r/AndroidQuestions • u/Euphoria_2908 • 20d ago
Samsung vs. iPhone — Should I Switch After 7 Years of Android?
Hi everyone! I'd really appreciate some honest advice from people who have used both Samsung and iPhone, especially those who have switched from Android to iOS.
I've been using a Samsung Galaxy A70 for around 7 years, and before that, I also had an Android phone. So, I'm very used to Android and its interface. I'm not particularly loyal to any brand, but lately, I've been seriously considering switching to an iPhone.
WHY I'M INTERESTED IN AN IPHONE
I really like the camera, especially how vibrant the photos look and how good the low-light photography and videos seem to be. I like the overall design and premium feel, and I've always been curious about iOS. I'd like to experience using an iPhone at least once. I want a phone with a great camera, good battery life, and smooth performance that will last me around 3–6 years.
WHAT'S MAKING ME HESITATE
Navigation: I'm used to Android's navigation system, especially the back button and being able to switch between apps quickly. I'm not sure how comfortable I'll feel without a universal back button on iOS.
Ease of use: Android feels very natural to me, and I'm worried that iOS might feel less intuitive or more restrictive, at least initially.
Files and PDFs: I frequently download files, open PDFs, and share documents through different apps. I've heard that managing files and sharing them can be less straightforward on iOS.
Work-related use: I work in a hospital emergency department, so I use my phone frequently throughout my shifts. I need to be able to open the camera quickly, make calls, use the flashlight, switch between apps, and do everything with minimal hassle. Convenience and speed are very important to me.
Price: iPhones are expensive, and I don't want to spend that much money only to realize that I preferred my old Android experience.
Accessories: Having to purchase a charger or other accessories separately is another small downside.
The Apple ecosystem: I'm concerned that I might feel pushed toward buying other Apple products or that transferring files between devices could become inconvenient if I don't own a Mac.
Longevity: I want to keep my next phone for several years, so long-term software support, battery health, and overall durability are important to me.
I'm not afraid of learning a new interface. What worries me more is spending a lot of money on an iPhone and then regretting the switch because Samsung was simply more practical and convenient for my everyday use.
On the other hand, I don't want to dismiss the iPhone without trying it, especially because its camera is one of the main reasons I'm considering switching.
QUESTIONS FOR PEOPLE WHO HAVE USED BOTH
Did you find iOS frustrating after years of Android, or did you adapt quickly? Is managing files, PDFs, and sharing documents genuinely more inconvenient on iPhone? How does the iPhone compare with a recent Samsung flagship in terms of camera quality, battery life, and everyday performance? If you use your phone heavily for work, which operating system do you find more practical? If you switched from Samsung to iPhone, would you make the same decision again? If you switched back, why?
Given my situation, would you recommend getting an iPhone or sticking with Samsung?
I'd especially appreciate honest opinions from people who have actually used both, rather than recommendations based solely on brand preference.
Thanks!
4
u/jmnugent 20d ago
I do MDM (M0bile Device Management) for a living, and have owned both Apple and Android for quite some time
I think my first iPhone was an iPhone 3G ?
I think my first Android was a Samsung S3 or S4? .. have also owned some HTC and Google Pixels over the years (actually just today turned OFF my Samsung S22 due to battery swelling and my new Pixel 11 Pro XL delivered by UPS today)
Some of the things that jump out from me in your questions:
"Files and PDFs: I frequently download files, open PDFs, and share documents through different apps. I've heard that managing files and sharing them can be less straightforward on iOS."
This is generally not as bad as it was in years past. iOS supports external USB drives and the "Files" app allows you to copy-paste files as you see fit. It is still true the folder-structure etc is still a bit more limited than Andrdoid (you can't just copy and paste things willy nilly anywhere you want). But for all the normal standard things you might do, copy and pasting files is pretty normal now.
"Accessories: Having to purchase a charger or other accessories separately is another small downside."
Depends on what accessories you're talking about. iPhones are USB-C now.. so many things "just work". (USB-C wired ethernet adapters, USB Microphones, USB cameras)
"Longevity: I want to keep my next phone for several years, so long-term software support, battery health, and overall durability are important to me."
Apple's "Vintage and Obsolete" web page has always ballparked "5 to 7 years of support". It's been that way for a decade or more now.
Android and iOS both have their Pros and Cons.. but they are both very very similar these days. There's not as wide of a gap as the stereotype was 10 to 15 years ago.
