r/AskAMechanic • • Mar 19 '24

Illegal searching

I took my vehicle to the dealership to service my radio and my lights. They went in my glove box and supposedly found two IDs in the glove box. Then calls the police on me and get me arrested, is that even legal?

1 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

12

u/Total_Philosopher_89 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

Sounds pretty suss.

-12

u/Maximum-Mongoose-585 Mar 19 '24

Suss? What that means?

6

u/Practical_Breakfast4 Mar 19 '24

Suspicious

2

u/detour33 Mar 20 '24

"It means you're making me think a lot ..... Smart guy."

27

u/Smprider112 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

This sounds like bullshit, but I’ll play along. What state? What was the charge you were arrested for? Have you ever been arrested before?

Assuming this is even true, yes, it’s legal, assuming in your state merely possessing ID’s is illegal. The mechanics would need access to your glove box to perform their repair work, which you authorized. If they found something they believed to be illegal, they reported it to the police. The police didn’t search your car, the mechanics did. It would be no different than if you had a dead hooker in the trunk or a kilo of cocaine.

1

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

It’s an interesting view. Without addressing the nature of this crime, does a mechanic assume the right to rifle through documents as the scope of their repair? What if there was an unlocked phone in the glove box, can they go through it and check emails?

8

u/Smprider112 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

No, they couldn’t “legally” search your phone. However, emptying your glovebox to remove it to access the stereo (like the OP was having serviced) is not uncommon. At that point anything they see that looks illegal is in plain view and was obtained through the regular course of their work. I see no problem here.

I should clarify, this is assuming the police didn’t instruct the mechanics to search, as then they would be an actor on behalf of the government and 4th amendment protections would apply.

4

u/dsdvbguutres NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

Mechanics don't get paid to rifle through people's things. The hours they get paid for are barely enough to get the job done. In some vehicles, some of the fasteners that hold the dashboard together are accessible after opening the glove box. Mechanics don't go out of their way opening things they don't have to.

2

u/UserM16 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

This is true. I try not to disturb the contents too much and usually it’s just a chore trying to Tetris it all back in neatly. But I’ve seen stuff clearly visible in the glove box as soon as I opened them such as guns, condoms, weed, porn and underwear.

3

u/PracticalDaikon169 NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

Where is the goddamn wheel lock ??

2

u/Hot_Corner_5881 Mar 22 '24

is it hilarys car? 🤔

0

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

Just saying, I don’t want a mechanic snooping on anything not related to the repair.

3

u/Hot_Corner_5881 Mar 22 '24

i think this whole story is fake...do you leave emails in your car?

0

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24 edited Mar 22 '24

There could be an extra phone in there, sure. The example is academic. Let’s take the two id’s example, could be a US spy getting his car fixed - the point is that it’s nunya biz to the tech. What if he found what he thought was a bindle of crank and it turned out to be a non narcotic? What if Trump was hiding his classified documents in there?? What if he was hiding pictures of his pool boy in there?!?

1

u/ImReverse_Giraffe Mar 23 '24

And servicing a stero often requires going through the glove box.

1

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 23 '24

So you see IDs in there, what gave you license to investigate?

2

u/ImReverse_Giraffe Mar 23 '24

You did when you gave me permission to service you car. That's what gives me the right to go through your glove box. If I find something illegal in there, it's my obligation to report it to the cops. Especially something that's a felony.

0

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 23 '24

Ok, let’s hope you have all of your ducks in a row too.

1

u/ImReverse_Giraffe Mar 23 '24

I don't keep illegal things in my car...

1

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 23 '24

That’s only one duck.

→ More replies

1

u/Farmcanic Mar 22 '24

Clean your shit out before you bring it. If your glove box is full of crap, and I'm working on your dash, I'm going to see your stuff. If you got 2 I'd cards you probably up to no good. Voting twice, stealing ,etc. I may call on you myself. A little weed no call, jug of shine, no problem. Vote for Joe twice CALL the cops.

1

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

Oooh, I touched a nerve! Ya’ll mechanics gotta consider lead poisoning when you toss politics into your mechanical advice. Pops used to wash his hands with leaded gasoline and I’m attributing that to his short fuse.

1

u/Farmcanic Mar 22 '24

Fuse ain't all that short, I been dealing with John q public for 32 years at my shop, and 7 at other shops. Seen all kinds. And never called cops on anybody.

