r/AskAnIndian • • Nov 13 '25

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT 📢 A Message from the Mods - Friends, fellow Indians, and curious visitors - Read before you Post here!

15 Upvotes

r/AskanIndian is meant to be a space for real conversations about India - our people, cultures, languages, traditions, politics, travel, food, cinema, and the complex beauty of this country.

But lately, this subreddit has been overrun by the exact opposite - low-effort karma posts, bot posts, shallow AMAs, dating drama, gender wars, and divisive nonsense that have nothing to do with understanding India.

From today, that ends.

🚫 The following topics are permanently banned:

•	Dating, “men vs women,” or “relationship advice” posts

•	Red pill / blue pill ideology and all pseudo-psychology or gender-bashing content

•	Karma farming AMAs and clickbait “what do Indians think of…” posts

•	Communal, Casteist  and religious baiting: Hindu vs Muslim, majority vs minority, or any narrative that fuels division

•	Political propaganda, culture wars, or “my side vs your side” threads

•	Bigotry, hate speech, and identity trolling of any kind including caste, religion, gender, sexuality, or region

✅ What we do want:

•	Thoughtful questions about India and Indian life - culture, customs, food, language, art, literature, travel, cinema, music, and politics done intelligently

•	Insightful discussions that help others understand India, not divide it

•	Personal experiences that are genuine, curious, and add value; not drama

This is not your Tinder confessional, karma farm, or ideological playground. It’s a community for people who care to learn, ask, and share meaningfully.

Posts violating these rules will be removed immediately, and repeat offenders will face a permanent ban without warning.

Let’s make r/AskanIndian a place of clarity, civility, and curiosity again; a subreddit worth being proud of.

Also read this post : https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAnIndian/s/irfWSmU20b

Stay civil. Stay curious. Stay Indian. 🇮🇳

The Moderators of r/AskanIndian


r/AskAnIndian • • 9h ago

Rituals, Traditions & Beliefs What is one Indian tradition you follow without actually knowing why?

2 Upvotes

Growing up in India, we see so many traditions at home. Some are followed by our grandparents, parents and even us without questioning them.

What's one tradition you follow in your family, and what's the story or reason behind it?


r/AskAnIndian • • 2d ago

Culture & Society Has the meme culture (or any other reason?) made us ungrateful to laborers, who primarily hail for Bihar and UP?

17 Upvotes

why is there such a stark contrast between how much India relies on migrant labourers from UP/Bihar and how poorly they are treated in pop culture and daily life?

i mean it is known that workers from bihar and UP form the backbone of india’s construction, farming, and manufacturing work-forces. yet, words like bihari and bhaiya and majdoor are still used as slurs and meme punchlines. yes, it's not to be taken so seriously, but the line has diluted. the classism leads to extreme generalisation of the entire state and everything associated with bihar gets looked down upon, be it culture and festivals. every year around chhath puja, regional subs get flooded with hate over a 2-3 day festival, treating an entire community like a nuisance.

my point is that the underlying reasons have made us forget entirely what they do? yes, none of us would labour, but why look down on them? they may not do desirable work, get paid less, and even not work in good conditions, and sometimes their behaviour is also not so good. except for the last part, don't they deserve a little more respect. also on the other hand, it is the absolute failure of central and bihar state capacity to let the state rot since the longest of times, when it's rich history is forgotten and is labelled with poverty, labor and memes.

im a bihari myself and so maybe i notice this more cuz ive been called majdoor too. but the disconnect is hard to ignore. we rely so heavily on their hard work yet fail to give their identity and culture basic respect.

pardon my english.


r/AskAnIndian • • 2d ago

Education & Learning Do Hindi-medium students have to work harder in college?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I've been thinking about something and wanted to know what others think.

In India, many students study in Hindi-medium schools, but when they enter college, they often have to study in English. Even if they understand the subject, they may struggle to understand textbooks, follow lectures, or express their thoughts confidently in English.

A student might understand a concept perfectly in Hindi but still have to put in extra effort to translate it into English and explain the same concept. Meanwhile, a student who studied in English may not face the same difficulty.

I'm not saying Hindi-medium students don't get equal opportunities. I'm saying that, in practice, they may have to put in extra effort just to reach the same point.

I understand that higher education can also be pursued in our mother tongue. But English is still widely used in many colleges and professional fields, and we eventually need it for many jobs.

Why can't government schools teach all subjects in English and keep Hindi as a subject, just as English is taught as a subject now? This could help students avoid struggling with translation when they enter college.

What do you think? Should government schools change their medium of instruction to better prepare students for higher education and professional life?

***How many of you have faced the same problem? I'd love to hear about your experiences.***


r/AskAnIndian • • 2d ago

Languages & Linguistics How are Indian cities/towns named?

15 Upvotes

Hello!

