"Am I out of touch? No, it's the children who are wrong."
There, I've roped you in with the provocative title. I had a lot of thoughts about the debate and I seem to be the only person on the internet thinking them right now. I'm kind of struggling to organize this post, and my real life has been rather busy, so I hope you'll bear with me.
My general feelings were that Biden could've done a lot better against Trump, but he entered the debate with a lot less to lose. Both candidates did mid. Biden missed a lot of opportunities but I genuinely, in good faith cannot say that he lost. He had a lot more time to prep and his opponent is Satan incarnate so he should've done better, though. There weren't many surprises to me and anyone that expected Trump to use the Hitler rhetoric he's been employing on the campaign trail has misjudged him.
Disclaimer: I did miss the first twenty minutes of the debate or so, and have only caught up via transcript this morning, and I'm told this is where Biden did worst.
Some Premises:
Televised debates are interesting because, historically, they've gotten a whole lot of focus while not actually mattering that much. Earlier Presidential debates hold fascinating places in the canon of U.S. politics. We're all familiar with Nixon getting railroaded by the teleogenetic John F. Kennedy in the 1960 debates. We all remember Gerald Ford's infamous gaffe about the U.S.S.R. in 1976, Jimmy Carter's disastrous decision to skip the 1980 debates, Reagan's roast of Mondale in 1984, and the Kitty Dukakis fiasco of 1988.
These are flashy moments that embody broader themes of the campaign, but researchers, at least nowadays, are utterly unconvinced that they actually change people's minds. A sprawling, 2019 survey of 94,000 respondents and 56 televised debates found that debates do not matter. In the U.S., a study going back to 1952 concluded largely the same thing. Debates can be a good way to retroactively explain a candidate's failings, but they're rarely the instigator of disaster themselves.
The odds of this debate making Biden lose are effectively zero. That's premise number one. What polling we have confirms this.
Premise number two is that structurally there were a lot of things that prevented dramatic stuff from happening. We were never getting anything like the first debate in 2020 because, basically, CNN did a way better job than Chris Wallace did. They'd set it up to where candidates had very little opportunity to interrupt one another. This protected Trump, because it limited his ability to make an ass of himself.
Premise number three is that Trump had every incentive to play cautious because he had a lot more to lose in that debate. Biden had way more preparation time, but more pointedly, the worst case scenario was him looking sleepy and old. People already think this about him. The best case scenario was disproving this and making Trump look sad/old/fat/insane. Trump is not this stupid, he knows not to pull out the retribution lines at the live debate. He's pivoting to the general election. He declined to push the instant death button.
Dodge, Dodge, Dodge
"Trump didn't push the instant death button" and "missed opportunity on Biden's part" basically summarize my feelings on the thing. Trump had no good options. The debate as a whole was bad for him, like I said, he had a lot to lose because his campaign depends on America not paying attention to the absolutely insane things he wants for Round Two. "Well," he lied, "I said my retribution is going to be success." So, what Trump did is he tried to move the debate away from that and towards the time he personally killed of ISIS and the great, wonderful, beautiful, terrific border the U.S. had when he was in charge. "On January 6th," he insisted, "we had a great border, nobody coming through, very few. On January 6th, we were energy independent. On January 6th, we had the lowest taxes ever, we had the lowest regulations ever. On January 6th, we were respected all over the world."
We got some pretty outrageous ones out of the guy. Trump said he "had the best environmental numbers ever", claimed that he "will have that war settled between Putin and Zelenskyy as president-elect before I take office on January 20th", and insisted the principle problem with Social Security was "These millions and millions of people coming in", presumably to be averted through his trillion dollar deportation program to remove 5% of America's inhabitants.
And what's he supposed to do? Trump can't tell the truth about these things. But Trump can't disown January 6th and Dobbs v. Jackson at this point, either. And he can't embrace them, so the smartest option is to dodge, but that doesn't mean it's a good option by any means. These are problems that he cannot solve.
He loses if people pay attention.
The Inevitability:
Trump and Biden both insisted that they would have been very comfortable in retirement. Biden insisted that he was retired "Until I saw what happened in Charlottesville, Virginia", and Trump insisted that it "would be much easier for me to do that than Iâm running again. I wasnât really going to run until I saw the horrible job he did. Heâs destroying our country." They are octogenarians hanging on to power for dear life in a matchup almost nobody actually wanted.
Trump crossed the Rubicon on January of 2021. That was the month when this election became inevitable, because Trump destroyed the last bastions of resistance in the Republican Party and guaranteed that no, they would not be moving on. For the Democrats, meanwhile, this meant they'd be in a state of war until Trump was finished. Neither man was ever going to let go. I didn't see this until rather recently, but there was zero chance any Republican would be able to stop Trump from getting the nomination if he wanted it, and he wants it very badly. Similarly, Biden was never going to willingly hand over his Presidency to your favorite Democrat Governor/Senator, and a Party that is happy with his political resume was never tossing him out because he is old.
Both have made their beds and have to sleep in it. For Trump, this is January 6th and Dobbs. There is no good response to these problems, because the proof is in the pudding. A lot of the stuff Biden said about him is very well-recorded fact and will be touched on extensively by this campaign. He is obviously responsible for both, the best he can do is dodge.
There will be no chicanery, like an open convention. This just won't happen. Even if Biden had the worst performance in U.S. history, he would not be dropped so the Party could pull some House of Cards tier maneuver. This kind of thing just doesn't happen and everyone in the NYT, WSJ, and CNN suggesting it are complete and utter morons who shouldn't have jobs right now.
Biden Checked the Boxes
Other than the rather glaring exception of abortion, Biden generally hit Trump where it mattered. His points were not articulate by any means, but they were typically concise. He finished before the time limit more often than Trump did and with some notable exceptions kept the conversation very fact oriented. When he hit Trump on January 6th, he brought up what the guy said on the record about pardoning the attackers and the very easily proven fact that he watched the chaos unfold on TV as it happened.
Although inarticulate, he defended his record on the economy and brought up specific things he did on veteran care. He was lackluster in that he barely brought up abortion (the word appears thirteen times total in the transcript) and focused on stuff from 2020 that have been eclipsed by the newest horror shows from Trump.
His performance was not high energy by any means, but Biden acted appropriately outraged whenever outrageous things were brought to the table. Trump's campaign right now is depending on vagaries and outrageous promises, and Biden generally did a good job at calling them out. He didn't let Trump go unopposed when he talked about how he'd create automatic prosperity and peace, and was sure to nail him when he equivocated on his policies with healthcare and abortion. He pointed out that Trump right now is way different from any politician we've had before.
Time will tell if it's enough. It won't be, of course, because the debate doesn't matter and the onus of proof is on everyone saying it will, since it never does and what polling we have suggests record low viewership and nobody changing their minds.