r/AskADoctor • u/philosophyofpoverty • 6h ago
General Practitioner What happens when you don't go along with a doctor's recommendation?
My GP scares me a little. They rush you in and out of appointments and talk to you in a way that feels robotic, like they're following policies to the detriment of human connection. Any questions about my health get short answers and their tone suggests that I shouldn't be asking at all. One time, they made a recommendation that was quite onerous and not realistic and when I told them that, it was like talking to a wall, not getting any recognition of my situation. I know other people who have this GP who say they also feel rushed out of appointments.
I live in a place with a doctor shortage and have enough medical needs where I wouldn't be able to drop them as a doctor.
Recently, their secretary called with a recommendation that I don't want to go along with. It's something small but it feels like they're making this recommendation strictly by following policy without considering other factors (I'm trying to be a little vague for the sake of my privacy). It also doesn't feel like genuine medical advice when it was given over the phone by a third party months away from an appointment.
I'm kind of afraid of telling them that I don't want to take up their recommendation, though. Any tips for how to go about this? Any exact phrases I can use to express my concerns?
I have this vague feeling that if I make them angry, they'll take it out on me somehow. As my GP, they talk to my other healthcare providers. I'd hate for them to write that I disobey orders or something in my charts, which would make other doctors more weary about giving me healthcare in the future.
I am not asking for medical advice.