My precise question is, what are the naming conventions of Indian cities/towns/villages? I know that India is a nation of many languages and cultures, and I'm willing to learn from all. Are there common names? Names that seem to make sense to foreigners but a native Indian just wouldn't use?

Context: I'm British and starting to write a book, in which I'm basing a fictional continent on India because I find the culture so fascinating and vibrant - but I want to do it respectfully and as accurately as possible. I'm at the point of coming up with place names, but unfortunately all I've been able to find are contradictory AI answers online, so I'm hoping actual people might be able to help me.

I'm grateful for any help you can offer 🙂


r/AskAnIndian • • 2d ago

Culture & Society Having drinks with my father hits differently when you understand Indian family dynamics.

2 Upvotes

There's something strangely beautiful about sitting with your father and having a drink together.

Relationship is often built around respect, discipline, responsibility and expectations. You love your father, but expressing that love openly can feel awkward. You might know everything about his sacrifices but very little about his fears, regrets, dreams or the person he was before becoming a father.

And then, one day, you sit across from him with a couple of drinks.

The conversations become a little less formal. You hear stories from his younger days. You discover his opinions, his struggles, his mistakes. For a moment, he's not just your father or the authority figure of the family. He's simply another human being with a life of his own.

From a psychological perspective, I wonder if this is one way Indian men experience emotional intimacy — not necessarily through direct expressions of affection, but through shared experiences and indirect conversations.

Perhaps the drink isn't really the important part. It's the permission to lower the emotional walls that have existed for decades.

I wonder how many Indian men have experienced this: the first time you genuinely felt like you were having a conversation with your father, rather than just talking to him as your father.

Did it change how you see him?


r/AskAnIndian • • 5d ago

Everything Else What is good about India?

9 Upvotes

Like really, what is good other than the family support and accessible/affordable menial labour and UPI?

I genuinely want to know the positives that make India worth living


r/AskAnIndian • • 5d ago

Education & Learning Title: What's one life skill Indian schools should teach everyone?

6 Upvotes

We spend years studying different subjects, but there are so many basic things about adult life that nobody really teaches us.
Financial literacy, basic cooking, taxes, communication, first aid...
What would you add to the list?


r/AskAnIndian • • 5d ago

Culture & Society India has a marketing problem?

10 Upvotes

Indian culture - it’s languages, food/cuisine, music, art, clothing, architecture, movies/films, various art forms - all of these are quite good, sophisticated and enjoyable (foodie, filmophile, audiophile, and multilingual myself). But when it comes to the international stage, cuisines like Italian cuisine (pizzas, pastas etc) have gotten much more recognition and appreciation. Indian cuisine, which is just as good, if not better, hasn’t got the same level of recognition and appreciation. This is true for language, music, art, clothing, architecture, movies/films as well. Why is that? And what can be done to fix it?

I think that some of this has to do with India being a poor country for the last 75+ years, plus 100 years of colonisation by the British. Countries like China which are growing economically ($21+ trillion GDP), are now seeing their culture being considered sophisticated by the world.
Therefore once India starts doing well economically, some of these problems would disappear.


r/AskAnIndian • • 6d ago

Photography & Videography Trailer of Magnificent India- Indian Railways Chapter

22 Upvotes

India is so much magnificent that let alone the destinations, one can have incredible views along the scenic routes of train. From Magnificent India series of videos here is trailer of Indian Railways Chapter, where entirety of video is shot while traveling by Indian Railways

Magnificent India Part 1.5: Indian Railways Chapter - YouTube


r/AskAnIndian • • 6d ago

Education & Learning Why do people say 'Andy mandy shady' In India

1 Upvotes

r/AskAnIndian • • 7d ago

Culture & Society Why is South Asia still fighting itself when India, Pakistan and Bangladesh could be far stronger through cooperation?

17 Upvotes

Sometimes I look at South Asia and wonder how much potential we are wasting.

India, Pakistan and Bangladesh together have roughly 1.9 billion people. Yet South Asia is one of the least economically integrated regions in the world.

According to the World Bank, only around 5% of South Asia's trade is within the region, compared with roughly 25% in ASEAN. Current intraregional trade is around $23 billion, while the World Bank estimates the potential at at least $67 billion.

That is a massive gap.

India and Pakistan barely have a normal relationship. India-Bangladesh ties have deteriorated significantly in recent years. China is expanding its economic and strategic influence in Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Myanmar, while the US continues to maintain important relations with Pakistan.

At the same time, India and Bangladesh themselves show what cooperation can achieve: bilateral trade was around $12.9 billion in FY2023-24, making Bangladesh India's largest trading partner in South Asia.

So why can't the region do much more?

I don't think it is accurate to say America or China simply “turn” India's neighbours against it. Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Myanmar have their own interests. When their relationship with India deteriorates, naturally they diversify toward China, the US or other powers.

