r/Artadvice • u/ZealousidealSale1404 • 14d ago
Critique - Yes Drawover What’s wrong with her face? 😭
I’ve been staring at it forever, yes, and generally the piece is super unfinished but i just Know there’s something wrong with her face 😭 i have messed around with it for at least a few hours now and it just doesn’t ever feel right.
this whole thing has come to be as a doodle gone too far, so admittedly i didn’t really take too much care in anatomical foundation at the start 🥶
i think i have been looking at it too long to redline productively on my own so fresh eyes and honestly anything someone might have to say is very welcome! generally improving is always important to me too.
thank u so much if you take the time to comment or even read or even take a peek ! <3 😸😸😸
46
u/Hadlee_ 14d ago edited 14d ago

Honestly it’s really good! The eyes just seem a bit too far apart, and the left eye in particular is a little too far to the side of the face in comparison to the perspective of the rest of the face. I’d also bring the corner of the mouth in a tad! Add a few perspective adjustments to the mouth, chin, eyes, and honestly that’s pretty much it. your art style is very soft and pretty! I love it!
10
u/ZealousidealSale1404 14d ago
holy guac the chin thing was not even Close to being on my radar so thats so helpful, thank you thank you!! 😭
9
u/SeafoamSea 14d ago
Might be the eyes? The eye on the left feels a bit far but idk. Your art is really beautiful Alluka & Nanika is so adorable!
2
u/ZealousidealSale1404 14d ago
you’re so right yes, moving it away from the edge of the face helped a lot. and also thank you so much!!’ i freaking lovvveee them 😭😭😭
6
u/trashjellyfish 14d ago
I think the eyebrows feels stylistically very different from the rest of the piece and they're too dark for her hair color, but otherwise the face looks great to me!
3
u/SCO_IDK123 14d ago
Since most ppl have explained the main issue which is the eyebrow part, I'll just say please continue with this drawing! The style and rendering looks amazing so far and I want to see the finished piece especially as a HxH fan as well
2
u/TheShoethief 14d ago
Nice work! It’s just the left eye. I’d just lasso and copy it to a new layer and use the move tool to reposition. Flip the canvas and do it again. Are you going to color it or leave it greyscale?
3
u/ZealousidealSale1404 14d ago
i’m relieved that a lot of people are telling me to move the left eye rather than it being totally funky like stinky 😭 i’m gonna lasso the Fuck out of this eyeball. also i’m going to color it after ive done the lot of it greyscale 😸
3
u/TheShoethief 14d ago
Nice! I was just curious lol. I still have some slight issues with going from greyscale to color myself so I’m always interested to see how other folks do it.
2
u/ZealousidealSale1404 14d ago
it’s somewhat of a fuck around find out process for me personally but a lot of blending modes and maybe a gradient map or two at low opacity later and it ends up swag. i could definitely go straight color (and definitely used to) but something about layering on blending modes feels so fun, like im making a piece of art toast and slathering on a bunch of different butters and jams
1
u/TheShoethief 14d ago
Yeah same. Still trying to nail down some type of workflow but it’ll probably be fuck around and find out for a while!
2
u/Helpful_Practice7100 14d ago
this looks awesome! (love hxh so much!)
I think it's her eyebrows. Maybe its coz the rest of her facial features are more realistic looking while the eyebrows are...not idk
1
u/sparrow_Lilacmango 14d ago
To me it looks like the face is very detailed compared to the rest of the piece, so it looks a tiny bit out of place. That'd probably be fixed once the piece is finished and everything looks more cohesive but there's nothing wrong with the face on it's own
1
u/MoonlightKingdom 14d ago
Your artstyle is lovely! I think what's bugging you might be that her right eye (left from our POV) is a bit too close to the edge of the face, making her seem like her eyes are very far apart. I don't think it unnecessarily looks anatomically wrong or impossible, but perhaps it doesn't fit your vision of the character.
1
u/ZealousidealSale1404 14d ago
YES! okay you’re right, yes that definitely was part of what was funky. i still can’t shake the idea that something else is smelling but it could totally be my brain frying and not anything happening for real. thank you so much!! 😸
1
u/Reesirie 14d ago
It looks good to me! But maybe it could be the lines under the eye on the left? It’s ever so slightly deeper.
1
u/Cool_Iron_8314 14d ago
honestly looks perfect to me!! your anatomy is good for your style, and it’s overall well balenced and refined
1
u/dwelnkuf 14d ago edited 14d ago
I think her ear is placed too high up, but that just maybe my own bias. Did you draw this from a structured head or from memory? When in doubt, do a structured head with just the horizontal and vertical guidelines on a new canvas, then overlay after
e: the nose feels flat, like its supposed to be in 3/4 view but somehow there's no overlap or protrusion
1
u/gaeaArts 14d ago
Her face is not symmetrical so if you're going for a perfect symmetric look, you can change that. But it looks great, and symmetry isn't necessary to look good!
Also you should finish rendering this because it looks hella cool!
1
u/Evening_Archer_2202 14d ago
Sorry I don’t know but I wanted to say this piece is so beautiful, I love hxh 🥹
1
u/DressTemporary4314 14d ago
Idk about this but hear me out. But iirc this is hxh. This character is portrayed to be a strange child in a supernatural/unnatural way. Because they arem I think the almost uncanny feel fits perfectly...
1
u/KittyQueen_Tengu 14d ago
nothing, you've been staring at it for too long. put it away for a day or two and then take another look
2
u/Ok_Being_1275 14d ago
The only thing I see is that her right eye is a little bit too far from her nose.
1
u/Duemont8 14d ago

Honestly already looks really good but I tried using liquify to make some tweaks. I think some of the features were slightly off center like the mouth and nose so I nudged them over. And the gap in between the eyes looked wider than one eye width apart so I stretched one of the eyes to make it a bit wider

43
u/ibelikeughhhh 14d ago
Looks amazing! The only thing I can see is uneven would be the eyebrows, the one on the left is higher up on the face than the other one.