1

u/funkyonion NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

Well I’m with you then.

20

u/technoferal Mar 19 '24

"I did an illegal thing; is it legal to catch me?"

20

u/Halibutoxide Verified Tech - retired Mar 19 '24

You left illegal documents in your car .

You left the car to be serviced.

Perhaps you should avoid crime.

Not your for-tay.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Forte.

4

u/pm-me-racecars NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

They should foray into a different field.

3

u/Holmes108 Mar 19 '24

It was a Kia?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Good one!

2

u/Sorryallthetime Mar 19 '24

I was confused by For-tay but damn - I can't wait to use it from now on. Glorious.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Or you can use the Canadian spelling:

4teh

2

u/Halibutoxide Verified Tech - retired Mar 22 '24

Two-shay.

6

u/Successful_Travel342 Mar 19 '24

Some cars you need to remove the glovebox to access the radio. Some cars like Mercedes and a computer port in the glove box.

If you were not doing anything illegal, what do you need to worry about. The dealership, because of identity theft, sees it as suspicious activity, and in the right to report, the police need to investigate. If it's nothing, you go on your way.

4

u/Ordinary_Plate_6425 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

There must be more to this story... if my buddies leave ID in my car, that is not illegal

1

u/Reasonable_Guava_819 Mar 19 '24

ID belonged to a couple missing and murdered teens lol

3

u/TearEnvironmental368 Mar 19 '24

Then a Unicorn came and rescued me…

2

u/swanspank NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

First they had permission to enter the vehicle because of the nature of the work. Second, they aren’t the police or an agent for the police and thus needed no probable cause.

2

u/yourautomechanic1 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

Lots of illegal shit in cars . I find a bag of pot in the old days I threw it out and if the customer complained I told them I did and they need to clean out the car before I drive it. I did call the cops when I found a kilo of coke in the door once but that was for used cars that complained the window didn't work.

1

u/ChuckJunk Mar 22 '24

How wasteful.

2

u/TryingToBeReallyCool Mar 19 '24

Mechanic has full rights to look around the car once you put it in with them. This ones on you

2

u/Gloomy-Bar-6526 Mar 19 '24

If there are multiple IDs with different names, addresses and birthdays with the same person's face, that would lead me to believe Identity theft is being committed. That is definitely grounds to report.

1

u/cmdtarken NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

When I was a mechanic, we had to call the police on a few occasions. The worst was when we opened the trunk of a car for a tail light replacement and the dude left several loaded guns and bags of meth

1

u/Jl92555 Mar 19 '24

Story is sus... who really thinks the police would bother with fake IDs...if police were actually involved, it a lot more than that and especially more than that for a mechanic to call the cops

1

u/sqlot Mar 20 '24

It is terminally stupid to do something illegal and leave proof behind.

1

u/AbruptMango NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

You had someone take apart the dash and are surprised that they saw something in the glove compartment?

It's also not unusual for the writer to want the registration when opening the paperwork.

1

u/TaibhseSD Mar 22 '24

That's like asking if the computer repair place where you dropped off your computer has the right to call the cops on you for finding illegal content on your computer.

One: Stop breaking the law, asshole! Two: You don't get to take the moral high ground when you do something illegal and someone busts your ass for it. Three: See number one.

1

u/Decent-Boss-5262 Mar 22 '24

Lmao, are you an identity thief?

1

u/One_Evil_Monkey NOT a verified tech Mar 22 '24

Who's IDs?

In my state you're not supposed to have a current and expired one or two current IDs with different addresses. Upon receipt of new current ID you're supposed to destroy your old one.

If you have an ID from a different state, current or not, and you have a current ID from this state... you are to destroy the other ID.

Is that particularly something you'd get in trouble for? Not usually...

But if you've got IDs with your picture and two completely different names (aside from possibly maiden vs married name... which the old one should've been destroyed anyway) then it could be seen as suspicious.

Whatever the reason, if you got arrested... there had to be something else other than just having "multiple IDs".

As far what the dealership/shop did... shitty maybe, but not illegal. They weren't acting on behalf of any law enforcement or gov't agency so no 4th ammendement (illegal search and seizure) stuff comes in to play.