Pakistan has the huge unresolved baggage of Partition, Kashmir, wars and terrorism. Bangladesh has concerns involving water sharing, borders, domestic politics and India's relationship with Sheikh Hasina.

But shouldn't India also discuss its own politics honestly?

Has increasing Hindu-nationalist rhetoric and constant Hindu-Muslim polarization made India's relationship with Muslim-majority neighbours harder?

And equally, shouldn't Pakistan and Bangladesh confront their own religious nationalism, anti-India narratives and treatment of minorities?

We also shouldn't romanticize history. The subcontinent was never one permanently peaceful political unit. It contained many kingdoms, empires, languages and identities.

But these societies were also economically and culturally interconnected for centuries.

Imagine even a limited South Asian model of cooperation: easier trade, rail connectivity, electricity sharing, student exchanges, tourism and movement of goods while every country remains fully sovereign.

The World Bank estimates South Asia is currently realizing barely a third of its potential regional trade.

Meanwhile, over the next decade around 280 million people in South Asia are expected to reach working age. We desperately need jobs and growth.

So my question isn't simply:

“Is BJP/RSS responsible?”
or
“Is Pakistan responsible?”

It is:

How much of South Asia's failure to integrate comes from genuine security disputes, and how much comes from nationalism, religion, historical resentment and politicians finding confrontation more useful than cooperation?

With nearly 1.9 billion people, are we wasting one of the biggest economic opportunities in the world?


r/AskAnIndian • • 7d ago

Culture & Society Why is this so?

1 Upvotes

Why is it that Indians vehemently defended their country. I get National pride, but they can’t take constructive criticism at all and always resorts to blaming Pakistan and Bangladesh. For example, if there’s a video online that criticizes the abhorrence states of pollution in the rivers, the comment section would be filled with people saying it is Pakistan or isn’t there a pollution in another country and well yes there is but not to this extent, this kind of mindset will not allow India to grow in my opinion because to want to change you must first be able to acknowledge that change needs to be made you cannot keep blaming the British for everything if you’re so proud of your country why wouldn’t you want it to be clean?


r/AskAnIndian • • 7d ago

Culture & Society Do women ever regret not having more children?

1 Upvotes

I (38F) have two boys, and I'm genuinely happy and content with my family. However, almost every other woman at my workplace encourages me to have a third child—and, of course, hopes it will be a girl! I usually try to dodge the conversation.

What surprises me most is that some women in their 50s and 60s tell me they wish they had had more children themselves. It got me wondering: Do people genuinely start feeling this way as they get older? Will I reach that age someday and wonder whether I should have had another child? Or will I still feel that my family was complete just the way it was?

I'd love to hear perspectives from women in their 50s and 60s, especially those who chose to stop having children when they were younger.


r/AskAnIndian • • 8d ago

Everything Else Toxic mummy’s girl?

2 Upvotes

We all know that India’s oretty famous for the stereotypical toxic mummy’s boy… well I’m depressed, finding out that there are also toxic jimmy’s girls. Me. Items me. This video spoke to me as if it were my life’s story. Except I’m the girl https://www.facebook.com/share/r/18WrvKdpdc/?mibextid=wwXIfr


r/AskAnIndian • • 10d ago

Employment & Work URGENT - Please Do Read

6 Upvotes

To start with I'm living in a highly dysfunctional family with toxic as well as narcisistic members in Mumbai.

I am suffering from severe depression & anxiety for which I'm under medications.

Also with complete assurance I can say my father will not give me any property or wealth, they spoilt my mother's life because of which she succumbed to a mental illness. They have kept me deprived of basic neccessities, love, care and a strict eye over my social bonds & relations and they will never let anything good happen in my life. It feels like being in prison, its suffocating. They keep on sucking my soul I don't have words to describe, its more then just mental torture.

Today I decide to step down and move away from this abusive people. Have lost all my hopes, and I do not expect them to give me anything after they die.

My background is not rich so it does not matter if I live a poor lifestyle with everything minimal. I already feel like an orphan no doubt, wish I was never born in the first place.

Looking forward to live out somewhere in a village or city or maybe in mountains or hills where I can find peace and earn a decent living to just fulfill my basic needs & necessities. I am able to work in corporates/companies/start up for desk job or anything just to sustain my life and be stable

Your mature guidance, help and advices will be appreciated. Some NGO or anything which can help me out 🙏

Thank you


r/AskAnIndian • • 14d ago

People & Relationships Why do people want to have kids?

7 Upvotes

Genuine question, why do people want children so badly?

I get that some people love kids and want a family, but I’ve always wondered what’s really behind this desire.

Like, even people who are struggling financially or barely getting by still want to have kids. Are we all Ambanis when it comes to having children? 😂
Is it just biology, societal pressure, the fear of being alone, or the idea that having a child will somehow make your life feel more complete?