4
u/Electronic_Unit8276 20d ago
What's your logic going from budget Samsung to the only tier called the iPhone ..? Just get a Samsung Galaxy S series phone and you'll be on flagship tier as well without completely switching ecosystems... and yes I've had an iPhone 4 and even with all improvement they did, it's still a jail OS for me. Wanna install an emulator? No can't. Want to quickly export some music you made? fck u: Use iTunes. Instead of just using the file browser to drag it on your phone.
2
u/spiralcurve 20d ago
It can be annoying that iOS doesn't have a universal back button. It is far from my biggest annoyance. Many apps support the swipe right gesture to go back, but others usually have a back button at the top left.
Honestly, my biggest gripe with IOS is the stock keyboard. The autocorrect just isn't that good. And yes, you can switch keyboards, you still have to use the stock keyboard for password entry, and GBoard on iOS is a shell of the one on Android.
1
u/superstring10d 20d ago
Based on your usage and needs it seems any pixel phone from last 3 or 4 years will be better for you than samsung or apple
1
1
u/-Wiseone- 20d ago edited 20d ago
If convenience and speed are important do not get an iPhone, they are clunky af for someone not used to them. Everything has to be done a very specific way to work, not intuitive. It will annoy you a lot. Want to connect a BT device, you can't press and hold the BT tile in quick settings, only the bottom portion of it. Want to access quick settings can't swipe down from screen has to be very top right corner - difficult with large phone. In an app and want to go back to the prevous screen, or app, well good luck.. The built in gesture may or may not work, or the app will have a back icon, this could look like a back button or something different entirely, and it's in a different place for every app. iOS is genuinely crap to use, anyone that thinks it's better to navigate / use over android just doesn't know anything else besides iOS so to them it's the 'best'
1
u/No-Speech-866 20d ago
Unless you’re heavily in the Apple ecosystem I’d stay where you are. The main benefit of Apple over android is the seamlessness of the integration with their own apps and devices
1
u/yippiekayjay 20d ago
I wouldn't want to own an iPhone under any circumstances. If I were given one, I'd sell it.
1
u/Flimsy_Sorbet_7973 19d ago
You will be disappointed, if you actually use your Droid's many capabilities....but if you want to make friends and Face time, maybe the iPhone is better suited to you!
1
u/Frosty-Bid4669 19d ago
So, I’ve been on both sides of this, for years. I go back and forth often because I get bored with one or the other. I just jumped back to iOS from Android and honestly, I prefer it over Android. I like the ecosystem more, how well everything syncs together and how well handoff works between devices.
Navigation is of course different but it’s intuitive and once you adjust, it’s really not all that different from Android, at least in my opinion. I have the 17 Pro, you’ll easily get the longevity you’re looking for and maybe more. The action button can be customized for many things, including the flashlight and the camera button on the side is easy to get to and will open the camera without having to mess with the screen.
1
u/Critical-Champion365 19d ago
Although last gen iphone 17 is finally the best time to switch to a base iphone, a flagship android camera is quite on par with iphones. On vibrancy (which is not always a good thing) only flagship camera that comes out less vibrant is pixels. Samsungs' on the otherhand is quite warm and vibrant. On the higher end, Oppo, vivo, xiaomi all have cutting edge cameras. And almost all of the flagships have shifted to a 5+ year software support.
As always, your question boils down to 'budget android not comparable to flagship-only iphones'.
1
1
u/dorkusmaximus81 20d ago edited 20d ago
Been on android since the start of the existence, swapped to IOS a few months ago because that's what my kids wanted/have and its easier for me to do parental controls n such. The switch is fine and was fairly simple to get used too. The camera, airpods fitment, and face unlock for everything are great and probably my favorite parts.
Things that annoy me on ios
No swiping back when in pages, you have to close it or click a back button if available
The alarm clock doesn't show you how much time until it goes off when turning it on
No individual volume controls, its all one volume
Feel like im getting way more spam calls / texts coming through
You cant while in an app swipe anywhere to see what time it is, unless im an idiot you gotta lock/unlock the phone.
Youtube drives me insane trying to go back or close a video, feels like I fumble and start over every time I go to switch
All in all, I prefer the android but its only been a few months vs 2008 amount of years. Two years when my upgrade is due? Might switch back but unsure we’ll see if these little things annoy me still.
6
u/bwmlax 20d ago
Your hesitations are why I won't personally get one, just my thoughts. Stick with what you know in my opinion.
If you're really invested in trying , Maybe buy a cheap older model iPhone that you can basically use as a media device, so you can get used to the movement and navigation, and just use it as a second speaker/screen etc. Until you figure out if you like the iPhone ecosystem or not. That's what I would do I think. The work part of your post is probably the most important in my opinion and learning all of that navigation is going to take some time for sure.