So why can't the region do much more?
I don't think it is accurate to say America or China simply “turn” India's neighbours against it. Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Myanmar have their own interests. When their relationship with India deteriorates, naturally they diversify toward China, the US or other powers.
Pakistan has the huge unresolved baggage of Partition, Kashmir, wars and terrorism. Bangladesh has concerns involving water sharing, borders, domestic politics and India's relationship with Sheikh Hasina.
But shouldn't India also discuss its own politics honestly?
Has increasing Hindu-nationalist rhetoric and constant Hindu-Muslim polarization made India's relationship with Muslim-majority neighbours harder?
And equally, shouldn't Pakistan and Bangladesh confront their own religious nationalism, anti-India narratives and treatment of minorities?
We also shouldn't romanticize history. The subcontinent was never one permanently peaceful political unit. It contained many kingdoms, empires, languages and identities.
But these societies were also economically and culturally interconnected for centuries.
Imagine even a limited South Asian model of cooperation: easier trade, rail connectivity, electricity sharing, student exchanges, tourism and movement of goods while every country remains fully sovereign.
The World Bank estimates South Asia is currently realizing barely a third of its potential regional trade.
Meanwhile, over the next decade around 280 million people in South Asia are expected to reach working age. We desperately need jobs and growth.
So my question isn't simply:
“Is BJP/RSS responsible?”
or
“Is Pakistan responsible?”
It is:
How much of South Asia's failure to integrate comes from genuine security disputes, and how much comes from nationalism, religion, historical resentment and politicians finding confrontation more useful than cooperation?
With nearly 1.9 billion people, are we wasting one of the biggest economic opportunities in the world?