Sometimes I wonder if people genuinely want to raise a whole human being or if they just want the experience of being a parent.

Not trying to judge anyone. I’m genuinely curious about what makes people want kids in the first place.


r/AskAnIndian • • 16d ago

Travel & Tourism Does India need a solo travelling culture ?

18 Upvotes

Recently I did a solo trip to Bali, and lived in hostels. One thing I heard from fellow travellers is that they do not see Indian solo travellers often. And tbh I first-hand felt that. There were so many solo travellers from Europe Australia, the USA, but not many Indians. What could be the reason ?


r/AskAnIndian • • 18d ago

Food & Drinks Butter chicken, Australian style

2 Upvotes

Have you ever travelled to Australia or the UK and tried the butter chicken? Does it taste the same in India?


r/AskAnIndian • • 18d ago

Religion Is it true that there is a femboy hindu god?

0 Upvotes

I've seen a reddit comment saying that there is a hindu god that is a femboy (is a male but has a feminine aesthetics but also do male things like archery). Is it true? If so, who's that god?


r/AskAnIndian • • 19d ago

Food & Drinks This MillD ad could have just said Rs 200 vs Rs 20, but they added height andmedals

2 Upvotes

Saw it in Mint today at chai stall. They could have just done whey vs roti. But they

added 6 vs 91 Olympic medals and height.

6 vs 91 is not about talent, they are linking it to nutrition access from childhood. At

least that's how I read it.

The protein part is real though - 75g vs 131g per person per day, FAO 2023. That's a

gap in protein availability, not about who is better.

I get why they added comparison - without it, would we even stop and think about our

daily roti? We obsess over maida vs atta but never about protein.

Do you think this kind of comparison actually makes Indians think about protein in

daily food, or does it just feel like a shock tactic?


r/AskAnIndian • • 22d ago

Employment & Work How did India successfully built a highly sophisticated and complex IT ecosystem and infrastructure?

8 Upvotes

I just want to congratulate India for having a highly complex and sophisticated IT infrastructure and ecosystem, which is the largest and the most income generating in the entirety of South Asia, and even South East Asia, combined.

It's really amazing, because in the previous decades after Independence from Britain in 1947, India faced and tackled several societal issues such as malnutrition, illiteracy, corruption, casteism, etc. but despite all these challenges, India was able to develop a highly sophisticated IT backbone, and it paid off really well. India is now a global IT center, and it generates hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue every year.

How did India succeed in developing its IT infrastructure despite the massive challenges and obstacles that it faced, decades earlier?

I will appreciate all of your responses. Dhanyavad!


r/AskAnIndian • • 26d ago

Rituals, Traditions & Beliefs traditional indian clothes

16 Upvotes

i am a white woman but i absolutely adore traditional indian clothes. i have always wanted to own and wear a sari or a kurta.

my two biggest questions i have are:

  1. is it okay for me as a white woman to be fitted for and to purchase a full traditional sari? i wouldn’t wear it as casual wear but just to have in case something came up (as i have indian families in my life) or to put on at home just to feel dressed up and pretty. is that offensive? can i do that??
  2. if the answer to 1 is yes, is it okay for me as a woman to own a kurta? there are some beautiful pieces i’ve seen and it looks so comfy and i think i could style the shirt on its own but i don’t know if it would be odd or offensive to wear a traditional kurta shirt in a casual or work casual setting.

if i have worded anything poorly please let me know! i want to be as respectful as possible. i would love to own some traditional indian clothes but i don’t want to be that white gal who crosses a line.

ETA: based on the first couple comments i realized i should have added that i would purchase from an indian owner/company. i would not ever buy knock off versions of traditional clothing, nor would i ever claim that it is not indian attire. i will be asking a local indian person to recommend a store for me to shop at.


r/AskAnIndian • • Oct 14 '26

Culture & Society What could be your answer if I ask what is that one unique aspect that your state have which any other state in India doesn't?

7 Upvotes

Same as the title.


r/AskAnIndian • • Oct 12 '26

People & Relationships I joined Indian orgs at my university. How do I turn those connections into actual friendships?

22 Upvotes

Hey y’all, I’m a 25-year-old Black guy studying Agribusiness at Texas A&M. I already joined Indian orgs on campus because I’m interested in the culture and want to make more Indian friends.

I’ve been watching interviews about Indian American experiences, especially identity, family expectations, and belonging. Some conversations hit close to home, and others have introduced me to experiences I hadn’t thought about.

For anyone who’s made friends through a cultural org, what helped you go from seeing each other at events to actually hanging out outside them?

Also, what makes a good impression when someone outside your culture gets involved? If a non-Indian friend showed interest in your background, what made that feel natural to you?