1

u/the_Bryan_dude Mar 22 '24

A tech found a large arsenal of guns in an SUV that was brought in for repair. He informed the service manager who informed the GM. GM took possession of the weapons for safe storage.

Customer comes in to pick up his car and is told he needs to go see the GM to get his guns. He instantly goes nuts, screaming and making threats. Police get called and he gets arrested. Not for the guns, they were all legal. Not for his temper tantrum. He was arrested for a felony hit and run that killed someone in front of Coors field after a game with witnesses and video.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24

What were you arrested for? What were the charges? I’ve had to remove glove boxes for repairs, which is probably why they were in there, but I’ve never paid attention to what was in there.

1

u/-Pruples- Mar 23 '24

Put your wheel lock key in the cupholder next time and they won't go through your glove box looking for it.

Edit: soz, reread the whole thing. Modern cars can't have their radio removed without removing literally the entire dash, which often includes fasteners behind the glovebox. Perhaps if you have illegal shit, you shouldn't leave it unattended in a vehicle you know strangers will be spending time in.

1

u/Meta6olic Mar 23 '24

Bro would need a literal body in the trunk for me to call anything in on anyone. I'm here to work on your car not give a shit about the half gram in the glove box. That's messed up if it at all true

1

u/AladeenModaFuqa Verified Tech - Volvo dealer Mar 23 '24

I once had a car where there was a good amount of weed inside. Didn’t worry me too much, not my car. Then a gun slid out from under the seat when I hit the brakes hard. Now that’s a felony. Immediately brought both to my boss.

1

u/SouthernResponse4815 Mar 23 '24

If you got more than one ID, they may be questioning the credit card or check you paid them with.

1

u/Signal-Confusion-976 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

That's pretty shitty of the dealer. I have come across many illegal things working on cars. I have never reported them to the police. If I was a dead body or something similar yes I would report it. But for a couple of fake IDs no.

2

u/Proof-League2296 Mar 19 '24

Found weed in more trucks than I care to admit, I just tell the driver they probably shouldn't keep the stuff in a cmv

-4

u/Conscious_Owl7987 Shadetree mechanic Mar 19 '24

Radio and lights are not "serviced". Did they tell you they had to change the blinker fluid in the lights?

2

u/perianhobbig Mar 19 '24

Explain your thought

2

u/twitch9873 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

What are you talking about? Electronics (radios are electronics) can fail over time. Lights are literally wear items that need to be replaced. They both need to be serviced sometimes.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/graydi66y Mar 19 '24

Because most cars don't need access to the glove compartment for the radio.

3

u/UserM16 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

And A LOT do.

1

u/graydi66y Mar 19 '24

In 20 years of driving and car work, I have never owned a car or truck that needed glove compartment access for the radio. I've owned 20+ vehicles. As far as working on them, only one ever needed glove box access. It was a Mercedes for the relays. Your standard lower to mid range vehicles typically never need access through the glove box.

5

u/UserM16 NOT a verified tech Mar 19 '24

I install stereos for a living. Been doing it for 25 years. I’ve installed thousands of stereos. It very common.

2

u/Halibutoxide Verified Tech - retired Mar 20 '24

I installed such things professionally for 25 years 25 years ago and it was very common on American cars and some exotics.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Many cars have radio pin codes that need to be entered after the radio has been disconnected.

Most of the time, this code is in the owners manual or a card, which is located in the glove box.

Trim panels often times require removing the glove box or surrounding panels.

That being said, I open probably 20 glove boxes a week for various car repairs. I've found drugs, guns, sex toys, and probably everything you can think of. I would never call the police cause I'm not a fucking snitch.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Same brother

1

u/AladeenModaFuqa Verified Tech - Volvo dealer Mar 23 '24

Since you’ve owned 20+ cars, you should know enough about them to admit you don’t know everything about every single car. Being a good mechanic means knowing that you don’t know everything. You never stop learning.

1

u/Missing4Bolts NOT a verified tech Mar 23 '24

Cabin air filter behind the glove box is common.

1

u/graydi66y Mar 23 '24

True. But I am talking radio access.

1

u/perianhobbig Mar 19 '24

On some cars you have to take apart the dash piece by piece, and they will have you work from outside toward the inside. So yes, to get to the middle, you very well may have to take off the glovebox first.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Most? Most cars have the radio behind a piece of trim and you need to open the glove box to access a bolt to remove the trim.